How to Write a Hypothesis - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
67 original exam-style questions - 29 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
How to Write a Hypothesis revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Psychology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 1 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 5 and chapter 9 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 3.
7.6 How to Write a Hypothesis
A It must predict the direction of the difference between the two conditions.
B It must be written in the null form before the study begins.
C Its variables must be stated in a form that can be measured or manipulated.
D It must be supported by at least two previous published studies.
Write a non-directional hypothesis for this study.
A Participants tested at 9am will have a faster mean reaction time in milliseconds than participants tested at 4pm.
B To investigate whether the time of day at which a person is tested affects their reaction time.
C Participants tested at 4pm will have a faster mean reaction time in milliseconds than participants tested at 9am.
D There will be a difference in mean reaction time in milliseconds between participants tested at 9am and participants tested at 4pm.
Erin writes the following hypothesis: 'Participants who talk to a highly attractive partner will volunteer more personal facts during the five-minute conversation than participants who talk to a partner of average attractiveness.'
State how many of the three available marks Erin would earn, and justify your answer.
Amelia writes: 'There will be a difference in mean heart rate in beats per minute between participants who play a fast-paced video game for fifteen minutes and participants who read a magazine for fifteen minutes.'
Kwame writes: 'To investigate whether playing a fast-paced video game affects heart rate.'
Niamh writes: 'Participants who play a fast-paced video game for fifteen minutes will have a higher mean heart rate in beats per minute than participants who read a magazine for fifteen minutes.'
Write a directional hypothesis for this study.
Write a directional hypothesis for this study.
Write an appropriate hypothesis for this study.
Write a directional hypothesis for this study.
Write an appropriate hypothesis for this study.
Write a directional hypothesis for this study.
Write a directional hypothesis for this study.
Write a directional hypothesis for this study.
Write a directional hypothesis for this study.
Tobi writes the following hypothesis: 'Participants who watch the violent clip will be more aggressive than participants who watch the nature documentary.'
State how many of the three available marks Tobi would earn, and justify your answer.
Saoirse writes: 'There will be a difference in the rating out of 5 that children give the construction toy between children who read about a boy character and children who read about a girl character.'
Rhys writes: 'Children will rate the toy differently depending on the character.'
State which of these two hypotheses would earn more marks, and justify your answer.
Callum writes the following: 'Will offenders who serve a sentence of under twelve months be reconvicted within two years more often than offenders who serve a sentence of over three years?'
Explain why Callum's statement would earn no marks as a hypothesis.
Zainab writes: 'Patients returning to a household rated high in expressed emotion will be readmitted to hospital within nine months more often than patients returning to a household rated low in expressed emotion.'
State how many of the three available marks Zainab would earn, and justify your answer fully.
Farhan writes: 'Offenders who complete the twelve-week programme will show a bigger change in impulsivity than those who do not.'
State how many of the three available marks Farhan would earn, and justify your answer fully.
Noah writes: 'Frustrated drivers will be more aggressive.'
Noah's hypothesis would earn no marks. Rewrite it so that it would earn all three marks, and state what you have changed.
Priya writes: 'To see whether mindfulness training reduces the stress scores of unpaid carers compared with a waiting list.'
State how many of the three available marks Priya would earn, and explain your answer.
Kwame writes: 'Participants who see the man carrying a kitchen knife will identify the correct photograph less often.'
Oliwia writes: 'Participants who type with two observers watching will type more words correctly per minute than participants who type alone.'
Yusuf writes: 'Participants will type faster when they are watched than when they are alone.'
The examination question read: 'Write a suitable hypothesis for this study.' No previous research is reported, so either a directional or a non-directional form is acceptable.
Write a non-directional hypothesis for this study.
Write a non-directional hypothesis for this study.
Write a directional hypothesis for this study.
Write a non-directional hypothesis for this study.
Write a non-directional hypothesis for this study.
Oliwia writes: 'Children who watch one row being spread out will answer correctly less often than children whose rows are not altered.'
Maja writes: 'Spreading one row of counters out will change the answers children give compared with leaving both rows unaltered.'
Leo writes: 'To investigate whether spreading out a row of counters affects conservation of number in five year olds.'
Rank these three statements from the highest scoring to the lowest scoring as answers to 'Write a suitable hypothesis for this study', and justify your ranking.
Maja writes: 'There will be no difference in the number of specific details given by bilingual adults tested in English and bilingual adults tested in Polish.'
Erin writes: 'There will be no difference in the change in confidence score out of 25 between students who attend the weekly debating club and students who do not.'
Four students answer the question 'Write a directional hypothesis for this study'.
Amelia writes: 'Pairs of identical twins will have a smaller absolute difference in extraversion score out of 100 than pairs of non-identical twins.'
Noah writes: 'Identical twins will be more similar in personality than non-identical twins.'
Saoirse writes: 'To investigate whether identical twins are more similar in extraversion than non-identical twins.'
Farhan writes: 'There will be a difference in the absolute difference in extraversion score out of 100 between pairs of identical twins and pairs of non-identical twins.'
Discuss the decision the psychologist faces between a directional and a non-directional hypothesis in this study, and explain what follows from that decision for her statistical analysis.
Design a study the psychologist could carry out to investigate this question. In your answer you must state a fully operationalised hypothesis and say what type of hypothesis it is, and you must justify your choice of experimental design, your operationalisation of the variables, and the inferential statistical test you would use.
Question 1
- IV: whether the answer is given out loud in front of the confederates or privately in writing oeB1
- DV: the number of the eighteen critical trials answered incorrectly oeB1
- Answer: IV: whether the answer is given publicly out loud or privately in writing. DV: the number of incorrect answers out of eighteen critical trials.
Question 2
- C. A hypothesis can only be tested if its variables are operationalised, that is stated in a measurable or manipulable formB1
- Answer: C
Question 3
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the twelve digits are read as three groups of four or as four groups of three oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of digits recalled in the correct position out of twelve oeB1
- Answer: There will be a difference in the number of digits recalled in the correct position out of twelve between participants who hear the digits read as three groups of four and participants who hear them read as four groups of three.
Question 4
- D. It predicts that a difference will occur but does not say which group will be fasterB1
- Answer: D
Question 5
- 3 marksB1
- justification: it is a clear directional prediction naming both conditions of the IV, highly attractive and average attractiveness, and it operationalises the DV as the number of personal facts volunteered during the five-minute conversation oeB1
- Answer: 3 marks. It is a clearly stated directional prediction, it names both conditions of the independent variable, and the dependent variable is operationalised as the number of personal facts volunteered in the five-minute conversation.
Question 6
- an aim is a general statement of what the researcher intends to investigate, the purpose of the study oeB1
- a hypothesis is a precise, testable statement predicting the relationship between the operationalised variables oeB1
- Answer: An aim states the general purpose of the study, for example to investigate whether the number of other passengers present affects helping behaviour. A hypothesis is a precise, testable prediction about the operationalised variables, for example that fewer passengers will offer help when six other passengers are present than when one other passenger is present.
Question 7
- it is an aimB1
- justification: it states the purpose of the study and makes no prediction about what will be found, and the variables are not operationalised oeB1
- Answer: It is an aim, because it states what the psychologist intends to investigate rather than predicting an outcome, and neither variable is stated in a measurable form.
Question 8
- it is a hypothesisB1
- justification: it makes a testable prediction about the outcome, naming both conditions of the IV and a measurable DV oeB1
- Answer: It is a hypothesis, because it predicts a specific outcome rather than stating a purpose, and both the conditions of the independent variable and the dependent variable are measurable.
Question 9
- IV: whether the participant is tested in a silent room or with a recording of office noise playing oeB1
- DV: the longest digit sequence recalled in the correct order oeB1
- Answer: IV: the listening condition, silent room or office noise. DV: the longest digit sequence recalled in the correct order.
Question 10
- IV: whether a familiar toy from home is present or absent during the separation oeB1
- DV: the number of seconds spent crying during the three-minute separation oeB1
- Answer: IV: presence or absence of a familiar toy from home. DV: the number of seconds spent crying during the three-minute separation.
Question 11
- operationalisation means defining a variable in terms of how it will be manipulated or measured in the study oeB1
- a workable operationalisation of the IV, for example testing students during the week of their final examinations compared with a week in the middle of the teaching term oeB1
- the operationalisation gives two clearly distinguishable conditions that another researcher could reproduce oeB1
- Answer: Operationalisation means stating a variable in terms of how it will be manipulated or measured. Stress could be operationalised as whether students are tested during the week of their final examinations or during a week in the middle of the teaching term, which gives two conditions another researcher could set up in exactly the same way.
Question 12
- a measurable operationalisation, for example the score out of 20 on a multiple choice test taken one week after the lecture oeB1
- the operationalisation states both what is measured and the scale or units it is measured on oeB1
- 'how well students learn' cannot be used because it gives no measurement procedure, so different researchers would measure different things and the study could not be replicated oeB1
- Answer: The dependent variable could be operationalised as the score out of 20 on a multiple choice test on the lecture content taken one week later. 'How well students learn' gives no procedure or units, so two researchers could measure it in entirely different ways and the study could not be replicated.
Question 13
- only one condition of the IV is named, as there is nothing for the caffeinated group to be compared with oeB1
- the DV is not operationalised, as 'score higher on a sustained attention task' does not state the scale or units oeB1
- a rewritten hypothesis naming both conditions and an operationalised DV, for example participants who drink a caffeinated drink will detect more targets out of 40 on a ten-minute sustained attention task than participants who drink a decaffeinated drink oeB1
- Answer: Participants who drink a caffeinated drink will detect more targets out of 40 on a ten-minute sustained attention task than participants who drink a decaffeinated drink. The original named only the caffeinated condition and did not say how attention was scored.
Question 14
- IV: the type of feedback received, written on a printed sheet or spoken by a tutor oeB1
- DV: the number of practice attempts completed in the thirty-minute session oeB1
- both variables are fully operationalised, because both conditions of the IV are described concretely and the DV states what is counted and over what period oeB1
- Answer: IV: type of feedback, written on a printed sheet or spoken by a tutor. DV: the number of practice attempts completed in thirty minutes. Both are fully operationalised, since the IV names two concrete conditions and the DV states the count and the time period.
Question 15
- previous findings on music and study performance conflict, so there is no consistent basis on which to predict a direction oeB1
- a non-directional hypothesis predicts only that a difference in test performance will be found, which is all the existing evidence supports oeB1
- Answer: The previous studies disagree about whether music helps or harms study performance, so there is no consistent evidence on which to base a prediction of direction. A non-directional hypothesis predicts only that test performance will differ between the two conditions, which is as far as the evidence allows her to go.
Question 16
- previous well-controlled research consistently shows rehearsing aloud improves recall, so there is a clear basis for predicting the direction oeB1
- a directional hypothesis states which condition will recall more words, which makes the prediction more precise and allows a one-tailed test oeB1
- Answer: Previous research consistently finds that rehearsing aloud improves recall over rehearsing silently, so she can justify predicting which condition will be better. A directional hypothesis states that the aloud condition will recall more words, which is a more precise prediction and permits a one-tailed test.
Question 17
- (a) a statement of purpose beginning 'to investigate' or equivalent, rather than a prediction oeB1
- (a) the aim names both the mindfulness course and reported sleep, for example to investigate whether completing a six-week mindfulness course affects the number of hours of sleep adults report each night oeB1
- (a) Answer: To investigate whether completing a six-week mindfulness course affects the number of hours of sleep adults report each night.
- (b) an aim is too general to test, as it does not state what result would count as support oeB1
- (b) the hypothesis makes a precise prediction with operationalised variables, which is what the statistical test is carried out on oeB1
- (b) Answer: The aim only states the purpose of the study, so nothing about it can be accepted or rejected by the data. The hypothesis turns the aim into a precise prediction about operationalised variables, and it is that prediction the statistical test evaluates.
Question 18
- (a) two concrete conditions are named, for example one other shopper standing nearby compared with six other shoppers standing nearby oeB1
- (a) the conditions are stated in countable terms that could be set up identically on each trial oeB1
- (a) Answer: The number of other shoppers standing within two metres of the actor, set at either one shopper or six shoppers.
- (b) a measurable outcome is named, for example whether a passer-by offers help within thirty seconds, or the number of seconds before the first offer of help oeB1
- (b) the measure states the observation window or the units, so every trial is scored the same way oeB1
- (b) Answer: The number of seconds between the folder being dropped and the first passer-by offering help, recorded up to a maximum of sixty seconds.
- (c) any one of: so the study can be replicated; so the hypothesis is testable; so every trial is measured in the same way; so the data can be analysed statistically oeB1
- (c) Answer: So that the study can be replicated by another researcher in exactly the same way.
Question 19
- (a) Kwame's statementB1
- (a) Answer: Kwame's statement.
- (b) Niamh's is directional and Amelia's is non-directionalB1
- (b) justification: Niamh predicts which group will have the higher heart rate, whereas Amelia predicts only that the two groups will differ oeB1
- (b) Answer: Niamh's is directional and Amelia's is non-directional. Niamh names which group will have the higher mean heart rate, while Amelia predicts only that a difference will be found.
- (c) both name both conditions of the IV in concrete terms, playing a fast-paced video game for fifteen minutes and reading a magazine for fifteen minutes oeB1
- (c) both state the DV with its units, mean heart rate in beats per minute oeB1
- (c) Answer: Both name both conditions of the independent variable concretely, fifteen minutes of a fast-paced video game against fifteen minutes of reading a magazine, and both state the dependent variable with its units, mean heart rate in beats per minute.
Question 20
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the participant tracks the dot alone or tracks the dot while repeating a word aloud oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of seconds out of 120 for which the cursor is kept on the dot oeB1
- Answer: Participants will keep the cursor on the moving dot for fewer seconds out of 120 in the dual task condition, when they track the dot while repeating a word aloud, than in the single task condition, when they track the dot alone.
Question 21
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, which is the type this stem justifies, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the question uses the verb 'smashed' or the verb 'contacted' oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the speed estimate given in miles per hour oeB1
- Answer: Participants asked how fast the cars were going when they smashed into each other will give a higher mean speed estimate in miles per hour than participants asked how fast the cars were going when they contacted each other.
Question 22
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, or a correctly written null hypothesis, which is the type this stem justifies, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the seated adult is the infant's primary caregiver or a friendly but unfamiliar adult oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of seconds during the five-minute session spent within one metre of the seated adult oeB1
- Answer: There will be a difference in the number of seconds spent within one metre of the seated adult during the five-minute session between infants observed with their primary caregiver and infants observed with a friendly but unfamiliar adult.
Question 23
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the key worker remains in the room or leaves the room for three minutes oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of seconds the child spends crying during the three-minute period oeB1
- Answer: Children will spend more seconds crying during the three-minute period when their key worker leaves the room than when their key worker remains in the room.
Question 24
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, or a correctly written null hypothesis, which is the type this stem justifies, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the participant sits with four confederates or with eight confederates oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of the fifteen critical trials on which the participant gives the same incorrect answer as the confederates oeB1
- Answer: There will be a difference in the number of the fifteen critical trials on which participants give the same incorrect answer as the confederates between participants sitting with four confederates and participants sitting with eight confederates.
Question 25
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, which is the type this stem justifies, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the researcher remains in the room or gives all further instructions by telephone from another room oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of minutes out of thirty for which the participant continues sorting the documents oeB1
- Answer: Participants whose researcher remains in the room will continue sorting the documents for more minutes out of thirty than participants whose researcher gives all further instructions by telephone from another room.
Question 26
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the participant completes six weekly sessions of systematic desensitisation or is placed on a waiting list with no treatment oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the anxiety rating about boarding an aircraft given on the scale from 0 to 10 oeB1
- Answer: Adults who complete six weekly sessions of systematic desensitisation will give a lower mean anxiety rating on the 0 to 10 scale than adults placed on a waiting list with no treatment.
Question 27
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, which is the type this stem justifies, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the adult in the film is praised for persisting or is ignored oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of seconds the child spends working on the difficult puzzle before asking to stop, up to a maximum of 300 oeB1
- Answer: Children who watch a film in which the adult is praised for persisting will spend more seconds working on the difficult puzzle before asking to stop than children who watch a film in which the adult is ignored.
Question 28
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the three-minute talk is delivered in front of two note-taking observers or alone in an empty room oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: heart rate in beats per minute recorded at the end of the talk oeB1
- Answer: Participants who deliver the three-minute talk in front of two note-taking observers will have a higher mean heart rate in beats per minute at the end of the talk than participants who deliver the talk alone in an empty room.
Question 29
- (a) a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (a) both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: learning a second, similar list of word pairs compared with completing a crossword for ten minutes oeB1
- (a) the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of word pairs recalled correctly out of twenty oeB1
- (a) Answer: Participants who learn a second, similar list of word pairs will recall fewer of the original twenty word pairs correctly than participants who spend ten minutes completing a crossword.
- (b) previous studies of retroactive interference consistently find that a similar second list reduces recall of the first oeB1
- (b) a consistent body of prior findings gives a justified basis for predicting which condition will recall fewer pairs, so the more precise directional form is warranted oeB1
- (b) Answer: Previous research on retroactive interference consistently reports that learning a similar second list lowers recall of the first, so there is a justified basis for predicting the direction. That allows the more precise directional prediction that the second-list group will recall fewer pairs.
Question 30
- (a) a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (a) both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: the cognitive interview compared with a standard interview of fixed direct questions oeB1
- (a) the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of accurate details about the theft reported oeB1
- (a) Answer: Witnesses interviewed using the cognitive interview will report more accurate details about the theft than witnesses interviewed using a standard interview consisting of a fixed list of direct questions.
- (b) any one advantage, for example it permits a one-tailed test, or it commits the researcher to a more precise and more easily falsified prediction oeB1
- (b) the advantage is developed in context, for example a one-tailed test places the whole region of rejection at the predicted end, so a genuine advantage of the cognitive interview needs less extreme data to reach significance than it would under a two-tailed test oeB1
- (b) Answer: Because the hypothesis is directional a one-tailed test can be used. A one-tailed test places the whole region of rejection at the predicted end rather than splitting it between both ends, so if the cognitive interview really does yield more accurate details, that difference needs less extreme data to reach significance than it would under a two-tailed test.
Question 31
- (a) a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (a) both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: completing the questionnaire immediately before giving a two-minute talk compared with immediately before watching a classmate give one oeB1
- (a) the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the score out of 40 on the standardised anxiety questionnaire oeB1
- (a) Answer: Students who complete the anxiety questionnaire immediately before giving a two-minute talk will score higher out of 40 than students who complete it immediately before watching a classmate give a two-minute talk.
- (b) only one condition of the IV is named, as there is nothing the talk-giving group is compared with oeB1
- (b) the DV is not operationalised, since 'feel more anxious' does not state the questionnaire or the score out of 40 that will be used to measure it oeB1
- (b) Answer: It names only one condition of the independent variable, giving nothing for the talk-giving group to be compared against, and it does not operationalise the dependent variable, since 'feel more anxious' says nothing about the anxiety questionnaire or its score out of 40.
Question 32
- (a) a statement of purpose rather than a prediction, for example beginning 'to investigate whether' oeB1
- (a) the aim names both the rehearsal manipulation and recall of the consonants oeB1
- (a) Answer: To investigate whether preventing rehearsal during an eighteen-second delay affects how well participants recall a set of three consonants.
- (b) a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (b) both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: sitting quietly for eighteen seconds compared with counting backwards in threes for eighteen seconds oeB1
- (b) the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of trials out of twelve on which all three consonants are recalled in the correct order oeB1
- (b) Answer: Participants who count backwards in threes for eighteen seconds will recall all three consonants in the correct order on fewer of the twelve trials than participants who sit quietly for eighteen seconds.
- (c) IV: whether the eighteen-second delay is spent sitting quietly or counting backwards in threes oeB1
- (c) DV: the number of trials out of twelve on which all three consonants are recalled in the correct order oeB1
- (c) Answer: IV: how the eighteen-second delay is spent, sitting quietly or counting backwards in threes. DV: the number of trials out of twelve on which all three consonants are recalled in the correct order.
Question 33
- 2 marksB1
- justification: it is a clear directional statement naming both conditions of the IV, but the DV is not operationalised, since 'more aggressive' does not state the count of aggressive word completions out of twenty oeB1
- Answer: 2 marks. The statement is clear and directional and names both conditions of the independent variable, but the dependent variable is not operationalised, because 'more aggressive' says nothing about the number of aggressive word completions out of twenty.
Question 34
- Saoirse's hypothesisB1
- justification: Saoirse names both conditions of the IV and operationalises the DV as the rating out of 5, whereas Rhys names neither condition explicitly and does not state how the rating is measured oeB1
- Answer: Saoirse's. She names both conditions of the independent variable, a boy character and a girl character, and operationalises the dependent variable as the rating out of 5. Rhys states neither condition explicitly and gives no measure.
Question 35
- it is written as a question rather than as a statement oeB1
- a hypothesis must be a testable prediction that the data can support or fail to support, and a question predicts nothing, so it scores zero however well operationalised its variables are oeB1
- Answer: It is phrased as a question, not as a statement. A hypothesis has to be a prediction that the data can support or fail to support, and a question makes no prediction, so it earns nothing even though both variables here are well operationalised.
Question 36
- 3 marksB1
- it is a clear directional statement naming both conditions of the IV, high and low expressed emotion households oeB1
- the DV is operationalised as readmission to hospital within nine months, which states both the outcome and the time window oeB1
- Answer: 3 marks. It is clear and directional, it names both conditions of the independent variable, and it operationalises the dependent variable as readmission to hospital within a stated nine-month window.
Question 37
- 2 marksB1
- it is a clear directional statement and it names both conditions of the IV, completing the twelve-week programme and not completing it oeB1
- the DV is not operationalised, since 'a bigger change in impulsivity' does not state the change in score out of 60 on the impulsivity questionnaire oeB1
- Answer: 2 marks. The statement is clear and directional and both conditions of the independent variable are named, but the dependent variable is not operationalised because it does not refer to the change in score out of 60 on the impulsivity questionnaire.
Question 38
- the rewritten hypothesis names both conditions of the IV: repeatedly delayed by slow traffic and given a clear road oeB1
- the rewritten hypothesis states the DV in operationalised form: the number of times the horn is sounded during the ten-minute drive oeB1
- the changes are identified, including that the original named only one condition of the IV, so there was nothing for the frustrated drivers to be compared with oeB1
- Answer: Participants who are repeatedly delayed by slow traffic will sound the horn more times during the ten-minute simulated drive than participants who are given a clear road. The changes are that the comparison condition has been added and that 'more aggressive' has been replaced by the count of horn soundings.
Question 39
- 0 marksB1
- the statement is an aim, not a hypothesis, because 'to see whether' states the purpose of the study rather than predicting an outcome oeB1
- an aim earns zero however well its variables are described, so the fact that Priya names both conditions and refers to stress scores does not rescue it oeB1
- Answer: 0 marks. 'To see whether' states the purpose of the study rather than predicting what will be found, so it is an aim. An aim earns nothing on a hypothesis question even when, as here, both conditions and the measure are described.
Question 40
- (a) 0 marksB1
- (a) justification: only one condition of the IV is named, the kitchen knife, with no comparison condition stated, and a one-condition statement scores zero however well the DV is operationalised oeB1
- (a) Answer: 0 marks. He names only one condition of the independent variable, giving nothing for the knife condition to be compared against. That scores zero however well the dependent variable is operationalised.
- (b) a directional prediction of the same form as the original, clearly stated oeB1
- (b) both conditions of the IV are named: carrying a kitchen knife and carrying a rolled-up newspaper oeB1
- (b) the change is identified: what was missing from the original and what has been added oeB1
- (b) Answer: Participants who see the man carrying a kitchen knife will identify the correct photograph from the set of ten less often than participants who see the man carrying a rolled-up newspaper.
Question 41
- (a) Oliwia earns 3 marksB1
- (a) Yusuf earns 1 markB1
- (a) Answer: Oliwia earns 3 marks and Yusuf earns 1 mark.
- (b) Oliwia operationalises the IV as typing with two observers watching against typing alone, whereas 'watched' and 'alone' restate the conditions without the detail the stem gives oeB1
- (b) Oliwia operationalises the DV as words typed correctly per minute, whereas 'faster' states neither the unit nor the accuracy requirement oeB1
- (b) Answer: Both name both conditions, so the difference is entirely operationalisation. Oliwia states the conditions as typing with two observers watching against typing alone and the dependent variable as words typed correctly per minute. Yusuf operationalises neither, and 'faster' gives no units and no accuracy requirement.
Question 42
- neither variable is manipulated by the researcher, as both hours of sleep and concentration score are simply measured as they occur oeB1
- in a correlation the two variables are called co-variables, and because nothing is manipulated no statement about cause can be made oeB1
- Answer: Neither variable is manipulated: both hours of sleep and concentration score are measured as they naturally occur. In a correlation the two measured variables are called co-variables, and because nothing is manipulated the study cannot show that one causes the other.
Question 43
- a directional hypothesis requires a one-tailed test, whereas a non-directional hypothesis requires a two-tailed test oeB1
- she must read the critical value from the one-tailed column of the table, and at a given significance level this critical value differs from the two-tailed one oeB1
- Answer: A directional hypothesis is tested with a one-tailed test, so she must read the critical value from the one-tailed column of the table rather than the two-tailed column. At the same significance level the two columns give different critical values.
Question 44
- a statement predicting a relationship or correlation, not a difference, and naming its direction as negative oeB1
- the first co-variable is operationalised: the number of close friends the person reports having oeB1
- the second co-variable is operationalised: the score out of 30 on the standardised loneliness questionnaire oeB1
- Answer: There will be a negative correlation between the number of close friends an adult reports having and their score out of 30 on the standardised loneliness questionnaire.
Question 45
- a statement predicting a relationship or correlation without naming its direction oeB1
- the first co-variable is operationalised: the number of minutes of daily exercise reported oeB1
- the second co-variable is operationalised: the score out of 25 on the standardised sleep quality questionnaire oeB1
- Answer: There will be a correlation between the number of minutes of daily exercise an adult reports and their score out of 25 on the standardised sleep quality questionnaire.
Question 46
- a statement predicting a difference, of either direction, rather than an aim or a question oeB1
- both conditions are named: a weekday morning and a Saturday afternoon oeB1
- the behavioural category is operationalised: the proportion or number of shoppers who stop to help the member of staff oeB1
- Answer: There will be a difference in the proportion of shoppers who stop to help the member of staff between observations made on a weekday morning and observations made on a Saturday afternoon.
Question 47
- a directional prediction, which is the type the consistent previous surveys justify oeB1
- both conditions are named: a household with a kerbside collection and a household that must take recycling to a central point oeB1
- the DV is operationalised: the pro-recycling attitude score out of 60 on the twelve-item questionnaire oeB1
- Answer: Residents whose household has a kerbside collection will have a higher mean pro-recycling attitude score out of 60 than residents whose household must take recycling to a central point.
Question 48
- (a) a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (a) both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: studying the six topics in the order given in the textbook compared with studying them in a random order oeB1
- (a) the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the score out of 50 on the test covering all six topics oeB1
- (a) Answer: There will be a difference in the mean test score out of 50 between students who study the six topics in the order given in the textbook and students who study them in a random order.
- (b) a statement that there will be no difference, with any difference attributed to chance oeB1
- (b) both conditions and the operationalised DV are retained in the null statement oeB1
- (b) Answer: There will be no difference in the mean test score out of 50 between students who study the six topics in the order given in the textbook and students who study them in a random order, and any difference found will be due to chance.
Question 49
- (a) there is a probability of less than one per cent that a difference this large would have arisen if the null hypothesis were true oeB1
- (a) the difference is therefore very unlikely to be due to chance alone oeB1
- (a) Answer: There is less than a one per cent probability that a difference of this size would have occurred if the null hypothesis were true, so the difference is very unlikely to be due to chance alone.
- (b) she may reject the null hypothesis and accept the alternative hypothesis oeB1
- (b) she may not conclude that the result is certain or proved, because a one per cent probability of a chance result remains oeB1
- (b) Answer: She may reject the null hypothesis and accept the alternative hypothesis. She may not conclude that the result is certain, because there remains up to a one per cent probability that the difference arose by chance.
Question 50
- (a) a statement, not an aim or a question, predicting a positive correlation, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (a) the first co-variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of pieces of unsolicited advertising email received in a week oeB1
- (a) the second co-variable is stated in operationalised form: the score out of 35 on the standardised measure of everyday irritability oeB1
- (a) Answer: There will be a positive correlation between the number of pieces of unsolicited advertising email an adult receives in a week and their score out of 35 on the standardised measure of everyday irritability.
- (b) as one co-variable increases the other also increases oeB1
- (b) stated in context: adults who receive more unsolicited advertising emails in a week tend to have higher irritability scores out of 35 oeB1
- (b) Answer: A positive correlation means that as one co-variable increases so does the other. Here it would mean that adults who receive more unsolicited advertising emails in a week tend to score higher out of 35 on the irritability measure.
Question 51
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the confederate supports acquittal by pointing to inconsistencies in the witness statements or to gaps in the forensic evidence oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of the four genuine participants in each group who vote to acquit oeB1
- Answer: There will be a difference in the number of the four genuine participants voting to acquit between groups in which the confederate points to inconsistencies in the witness statements and groups in which the confederate points to gaps in the forensic evidence.
Question 52
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the participant has a current diagnosis of depression or no history of depression oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of trials out of sixty on which the participant looks first at the negative word oeB1
- Answer: There will be a difference in the number of trials out of sixty on which participants look first at the negative word between adults with a current diagnosis of depression and adults with no history of depression.
Question 53
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, which is the type this stem justifies, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the participant has a diagnosis of obsessive-compulsive disorder or no psychiatric diagnosis oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of times the participant returns to the door and handles the lock during the two minutes oeB1
- Answer: Adults with a diagnosis of obsessive-compulsive disorder will return to the door and handle the lock more times during the two-minute period than adults with no psychiatric diagnosis.
Question 54
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the hour before bed is spent in a brightly lit room or a dimly lit room oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the mean number of minutes between getting into bed and falling asleep across the seven nights oeB1
- Answer: There will be a difference in the mean number of minutes between getting into bed and falling asleep between the week in which participants spend the hour before bed in a brightly lit room and the week in which they spend it in a dimly lit room.
Question 55
- a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: whether the member of staff works three twelve-hour shifts per week or four nine-hour shifts per week oeB1
- the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the score out of 50 on the standardised workplace stress questionnaire oeB1
- Answer: There will be a difference in the mean score out of 50 on the standardised workplace stress questionnaire between staff working three twelve-hour shifts per week and staff working four nine-hour shifts per week.
Question 56
- (a) a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (a) both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: a point after every fifth press compared with a point after an unpredictable number of presses averaging one in five oeB1
- (a) the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of key presses made after the reward is switched off, before stopping oeB1
- (a) Answer: Participants rewarded after an unpredictable number of presses averaging one in five will make more key presses before stopping, once the reward is switched off, than participants rewarded after every fifth press.
- (b) 'how long participants keep playing' does not state what is counted or in what units, so different researchers could measure it in different ways oeB1
- (b) an operationalised DV makes the study replicable and allows the data to be analysed statistically, because every participant is scored on the same quantity oeB1
- (b) Answer: 'How long participants keep playing' names no unit and no procedure, so one researcher might time it in minutes and another count presses. Stating the dependent variable as the number of key presses after the reward is switched off scores every participant on the same quantity, which makes the study replicable and the data analysable.
Question 57
- correct order: Oliwia highest, then Maja, then Leo lowestB1
- Oliwia scores highest because she gives a clear directional prediction naming both conditions of the IV and an operationalised DV, whether the child answers correctly oeB1
- Leo scores lowest because his statement is an aim, which earns zero, whereas Maja names both conditions and so reaches the one-mark tier, operationalising neither variable oeB1
- Answer: Oliwia, then Maja, then Leo. Oliwia gives a clear directional prediction with both conditions of the independent variable and an operationalised dependent variable, so 3 marks. Maja names both conditions but operationalises neither variable, so 1 mark. Leo has written an aim rather than a prediction, so 0.
Question 58
- (a) 3 marksB1
- (a) Maja has written a null hypothesis, and where the question asks for an appropriate hypothesis and the evidence justifies a non-directional prediction, a correctly written null hypothesis is credited in full oeB1
- (a) Answer: 3 marks. She has written a null hypothesis. Because the question asked for an appropriate hypothesis and the conflicting evidence means the appropriate prediction is non-directional, a correctly written null hypothesis earns full credit here.
- (b) a null hypothesis predicts no difference, so it states no direction oeB1
- (b) a question that demands a directional hypothesis is answered only by a statement predicting which condition will score higher, so a null hypothesis is the wrong type and scores zero oeB1
- (b) Answer: A null hypothesis predicts no difference, so it states no direction at all. A question that explicitly demands a directional hypothesis can only be answered by a statement saying which condition will score higher, so the null form is the wrong type and earns zero.
Question 59
- (a) 0 marksB1
- (a) she has written a null hypothesis oeB1
- (a) Answer: 0 marks. She has written a null hypothesis.
- (b) the marks for operationalisation are only available once the hypothesis is of the type the question demanded oeB1
- (b) because the question asked for a directional hypothesis and she wrote a null one, the answer is judged the wrong type and scores zero before operationalisation is considered at all oeB1
- (b) Answer: Marks for naming both conditions and operationalising the dependent variable only become available once the hypothesis is of the type the question demanded. Her statement is a null hypothesis where a directional one was required, so it is the wrong type and scores zero before the quality of the operationalisation is considered.
Question 60
- (a) a statement, not an aim or a question, making a directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (a) both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: the five-minute guided breathing exercise compared with sitting quietly for five minutes oeB1
- (a) the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the anxiety rating out of 30 on the standardised scale oeB1
- (a) Answer: Students who complete a five-minute guided breathing exercise before the mock examination will give a lower anxiety rating out of 30 than students who sit quietly for five minutes.
- (b) a statement that there will be no difference, or that any difference is due to chance oeB1
- (b) both conditions of the IV and the operationalised DV are retained in the null statement oeB1
- (b) Answer: There will be no difference in the mean anxiety rating out of 30 between students who complete a five-minute guided breathing exercise and students who sit quietly for five minutes, and any difference found will be due to chance.
- (c) part (a) explicitly demanded a directional hypothesis, which must state which condition will score lower or higher oeB1
- (c) a null hypothesis predicts no difference, so it is the wrong type for that question and earns zero regardless of how well its variables are operationalised oeB1
- (c) Answer: Part (a) explicitly asked for a directional hypothesis, which must say which group will report lower anxiety. The null hypothesis predicts no difference at all, so it is the wrong type for that question and earns zero however well its variables are operationalised.
Question 61
- (a) Amelia 3 marks and Noah 2 marksB1
- (a) Saoirse 0 marks and Farhan 0 marksB1
- (a) Answer: Amelia 3, Noah 2, Saoirse 0, Farhan 0.
- (b) Saoirse has written an aim, which predicts nothing and therefore earns zero regardless of detail oeB1
- (b) Noah has written a directional prediction naming both conditions of the IV, so he earns two marks, losing only the third because the DV is not operationalised oeB1
- (b) Answer: Saoirse has written an aim. An aim makes no prediction, so it earns zero however much detail it contains. Noah has written a directional prediction that names both conditions of the independent variable, so he earns two of the three marks and loses only the one for operationalising the dependent variable.
- (c) the question asked for a directional hypothesis, and the stem's consistently greater similarity in identical pairs is what makes that the appropriate type oeB1
- (c) Farhan's hypothesis is non-directional, which is the wrong type here, and a hypothesis of the wrong type scores zero however well its variables are operationalised oeB1
- (c) Answer: The question asked for a directional hypothesis, and the stem's consistent evidence supports one. Farhan's is non-directional. That is the wrong type for the question that was asked, and the wrong type scores zero no matter how well the variables are operationalised.
Question 62
- a statement predicting a difference, of either direction, rather than an aim or a question oeB1
- both conditions are named: articles sampled from tabloid newspapers and articles sampled from broadsheet newspapers oeB1
- the coding unit is operationalised: the number of uses per article of a word from the pre-agreed list of stigmatising terms oeB1
- Answer: Articles sampled from tabloid newspapers will contain more uses per article of words from the pre-agreed list of stigmatising terms than articles sampled from broadsheet newspapers.
Question 63
- (a) she should use the one-tailed critical value of 5B1
- (a) justification: her hypothesis is directional, and a directional hypothesis is tested one-tailed oeB1
- (a) Answer: She should use the one-tailed critical value of 5, because her hypothesis is directional and a directional hypothesis is tested with a one-tailed test.
- (b) the result is significant, because for the sign test the calculated value of 5 is equal to or less than the critical value of 5 oeB1
- (b) with a non-directional hypothesis the critical value would have been 4, and as 5 is greater than 4 the result would not have been significant oeB1
- (b) Answer: The result is significant, because for the sign test the calculated value must be equal to or less than the critical value, and 5 is equal to 5. Had she written a non-directional hypothesis the critical value would have been 4, and since 5 is greater than 4 the result would not have reached significance.
Question 64
- (a) a statement, not an aim or a question, making a non-directional prediction, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (a) both conditions of the independent variable are named in operationalised form: warm lighting and cool lighting oeB1
- (a) the dependent variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of facial expressions identified correctly out of thirty oeB1
- (a) Answer: There will be a difference in the number of facial expressions identified correctly out of thirty between participants who view the photographs under warm lighting and participants who view them under cool lighting.
- (b) the Mann-Whitney test, or the unrelated t-test if the data are treated as interval and normally distributed oeB1
- (b) the hypothesis predicts a difference rather than a relationship oeB1
- (b) the design is independent groups, since participants are randomly allocated to one lighting condition only, and the data are at least ordinal oeB1
- (b) Answer: A Mann-Whitney test. The hypothesis predicts a difference rather than a relationship, the design is independent groups because each participant experiences only one lighting condition, and the number correct out of thirty is at least ordinal data.
- (c) two-tailedB1
- (c) because the hypothesis is non-directional: it predicts a difference without stating which condition will score higher oeB1
- (c) Answer: Two-tailed, because the hypothesis is non-directional: it predicts a difference without saying which lighting condition will score higher.
Question 65
- (a) the number of hours a week spent in organised sport oeB1
- (a) the score out of 20 on the standardised measure of self-esteem oeB1
- (a) Answer: The number of hours a week spent in organised sport, and the score out of 20 on the standardised self-esteem measure.
- (b) a statement, not an aim or a question, predicting a positive correlation, stated clearly enough to be understood on a single reading oeB1
- (b) the first co-variable is stated in operationalised form: the number of hours a week spent in organised sport oeB1
- (b) the second co-variable is stated in operationalised form: the score out of 20 on the standardised self-esteem measure oeB1
- (b) Answer: There will be a positive correlation between the number of hours a week a teenager spends in organised sport and their score out of 20 on the standardised self-esteem measure.
- (c) a correlation shows only that the two co-variables vary together, and neither has been manipulated, so causation cannot be inferred oeB1
- (c) the relationship could run the other way, with teenagers who already have higher self-esteem choosing to join more sport, or a third variable such as family income could explain both oeB1
- (c) Answer: A correlation shows only that the two co-variables vary together, and because neither was manipulated no cause can be inferred. The relationship could run the other way, with higher self-esteem leading teenagers to join more sport, or a third variable such as family income could raise both.
Question 66
- Level 4 Discussion is clear, coherent and well organised. The evidence in the stem is weighed rather than described, and the consequences for the analysis are accurate and explicit. Specialist terminology is used effectively throughout.7-8
- Level 3 Discussion is mostly clear and organised. The evidence is used to support a position, although some of the reasoning is underdeveloped. Consequences for the analysis are broadly accurate. Specialist terminology is mostly used appropriately.5-6
- Level 2 Discussion lacks clarity or organisation in places. The evidence is described more than it is weighed, or only one side of the decision is considered. Consequences for the analysis are limited or partly inaccurate. Specialist terminology is used inconsistently.3-4
- Level 1 Discussion is muddled or very limited. The difference between the two types of hypothesis may be asserted without reference to the stem, and consequences for the analysis are absent or incorrect. Specialist terminology is absent or inappropriate.1-2
- Indicative content:
- the direction of a hypothesis must be justified by the existing evidence, not by what the researcher hopes to find
- four of the six studies point one way, which on a simple count would favour a directional hypothesis
- counting studies is a weak basis for the decision, because the two studies that report no effect are the better controlled and used an active control condition
- where well-controlled evidence conflicts with less well-controlled evidence the field cannot be said to point consistently in one direction, which favours a non-directional hypothesis
- a non-directional hypothesis predicts only that mood scores will differ between the gratitude condition and the control condition
- a non-directional hypothesis is tested two-tailed, so the critical value is read from the two-tailed column and a difference in either direction can reach significance
- a directional hypothesis would be tested one-tailed, which makes a difference in the predicted direction easier to detect but leaves a difference in the opposite direction undetectable
- choosing a directional hypothesis here would risk a Type II error with respect to a harmful effect, since a fall in mood could not be reported as significant
- whichever type is chosen, both conditions of the independent variable and an operationalised measure of mood must appear in the hypothesis
- the decision should be made and recorded before the data are collected, since choosing the direction afterwards would inflate the chance of a Type I error
Question 67
- Level 4 The design is coherent and could be carried out as described. A fully operationalised hypothesis of a correctly identified type is stated. Justifications for the design, the operationalisation and the statistical test are accurate and are tied to the specific features of this study. Specialist terminology is used effectively throughout.10-12
- Level 3 The design is mostly coherent and workable. The hypothesis is stated and largely operationalised, and its type is correctly identified. Justifications are mostly accurate, although one is underdeveloped or generic. Specialist terminology is mostly used appropriately.7-9
- Level 2 The design is partly workable but important details are missing or unclear. The hypothesis is present but one variable is not operationalised, or its type is not identified. Some justification is offered but it is limited or partly inaccurate. Specialist terminology is used inconsistently.4-6
- Level 1 The design is fragmentary and could not be carried out as described. The hypothesis is absent, is an aim, or leaves both variables unoperationalised. Justification is absent or incorrect. Specialist terminology is absent or inappropriate.1-3
- Indicative content:
- an independent groups design in which one group of carers receives a two-hour supervised break twice a week for six weeks and a matched group continues without the breaks
- a repeated measures design measuring each carer before and after the six-week period, which controls participant variables but introduces order effects and cannot separate the break from the passage of time
- a matched pairs design pairing carers on hours of care given per week and on the condition of the relative, which controls the most important participant variables without order effects
- the independent variable operationalised as whether the carer receives the two-hour supervised break twice weekly for six weeks or continues with their usual arrangements
- the dependent variable operationalised as the score on a standardised carer strain questionnaire, for example out of 40, administered at the end of the six weeks
- a directional hypothesis is justifiable where the student cites consistent evidence that respite reduces carer strain, and a non-directional hypothesis is justifiable where the student notes that breaks may also increase anxiety about leaving the relative
- a worked hypothesis such as: carers who receive a two-hour supervised break twice a week for six weeks will score lower on the carer strain questionnaire out of 40 than carers who continue with their usual arrangements
- the null hypothesis stated alongside the alternative, with any difference attributed to chance
- a Mann-Whitney test for an independent groups design with at least ordinal data, or a Wilcoxon test for a repeated measures or matched pairs design
- the test is one-tailed for a directional hypothesis and two-tailed for a non-directional one, and the significance level should be set at 0.05 before the data are collected
- sampling from the charity's own membership list produces a volunteer sample, which limits how far the findings generalise to carers who are not charity members
- ethical considerations include informed consent, the right to withdraw, and the difficulty of offering a valued service to one group and not the other, which may be addressed by offering the breaks to the control group after the study
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.