Power and Developments
This topic examines who holds power in global politics and how the distribution of power has changed. Hard power is the use of coercion or payment, through military force or economic tools such as sanctions, trade restrictions or aid. Soft power, a term from Joseph Nye, is the ability to shape what others want through attraction: culture, values, diplomacy and institutions. A great power has major influence across several areas; a superpower, in the Cold War sense, had global reach in military and economic terms. The shape of the international order is described by polarity: unipolarity (one dominant power, as the USA was after the Soviet collapse in 1991), bipolarity (two, as in the Cold War) and multipolarity (several). Emerging powers are states whose economic and political weight is rising; BRICS is a grouping originally of Brazil, Russia, India and China, with South Africa joining in 2010, and later expanded. Political systems are classified as democratic, non-democratic or autocratic; a failed state cannot maintain basic order or services, while a rogue state is a label used by other states for one seen as flouting international norms, and the label is contested. The spread of liberal democracy, the rule of law and liberal economies is a further axis of change, as are spheres of influence (the US Monroe Doctrine of 1823 is a classic example), bilateral deals and a resurgence of nationalism. Examiners expect you to argue whether power has actually shifted and to separate a change in the distribution of power from a change in how states cooperate.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Define the power terms precisely and give an instrument for each: hard power (armed forces, sanctions) and soft power (culture, education, diplomacy, aid delivered through attractive institutions). Remember that the same instrument can serve both, depending on use.
- Use a measure for any claim about power, and say which measure: military spending, GDP, population, technology, alliances and cultural reach. A state strong on one measure may be weaker on another.
- Distinguish polarity from performance. A multipolar order means power is more widely spread; it does not tell you whether cooperation or conflict is more likely, so address both.
- Name the order in each period with its dates: bipolar during the Cold War to 1991, a unipolar moment under the USA afterwards, and the debate about whether China, India and others now make a multipolar order.
- Treat classifications (democratic, non-democratic, failed, rogue) as contested labels. Give criteria and an example, and note who applies the label and why.
- Link to the other topics: institutions and regional groupings can add or reduce power, and the realist and liberal theories give different readings of the same shifts.
- For the 30-mark evaluation, argue that power has shifted in some dimensions (economic weight, regional influence) but not others (the USA still leads militarily), then state a clear judgement on 'multipolar'.
Worked example
Explain one difference between hard power and soft power, with an example of each. (4 marks)
- State hard power: the capacity to get outcomes by coercion or payment, for example military force or economic sanctions. Choose a specific example with a date if you can, such as sanctions imposed on Russia after 2014 or 2022.
- State soft power: the capacity to get outcomes through attraction and persuasion (Joseph Nye's term), for example the appeal of a state's culture, education system or diplomacy, such as the worldwide reach of Hollywood films or of university study in the UK and USA.
- State the difference explicitly: hard power works by making others do something through threat or reward, while soft power works by shaping preferences, so others want what you want.
- Add the limit: soft power is hard to control and slow, because it depends on how foreign publics view a country and cannot be switched on by a government decision. This lifts the answer from description to explanation.
- Check the marks: one for each definition, one for each example, with the explicit difference counted within the second definition.
Practice questions
Q1What distinguishes a superpower from a great power?Show answer
Answer: A great power has significant influence and capability but typically regional or selective reach. A superpower, as the term was used for the USA and USSR in the Cold War, has global military, economic and ideological reach that no other states can match.
Q2Define unipolarity and give a historical example.Show answer
Answer: A system in which a single state is predominant. The usual example is the period after the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, when the USA had no peer in military power, sometimes called the unipolar moment (a phrase from Charles Krauthammer, 1990/91).
Q3Explain why a state can be a major economic power but weak in soft power.Show answer
Answer: Economic size gives resources for hard power, but soft power depends on whether others admire its values, culture or institutions. A large economy whose government restricts media, or is distrusted abroad, may command wealth but little attraction.
Q4What is meant by a failed state? Give one example.Show answer
Answer: One whose government cannot maintain basic order, control its territory or provide essential services. Somalia, after the collapse of its central government in 1991, is frequently used as an example.
Q5Explain why 'rogue state' is a controversial label.Show answer
Answer: It is applied by powerful states to others they see as defying international norms, but there is no agreed legal definition. Critics say the label reflects the interests of those using it and that powerful states break norms too, so it is a political judgement not an objective category.
Q6In an invented table, State X has 30% of global military spending and State Y has 10%. What is the ratio of X to Y and the gap in percentage points?Show answer
Answer: The ratio is 30:10, which simplifies to 3:1. The gap is 30 - 10 = 20 percentage points. (Military spending alone would not show economic or soft power.)
Q7Explain one way in which a sphere of influence limits the independence of smaller states.Show answer
Answer: A great power treats a neighbouring region as an area where it expects to be the dominant influence, so it may resist outside alliances or intervene to prevent them. The Monroe Doctrine (1823) warned European powers off the Americas; Russia's claims over its neighbours are a contemporary case.
Q8What does it mean to say China is an emerging power?Show answer
Answer: It means that its relative economic, political and military weight is rising, so the distribution of power is changing. Since the late 1970s market reforms its economy has grown very rapidly and it is now generally ranked as the world's second largest economy, which is a statement about change over time, not just current size.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Politics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Q1[6 marks]Explain two features of a multipolar world order that distinguish it from a unipolar one. (6 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[12 marks]Analyse how the rise of emerging powers has affected the ability of global institutions to address international problems. (12 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
See real A Level Politics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Power and Developments worksheet pack - 3 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This worksheet is chapter 15 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 4, a free printable practice book.
Other versions of this worksheet: