Work, Poverty and Welfare: Explanations and Measurement of Poverty - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
11 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Work, Poverty and Welfare: Explanations and Measurement of Poverty revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Sociology practice
This topic is chapter 15 of A Level Sociology Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 31 of A Level Sociology 10-Minute Tests.
8.1 Work, Poverty and Welfare: Explanations and Measurement of Poverty
Question 1
- definition: identifies life chances as opportunities individuals have to improve their quality of life and access resourcesB1
- applies the concept to poverty, e.g. limited life chances due to low status, poor education or weak marketable skills reduce access to well-paid jobsB1
- development, e.g. this explains poverty as a result of unequal distribution of economic and social resources rather than individual moral failureB1
- Answer: Life chances are the opportunities individuals have to improve their quality of life and access resources; limited life chances, through low status, poor education or weak marketable skills, reduce access to well-paid jobs and so help explain poverty as a result of unequal distribution of economic and social resources.
Question 2
- identifies suitable evidence, e.g. longitudinal data showing intergenerational unemployment and welfare dependence in certain areasB1
- explains why it is relevant, e.g. such evidence would support or challenge the claim that poverty and family breakdown persist across generationsB1
- Answer: A sociologist could use longitudinal data tracking families to see if unemployment and welfare dependence persist across generations in certain areas; this would test Murray's claim that an underclass culture perpetuates poverty across generations.
Question 3
- identifies a genuine strength, e.g. captures different aspects of living standards and social participationB1
- brief development, e.g. this provides a fuller picture of exclusion than income aloneB1
- Answer: A strength is that a multidimensional measure captures different aspects of living standards and social participation, providing a fuller picture of exclusion than income alone.
Question 4
- identifies first limitation, e.g. childcare provision and costs limit womens ability to increase paid workB1
- develops first limitation, e.g. even if childcare funding increases, part-time low paid jobs and employer practices may persistB1
- identifies second limitation, e.g. pension rules and fragmented employment histories make reducing old-age female poverty difficultB1
- develops second limitation, e.g. policy changes to pensions require long lead times and face political resistanceB1
- Answer: Two limitations are that insufficient affordable childcare and persistent low pay in part-time work limit womens ability to increase paid work, and that fragmented employment histories and pension rules make reducing old-age female poverty difficult, since pension reform is complex and slow.
Question 5
- Level 1 Basic statements about causes of poverty with little development or use of sociological perspectives. Limited or no evaluation and a weak or no conclusion.1-3
- Level 2 Clear description of one or two explanations, for example structural factors and cultural explanations, with some use of sociological ideas. Limited evaluation of strengths and weaknesses and a simple conclusion.4-6
- Level 3 Good analysis of competing views: clear explanation of structural accounts such as Marxist and Weberian arguments and cultural or individualist accounts such as New Right explanations. Relevant evidence or examples used. Balanced evaluation showing understanding of limitations on both sides.7-9
- Level 4 Excellent analysis and evaluation, comparing Marxist, Weberian and structural accounts with New Right and cultural explanations, and feminist perspectives on gendered poverty. Discussion of empirical evidence and methodological issues, recognition of complexity and interaction between structure and agency, and a supported, well-reasoned conclusion.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Structural explanations: Marxist view of capitalism producing low pay, insecure employment and spatial concentration of poverty; Weberian life chances showing how class, status and party affect access to resources.
- New Right and cultural explanations: Murray's underclass and culture of dependency, claim that attitudes, family breakdown and welfare dependency reduce employment incentives and perpetuate poverty.
- Feminist perspective: feminisation of poverty shows structural factors intersect with gendered roles and labour market inequalities to produce gendered patterns of poverty.
- Evidence and evaluation: use of longitudinal studies, regional unemployment data and measures of material deprivation to assess structural causes; criticisms of cultural explanations for blaming the poor and insufficiently accounting for economic restructuring.
- Interactionist or nuanced approaches: some sociologists argue for a combination of factors, where structural economic change produces conditions in which certain cultural patterns emerge, so structure and agency interact.
- Methodological issues: difficulties in proving causation, limits of income-thresholds versus multidimensional measures, and the role of ideology in shaping policy responses.
- Conclusion should weigh the relative explanatory power of structural factors against cultural and individual explanations and argue a justified position, for example that structure provides the primary cause but culture and agency shape outcomes and policy effects.
Question 6
- identifies that relative poverty compares someone's resources to the standard of living in their society, not a fixed minimumB1
- development, e.g. often operationalised as having income below a percentage of median income, for example below 60% of median household incomeB1
- Answer: Relative poverty compares a person or household's resources to the standard of living in their society; it is often measured as having income below a set percentage of median household income, for example below 60% of the median.
Question 7
- identifies a weakness, e.g. responses are influenced by personal expectations and cultural normsB1
- explains the weakness, e.g. two people with similar incomes might answer differently so the measure lacks objectivity and comparabilityB1
- Answer: A weakness is that responses are influenced by personal expectations and cultural norms; two people with similar incomes might answer differently, so the measure lacks objectivity and comparability.
Question 8
- identifies first difference, e.g. Townsend uses multiple indicators of resources and living standards rather than income aloneB1
- develops first point, e.g. Townsend included lack of common goods, overcrowding and inability to afford social activitiesB1
- identifies second difference, e.g. Townsend emphasises socially perceived necessities and exclusion rather than a single income cutoffB1
- develops second point, e.g. his approach captures exclusion from ordinary living standards as judged against society's normsB1
- Answer: Townsend uses multiple indicators of living standards rather than income alone, for example lack of common goods and overcrowding, and he emphasises socially perceived necessities and exclusion rather than a single income cutoff, capturing inability to participate in ordinary social life.
Question 9
- identifies a criticism, e.g. a single national income threshold does not reflect regional differences in living costsB1
- develops that point, e.g. the same income may buy less in an area with higher prices, so households on similar incomes can have different living standardsB1
- identifies a second criticism, e.g. income alone does not show non-income resources or debtsB1
- develops second criticism, e.g. households on similar incomes may have different savings or debt repayments, leaving them with different resources to meet their needsB1
- Answer: A single national income threshold does not reflect regional differences in living costs: the same income may buy less in an area with higher prices, so households on similar incomes can have different living standards. Income alone also does not show non-income resources or debts: savings may help a household meet its needs, while debt repayments may leave another household on the same income with fewer resources.
Question 10
- first point: identifies that the 25% figure measures income below a numerical threshold whereas the 18% figure records absence of at least two typical goods or activitiesB1
- development of first point, e.g. savings or debt repayments could affect access to goods at a given income; the percentages alone do not show which households fall into both groupsB1
- second point: identifies that absence of typical goods or activities does not by itself demonstrate financial deprivation or inability to participate in ordinary social lifeB1
- development of second point, e.g. absence may reflect preference or other reasons rather than inability to afford the goods or activities; the 18% figure alone does not establish the cause or severity of deprivationB1
- Answer: First, the 25% figure identifies households below an income threshold, while the 18% figure records households lacking at least two typical goods or activities. Savings or debt repayments could affect access to goods at a given income, but these percentages do not show which households fall into both groups. Second, absence of typical goods or activities does not by itself demonstrate financial deprivation or inability to participate in ordinary social life. It may reflect preference or other reasons rather than inability to afford them, so the 18% figure alone does not establish the cause or severity of deprivation.
Question 11
- identifies first Marxist point, e.g. poverty results from capitalist exploitation where surplus value is taken from workersB1
- develops first point, e.g. low wages and insecure employment are structural outcomes of profit maximisationB1
- identifies second Marxist point, e.g. poverty is maintained by ruling class ideology and institutions that legitimise inequalityB1
- develops second point, e.g. education, media and the state reproduce ideas that blame the poor and justify low payB1
- Answer: Marxists say poverty arises from capitalist exploitation, where profit motives produce low wages and insecure jobs, and is reproduced by ruling class ideology and institutions such as education and media that legitimise inequality and blame the poor.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.