Impacts of Water Insecurity and Conflict Over Shared Rivers - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
15 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Impacts of Water Insecurity and Conflict Over Shared Rivers revision guideMore GCSE Geography practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 8 of GCSE Geography Topic Workbook 4 and chapter 1 of GCSE Geography 10-Minute Tests 3.
8.2 Impacts of Water Insecurity and Conflict Over Shared Rivers
'Economic interdependence and diplomacy make violent conflict over shared rivers unlikely.' Evaluate the extent to which you agree with this statement.
Question 1
- lack of reliable, sufficient or safe access to water for people and for agriculture within a basin, oeB1
- Answer: Lack of reliable, sufficient or safe access to water for people and for agriculture within a river basin.
Question 2
- waterborne disease outbreak, e.g. cholera or diarrhoeal illnessB1
- Answer: An outbreak of waterborne disease, for example cholera or diarrhoeal illness.
Question 3
- increased time spent collecting water, reducing time for education or paid workB1
- greater exposure to safety risks when travelling to distant water sources, oeB1
- reduced dignity and privacy where sanitation and water for hygiene are lacking, oeB1
- Answer: Increased time spent collecting water, reducing time for education or paid work; greater exposure to safety risks when travelling to distant water sources; and reduced dignity and privacy where sanitation and water for hygiene are lacking.
Question 4
- resource scarcity creates strong national interest, e.g. water is essential for drinking and irrigation, increasing stakes and willingness to act, oeB1
- asymmetric power and dependency, e.g. downstream countries may be much more dependent on the river so feel existentially threatened by upstream development, oeB1
- lack of effective legal agreements or mistrust, e.g. absence of a binding treaty on water sharing increases uncertainty and competition, oeB1
- political leaders may use water disputes to gain domestic support or distract from internal problems, raising rhetoric and tension, oeB1
- inability to resolve technical issues like filling schedules and drought management can lead to repeated crises and brinkmanship, oeB1
- Answer: Disputes escalate because water scarcity raises the national stakes and willingness to act; asymmetric dependency makes downstream states feel existentially threatened by upstream projects; the absence of binding agreements and mistrust increases uncertainty and competition; political leaders may use the dispute to gain domestic support, raising rhetoric; and inability to agree on technical issues like filling schedules can lead to repeated crises and brinkmanship.
Question 5
- Level 4 A thorough, well-balanced evaluation that uses accurate named examples (e.g. the Nile basin and GERD, other transboundary rivers), weighs evidence that economic interdependence and diplomacy reduce incentives for violence against counter-evidence such as power asymmetry, historical grievances and failed diplomacy, and reaches a justified, clear conclusion on the extent to which violent conflict is unlikely.7-8
- Level 3 A clear evaluation that considers both sides with relevant examples; the argument is reasoned and a conclusion is given, though some points may be less developed or supported.5-6
- Level 2 Some relevant points about how economic links and diplomacy can prevent conflict are made, or some counter-arguments are given, but the analysis is limited and the conclusion is generalised.3-4
- Level 1 One or two simple, relevant points are made with little development or no clear conclusion.1-2
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Arguments agreeing with the statement: economic interdependence creates mutual costs to conflict, for example shared water infrastructure and cross-border trade make states prefer negotiation; dams like GERD offer potential for regional electricity trade which creates incentives for cooperation.
- Diplomacy and institutions can provide mechanisms for dispute resolution, e.g. negotiations, technical committees and mediation reduce the risk of unilateral violent action.
- Arguments challenging the statement: where vital resources are scarce, states may accept high costs to secure supplies, especially if one state is highly dependent; downstream states like Egypt may feel existentially threatened and resort to coercive measures if diplomacy fails.
- Power asymmetry matters: a militarily stronger state can impose outcomes or threaten force, while weaker states may take risky actions to secure their needs.
- History and national identity can inflame disputes, with leaders using nationalist rhetoric and domestic politics making compromise difficult.
- Case-study detail: in the Nile basin, prolonged negotiation over GERD illustrates both diplomacy and ongoing tension; agreements on filling and drought management remain contentious, showing diplomacy reduces but does not remove the risk.
- A balanced conclusion weighs that economic interdependence and diplomacy lower the probability of violent conflict, but do not make it impossible where dependency, mistrust, weak institutions or acute scarcity persist.
Question 6
- contaminated water contains pathogens from sewage or animal waste, oeB1
- people drinking or using that water become infected, increasing diarrhoeal illness rates, oeB1
- Answer: Contaminated river water can contain pathogens from sewage or animal waste, and when people drink or use that water they become infected, increasing rates of diarrhoeal illness.
Question 7
- reduced crop yields due to insufficient irrigation or poor water qualityB1
- loss of livestock or reduced productivity from lack of clean drinking water for animalsB1
- Answer: Reduced crop yields from insufficient irrigation or poor water quality; and loss of livestock or reduced productivity because animals lack clean drinking water.
Question 8
- increased treatment costs or production shutdowns due to water contaminationB1
- Answer: Increased treatment costs or production shutdowns due to water contamination.
Question 9
- increased public spending on emergency water supplies or treatment works, oeB1
- loss of business rates or reduced economic activity if industry or agriculture decline, oeB1
- reduced tax revenue and higher welfare costs as households become poorer, oeB1
- Answer: Increased public spending on emergency water supplies or treatment works; loss of business rates or reduced economic activity if industry or agriculture decline; and reduced tax revenue with higher welfare costs as households become poorer.
Question 10
- chlorination or other treatment of drinking water suppliesB1
- Answer: Chlorination or other treatment of drinking water supplies.
Question 11
- one valid way, e.g. children are kept home to collect water from distant or safe sources, or children fall ill from contaminated water, oeB1
- linked effect on attendance, e.g. time for schooling is reduced because of water collection, or illness causes absenteeism, oeB1
- Answer: Children may be kept home to collect water from distant or safe sources, reducing time for schooling; alternatively, illness from contaminated water can cause pupils to miss school.
Question 12
- reduced habitat area and lower flows harming fish and invertebrate populations, oeB1
- linked detail, e.g. wetlands and riparian vegetation can dry out, reducing biodiversity, oeB1
- Answer: Reduced habitat area and lower flows harming fish and invertebrate populations; wetlands and riparian vegetation can dry out, reducing biodiversity.
Question 13
- households may need to buy bottled or tanker-supplied water when river supplies are unsafe or unreliable, oeB1
- this increases regular household spending, leaving less money for food, education or health, oeB1
- linked example or consequence, e.g. poorer families become more vulnerable economically and socially, oeB1
- Answer: Households may have to buy bottled or tanker-supplied water when river supplies are unsafe or unreliable; this raises regular spending, leaving less money for food, education or health, which increases economic vulnerability.
Question 14
- reduced flow means less dilution of pollutants, so concentrations of contaminants rise, oeB1
- this makes water harder to treat and increases health risks for downstream users, oeB1
- Answer: Reduced flow means there is less dilution of pollutants, so concentrations of contaminants rise; this makes water harder to treat and increases health risks for downstream users.
Question 15
- concern 1, e.g. reduced Nile flow affecting Egypt's water supply for population and irrigation, oeB1
- linked detail, e.g. Egypt relies on the Nile for over 90% of its freshwater needs historically, oeB1
- concern 2, e.g. control over timing and volume of releases from GERD affecting downstream agriculture and power generation in Sudan and Egypt, oeB1
- linked detail, e.g. sudden releases or prolonged filling periods could damage crops or reservoirs downstream, oeB1
- concern 3, e.g. long-term changes to sediment flow and river ecology that could harm agriculture and fisheries in Egypt, oeB1
- linked detail, e.g. sediment trapped by a large dam reduces nutrient-rich silt reaching downstream floodplain soils, oeB1
- Answer: Egypt is concerned that GERD could reduce Nile flow affecting its water supply for people and irrigation (Egypt historically relies on the Nile for the vast majority of its freshwater); it is also concerned that control over timing and volume of releases could harm downstream agriculture and power generation in Sudan and Egypt, and that the dam could trap sediment, changing river ecology and reducing nutrient-rich silt reaching downstream soils.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.