Issue Evaluation: Interpreting Resources and Reaching a Justified Decision - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
15 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Issue Evaluation: Interpreting Resources and Reaching a Justified Decision revision guideMore GCSE Geography practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 11 of GCSE Geography Topic Workbook 5.
10.8 Issue Evaluation: Interpreting Resources and Reaching a Justified Decision
Resources booklet: Rivermere
Rivermere is a fictional town. All places, features and figures in this booklet are fictional and were written for Revision Library as original teaching material.
Rivermere is a fictional town on the River Cheriton. Its council must choose between two flood-management options, Option A and Option B. Use the notes, Figure 1 and Figure 2 to answer the questions in this pack. Read the whole booklet before you start the questions.
NOTES ON THE TWO OPTIONS
Option A is a diversion channel. It would be dug across the floodplain at Proposed Site A to carry flood water away from the town.
Option B is a raised bank (an embankment). It would be built along the river bank at Proposed Site B, away from the marshes, to hold flood water back from the town.
The council can choose only one option. The costs and the number of houses protected are predictions.
FIGURE 1: Map of Rivermere
North is at the top of the map. The map is described feature by feature below. Each label on the map is in bold, exactly as it is written on the map.
River Cheriton: flows from the west (left) edge of the map to the east (right) edge, through Rivermere.
Floodplain: shaded, low-lying land on both banks of the River Cheriton. It is wide in the west and narrows towards the east. All land outside the floodplain is higher ground.
Rivermere Marshes (SSSI): marshland on the floodplain, on the north bank, in the west of the map. SSSI means Site of Special Scientific Interest, a legally protected wildlife area.
Proposed Site A: on the floodplain, on the north bank, immediately east of Rivermere Marshes (SSSI) and about 2.5 km upstream (west) of the town centre. No footpath or cycle route is marked at Proposed Site A.
Proposed Site B: on the north bank at the western edge of the town, about 0.5 km upstream (west) of the town centre and about 2.5 km downstream (east) of Rivermere Marshes (SSSI).
Town centre: on the north bank, in the east of the map.
Old Mill: on higher ground about 1 km north-west of the town centre, away from the river and outside the floodplain.
Public footpath: links Proposed Site B to the town centre. It is the only footpath marked on the map.
Planned cycle route: a route along the north bank of the River Cheriton from the town centre to Proposed Site B, where it ends. It is planned and has not been built yet.
FIGURE 2: Table comparing the two flood-management options
| Measure | Option A | Option B |
|---|---|---|
| What is built | Diversion channel across the floodplain at Proposed Site A | Raised bank along the river at Proposed Site B |
| Initial construction cost (thousand pounds) | 1,200 | 1,000 |
| Houses protected | 480 | 320 |
| Environmental impact score (1 = low impact, 10 = high impact) | 7 | 4 |
| Predicted annual maintenance cost (thousand pounds per year) | 25 | 8 |
| New jobs created | - | 25 |
| New footpaths (length in km) | - | 1.2 |
A dash (-) means that no figure is given for that option.
Question 1
- River CheritonB1
- Answer: River Cheriton.
Question 2
- on the floodplainB1
- Answer: Proposed Site A is on the floodplain.
Question 3
- identification of a sensitive feature, e.g. 'marshland', 'wetland', 'wildlife habitat' or 'protected site / SSSI', oeB1
- correct map label cited: 'Rivermere Marshes (SSSI)', 'Rivermere Marshes' or 'SSSI', oeB1
- Answer: SSSI, labelled 'Rivermere Marshes'.
Question 4
- reading the cost value from Table: 1,200 (thousand pounds) seen, oe (a correct answer with no working scores both marks)M1
- 1,200 thousand pounds, accept 1,200 or 1200 or 1.2 million pounds (i.e. £1,200,000) caoA1
- Answer: 1,200 thousand pounds, i.e. £1,200,000.
Question 5
- evidence for Option A maintenance cost from Table, e.g. 'Option A maintenance = £25 thousand per year' or similar, oeB1
- evidence for Option B maintenance cost from Table, e.g. 'Option B maintenance = £8 thousand per year' or similar, oeB1
- Answer: Option A maintenance cost: £25 thousand per year. Option B maintenance cost: £8 thousand per year.
Question 6
- Level 1 A few simple points about the pros and cons of the options are made, with limited use of the resources. The response may give an undeveloped judgement with little evidence.1-3
- Level 2 A balanced evaluation that uses the resources to compare benefits and drawbacks of both options, with some supporting evidence. A conclusion is given, but the justification may be limited.4-6
- Level 3 A detailed, well-supported evaluation using specific evidence from the map and Table to weigh environmental, social and economic factors. A clear, justified decision is reached that considers trade-offs and long-term implications.7-9
- Indicative content:
- Use Table figures: construction costs, houses protected (480 for A, 320 for B), environmental impact scores (Option A = 7, Option B = 4), maintenance costs (Option A = £25k/yr, Option B = £8k/yr), social benefits such as jobs or new footpaths shown for Option B.
- Use map evidence: Option A is on the floodplain adjacent to Rivermere Marshes SSSI and could damage sensitive habitats; Site B links to the public footpath and cycle route, improving community access and leisure.
- Economic factors: Option A protects more homes, potentially reducing flood damage costs for more residents, but has higher initial cost and higher maintenance. Option B has lower initial and maintenance costs but protects fewer houses and so may leave some properties more vulnerable.
- Environmental factors: Option B has a lower environmental impact score and avoids the SSSI, supporting wildlife protection and long-term ecosystem services; Option A risks habitat loss and disturbance to the marshes.
- Social factors: Option B may bring community benefits such as new jobs and improved access, as shown in the Table; Option A may provide greater peace of mind to more homeowners by protecting more houses.
- Weighing trade-offs: consider long-term maintenance budgets, the value of the SSSI and ecosystem services, community access and wellbeing, and the number of properties protected when making a justified choice.
- A high-scoring response should reach a clear decision, for example recommending Option B if protecting habitats and long-term costs are prioritised, or recommending Option A if protecting the maximum number of homes is judged to be the priority, and should explain why other factors were less decisive.
Question 7
- calculation shown, e.g. 480 - 320 or 320 - 480 seen, oe (a correct answer with no working scores both marks)M1
- 160 houses caoA1
- Answer: 160 houses.
Question 8
- Option B has the lower scoreB1
- scores given, e.g. Option A = 7 and Option B = 4, oeB1
- Answer: Option B has the lower environmental impact score. Option A = 7, Option B = 4.
Question 9
- identifies a benefit to people listed in Figure 2 for Option B, other than houses protected: new jobs created, or new footpaths, oeB1
- gives the value shown in Figure 2 that matches the benefit named: 25 (new jobs) or 1.2 km (new footpaths)B1
- a developed point on how it helps people in Rivermere, e.g. gives local people work and income (jobs), or more places to walk and reach the river (footpaths), oeB1
- Answer: For example, Option B creates 25 new jobs (Figure 2), which gives local people work and income. (Alternatively: 1.2 km of new footpaths, which gives more places to walk.)
Question 10
- reason 1, e.g. Site B is adjacent to the public footpath linking to town centre, oeB1
- reason 2, e.g. Site B has direct access to the planned cycle route along the river, or Site B is about 0.5 km from the town centre compared with about 2.5 km for Site A, oeB1
- Answer: Site B is next to the public footpath linking to the town centre, making it more walkable for residents; it also has direct access to the planned cycle route along the river, improving sustainable access.
Question 11
- calculation shown, e.g. (cost in thousands x 1000) / number of houses, oe (a correct answer with no working scores both marks)M1
- £3,125 caoA1
- Answer: £3,125.
Question 12
- reason 1, any one of the reasons below, supported by a Figure 1 or Figure 2 fact: lower environmental impact score (4 v 7) / away from Rivermere Marshes (SSSI); lower initial cost (1,000 v 1,200 thousand pounds); lower annual maintenance (8 v 25 thousand pounds a year); 25 new jobs; 1.2 km of new footpaths; links to the public footpath / planned cycle route, oeB1
- reason 2, a different reason from the list in the line above, supported by a Figure 1 or Figure 2 fact, oeB1
- Answer: Because Option B has a lower environmental impact score and avoids harming the Rivermere Marshes SSSI, and because it has lower annual maintenance costs (£8k vs £25k), reducing long-term spending.
Question 13
- advantage, e.g. protects a larger number of houses (480) or reduces flood risk to the town centre, with evidence from Table or map, oeB1
- disadvantage, e.g. high environmental impact on floodplain habitats near Rivermere Marshes or disturbance to an SSSI, with map reference, or a higher initial cost (1,200 v 1,000 thousand pounds) or higher annual maintenance (25 v 8 thousand pounds a year) than Option B, oeB1
- clear linkage between the evidence and the stated advantage or disadvantage, oeB1
- Answer: Advantage: Option A would protect more houses (480), reducing flood risk to a larger part of the town. Disadvantage: building a diversion channel on the floodplain could damage floodplain habitats close to the Rivermere Marshes SSSI.
Question 14
- environmental advantage, e.g. less disturbance to the Rivermere Marshes SSSI or floodplain habitats, linked to map location of marshes, oeB1
- economic disadvantage, e.g. Option B protects fewer houses (320) so cost per house is higher or less overall protection, linked to Table figures, oeB1
- explicit use of evidence from the resources to support both points, oeB1
- Answer: Environmental advantage: Option B keeps defences away from the Rivermere Marshes SSSI on the floodplain, so it causes less damage to sensitive habitats. Economic disadvantage: Option B protects fewer houses (320), raising the cost per house and giving less overall protection compared with Option A (evidence from the Table).
Question 15
- point about recreational access for Option A or B, e.g. no footpath or cycle route is marked at Proposed Site A and Figure 2 gives no new footpath length for Option A, so it adds little or no recreational access; Site A is about 2.5 km from the town centre, oeB1
- point about recreational access for the other option, e.g. Site B already links to a footpath and cycle route so Option B enhances community access, linked to map, oeB1
- point about wildlife habitat for Option A or B, e.g. Option A on floodplain may damage marsh habitats and SSSI, linked to map and environmental impact score, oeB1
- point about wildlife habitat for the other option, e.g. Option B avoids the marshes, reducing habitat damage (environmental impact score 4 v 7), with evidence, oeB1
- Answer: Recreational access: Option B sits beside the existing footpath and planned cycle route in Figure 1, so it supports easy community access; Option A has no footpath or cycle route marked at Site A (about 2.5 km from the town centre) and Figure 2 gives no new footpath length for it, so it adds little recreational access. Wildlife habitat: Option A on the floodplain risks damaging the Rivermere Marshes SSSI and floodplain habitat (Table shows higher environmental impact score), whereas Option B keeps defences away from the marshes and so has a lower impact on key habitats.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.