Theories of Global Politics
Theories of global politics are competing explanations of how states behave in an international system that has no world government. The starting point is international anarchy: the absence of any authority above sovereign states that can make and enforce rules, which is not the same as chaos or constant war. Realism (classical thinkers such as Thucydides and Hans Morgenthau; structural or neo-realists such as Kenneth Waltz) holds that states are the main actors, that their first priority is survival, and that in a self-help system they rely on their own power. Anarchy produces a security dilemma, a term associated with John Herz, in which steps one state takes to feel safe look threatening to others and provoke counter-measures. Realists also stress relative gains: what matters is how much a rival gains compared with you. Liberalism (Kant, and later Robert Keohane and Joseph Nye on complex interdependence) accepts anarchy but argues that cooperation is possible and rational, because states, firms and international organisations share interests, trade creates mutual gains, institutions supply rules and information, and democracies tend not to fight each other. Hedley Bull's society of states idea sits between the two: states share rules and norms, such as sovereignty and diplomacy, which give anarchy a degree of order. Examiners test whether you can define these terms precisely, apply theories to dated developments since 2000, and weigh competing explanations rather than describe each one in turn.
Before you start
No prerequisites. You can start here.
Method
- Define the key term first and in one line (anarchy, security dilemma, relative gains, complex interdependence, society of states). A precise definition secures the knowledge marks before you apply anything.
- Attach every claim to a named theory and, where you can, a named thinker: Morgenthau for human nature and power, Waltz for the structure of the system, Keohane and Nye for complex interdependence, Bull for the society of states.
- Keep the reasoning chain explicit: assumption, then mechanism, then outcome. For example, anarchy and uncertainty about intentions, so a security dilemma, so arms racing, so insecurity even without aggression.
- Use a dated development as evidence and say what it shows for each theory. A development rarely proves one theory; a realist and a liberal can read the same event differently, and showing both readings is what analysis means here.
- For a 12-mark analyse question, build two or three developed paragraphs with a clear contrast between theories and include any synoptic link the question asks for, such as a link to a Component 1 ideology (liberalism and conservatism supply useful parallels).
- For the 30-mark evaluate essay, plan a thesis, two or three arguments for, two or three against with a rival theory, and a conclusion that gives a judgement about the extent of the claim, not a repeat of both sides.
- Never treat anarchy as meaning constant war, and never treat liberals as naive about power. Both slips are common and both cap the quality of analysis.
Worked example
Explain how a security dilemma could lead to a costly arms race between two neighbouring states that both claim to want peace. (4 marks)
- Name the starting condition: international anarchy means there is no higher authority to protect either state, so each is responsible for its own security (self-help).
- Describe the first move: State A increases its defence spending and builds up forces near the border to feel safer, and it sincerely regards the step as defensive.
- Show the uncertainty: State B cannot read State A's intentions, and capabilities that could defend can also attack, so State B treats the build-up as a possible threat.
- Complete the chain: State B responds with its own build-up, which State A now reads as confirming its fears, so both spend more and neither becomes more secure. Link to the term 'security dilemma' and note that neither state needs hostile intentions for this to happen.
- Check the answer against the marks: one mark for the anarchy and self-help point, one for the defensive build-up, one for uncertainty about intentions, one for the reciprocal escalation that leaves both worse off.
Practice questions
Q1Define the term 'relative gains' and say why realists think it makes cooperation difficult.Show answer
Answer: Relative gains means judging a deal by how much you gain compared with other states, not only by whether you gain at all. Realists argue that a rival who gains more could convert that advantage into power over you in an anarchic system, so states may refuse agreements that benefit everyone if the benefits are unequal.
Q2Which neo-realist wrote Theory of International Politics (1979), and what does he argue explains state behaviour?Show answer
Answer: Kenneth Waltz. He argues that the structure of the international system (anarchy and the distribution of power among states) shapes state behaviour, rather than human nature, which classical realists such as Morgenthau emphasised.
Q3Explain what liberals mean by complex interdependence.Show answer
Answer: Keohane and Nye's term for a world in which states are tied together by many channels (trade, investment, transnational firms, NGOs, institutions), in which military force is less usable and less central, and in which there is no fixed hierarchy of issues with security always on top. Because a break in these ties is costly for everyone, cooperation is more likely.
Q4Explain what the democratic peace claim is and which thinker is its main source.Show answer
Answer: Liberals argue that democracies rarely, if ever, go to war with each other, because of accountable leaders, public opposition to costly wars and shared norms. Its roots are in Immanuel Kant's essay Perpetual Peace (1795), which argued for republican government, a federation of free states and free trade.
Q5Use the Cold War arms race between the USA and the USSR to illustrate a security dilemma.Show answer
Answer: Each superpower built nuclear and conventional forces that it described as deterrence, but the other saw a threat and matched it. Both amassed far more weapons than either needed for security (tens of thousands of nuclear warheads by the 1980s) and both felt no safer, which is the pattern of a security dilemma.
Q6Explain how Hedley Bull's society of states differs from a purely realist account of international politics.Show answer
Answer: Bull (The Anarchical Society, 1977) accepts anarchy but argues that states form a society because they recognise shared rules and institutions such as sovereignty, diplomacy and international law, so there is order without a world government. A purely realist account stresses power and self-help and treats rules as weak constraints that follow state interests.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Politics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Q1[6 marks]Explain two ways in which liberal ideas about interdependence challenge the realist view of how states behave. (6 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[12 marks]Analyse the extent to which realism and liberalism differ in explaining why states cooperate in an anarchic international system. You must use at least one development since 2000 and make a synoptic link to an idea studied in Component 1. (12 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
See real A Level Politics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Theories of Global Politics worksheet pack - 3 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This worksheet is chapter 11 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 4, a free printable practice book.
Other versions of this worksheet: