A Level Politics Topic Workbook 4 includes The US Supreme Court: Role, Appointment and Judicial Philosophy (from page 3); Civil Rights in the United States: Race, Gender and LGBT+ Rights (from page 8); US Elections: The Electoral College, Primaries and Caucuses (from page 12); US Political Parties, Pressure Groups and Campaign Finance (from page 16); Comparative US/UK Constitutions: Federal and Unitary Government (from page 18); Comparative US/UK Legislatures: Congress and Parliament (from page 24); Comparative US/UK Executives: The President and the Prime Minister (from page 29); Comparative US/UK Judiciaries and Rights Protection (from page 33); Comparative US/UK Democracy and Participation (from page 39); US Voting Behaviour and the Participation Crisis (from page 44); Theories of Global Politics (from page 47); The State and Globalisation (from page 51); Global Governance: Political and Economic (from page 56); Global Governance: Human Rights and Environmental (from page 61); Power and Developments (from page 65); Regionalism and the European Union (from page 69).
Worked question 5 - Comparative US/UK Constitutions: Federal and Unitary Government
Open the included worksheet
Explain with examples how the US Supreme Court has limited the power of other branches through judicial review, referencing at least one landmark case such as Marbury v Madison. Briefly assess one constraint on the Court's ability to exercise this check.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 5
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies Marbury v Madison 1803 as establishing judicial review |
| B1 | explains Marbury significance, e.g. court asserted power to declare acts of Congress unconstitutional |
| B1 | identifies a modern example, e.g. decisions limiting executive action or striking down state laws |
| B1 | gives development of the modern example, e.g. examples such as United States v Lopez 1995 limiting Congress power under the Commerce Clause, or NFIB v Sebelius 2012 on the Affordable Care Act |
| B1 | explains consequence, e.g. demonstrates the Court can check legislature and executive by interpreting constitutional limits |
| B1 | provides a brief assessment of one constraint, e.g. standing requirements restrict which disputes the Court can hear, so it cannot review every disputed government action |
- Answer: Marbury v Madison 1803 established the principle of judicial review, allowing the US Supreme Court to declare acts of Congress unconstitutional. In modern times the Court has constrained other branches, for example United States v Lopez 1995 limited Congress's Commerce Clause reach, and NFIB v Sebelius 2012 placed limits and conditions on parts of the Affordable Care Act. These cases show the Court interprets constitutional boundaries and can nullify legislation or executive acts, though its power is constrained by issues of standing, judicial appointment politics and institutional caution. For example, standing requirements restrict which disputes the Court can hear, so it cannot review every disputed government action.
Question 2 - Comparative US/UK Constitutions: Federal and Unitary Government
Open the included worksheet
Explain one reason why the US Constitution is described as entrenched, with a brief reference to Article V.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 2
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies that entrenched means the constitution is difficult to change |
| B1 | refers to Article V and a requirement for supermajorities or state ratification to amend |
| B1 | explains consequence, e.g. entrenchment makes fundamental change slower and protects core rights and structures |
- Answer: Entrenched means the US Constitution is difficult to change because Article V requires an amendment to be proposed by two thirds of both Houses or a convention called by two thirds of state legislatures, and then ratified by three quarters of the states, which makes fundamental change slow and protects core institutions and rights.
Question 1 - Comparative US/UK Constitutions: Federal and Unitary Government
Open the included worksheet
In the context of US and UK constitutions, identify two formal sources of the UK constitution.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 1
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | one valid formal source, e.g. Acts of Parliament such as the Human Rights Act 1998 |
| B1 | a second valid formal source, e.g. common law or statute example such as the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 |
- Answer: Any two of: Acts of Parliament (statute) such as the Human Rights Act 1998, Constitutional Reform Act 2005; common law; treaties; Royal Prerogative exercised through statute or convention.
Question 1 - US Elections: The Electoral College, Primaries and Caucuses
Open the included worksheet
State what is meant by an open primary, a closed primary and a caucus in US nomination contests.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 1
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | States what an open primary is, allowing any registered voter to participate regardless of party |
| B1 | States what a closed primary is, limited to voters registered with the party holding the primary |
| B1 | States what a caucus is, a local meeting of party members to select delegates often involving discussion and rounds of voting |
- Answer: An open primary allows any registered voter to take part regardless of party; a closed primary restricts participation to voters registered with that party; a caucus is a local meeting of party members who discuss and select delegates through in-person rounds of voting.
Question 3 - Global Governance: Political and Economic
Open the included worksheet
A fictional development exercise compares a loan programme requiring rapid spending cuts and trade liberalisation with a poverty strategy prepared through consultations with local organisations. Explain one rationale and one possible drawback of the first approach, then one intended improvement and one continuing limitation of the second. Relate your answer to SAPs and PRSPs.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 3
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | Explains one rationale for SAP-style adjustment: spending restraint can stabilise public finances, or trade liberalisation can improve competition and market incentives. Credit another valid rationale linked to the first approach. |
| B1 | Explains one possible SAP drawback: rapid spending cuts can damage services or burden poorer households, or rapid trade liberalisation can expose domestic producers to competition and cause unemployment. Credit another valid drawback linked to the first approach. |
| B1 | Explains one intended PRSP improvement: participation in a country-led poverty strategy can improve local ownership or reflect local priorities. Credit another valid improvement linked to the second approach. |
| B1 | Explains one continuing PRSP limitation: consultation need not give local groups control because lenders, domestic elites or fiscal constraints can narrow policy choices. Credit another valid continuing limitation. |
- Answer: SAP-style spending restraint can stabilise public finances, but rapid trade liberalisation can expose domestic producers to competition and cause unemployment. PRSP participation can improve local ownership by reflecting local priorities, while lender influence can still constrain policy choices.
Question 2 - Global Governance: Political and Economic
Open the included worksheet
A fictional classroom summit exercise, dated October 2026, gives a G7 meeting a pledge to support emergency food imports. Two participating governments fund deliveries; another delays its contribution. Explain one route by which the pledge could help and one limit on treating it as an enforceable instruction. No real summit statement is quoted.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 2
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | Identifies one route by which the pledge could help, such as coordinating national resources for emergency food imports; accept another valid route grounded in the exercise. |
| B1 | Explains how that route could help: for example, the two funded deliveries contribute to food provision, or coordination can bring resources together to meet import needs. The printed deliveries are one possible illustration, not a compulsory example. |
| B1 | Identifies one limit on enforceability, such as the G7 having no formal mechanism to impose decisions or participating governments retaining control of contributions; accept another accurate limit. |
| B1 | Explains why that limit prevents the pledge guaranteeing action: for example, the delayed contribution shows reliance on national follow-through. Credit equivalent explanations; delivery by some governments still counts as partial achievement. |
- Answer: The pledge can coordinate national resources around emergency food imports. The two funded deliveries show a practical contribution to implementation in this exercise. The G7 has no formal mechanism to impose its decisions on participating states. The delayed contribution shows reliance on national follow-through; delivery by some governments still counts as partial achievement.
Question 3 - The State and Globalisation
Open the included worksheet
Using the 2007/2008 global financial crisis as your dated example, explain one advantage and one disadvantage of economic interconnectedness and give one reason why its impact on sovereignty need not be identical for every state.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 3
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | Advantage identified: cross-border finance can widen access to investment or spread financial risk. |
| B1 | Advantage developed: access to external funds can support activity beyond the resources available domestically; credit other valid developed benefits without claiming the crisis itself was beneficial. |
| B1 | Disadvantage identified: interconnected financial systems can transmit shocks across borders, illustrated by the 2007/2008 crisis. |
| B1 | Disadvantage developed: dependence on external credit or confidence can constrain national policy choices even where legal powers remain. Accept other valid developments, such as transmitted losses reducing lending and therefore investment or employment. |
| B1 | Explains uneven impact, for example states differ in financial exposure, resources or policy capacity. Credit an accurate reason linked to variation rather than claiming identical loss of sovereignty everywhere. |
- Answer: Cross-border finance supplies investment beyond domestic savings, supporting additional productive activity. In the 2007/2008 global financial crisis, financial links also transmitted losses and credit shortages internationally, constraining national policy choices even where legal powers remained. States differed in financial exposure and resources available to respond, producing unequal effects on practical sovereignty.