Work and Welfare: Changing Work, Worklessness and Welfare Policy - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Work and Welfare: Changing Work, Worklessness and Welfare Policy revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Sociology practice
This topic is chapter 16 of A Level Sociology Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 32 of A Level Sociology 10-Minute Tests.
8.2 Work and Welfare: Changing Work, Worklessness and Welfare Policy
Question 1
- identifies one criticism, e.g. retraining alone does not improve the security of available jobsB1
- explains using Item A, e.g. courses could address the stated digital-skill and qualification gaps, but cannot by themselves turn mainly part-time service and gig vacancies with no guaranteed hours into secure employmentB1
- identifies a second criticism, e.g. practical barriers such as transport or childcare difficulties can prevent access to work even after retrainingB1
- explains with development, e.g. if workers cannot travel to jobs or arrange childcare, gaining relevant skills will not enable them to take those jobs without additional supportB1
- Answer: One criticism is that retraining alone does not improve job security. Item A reports gaps in digital skills and formal qualifications, so courses could help, but they cannot by themselves turn mainly part-time service and gig vacancies with no guaranteed hours into secure employment. A second criticism is that practical barriers can prevent access to work even after retraining. For example, if workers cannot travel to jobs or arrange childcare, gaining relevant skills will not enable them to take those jobs without additional support. These possible barriers come from sociological knowledge rather than being stated in Item A.
Question 2
- identifies an ethical issue, e.g. risk of punishing vulnerable people who cannot meet conditions due to illness or caring responsibilitiesB1
- development, e.g. sanctions could push people into poverty or harm wellbeing if safeguards are inadequateB1
- Answer: An ethical issue is the risk of punishing vulnerable claimants who cannot meet conditions because of illness or caring duties; sanctions could push these people into poverty or harm their wellbeing if safeguards are insufficient.
Question 3
- identifies a feature, e.g. Universal Credit combines several means-tested benefits into one monthly paymentB1
- development, e.g. it merges jobseeker's allowance, housing benefit and tax credits among othersB1
- identifies a second feature, e.g. has stronger conditionality and an emphasis on moving claimants into workB1
- development, e.g. claimants must show job search activity and can face sanctions if they do notB1
- Answer: Universal Credit combines several means-tested benefits into one monthly payment, merging payments such as jobseeker's allowance and housing benefit, and emphasises stronger conditionality by requiring claimants to show job search activity and potentially face sanctions.
Question 4
- identifies pluralism as support for mixed provision from state, market and voluntary sectorsB1
- explains pluralist idea that diversity allows choice and fills gaps state provision may not coverB1
- identifies residualism as favouring minimal state role and support only as a last resortB1
- explains residualists argue extensive universal welfare can reduce personal responsibility and be unaffordableB1
- Answer: Pluralists support mixed welfare provision from state, market and voluntary sectors, arguing diversity gives choice and fills gaps, while residualists favour a minimal state role providing support only as a last resort, arguing that universal provision can reduce personal responsibility and be unaffordable.
Question 5
- identifies reason one, e.g. monthly payment timing can be problematic for people used to weekly wagesB1
- explains development, e.g. large monthly payments followed by delays or advances can cause budgeting difficulties and risk of rent arrearsB1
- identifies reason two, e.g. strict conditionality and sanctions can reduce income security when employment is unpredictableB1
- explains development, e.g. low-paid or gig work with variable hours can make meeting conditions hard, risking sanctions and loss of incomeB1
- Answer: Monthly payment timing can cause budgeting problems for workers used to weekly pay, risking rent arrears, and strict conditionality with sanctions can reduce income security for those in unstable or variable-hour work who may struggle to meet requirements.
Question 6
- Level 1 Simple, limited points about welfare-to-work policies, with little development. May describe a single policy without linking to sociological perspectives or provide unsupported assertion about effectiveness.1-3
- Level 2 Some relevant knowledge and application. Describes welfare-to-work policies and gives basic reasons why they might help, with limited use of sociological perspectives or evidence. Some attempt at evaluation, but unbalanced.4-6
- Level 3 Clear knowledge and application. Explains how welfare-to-work policies can reduce worklessness using sociological ideas such as human capital and behaviourist approaches, and offers criticisms from structural and feminist perspectives. Some balanced assessment and examples.7-9
- Level 4 Comprehensive, well-developed response with effective evaluation. Uses competing sociological perspectives, for example New Right support for conditionality, social democratic or structural critiques that stress job creation and local investment, and feminist concerns about care responsibilities. Reaches a supported conclusion on how far welfare-to-work policies alone are sufficient.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Points that support welfare-to-work policies: conditionality can motivate active job search; training increases skills and employability; wage subsidies reduce employer risk and create opportunities; policymakers can target support to local needs.
- New Right perspective: supports conditionality and work incentives, arguing benefits should encourage work and reduce dependency.
- Human capital perspective: emphasises reskilling and training to match employer needs, improving long-term prospects.
- Structural criticisms: decline in local job opportunities, automation and lack of investment mean training alone cannot create jobs; need for demand-side policies and regional investment.
- Feminist critique: welfare-to-work can punish carers if childcare and caring responsibilities are not addressed; conditionality may unfairly sanction those with caring duties.
- Practical and ethical issues: sanctions can increase hardship, digital access and budgeting challenges under Universal Credit may limit policy effectiveness.
- Evidence from Item-like contexts: where vacancies are low or insecure (gig work), wage subsidies and retraining may have limited effect unless job quality and availability improve.
- Conclusion should weigh perspectives, recognising welfare-to-work can be part of a solution but is unlikely to be sufficient on its own without job creation, supportive services and safeguards.
Question 7
- identifies reskilling as workers learning new skills to adapt to changes in technology or job requirements (oe)B1
- development, e.g. retraining to use new software or to move from manual tasks to more technical tasksB1
- Answer: Reskilling is workers learning new skills to adapt to changes in technology or job requirements, for example retraining to use new software or to move from manual tasks to more technical roles.
Question 8
- identifies a feature, e.g. short-term, task-based work accessed through digital platformsB1
- development, e.g. workers may have flexible hours and choose tasks through an appB1
- further development, e.g. often limited employment rights such as sick pay or guaranteed hoursB1
- Answer: The gig economy involves short-term, task-based work accessed through digital platforms; workers often have flexible hours and choose tasks via apps, but typically have limited employment rights like no sick pay or guaranteed hours.
Question 9
- identifies one reason, e.g. structural economic change reducing demand for certain jobsB1
- explains how the decline of industries like manufacturing leads to job losses and localised unemploymentB1
- identifies a second reason, e.g. individual-level barriers such as lack of skills or qualificationsB1
- explains how lacking relevant skills makes it harder for someone to find new work, prolonging unemploymentB1
- Answer: Structural economic change can reduce demand for certain jobs, for example decline in local manufacturing causes job losses and local unemployment; individual barriers like lack of skills or qualifications make it harder to find new roles, prolonging unemployment.
Question 10
- identifies Beveridge as advocating a universal welfare state providing benefits to prevent the 'five giants' of want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idlenessB1
- development, e.g. universal provision paid from taxation designed to support citizens across the life courseB1
- Answer: The Beveridge model advocates a universal welfare state providing benefits to prevent the 'five giants' (want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness), with universal provision paid from taxation to support citizens across the life course.
Question 11
- identifies a problem, e.g. matching training to local job vacanciesB1
- development, e.g. training may not fit the types of jobs available, leaving people trained for skills employers do not needB1
- further point, e.g. transport or childcare barriers can prevent people from taking jobs even if vacancies existB1
- Answer: A practical problem is matching training to local job vacancies: training may not fit local employer needs, and factors like transport or childcare can prevent people taking available jobs even when they have new skills.
Question 12
- (a) a correct barrier, e.g. lack of digital skillsB1
- (a) a second correct barrier, e.g. local vacancies are mainly part-time or gig work with no guaranteed hoursB1
- (a) Answer: Lack of digital skills, and that local vacancies are mainly part-time or gig jobs with no guaranteed hours.
- (b) identifies how a wage subsidy could make employers more willing to hireB1
- (b) explains development, e.g. reducing employers' costs could lead to more part-time hires and quicker re-employment for redundant workersB1
- (b) Answer: A wage subsidy could make employers more willing to hire by reducing their costs, which may increase part-time offers and help redundant workers regain employment more quickly.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.