Global Governance: Political and Economic
Global governance is the set of institutions, rules and practices through which states and other actors manage problems that cross borders when no world government exists. Its political side centres on the United Nations (founded 1945): the Security Council has primary responsibility for international peace and security, has five permanent members (the USA, UK, France, Russia and China) who can each veto a substantive resolution, and needs nine of its fifteen votes to pass one; the General Assembly includes every member state, debates and recommends, and its resolutions are generally not binding. NATO (1949) is a collective defence alliance built on Article 5, the commitment that an armed attack on one member is treated as an attack on all, which has been invoked once, after the 11 September 2001 attacks. The economic side includes the IMF and World Bank (both stemming from the Bretton Woods conference of 1944), the WTO (1995, successor to the GATT of 1947), and summit groups such as the G7 and G20. Structural adjustment programmes (SAPs) attached policy conditions to loans from the 1980s; poverty reduction strategy papers (PRSPs) from 1999 were meant to give borrowers more ownership. Development theories you need to contrast are modernisation, neo-classical (market-led) and structuralist or dependency accounts. The North-South divide is a shorthand for inequality, not a precise map. Civil society, including NGOs, monitors and pressures institutions. The exam tests whether you can explain how institutions work, why they are criticised (unequal voting power, vetoes, conditionality) and whether reform could make them more effective.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Learn each institution as three facts: its role, its decision rule, and its main weakness (for example the Security Council: peace and security, nine votes and no veto, paralysis when a permanent member's interests are involved).
- Keep political and economic governance distinct and then connect them: the same powerful states often dominate both, which is why critics talk of unequal power.
- For development, state each theory's cause of poverty and its remedy: modernisation (lack of capital, technology and modern institutions, so follow the path of industrialised states), neo-classical (state interference and barriers to trade, so liberalise and privatise), structuralist or dependency (unequal trade and historical exploitation, so reform global rules or protect domestic industry).
- Evaluate conditionality fairly: SAPs aimed at fiscal discipline and open markets, and critics argued they cut health and education spending; PRSPs aimed at consultation but critics said the conditions stayed. Give both sides.
- Use dated examples to keep claims concrete, such as the Security Council's authorisation of force in Libya in 2011 (Resolution 1973), the G20's emergence as a leaders' forum after the 2008 crisis, and the WTO Appellate Body ceasing to function in December 2019.
- For reform questions, set the case for reform (more representative Security Council, rebalanced IMF voting) against obstacles (the permanent members would have to approve changes to their own privileges) and against alternative explanations of failure, such as state interests.
- For numeric items, such as poverty rates, calculate in percentage points where the question asks for a change in a rate, and name one thing the figure does not capture.
Worked example
Explain one limitation on the effectiveness of the UN Security Council as a body of global political governance, and say how it could be addressed. (4 marks)
- Choose the limitation and name it exactly: the veto held by each of the five permanent members, which can block any substantive resolution even if the other fourteen members vote in favour.
- Explain the effect: where a permanent member or its ally is involved in a conflict, the Council can be unable to authorise action, so its responsibility for peace and security goes unmet.
- Support with a dated example. In 2011 Resolution 1973 on Libya passed because Russia and China abstained rather than vetoed; in other crises since then vetoes have blocked draft resolutions on Syria. Use only an example you can describe accurately.
- Offer a reform and its obstacle: limit use of the veto in cases of mass atrocity, or extend permanent membership. Note that changing the UN Charter requires the support of all five permanent members, so those who benefit would have to agree to give up privilege.
- Check the marks: one for the limitation, one for its effect, one for the example, one for a reform with a note of its difficulty.
Practice questions
Q1How many votes does a substantive Security Council resolution need to pass, and what can prevent it?Show answer
Answer: Nine of the fifteen members must vote in favour, with no veto from any of the five permanent members. A permanent member that abstains does not block the resolution; only a 'no' vote from a permanent member vetoes it.
Q2State what NATO's Article 5 says and the one occasion on which it has been invoked.Show answer
Answer: An armed attack against one or more members is considered an attack against them all, and each will take the action it deems necessary. It was invoked after the 11 September 2001 attacks on the USA.
Q3State one difference between the roles of the IMF and the World Bank.Show answer
Answer: The IMF focuses on global monetary and financial stability, lending short-term to countries with balance-of-payments problems; the World Bank focuses on long-term development and poverty reduction, financing projects and programmes.
Q4What is the difference between a structural adjustment programme (SAP) and a poverty reduction strategy paper (PRSP)?Show answer
Answer: SAPs, used from the 1980s, tied IMF and World Bank loans to conditions such as cutting public spending, privatising and opening markets. PRSPs, introduced in 1999, required borrowing governments to prepare a national poverty strategy, supposedly with civil society consultation, to give more national ownership, though lenders still reviewed and approved them.
Q5In an invented classroom dataset a country has 12 million people at both dates. At the first date 3 million are below the poverty line; at the second, 1.8 million are. Calculate the fall in the poverty rate in percentage points.Show answer
Answer: First rate: 3 / 12 = 25%. Second rate: 1.8 / 12 = 15%. The fall is 25 - 15 = 10 percentage points. (This is a fall of 40% in the number in poverty, which is a different measure.)
Q6Explain what a dependency theorist would say is the main cause of underdevelopment.Show answer
Answer: That poor countries are held back by their position in an unequal global economy: they export cheap raw materials and import costly manufactures, and historical colonial relationships and unequal terms of trade transfer wealth to richer states. The remedy is changing those structures, not simply following the path of industrialised states.
Q7Explain why the North-South divide should not be treated as a precise geographic boundary.Show answer
Answer: It is a rough shorthand for wealth and power differences. Some Southern-hemisphere states, such as Australia and New Zealand, are rich, while many poorer states lie north of the equator; and emerging economies such as China and India have grown rapidly, so the grouping hides large variation within each side.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Politics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Q1[6 marks]Explain two criticisms of the World Trade Organization as a body of economic global governance. (6 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[12 marks]Analyse how the design of international institutions can both enable and restrict cooperation to resolve conflict and reduce poverty. Use the United Nations Security Council and the IMF or World Bank in your answer. (12 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
See real A Level Politics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Global Governance: Political and Economic worksheet pack - 4 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This worksheet is chapter 13 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 4, a free printable practice book.
Other versions of this worksheet: