Secondary and Official Statistics - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Secondary and Official Statistics revision guideMore GCSE Sociology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 1 of GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 14 of GCSE Sociology 10-Minute Tests 1.
2.6 Secondary and Official Statistics
- A) covert participant observation
- B) official statistics
- C) unstructured group interviews
- D) a self-written questionnaire pilot
Question 1
- identifies that Durkheim compared official suicide-rate statistics between different countries, religions and social groups to look for patternsB1
- development, e.g. from these patterns he argued suicide rates were explained by differing levels of social integration and regulation, not simply individual psychologyB1
- Answer: Durkheim compared official suicide-rate statistics between different countries, religions and social groups to look for patterns, and argued from these patterns that suicide rates were explained by differing levels of social integration and regulation, not simply individual psychology.
Question 2
- identifies a genuine criticism, e.g. interpretivist critics such as Atkinson and Douglas argue Durkheim treated suicide statistics as straightforward objective factsB1
- development, e.g. when in reality they are shaped by the differing ways coroners in different countries/religions interpret and classify deaths, undermining the comparisons Durkheim madeB1
- Answer: Interpretivist critics such as Atkinson and Douglas argue Durkheim treated suicide statistics as straightforward objective facts, when in reality they are shaped by the differing ways coroners in different countries and religions interpret and classify deaths, undermining the international comparisons Durkheim made.
Question 3
- calculates the percentage increase in exclusions: (60-40)/40 x 100 = 50%B1
- identifies the news report's interpretation as treating the statistics as a straightforward, objective measure of worsening pupil behaviour (a positivist-style reading)B1
- identifies the change in recording policy as a key piece of contextual informationB1
- explains that at least part of the rise is likely to be a product of officials now recording incidents that would previously have gone unrecorded, not necessarily a real rise in bad behaviourB1
- explains this supports the interpretivist view that official statistics can be socially constructed, reflecting recording decisions as much as realityB1
- accurate use of terminology throughout (official statistics, socially constructed, positivist/interpretivist)B1
- Answer: (60-40)/40 x 100 = 50% increase in recorded exclusions. The news report treats this as straightforward proof pupil behaviour is worsening, but the Local Authority's change in recording policy means at least part of the rise likely reflects officials now recording incidents that previously went unrecorded, not necessarily a real change in behaviour, supporting the interpretivist view that official statistics can be socially constructed.
Question 4
- Level 4 A detailed, well-balanced evaluation that accurately explains BOTH the positivist case for official statistics AND the interpretivist critique of them, supported by accurate reference to Durkheim and to Atkinson/Douglas. Strengths and weaknesses are analysed, and a reasoned, supported judgement is reached. Sociological terminology is used accurately and consistently throughout.10-12
- Level 3 A clear evaluation that explains both the positivist case and the interpretivist critique, with some accurate detail. Some analysis of strengths/weaknesses. An attempt at a conclusion, which may be only partly supported.7-9
- Level 2 Some relevant explanation of official statistics, with limited development or accuracy. Little clear evaluation or comparison of views.4-6
- Level 1 One or two isolated, undeveloped points about official statistics, with little or no sociological terminology or accurate detail.1-3
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Positivist case: official statistics, such as those used by Durkheim in his study of suicide, are standardised, large-scale and free to access, allowing patterns to be tested scientifically.
- Positivist case continued: they cover whole populations or very large samples, giving a reliable, comparable basis for research no individual sociologist could otherwise afford.
- Interpretivist critique: statistics are socially constructed, the end product of officials' interpretive decisions, as shown by Atkinson's study of coroners classifying suicides and Douglas's related work.
- Interpretivist critique continued: recording practices can change over time or between areas, as illustrated by scenarios like Q12, meaning shifts in recorded figures may reflect administrative decisions rather than real social change.
- The dark figure problem, especially in crime statistics, means recorded figures can significantly underestimate the true scale of a behaviour.
- Evaluation: reliability is high, since official statistics are collected in a standardised way and can be checked/repeated, but validity is more contested, since figures may not measure what they appear to measure.
- A balanced conclusion should weigh official statistics' scale, cost and reliability against real concerns about their validity, noting sociologists often combine them with other sources, such as victim surveys, to check their accuracy.
Question 5
- identifies 'hard' statistics as official figures collected through a standardised, largely factual recording process, such as births, deaths or marriagesB1
- development, e.g. generally seen as more straightforwardly reliable than 'soft' statistics, such as crime figures, which depend more on subjective interpretationB1
- Answer: 'Hard' statistics are official figures collected through a standardised, largely factual recording process, such as births, deaths or marriages, generally seen as more straightforwardly reliable than 'soft' statistics, such as crime figures, which depend more on subjective interpretation.
Question 6
- identifies a genuine example, e.g. crime statistics, depending on police recording decisions, or suicide statistics, depending on coroners' judgementsB1
- brief development linking the example to Q14's definition of a soft statisticB1
- Answer: Crime statistics are a soft statistic, since whether an incident is recorded as a crime depends on police officers' judgements, not just what happened; suicide statistics are another example, depending on coroners' interpretive judgements.
Question 7
- calculates the change in recorded incidents: 156 - 120 = 36B1
- calculates the percentage change: 36/120 x 100 = 30% increaseB1
- identifies that a rise in recorded incidents could reflect a change in reporting or recording practices, for example more victims coming forward, or a police policy change, rather than a genuine rise in offendingB1
- concludes that recorded figures alone cannot show whether the true, underlying rate of the offence has changed, illustrating the dark-figure/social-construction problem with official statisticsB1
- Answer: 156 - 120 = 36; 36/120 x 100 = 30% increase in recorded incidents. However, this rise could reflect more victims reporting the offence, or a change in police recording practice, rather than a genuine rise in the offence itself, so the figures alone cannot prove the true rate has changed.
Question 8
- identifies a genuine additional source, e.g. victim survey data covering the same years and areaB1
- brief development, e.g. since victim surveys are less directly affected by police recording decisionsB1
- Answer: A sociologist could compare the figures with victim survey data covering the same years and area, since victim surveys are less directly affected by police recording decisions than police-recorded statistics.
Question 9
- (a) identifies a genuine advantage, e.g. they are free and quick to accessB1
- (a) development, e.g. and often cover a very large, sometimes whole-population sample that an individual researcher could never afford to survey themselvesB1
- (a) Answer: Official statistics are free and quick to access, and often cover a very large, sometimes whole-population sample that an individual researcher could never afford to survey themselves.
- (b) identifies a genuine disadvantage, e.g. they are collected for administrative purposes, not the sociologist's specific research questionB1
- (b) development, e.g. or the definitions used to collect them may change over time, making comparisons difficultB1
- (b) Answer: Official statistics are collected for administrative purposes, not the sociologist's specific research question, and the definitions used to collect them may change over time, making comparisons difficult.
Question 10
- identifies that interpretivists argue statistics do not simply record objective facts but are the end product of decisions and interpretations made by officialsB1
- development, e.g. whether an incident is recorded as a crime can depend on a police officer's judgement, not just what 'really' happenedB1
- further point, e.g. this means official statistics may tell us more about officials' decision-making than about the true scale of a behaviourB1
- further point, e.g. interpretivist sociologists such as J. Maxwell Atkinson studied the interpretive work coroners do when classifying a death as a suicideB1
- Answer: Interpretivists argue statistics are 'socially constructed', the product of decisions and interpretations made by officials, such as a police officer's judgement about whether to record an incident as a crime. This means statistics may reveal more about officials' decision-making than the true scale of a behaviour; Atkinson's study of coroners' interpretive work in classifying suicides is a classic example.
Question 11
- identifies a genuine method, e.g. using a victim survey, such as the Crime Survey for England and WalesB1
- brief development, e.g. alongside police-recorded figures, to get a fuller picture of crimeB1
- Answer: Sociologists can use a victim survey, such as the Crime Survey for England and Wales, alongside police-recorded figures, to get a fuller picture of crime than official statistics alone can give.
Question 12
- B (official statistics)B1
- Answer: B
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.