A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 5 includes How to Write a Hypothesis (from page 3); Gender Bias in Psychological Theory and Research (from page 33); Culture Bias in Psychological Theory and Research (from page 37); Free Will and Determinism: Philosophical Positions (from page 41); Biological, Environmental and Psychic Determinism and the Scientific Approach (from page 45); The Nature-Nurture Debate and the Interactionist Approach (from page 50); Holism and Reductionism in Psychological Explanation (from page 55); Idiographic and Nomothetic Approaches to Psychological Investigation (from page 59); Ethical Implications of Research Studies and Theory (from page 64); Applying Issues and Debates to Memory and Eyewitness Testimony Research (from page 68); Applying Issues and Debates to Conformity and Obedience Research (from page 73).
Worked question 62 - How to Write a Hypothesis
Open the included worksheet
A psychologist plans a content analysis of how mental health is presented in newspapers. One hundred articles mentioning mental health will be sampled, fifty from tabloid newspapers and fifty from broadsheet newspapers, and each article will be coded for the number of times a person with a mental health condition is described using a word from a pre-agreed list of stigmatising terms. Write a suitable hypothesis for this content analysis.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 62
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | a statement predicting a difference, of either direction, rather than an aim or a question oe |
| B1 | both conditions are named: articles sampled from tabloid newspapers and articles sampled from broadsheet newspapers oe |
| B1 | the coding unit is operationalised: the number of uses per article of a word from the pre-agreed list of stigmatising terms oe |
- Answer: Articles sampled from tabloid newspapers will contain more uses per article of words from the pre-agreed list of stigmatising terms than articles sampled from broadsheet newspapers.
Question 35 - How to Write a Hypothesis
Open the included worksheet
A forensic psychologist investigates whether the length of a custodial sentence affects reoffending. Records are examined for two hundred offenders released from prison, half of whom served a sentence of under twelve months and half of whom served a sentence of over three years. The psychologist records whether each offender is reconvicted within two years of release.
Callum writes the following: 'Will offenders who serve a sentence of under twelve months be reconvicted within two years more often than offenders who serve a sentence of over three years?'
Explain why Callum's statement would earn no marks as a hypothesis.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 35
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | it is written as a question rather than as a statement oe |
| B1 | a hypothesis must be a testable prediction that the data can support or fail to support, and a question predicts nothing, so it scores zero however well operationalised its variables are oe |
- Answer: It is phrased as a question, not as a statement. A hypothesis has to be a prediction that the data can support or fail to support, and a question makes no prediction, so it earns nothing even though both variables here are well operationalised.
Question 57 - How to Write a Hypothesis
Open the included worksheet
A psychologist investigates conservation of number in young children. Forty children aged five years each see two rows of eight counters. For half the children the counters in one row are spread further apart while the child watches; for the other half neither row is altered. Each child is then asked whether the two rows contain the same number of counters, and the psychologist records whether the child answers correctly.
Oliwia writes: 'Children who watch one row being spread out will answer correctly less often than children whose rows are not altered.'
Maja writes: 'Spreading one row of counters out will change the answers children give compared with leaving both rows unaltered.'
Leo writes: 'To investigate whether spreading out a row of counters affects conservation of number in five year olds.'
Rank these three statements from the highest scoring to the lowest scoring as answers to 'Write a suitable hypothesis for this study', and justify your ranking.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 57
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | correct order: Oliwia highest, then Maja, then Leo lowest |
| B1 | Oliwia scores highest because she gives a clear directional prediction naming both conditions of the IV and an operationalised DV, whether the child answers correctly oe |
| B1 | Leo scores lowest because his statement is an aim, which earns zero, whereas Maja names both conditions and so reaches the one-mark tier, operationalising neither variable oe |
- Answer: Oliwia, then Maja, then Leo. Oliwia gives a clear directional prediction with both conditions of the independent variable and an operationalised dependent variable, so 3 marks. Maja names both conditions but operationalises neither variable, so 1 mark. Leo has written an aim rather than a prediction, so 0.
Question 8 - Ethical Implications of Research Studies and Theory
Open the included worksheet
Explain how historic misuse of psychiatric classification, for example labelling homosexuality as a disorder, illustrates Sieber and Stanley's concern about how findings may be interpreted and applied.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 8
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| M1 | identifies that past psychiatric classifications were used to justify discrimination and policy against groups oe |
| A1 | explains that such classifications were framed as scientific authority, which made public and institutional discrimination seem justified oe |
| A1 | links this to Sieber and Stanley: shows how interpretation and application of findings can create social harm beyond the study itself oe |
| A1 | may note the lasting consequences, e.g. stigma, legal restrictions, and slow social change even after scientific reclassification oe |
- Answer: Labelling homosexuality as a disorder was interpreted as scientific endorsement of discrimination, helping to justify legal and social exclusion. This exemplifies Sieber and Stanley's worry that research and classification can be applied in ways that harm groups, producing long lasting stigma and policy consequences beyond the original research.
Question 5 - Ethical Implications of Research Studies and Theory
Open the included worksheet
A researcher finds a weak correlation between childhood nutrition and adult cognitive test scores in a large population data set. State three cautions the researcher should include in public communications to avoid misinterpretation.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 5
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| M1 | states a caution, e.g. note that correlation does not imply causation oe |
| A1 | adds a relevant statistical caution, e.g. state the effect size is small and much variance remains unexplained oe |
| A1 | suggests a practical caution, e.g. warn against using the finding to generalise to individuals or to justify policy without further evidence oe |
- Answer: E.g. emphasise that correlation does not imply causation, report that the effect size is small and that most variance is unexplained, and warn against using the finding to make claims about individuals or justify policy without more evidence.
Question 7 - Applying Issues and Debates to Conformity and Obedience Research
Open the included worksheet
A newspaper links real-world abuse at a prison to findings from Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Experiment, claiming 'ordinary people became monsters because of the situation'. Evaluate briefly one strength and one limitation of using Zimbardo's findings to explain such real-world events, referring to the issue of determinism versus individual responsibility.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 7
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| M1 | strength: situational explanation is supported, e.g. Zimbardo shows situational factors can strongly influence behaviour so it helps explain how normal people may act abusively under certain roles |
| A1 | explains why this matters for understanding events, e.g. highlights systemic rather than only individual causes and informs institutional remedies |
| M1 | limitation: overgeneralisation or ecological validity problem, e.g. the simulated prison and real prisons differ in scale, context and oversight |
| A1 | explains consequence for responsibility, e.g. relying solely on situational determinism risks excusing individuals and neglecting dispositional differences and accountability |
- Answer: Strength: Zimbardo supports situational determinism, showing how roles and environment can push ordinary people to abusive behaviour, which helps identify systemic solutions. Limitation: the simulated prison differs from real prisons, so applying the findings directly risks overgeneralisation and might underplay individual responsibility and dispositional differences.
Question 5 - Applying Issues and Debates to Conformity and Obedience Research
Open the included worksheet
An investigator argues that publishing dramatic examples of obedience research risks social harm by normalising abuse. Analyse two ways researchers might present results to reduce this risk while still informing policy, referring to the publication context.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 5
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| M1 | first way identified, e.g. contextualising findings with clear limitations about sample and setting |
| A1 | analysis of effect, e.g. prevents overgeneralisation and reduces risk of normalising extreme behaviours as inevitable |
| M1 | second way identified, e.g. emphasising actionable recommendations for policy and safeguards rather than deterministic headlines |
| A1 | analysis of effect, e.g. focuses attention on prevention and responsibility, guiding policy to reduce harm |
| M1 | development, e.g. use careful language, avoid sensationalist framing, and include voices of affected groups |
| A1 | analysis of overall benefit, e.g. this maintains informative value for policymakers while reducing social sensitivity and potential misuse |
- Answer: Researchers can contextualise findings with clear limits on sample and setting to avoid implying inevitability, and emphasise practical safeguards and policy recommendations rather than sensationalist conclusions. Using careful, non-sensational language and including stakeholder perspectives helps inform policy while reducing the risk of normalising abuse.