Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 12 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
24 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 12 revision guideMore 11+ English practice
This topic is chapter 6 of 11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 4.
1.2-12 Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 12
Mail Rail: The Railway Beneath London's Streets
Original non-fiction text written for Revision Library.
For most of the twentieth century, hidden more than twenty metres below the busy streets of central London, a secret railway carried millions of letters and parcels every single day. There were no passengers, no windows, and no daylight: only small, driverless electric trains rattling through narrow tunnels in the dark.
The Post Office Railway, later nicknamed Mail Rail, opened in 1927 after almost twenty years of planning and construction. Engineers had grown frustrated watching horse-drawn carts and delivery vans crawl through London's ever-worsening traffic, so they proposed something radical: a miniature underground railway built purely to move post, running six and a half miles between Paddington in the west and Whitechapel in the east.
The trains themselves were barely large enough for a person to sit inside comfortably, which was exactly the point; they were never designed to carry passengers, only mailbags. At its busiest, Mail Rail moved around four million letters a day, gliding silently beneath some of London's most famous streets while the traffic above crawled along, entirely unaware of what lay beneath.
"People are always astonished to learn how long it operated," explains Dr Isla Ferguson, a transport historian who has studied the railway for over a decade. "For seventy-six years, Mail Rail quietly kept the city's post moving, through the Second World War, through strikes, through decades of change on the streets above. Almost nobody who used the postal service ever gave it a single thought."
Despite its long service, Mail Rail was finally closed in 2003. Royal Mail decided that transporting post by road had become considerably cheaper than maintaining a private underground railway, its stations, and its ageing fleet of trains. For over a decade afterwards, the tunnels sat silent and unused, visited only occasionally by engineers checking that the structure remained safe.
In 2017, however, a short section of Mail Rail reopened to the public for the first time in its history, as part of a new postal museum built above one of its old depots. Visitors can now ride a small train through part of the original tunnel network, experiencing, in miniature, the same dark, narrow passageway that once carried the nation's letters. Some historians argue that the railway should never have closed at all, pointing out that London's road traffic has only grown worse since 2003; others maintain that reopening even a short stretch as a visitor attraction was a fitting way to preserve a genuinely remarkable piece of engineering history.
- A) Simple
- B) Compound
- C) Complex
- D) Minor
- A) Noun
- B) Adjective
- C) Adverb
- D) Preposition
Question 1
- Identifies the contrast between the smooth, silent movement below ground and the slow, unaware traffic aboveB1
- Explains that 'gliding silently' suggests the railway's quiet efficiencyB1
- Explains that 'entirely unaware' emphasises how completely hidden and unnoticed this remarkable system was, adding a sense of wonderB1
- Answer: The contrast between the trains 'gliding silently' below and the traffic that 'crawled along, entirely unaware' above emphasises the railway's quiet efficiency, and shows how completely hidden and unnoticed this remarkable system was, adding a sense of wonder for the reader.
Question 2
- Adds authority/credibility, since she is an expert (a transport historian) who has studied the railway closelyB1
- Makes the information feel more personal and engaging for the reader than a plain statement of factB1
- The specific detail within the quotation ('seventy-six years') emphasises how impressively long the railway operated, making the claim feel more vivid and convincingB1
- Answer: Including an expert's direct words makes the information more credible, since Dr Ferguson speaks from years of research into the railway; her specific detail about 'seventy-six years' of service also makes the achievement feel more vivid and impressive to the reader.
Question 3
- Transporting post by road had become cheaper than maintaining the underground railwayB1
- This included the cost of maintaining the stations and the ageing fleet of trainsB1
- Answer: Royal Mail decided that transporting post by road had become considerably cheaper than maintaining the underground railway, its stations and its ageing fleet of trains.
Question 4
- (a) CB1
- (a) Answer: C) Complex
Question 5
- Visitors ride through part of the original tunnel network, not a copy or modelB1
- They experience 'in miniature' the same dark, narrow passageway that carried the nation's letters, giving a direct, authentic connection to the pastB1
- Answer: Visitors ride through part of the actual original tunnel network, experiencing 'in miniature' the same dark, narrow passageway that once carried the post, giving them a direct and authentic connection to the past.
Question 6
- Identifies that the paragraph opens with positive/celebratory content (the museum, the chance to ride a train through the tunnels)B1
- Identifies that this is followed by two opposing expert viewpoints: some historians think it should never have closed, others feel reopening a short stretch was fittingB1
- Explains the effect, e.g. presenting both viewpoints one after another allows the reader to weigh up the debate for themselves, giving the article a fair, balanced conclusionB1
- Answer: The paragraph opens by describing the new museum and the chance to ride through the original tunnels, then sets out two opposing expert viewpoints: that the railway should never have closed, and that reopening a short stretch was a fitting solution. Presenting both views one after another allows the reader to weigh up the debate for themselves, giving the article a fair, balanced conclusion.
Question 7
- Identifies the connective 'however'B1
- Explains its effect, e.g. it signals a contrast between the railway's closure and the surprising, more positive news of its later reopeningB1
- Answer: The connective is 'however'. It signals a contrast between the railway's closure in paragraph 5 and the more positive, surprising news of its later reopening.
Question 8
- (a) Meaning close to 'annoyed or impatient because of being unable to change or improve a situation'B1
- (a) Answer: annoyed and impatient at being unable to improve a situation
- (b) Meaning close to 'moving smoothly and quietly, without effort'B1
- (b) Answer: moving smoothly and quietly, without effort
- (c) Meaning close to 'growing old, becoming worn through age'B1
- (c) Answer: growing old and becoming worn through age
- (d) Meaning close to 'to keep something safe from harm, decay or loss'B1
- (d) Answer: to keep something safe from harm, decay or loss
Question 9
- They were frustrated by horse-drawn carts and delivery vans crawling through London's worsening trafficB1
- They proposed a miniature underground railway built purely to move post, avoiding the traffic problemB1
- Answer: Engineers were frustrated by delivery vans and carts crawling through London's worsening traffic, so they proposed a miniature underground railway built purely to move post, avoiding the traffic entirely.
Question 10
- Because the trains were built only to carry mailbags/post, not passengersB1
- Answer: Because the trains were built only to carry mailbags, not passengers.
Question 11
- (a) CB1
- (a) Answer: C) Adverb
Question 12
- Identifies that the semicolon links two closely related independent clauses (each of which could stand alone as a sentence)B1
- Explains that the second clause develops or explains the idea introduced in the first, without needing a conjunctionB1
- Answer: The semicolon links two closely related independent clauses, without a conjunction; the second clause explains and develops the idea introduced in the first.
Question 13
- More than twenty metresB1
- Answer: More than twenty metres below the streets.
Question 14
- Around four millionB1
- Answer: Around four million.
Question 15
- The Second World WarB1
- Strikes (or 'decades of change on the streets above')B1
- Answer: The Second World War, and periods of strikes.
Question 16
- 2003B1
- Answer: 2003.
Question 17
- 2017B1
- Answer: 2017.
Question 18
- driverless electric trainsB1
- Answer: driverless electric trains
Question 19
- 1927B1
- Answer: 1927.
Question 20
- Six and a half milesB1
- Between Paddington and WhitechapelB1
- Answer: Six and a half miles, between Paddington and Whitechapel.
Question 21
- Level 1 Basic identification of purpose (e.g. to inform), with little or no use of evidence.1
- Level 2 Clear identification of purpose with relevant supporting evidence from the text.2-3
- Level 3 Well-evidenced explanation of purpose, showing how specific facts, dates and quotations build the writer's case across the whole article.4
- Indicative content:
- Purpose is to inform readers about Mail Rail's history, and to convey admiration for a remarkable, largely forgotten piece of engineering
- Precise dates (1927, 2003, 2017) and figures (six and a half miles, four million letters a day) give the article factual authority
- The historical detail (built to escape traffic, survived the Second World War) creates a sense of scale and achievement
- The expert quotation from Dr Isla Ferguson adds credibility and a human perspective to the historical facts
Question 22
- Identifies that the writer presents Mail Rail as a genuinely impressive feat of engineering, largely unnoticed by the public it servedB1
- Supports this with reference to specific detail, e.g. it moved around four million letters a day for seventy-six years, 'almost nobody... ever gave it a single thought'B1
- Explains that the closing paragraph, describing the museum and the ongoing debate about its closure, suggests the railway's legacy is still valued and discussed todayB1
- Answer: The writer creates the impression that Mail Rail was a genuinely impressive feat of engineering that operated almost invisibly, moving around four million letters a day for seventy-six years while 'almost nobody... ever gave it a single thought'. The final paragraph, describing the museum and the ongoing debate about its closure, suggests its legacy is still valued and discussed today.
Question 23
- Identifies that the chronological structure lets the reader follow the railway's whole story in a clear, logical orderB1
- Explains the effect, e.g. it builds towards the final debate about whether the closure was the right decision, which only makes sense once the reader understands the full historyB1
- Answer: The chronological structure lets the reader follow the railway's whole story, from its opening to its closure and reopening, in a clear, logical order. This builds towards the final debate about whether the closure was right, which only makes full sense once the reader understands the complete history.
Question 24
- Level 1 States a viewpoint with little or no justification; minimal or no textual reference.1-2
- Level 2 Gives a clear opinion supported by relevant reference to at least one viewpoint from the text.3
- Level 3 Gives a well-reasoned, developed opinion that engages with both viewpoints from paragraph 6, supported by precise textual evidence.4
- Indicative content:
- Case for agreeing: London's road traffic has 'only grown worse since 2003', suggesting the underground railway is needed more than ever
- Case for disagreeing: Royal Mail found road transport 'considerably cheaper', and the reopened section already preserves the railway's history for visitors
- Either viewpoint is acceptable if supported by precise evidence from the text
- Reward answers that weigh the historical/practical value of the railway against the financial reality described in paragraph 5
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.