The State and Globalisation
This topic asks what a state is, what sovereignty means, and whether globalisation has weakened it. A state is a political community with a defined territory, a permanent population, a government and recognition from other states; a nation is a group with a shared identity; a nation-state is where the two broadly coincide. Sovereignty is supreme authority within a territory. Internal sovereignty is the state's final say over its own people and institutions; external sovereignty is recognition as an independent equal by other states, a principle usually traced to the Peace of Westphalia (1648). A useful distinction is between legal sovereignty (who has the formal right to make law, such as Parliament in the UK) and political sovereignty (the practical ability to get things done, which can be limited by markets, firms or treaties). Globalisation is the growing interconnectedness of economies, politics and cultures across borders, driven by technology, trade, finance and migration. Hyperglobalisers such as Kenichi Ohmae argue the nation-state is losing relevance; sceptics such as Paul Hirst and Grahame Thompson argue states remain central and that globalisation is exaggerated; transformationalists such as David Held and Anthony McGrew argue states survive but their roles are being reshaped. You are tested on separating these ideas precisely and on judging how far sovereignty has really changed, using dated cases such as the 2007-2008 financial crisis or the UK's exit from the EU.
Method
- Define the terms before using them: state, nation, nation-state, internal and external sovereignty, legal and political sovereignty. Most weak answers merge them.
- When a question says 'sovereignty', ask which kind. A state can keep legal sovereignty while its political sovereignty is limited by economic reality, and that gap is often the heart of the argument.
- Name the three schools of globalisation (hyperglobalist, sceptic, transformationalist) and attach each to what it predicts for the state, with a named thinker where you can.
- Distinguish the forms of globalisation (economic, political, cultural) and give a dated illustration of each; technological change is the common driver.
- Weigh evidence both ways: for erosion (financial crisis contagion, firms moving investment, pooled decisions in organisations) and against it (states bailed out banks in 2008, still tax, police and make war, and can leave arrangements, as the UK did).
- Show that effects differ between states: a large economy has more room to act than a small, dependent one, so avoid saying 'globalisation reduces sovereignty' as if it applied equally to everyone.
- Finish with a judgement tied to the wording of the question, such as 'reduced' versus 'changed', and say which form of sovereignty your conclusion is about.
Worked example
Evaluate the extent to which globalisation has reduced the sovereignty of nation-states. (30 marks) Plan the essay.
- Define the terms in the introduction: sovereignty as supreme authority, split into legal and political, and globalisation as growing interconnectedness. State a thesis that globalisation has mainly changed how states use sovereignty rather than removing it.
- Argument for reduction (paragraph 1): economic interconnectedness. Use the 2007-2008 financial crisis, which spread from US mortgage markets to banks worldwide and forced governments to coordinate and borrow, showing that national control over economic outcomes is limited. Name the hyperglobalist reading.
- Argument for reduction (paragraph 2): pooled authority and non-state actors. Use membership of international organisations, rules set outside national law, and multinational companies able to move investment, so that political sovereignty is constrained even where the legal right to decide remains.
- Argument against (paragraph 3): states remain decisive. Governments rescued banks in 2008, Parliament remained legally sovereign over withdrawal from the EU, and the Miller I ruling of the UK Supreme Court in 2017 confirmed that Parliament had to authorise the process, which the sceptics cite as evidence that states still hold the key powers.
- Argument against (paragraph 4): variation. Powerful states shape the rules while small, aid-dependent states have less freedom, so the claim of general decline hides real differences. Bring in the transformationalist view.
- Conclude with a judgement: legal sovereignty has largely survived and political sovereignty has been constrained unevenly, so 'reshaped' is a more accurate word than 'reduced'. Say what would change your mind, for example sustained evidence of states unable to leave arrangements.
Practice questions
Q1Distinguish a nation from a state.Show answer
Answer: A nation is a group of people who share an identity (such as language, culture, history or belief in a common community). A state is a political and legal entity with territory, a population, a government and recognition by other states. The two can differ, as with stateless nations or states containing several nations.
Q2What is the difference between internal and external sovereignty?Show answer
Answer: Internal sovereignty is a state's supreme authority over everything within its territory. External sovereignty is its recognition by other states as independent and equal, free from outside control.
Q3What is the significance of the Peace of Westphalia (1648) for the study of sovereignty?Show answer
Answer: It is conventionally seen as the origin of the modern state system, because the treaties ending the Thirty Years' War stressed that rulers had authority over their own territories without outside interference. Many historians say the traditional account overstates this, but the date is the usual symbol for the principle of state sovereignty.
Q4Give one example each of economic and cultural globalisation.Show answer
Answer: Economic: the growth of multinational companies and global supply chains, or the spread of financial contagion in 2008. Cultural: the worldwide spread of streaming services, music, social media platforms and fast food brands, which carry shared tastes across borders.
Q5Explain how the Hirst and Thompson view of globalisation differs from the hyperglobaliser view.Show answer
Answer: Hirst and Thompson (Globalization in Question, 1996) argue that the world economy is not new or truly global, that trade is concentrated among a few regions and that states remain central regulators. Hyperglobalisers such as Ohmae argue that borderless markets are making the nation-state obsolete.
Q6Explain why Parliament can keep legal sovereignty while a state's political sovereignty is limited.Show answer
Answer: Legal sovereignty is the formal right to make and unmake law and Parliament still holds it, even when it signs treaties. Political sovereignty is the real ability to achieve outcomes, which can be limited by markets, dependence on trade partners, multinational firms or the reaction of other states. A government can have the legal power to raise a tax rate yet face a capital flight that makes doing so costly.
Q7Explain one way in which state sovereignty can be an obstacle to dealing with a cross-border problem such as air pollution.Show answer
Answer: Because each state has the final say within its borders and no higher authority can compel it, a state can refuse to cut emissions or agree rules even though the harm crosses borders. Cooperation therefore depends on voluntary agreement, and a state may free-ride on others' efforts.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Politics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Q1[6 marks]Explain two ways in which technological change has increased global interconnectedness. (6 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[12 marks]Analyse how a hyperglobaliser and a globalisation sceptic would each interpret the effect of the 2007-2008 global financial crisis on the sovereignty of nation-states. (12 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
See real A Level Politics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the State and Globalisation worksheet pack - 4 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This worksheet is chapter 12 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 4, a free printable practice book.
Other versions of this worksheet: