Observation: Participant, Non-Participant, Covert and Overt - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Observation: Participant, Non-Participant, Covert and Overt revision guideMore GCSE Sociology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 13 of GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 13 of GCSE Sociology 10-Minute Tests 1.
2.5 Observation: Participant, Non-Participant, Covert and Overt
- A) covert non-participant observation
- B) overt participant observation
- C) a structured interview survey
- D) analysis of official statistics
Question 1
- identifies overt participant observation as the researcher taking part in the group's everyday life while the group knows who the researcher is and that they are being studiedB1
- development, e.g. Whyte spent an extended period living in the neighbourhood and befriending gang members, who knew he was a researcher, to understand their way of life from the insideB1
- Answer: Overt participant observation involves the researcher taking part in the group's everyday life while the group knows who the researcher is and that they are being studied. Whyte spent an extended period living in the neighbourhood and befriending gang members, who knew he was a researcher, to understand their way of life from the inside.
Question 2
- identifies a genuine criticism, e.g. the close, long-term relationship the researcher builds with the group risks biasB1
- development, e.g. the researcher may become too sympathetic toward, or protective of, the people they have got to know, affecting objectivityB1
- Answer: Critics argue the close, long-term relationship a researcher builds with a group in studies like Whyte's risks bias, since the researcher may become too sympathetic toward, or protective of, the people they have got to know, affecting objectivity.
Question 3
- identifies the method as covert participant observationB1
- identifies a strength: because the group does not know she is a researcher, their behaviour is more likely to be natural, avoiding the Hawthorne effectB1
- identifies a further strength: joining in over several months should give her detailed, in-depth, valid insight into the group's norms and motivesB1
- identifies a problem: she cannot gain informed consent from the group, since they do not know they are being studiedB1
- identifies a further problem: recording observations from memory afterwards, rather than at the time, risks inaccuracy or selective recall, affecting reliabilityB1
- accurate use of terminology throughout (covert, participant observation, Hawthorne effect, informed consent, validity/reliability)B1
- Answer: This is covert participant observation. Its strengths are that the group's natural behaviour is unaffected by knowing they are watched, avoiding the Hawthorne effect, and joining in over several months should give detailed, valid insight into the group's norms. Its problems are that she cannot gain informed consent from a group unaware they are being studied, and recording observations from memory afterwards risks inaccuracy or selective recall, affecting reliability.
Question 4
- Level 4 A detailed, well-balanced evaluation that accurately explains BOTH the strengths and the problems of covert participant observation, supported by accurate reference to studies such as Whyte's and Patrick's. Strengths and weaknesses are analysed, and a reasoned, supported judgement is reached. Sociological terminology is used accurately and consistently throughout.10-12
- Level 3 A clear evaluation that explains both strengths and problems of covert observation, with some accurate detail. Some analysis and an attempt at a conclusion, which may be only partly supported.7-9
- Level 2 Some relevant explanation of covert observation, with limited development or accuracy. Little clear evaluation or comparison of views.4-6
- Level 1 One or two isolated, undeveloped points about observation, with little or no sociological terminology or accurate detail.1-3
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Strengths: because the group does not know they are being studied, their behaviour is more natural, avoiding the Hawthorne effect, and giving high validity.
- Strengths continued: covert methods can give deep access to closed or suspicious groups, such as the gang studied covertly by James Patrick in A Glasgow Gang Observed, who felt an overt approach would not have been possible.
- Strengths continued: extended, close involvement can produce rich, valid data on the group's own meanings and motives, as in Whyte's overt but similarly immersive Street Corner Society.
- Weaknesses: covert observation raises serious ethical problems, including no informed consent and no genuine right to withdraw, since participants do not know they are subjects of research.
- Weaknesses continued: the researcher risks 'going native', and evidence recorded from memory after the event, rather than at the time, can reduce reliability.
- Weaknesses continued: covert studies are usually small-scale and hard for another researcher to repeat exactly, making them low in reliability even where they are high in validity.
- A balanced conclusion should weigh covert observation's strength in validity and access for closed groups against its ethical problems and weaker reliability, noting the positivist tradition tends to favour more reliable, repeatable methods while the interpretivist tradition values the depth of understanding covert observation can offer.
Question 5
- identifies validity as the extent to which a research method actually measures or captures what it claims or intends to measure (oe)B1
- development, e.g. producing a true, authentic picture of what is being studiedB1
- Answer: Validity is the extent to which a research method actually measures or captures what it claims to measure, producing a true, authentic picture of what is being studied.
Question 6
- identifies that observation directly witnesses real behaviour as it happensB1
- development, e.g. rather than relying on what people say they do, as in a questionnaire or interviewB1
- Answer: Observation directly witnesses real behaviour as it happens, rather than relying on what people say they do in a questionnaire or interview, which is why it is generally considered high in validity.
Question 7
- checks the total: 21+6+3 = 30, matching the stated 30 observation pointsB1
- calculates the percentage on-task = 21/30 x 100 = 70%B1
- identifies that because the categories are pre-set and clearly defined, another researcher using the same schedule could repeat the observation and compare results directlyB1
- concludes this standardised, tally-based approach makes structured observation more reliable (comparable/repeatable) than an unstructured, descriptive observation would beB1
- Answer: 21 + 6 + 3 = 30, consistent with the 30 observation points. Percentage on-task = 21/30 x 100 = 70%. Because the behaviour categories are pre-set and standardised, another researcher could repeat the same tally and get comparable results, making this structured method relatively reliable.
Question 8
- identifies that the pre-set categories may be too simplistic and force complex behaviour into limited boxesB1
- development, e.g. losing detail or meaning that a qualitative, unstructured observation might capture, reducing validityB1
- Answer: Pre-set categories such as 'on-task'/'off-task' may be too simplistic and force complex behaviour into limited boxes, losing detail or meaning that a qualitative, unstructured observation might capture, reducing validity.
Question 9
- (a) identifies overt observation as where the group being studied knows the researcher's identity and purposeB1
- (a) identifies covert observation as where the group does not know, and the researcher's true identity/purpose is hiddenB1
- (a) Answer: In overt observation, the group being studied knows the researcher's identity and purpose; in covert observation, the group does not know, and the researcher's true identity and purpose are hidden.
- (b) identifies that it removes the risk of people behaving unnaturally because they know they are being watched (the Hawthorne effect)B1
- (b) development, e.g. the behaviour observed is therefore more natural, improving validityB1
- (b) Answer: Covert observation removes the risk of the Hawthorne effect, since people do not know they are being watched, so the behaviour observed is more natural, improving validity.
Question 10
- identifies a first problem, e.g. a gatekeeper, such as a group leader, may refuse the researcher entry or permissionB1
- development of the first problemB1
- identifies a second problem, e.g. some groups, such as criminal or deviant subcultures, may be dangerous or hard to approach without an existing personal connectionB1
- development of the second problemB1
- Answer: A gatekeeper, such as a group leader, may refuse the researcher entry or permission to study the group at all. Some groups, such as criminal or deviant subcultures, may also be dangerous or hard to approach without an existing personal connection to gain access.
Question 11
- identifies that the researcher stays detached and does not join in with the group's activitiesB1
- development, e.g. reducing the risk of losing objectivity or 'going native'B1
- Answer: In non-participant observation the researcher stays detached and does not join in with the group's activities, reducing the risk of losing objectivity or 'going native'.
Question 12
- B (overt participant observation)B1
- Answer: B
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.