Worked question 17 - Crime Patterns by Class, Ethnicity and Age
Item E: Two wards, two pictures
A hypothetical scenario written for this exercise; the wards, figures and study described are entirely invented.
A student researching crime statistics for a class project compares two neighbouring, entirely fictional wards. In Ashfield ward, police stop-and-search rates for young people are three times higher than in Oakdene ward. However, an anonymous self-report survey of teenagers in both wards, carried out for the same class project, finds broadly similar levels of reported drug use in Ashfield and Oakdene. Ashfield also has a larger number of visible police patrols and CCTV cameras than Oakdene.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 17
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | identifies self-report studies as asking people directly, often anonymously, whether they have committed offences |
| B1 | explains this can uncover unreported or undetected behaviour, such as the drug use reported by teenagers in both wards in Item E |
| B1 | identifies that together these sources can reveal a 'dark figure' of crime that official statistics alone miss |
| B1 | explains this matters for interpreting patterns such as the Ashfield/Oakdene comparison, since official figures alone would have suggested a real behavioural difference between the wards that Item E's self-report evidence does not support |
| B1 | development, e.g. combining sources helps sociologists check whether a recorded pattern reflects real behaviour or policing practice |
| B1 | accurate use of terminology throughout |
- Answer: Self-report studies ask people directly, often anonymously, whether they have offended, which can uncover behaviour official statistics miss, such as the similar drug use across both wards in Item E; combining this with police-recorded figures shows that Ashfield's higher recorded stop-and-search rate does not reflect a real behavioural difference, revealing the dark figure that official statistics alone would have hidden.






