Organisational structures and span of control - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
15 original exam-style questions - 5 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Organisational structures and span of control revision guideMore GCSE Business practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 13 of GCSE Business Topic Workbook 3 and chapter 14 of GCSE Business 10-Minute Tests 2.
4.1 Organisational structures and span of control
- A) The list of products a business sells
- B) The way a business arranges its staff into levels of authority and responsibility, often shown as a chart
- C) The total amount of money a business owes
- D) The advertising methods a business uses
- A) The number of hierarchy levels in a business
- B) The number of subordinates that report directly to one manager
- C) The distance between a business's head office and its branches
- D) The number of customers a business serves each year
Recommend whether Bramwell Logistics should go ahead with delayering across all 4 departments. Justify your answer using the figures and points made earlier in this pack.
Question 1
- B caoB1
- Answer: B
Question 2
- B caoB1
- Answer: B
Question 3
- one acceptable factor, e.g. how experienced/skilled the subordinates areB1
- a second acceptable factor, e.g. how complex or routine the work is, or how much time the manager has to supervise each personB1
- Answer: Any two, e.g. how experienced the subordinates are; how complex or routine the work is.
Question 4
- one acceptable way, e.g. giving department managers extra management trainingB1
- a second acceptable way, e.g. appointing team leaders among the warehouse staff, or introducing clearer written procedures/checklistsB1
- Answer: Any two, e.g. extra management training for department managers; appointing team leaders among warehouse staff.
Question 5
- (a) the number of levels of authority within a business, from the most senior to the most juniorB1
- (a) Answer: The number of levels of authority within a business, from most senior to most junior.
- (b) the route through which instructions/authority pass down from senior management to junior staffB1
- (b) Answer: The route through which instructions pass down from senior management to junior staff.
- (c) removing one or more layers/levels of management from a hierarchyB1
- (c) Answer: Removing one or more layers of management from a hierarchy.
Question 6
- (a) 24 supervisors caoB1
- (a) Answer: 24 supervisors.
- (b) 192 warehouse staff cao (ft from part a)B1
- (b) Answer: 192 warehouse staff.
- (c) 221 employees cao (ft from parts a and b)B1
- (c) Answer: 221 employees.
Question 7
- identifies the point, e.g. decentralising routine decisions to team leaders reduces the number of decisions each department manager must make personallyB1
- develops the point, e.g. this is especially useful with a wide span of control of 48, where one manager cannot make every decision themselvesB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. decisions can be made faster, closer to the warehouse floor, and team leaders may feel more trusted and motivatedB1
- Answer: Decentralising routine decisions to team leaders reduces the number of decisions each department manager must make personally, which matters with a span of control of 48; decisions are made faster and team leaders may feel more trusted and motivated.
Question 8
- identifies the advantage, e.g. each manager has a narrow span of controlB1
- develops the point, e.g. this means a manager can supervise, support and check each subordinate's work more closelyB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. leading to closer quality control and clearer promotion routes for staffB1
- Answer: A tall structure gives each manager a narrow span of control, so they can supervise and support each subordinate more closely, leading to closer quality control and clearer promotion routes.
Question 9
- identifies the advantage, e.g. there are fewer levels for a decision or instruction to pass throughB1
- develops the point, e.g. this makes the chain of command shorter, so messages reach warehouse staff more quickly and accuratelyB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. this can also mean fewer managers' salaries to pay, reducing overall staffing costsB1
- Answer: A flat structure has fewer hierarchy levels, so a shorter chain of command lets instructions reach warehouse staff more quickly and accurately, and fewer managers' salaries also reduce staffing costs.
Question 10
- 192 / 4 seen (ft from question 6b)M1
- 48 caoA1
- Answer: 48.
Question 11
- identifies the point, e.g. removing the supervisor layer shortens the chain of command between department managers and warehouse staffB1
- develops the point, e.g. messages and instructions no longer have to pass through an extra level, so they travel faster and are less likely to be distortedB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. this can improve communication and speed up decision making now that the layer of 24 supervisors has been removedB1
- Answer: Removing the supervisor layer shortens the chain of command between department managers and warehouse staff, so messages travel faster and are less likely to be distorted, improving communication and speeding up decision making.
Question 12
- (a) £28,800 cao (ft from question 6a)B1
- (a) Answer: £28,800.
- (b) (24 x 27,000) - 28,800 seen (ft from part a)M1
- (b) £619,200 caoA1
- (b) Answer: £619,200.
Question 13
- identifies the point, e.g. a span of control of 48 is very wide for one department manager to oversee directlyB1
- develops the point, e.g. this leaves the manager far less time to support, train or check the work of each individual warehouse workerB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. supervision and quality control could suffer, and staff may feel less supported, potentially reducing motivationB1
- Answer: A span of control of 48 is very wide, leaving each department manager far less time to support or check individual warehouse workers, so supervision and quality could suffer and staff may feel less supported.
Question 14
- identifies the point, e.g. the supervisor role, question 6a, was a step on the promotion ladder for warehouse staffB1
- develops the point, e.g. removing this layer removes that promotion opportunity from the business's structureB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. remaining warehouse staff may feel there is less chance to progress, which could reduce their motivation, even though some may instead value the wider responsibility of a team-leader-style roleB1
- Answer: The supervisor role was a step on the promotion ladder for warehouse staff, so removing it takes away that promotion route; remaining staff may feel there is less chance to progress and become less motivated, although some may instead value the wider responsibility of a team-leader-style role.
Question 15
- Level 1 Makes simple, undeveloped comments about the delayering decision, with little or no use of the pack's figures and no clear recommendation.1-3
- Level 2 Gives a developed argument for or against delayering, using some of the pack's figures, but does not fully weigh both sides or reach a clearly justified recommendation.4-6
- Level 3 Weighs the evidence for and against delayering, using the span-of-control, cost-saving and redundancy figures from this pack, and reaches a justified recommendation supported by that analysis.7-9
- Indicative content:
- For delayering: it produces a large net saving of £619,200 in year one alone (question 12b), and this saving would recur every following year without the one-off redundancy cost, since the ongoing salary saving is £648,000 a year.
- For delayering: a shorter chain of command (question 11) can speed up communication between department managers and warehouse staff, and decentralising routine decisions to team leaders (question 7) can help manage the wider span.
- Against delayering: a span of control of 48 (question 10) is extremely wide compared with the current supervisor ratio of 8 (question 6), risking weaker day-to-day supervision, slower support for staff, and lower quality control.
- Against delayering: removing the supervisor layer removes a promotion route for warehouse staff (question 14), which could reduce motivation and increase staff turnover, partly offsetting the financial saving.
- Judgement: given the very large and recurring financial saving compared with the one-off redundancy cost, a reasonable recommendation is that Bramwell Logistics should go ahead with delayering, provided it invests part of the saving in manager training and team-leader roles (questions 4 and 7) to manage the risks of the much wider span of control.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.