Compensatory Education Policies and Closing the Achievement Gap - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Compensatory Education Policies and Closing the Achievement Gap revision guideMore GCSE Sociology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 5 of GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 4 and chapter 23 of GCSE Sociology 10-Minute Tests 2.
4.12 Compensatory Education Policies and Closing the Achievement Gap
Question 1
- identifies a correct aim, e.g. to raise pupil attainment in disadvantaged neighbourhoodsB1
- brief development, e.g. by encouraging partnerships between schools, businesses and community organisationsB1
- Answer: An aim was to raise pupil attainment in disadvantaged neighbourhoods, for example by encouraging partnerships between schools, businesses and community organisations to bring extra resources and expertise.
Question 2
- identifies a limitation, e.g. short term or variable quality of services across areasB1
- development, e.g. inconsistent provision means some centres have little lasting effect on school attainmentB1
- Answer: One limitation is the short term or variable quality of Sure Start services across areas; inconsistent provision means some centres may have little lasting effect on children's later school attainment.
Question 3
- identifies a method, e.g. longitudinal analysis of attainment data for disadvantaged and non disadvantaged pupils before and after Pupil Premium introductionB1
- gives an advantage, e.g. allows measurement of change over time and attribution of trends to the policy if other factors are controlledB1
- Answer: One method is longitudinal analysis of attainment data for disadvantaged and non disadvantaged pupils before and after Pupil Premium introduction; an advantage is it allows measurement of change over time and helps attribute trends to the policy if other factors are controlled.
Question 4
- identifies a similarity, e.g. both provide extra resources targeted at disadvantaged pupils or disadvantaged areasB1
- explains the similarity, e.g. extra funding is intended to allow additional teaching or support that raises attainmentB1
- identifies a second linked point, e.g. both aim to reduce barriers to participation and engagement in learningB1
- development, e.g. both rely on local implementation choices which affect their successB1
- Answer: Both Pupil Premium and Education Action Zones provide extra resources targeted at disadvantage so schools can offer additional teaching or support to raise attainment, and both aim to reduce barriers to participation and engagement, with success depending on local implementation choices.
Question 5
- identifies a short term outcome, e.g. improved test scores or better school attendanceB1
- identifies a long term outcome, e.g. higher rates of qualifications or improved employment prospects for disadvantaged pupilsB1
- Answer: A short term outcome is improved test scores or better school attendance; a long term outcome is higher rates of qualifications and improved employment prospects for disadvantaged pupils.
Question 6
- Level 1 Basic statements about compensatory policies with limited or no use of sociological ideas or examples. Little or no judgement on overall effectiveness.1-3
- Level 2 Clear description of one or two compensatory policies and some sociological reasons for their impact. Limited evaluation with some balance, but conclusions are simple or unsupported.4-6
- Level 3 Good explanation of how compensatory policies like Sure Start, EMA and the Pupil Premium can reduce barriers to attainment, and recognition of evidence showing mixed results. Some balanced evaluation using sociological concepts such as structural inequality and policy implementation differences.7-9
- Level 4 Detailed, balanced discussion using multiple sociological perspectives and evidence. Shows how policies have produced local successes but limited national narrowing of the class gap, explains reasons such as structural poverty, variable implementation, and the dark figure of need, and reaches a supported conclusion on how far sociologists would agree.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Descriptions of named policies: Sure Start (early years support), Education Action Zones (area based funding), EMA (payments to encourage post 16 participation), Pupil Premium (per pupil funding).
- Evidence of positive impacts: targeted tutoring raising attainment in some schools, Sure Start improvements in early language in some evaluations, higher post 16 retention where EMA operated, some schools reporting improved disadvantaged pupil outcomes with Pupil Premium.
- Evidence of limited or mixed impact: national data showing persistent class gaps in GCSE and A level outcomes despite policy waves; evaluations noting many schools showed little change; variable take up and variable quality of provision.
- Sociological reasons for limited impact: structural causes such as poverty, housing and health that education policy alone cannot solve; cultural factors and parental resources; stigma and low take up limiting reach.
- Policy implementation issues: variation between schools and local areas, short term funding cycles, targets focusing on measurable outcomes leading to narrow interventions, and accountability pressures distorting use of funds.
- Different sociological perspectives: functionalist view might argue targeted support increases meritocratic opportunity; Marxist or conflict perspectives would argue policies are limited because they do not challenge broader class structures and reproduce inequality; feminist perspectives might note gendered effects and the need for family support; interactionist points on how teacher expectations and labelling affect disadvantaged pupils.
- Methodological points: difficulty attributing causation, need for longitudinal studies, issues of selection bias and the dark figure of unmet need, and differences between quantitative attainment data and qualitative improvements in wellbeing.
- Reasoned conclusion weighing evidence and perspectives, for example agreeing that compensatory policies have produced important local improvements but that many sociologists would argue they have not, on balance, eliminated the class achievement gap nationally.
Question 7
- identifies a correct aim, e.g. to improve early childhood development and school readiness for children from disadvantaged familiesB1
- explains how this works, e.g. by offering childcare, parenting support and health services to boost language and social skills before schoolB1
- identifies a linked outcome, e.g. raising attainment at entry to school and reducing early gapsB1
- development, e.g. this early intervention is intended to reduce longer term class-based attainment differencesB1
- Answer: Sure Start aimed to improve early childhood development and school readiness for disadvantaged children by offering childcare, parenting support and health services to boost language and social skills before school, so reducing early attainment gaps that feed class differences later.
Question 8
- identifies a correct mechanism, e.g. EMA provided regular payments to low income students staying in post 16 educationB1
- explains how this reduces barriers, e.g. payments helped cover travel, books or lost earnings, making staying in education more affordableB1
- identifies a linked effect, e.g. increasing retention in further education among working class studentsB1
- development, e.g. higher retention should increase attainment and reduce long term class gaps in qualifications and opportunitiesB1
- Answer: EMA provided regular payments to low income students staying in post 16 education to help cover travel, books or lost earnings, making it more affordable to remain in education, increasing retention among working class students and helping reduce class differences in qualifications.
Question 9
- identifies a correct feature, e.g. targeted extra funding for schools in a specific deprived areaB1
- development, e.g. the funding could be used for specialist staff, after school programmes or community linksB1
- further development, e.g. zones aimed to coordinate local services to tackle educational disadvantage holisticallyB1
- Answer: Education Action Zones provided targeted extra funding for schools in specific deprived areas, used for specialist staff, after school programmes and stronger community links, aiming to coordinate local services to tackle disadvantage holistically.
Question 10
- identifies a plausible reason drawn from Item A, e.g. variation in how schools use the fundingB1
- develops with reference to policy, e.g. some schools may use Pupil Premium for targeted tutoring while others spend it on general resourcesB1
- links to outcome, e.g. targeted use is more likely to raise measurable attainment, explaining the difference between the 60 and 140 schoolsB1
- further development or alternative reason, e.g. baseline differences or pupil intake make some schools harder to shift in short timescalesB1
- Answer: One reason is variation in how schools use the Pupil Premium: some schools use it for targeted tutoring and small group interventions that raise measurable attainment, while others spend it on broader resources with less immediate impact. Baseline differences in intake or greater levels of disadvantage may also make some schools harder to improve quickly, explaining the mixed results in Item A.
Question 11
- identifies a valid criticism, e.g. EMA payments may not be large enough to remove all barriers for the poorest studentsB1
- brief development, e.g. students still face childcare, travel or living costs that limit true equality of participationB1
- Answer: One criticism is EMA payments may not have been large enough to remove all barriers for the poorest students; they could still face childcare, travel or living costs that limit equal participation in post 16 education.
Question 12
- identifies one reason, e.g. limited reach so not all disadvantaged families access servicesB1
- explains how this limits impact, e.g. non participants remain unsupported so overall class gaps persistB1
- identifies second reason, e.g. wider structural factors such as poverty and housing continue to affect developmentB1
- explains link, e.g. services cannot fully compensate for material deprivation that harms schooling readinessB1
- Answer: Sure Start may not close the gap because not all disadvantaged families access its services, leaving some children unsupported, and because wider structural factors like poverty and poor housing continue to affect early development in ways services cannot fully offset.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.