Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
Psychology
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?
A Level Psychology · Topic guide

Conformity: types, explanations, Asch's research and Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Experiment

Conformity is the tendency to change one's behaviour or opinions to match those of a group, even without being directly told to. Psychologists distinguish three types, compliance, identification and internalisation, based on whether the change is public or private, and temporary or permanent, explained by informational social influence (ISI) and normative social influence (NSI) and studied through Asch's line-judgment experiments and Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Experiment.

Year 12-13 (A Level)Social InfluenceAQAOCRWJECEduqasEdexcel

Before you start

No prerequisites. You can start here.

Method

  1. Learn the definitions of the three types of conformity (internalisation, compliance, identification) and how they differ in whether the change is public/private and temporary/permanent.
  2. Learn the two explanations for why conformity happens: informational social influence (ISI) and normative social influence (NSI), and the kind of situation that triggers each.
  3. Learn Asch's (1951) line-judgment procedure: a lone real participant among confederates, critical trials, and a unanimous incorrect answer.
  4. Learn Asch's key findings on overall conformity rate and individual differences between participants.
  5. Learn the variables Asch went on to manipulate (group size, unanimity, task difficulty) and how each affected conformity.
  6. Learn Zimbardo's (1971) Stanford Prison Experiment procedure and findings for both the 'guards' and the 'prisoners'.
  7. Learn the main evaluation points for both studies: sample bias, temporal validity (Perrin and Spencer, 1980), ecological validity, and the ethical issues raised by Zimbardo's study.
  8. Practise applying the types and explanations of conformity to new, everyday scenarios you have not seen before.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeWriting that 75% of Asch's responses were conforming.

    InsteadIn Asch's study about 75% of participants conformed at least once, and about a quarter never did. Across all critical trials conformity was roughly a third (sources quote figures between about 32% and 37%). State whether a figure refers to participants or to trials.

  • MistakeSaying that conformity keeps rising steadily as the group gets bigger.

    InsteadIn Asch's group size variation conformity rose with the size of the majority up to about three confederates, then levelled off. Describe it as rising and then levelling off, not as a straight-line increase.

  • MistakeTreating identification and internalisation as the same type of conformity.

    InsteadInternalisation means the group's view has become the person's own, in private as well as in public. Identification is adopting a group's views or behaviour because we value belonging to it, which does not need us to agree privately and may fade if we stop identifying with the group.

Worked examples

Example 1

At a work leaving-drinks event, colleagues are asked to guess how many sweets are in a jar. Priya privately thinks there are around 40, but the four colleagues who answer before her all confidently say '90'. She then says '90' too. Later, at home on her own, she still privately believes the true number is close to 40. Identify the type of conformity Priya has shown and explain which explanation for conformity (ISI or NSI) best accounts for her behaviour.

  1. Check whether Priya's private opinion changed: she still believes 40 privately, so only her public answer changed while the group was present.
  2. This matches compliance, a public-only change that reverses once group pressure is removed.
  3. Consider why she went along with the group: she does not update her own estimate at all, so she is not treating the group as a source of correct information, which rules out ISI.
  4. She most likely conformed to avoid seeming out of step with four confident colleagues at a social event, which is normative social influence (NSI), going along to be accepted or to avoid standing out.
  5. State the final answer: Priya shows compliance, driven by normative social influence.

Example 2

A hypothetical replication of Asch's procedure uses 50 participants, each given 12 critical trials. Across all participants, 198 critical-trial answers matched the group's wrong answer, and 38 participants conformed at least once. Two participants who conformed were interviewed afterwards. Tara said, 'I thought my eyes must be wrong, because they all agreed.' Jo said, 'I could see it was wrong, but I did not want to be the odd one out.' (a) Calculate the percentage of critical trials with conformity, and the percentages of participants who conformed at least once and who never conformed. (b) Explain why the first percentage is much lower than the second. (c) Identify the explanation and type of conformity that best fits each interview.

  1. Trials: 50 x 12 = 600 critical trials, and 198 / 600 x 100 = 33%.
  2. Participants: 38 / 50 x 100 = 76% conformed at least once, so 12 / 50 x 100 = 24% never conformed.
  3. Why they differ: the participant percentage counts anyone who conformed even once, while the trial percentage counts every answer from every participant. The 12 who never conformed add 144 trials with no conformity, and the 38 who did conform gave 198 conforming answers out of their 456 trials (about 43%, or 5.2 of 12 trials each on average), so on average they still answered independently on more than half of their trials. This shows individual differences and that conformity was partial.
  4. Jo: she saw the answer was wrong but went along to avoid standing out. That is normative social influence, and her private view did not change, so it is compliance.
  5. Tara: she doubted her own judgement because the group agreed, treating them as a source of correct information. That is informational social influence, and as her private belief shifted it is closer to internalisation, if the change lasts.
  6. Answer: 33% of critical trials, 76% of participants conformed at least once and 24% never did. Jo shows compliance through normative influence and Tara shows informational influence leading towards internalisation.

Example 3

Fictional scenario: Before joining a community photography collective, Niamh prefers carefully posed photographs. She joins because belonging to the collective matters to her. Its members favour spontaneous photographs. While she identifies with the collective, she displays spontaneous photographs and privately regards that style as better, even when viewing photographs alone. After leaving and no longer identifying with the collective, she returns to preferring posed photographs, in private and in her own displays. No new information about either style is given. A student argues that Niamh must have internalised the preference because she accepted it when alone. Which type of conformity best fits the whole account? Explain why the student's evidence is insufficient, and how continued private acceptance after leaving would affect the conclusion.

  1. Separate public behaviour from private acceptance. Niamh both displays spontaneous photographs and prefers them when alone while she identifies with the collective, so the account includes a private change rather than only a public display.
  2. Compare that acceptance with what happens when her group membership and identification end. She returns to posed photographs both privately and in her displays, so the changed preference does not persist beyond her identification with the collective in this account.
  3. Identification is the best fit: belonging matters to Niamh, and the adopted preference fades when she no longer identifies with the collective. This applies the guide's distinction between adopting a valued group's views and a lasting change to one's own beliefs.
  4. The student's conclusion uses only the period when Niamh still identifies with the group. Accepting the preference when alone shows private acceptance at that point, but does not establish the lasting change associated with internalisation. The later reversal is relevant evidence against that conclusion.
  5. If she continued to accept the preference privately after leaving and no longer identifying with the collective, that would instead support internalisation. It would be evidence of persistence beyond membership, although a limited account could not establish that the preference would last permanently.
  6. Conclusion: the whole account is most consistent with identification, because acceptance changes with her identification with a valued group. Private acceptance while alone is insufficient to establish internalisation; continued private acceptance after identification ends would strengthen that alternative. The fictional account illustrates the distinction rather than proving a psychological cause.

Practice questions

Q1[2 marks]What is the key difference between compliance and internalisation?Show answer

Answer: Compliance is a temporary, public-only change that reverses once group pressure is removed; internalisation is a genuine, permanent change to private belief as well as public behaviour.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q2[1 mark]Which explanation for conformity involves wanting to be liked or accepted by a group?Show answer

Answer: Normative social influence (NSI).

Got it right?
Q3[1 mark]In Asch's study, what did the confederates do on critical trials?Show answer

Answer: They unanimously gave the same, obviously incorrect answer.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q4[1 mark]According to Asch's research, what happened to conformity when one confederate broke unanimity by giving a different answer?Show answer

Answer: Conformity fell sharply.

Got it right?
Q5[2 marks]What was the planned duration of Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Experiment, and how long did it actually run?Show answer

Answer: It was planned to run for two weeks but was stopped after six days.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q6[1 mark]In Asch's control condition, where participants judged the lines with no confederates present, roughly what proportion of responses were incorrect?Show answer

Answer: Fewer than 1 percent of responses were incorrect.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.

Exam-style questions

Written in the style of a A Level Psychology exam paper, with a full mark scheme.

Exam tips

  • Decide the type of conformity first by asking whether the private opinion changed, then decide the explanation by asking whether the person was unsure (informational) or wanted acceptance (normative).
  • When you quote Asch's figures, state whether they refer to critical trials or to participants, and name the condition they come from.
  • In an evaluation of Asch or Zimbardo, name the specific feature of the study you are criticising first, then say what it limits about the conclusion. 'It lacks validity' on its own names neither.
Q1[4 marks]A group of five friends are choosing a restaurant for a birthday meal. Four of them, who know the area well, confidently suggest an Italian restaurant. The fifth friend, Leo, does not know the area and is unsure which restaurant would be best. He goes along with the Italian suggestion, and later admits he thinks it was probably a good choice. Identify and explain which explanation for conformity best accounts for Leo's behaviour.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 4 available

Got it right?
Q2[6 marks]Perrin and Spencer's (1980) replication of Asch's procedure, using British engineering students, found much lower conformity than Asch's original 1950s study. Explain what this finding suggests about Asch's original conclusions, and give one other limitation of Asch's original sample.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 6 available

Got it right?

See real A Level Psychology past-paper questions, with official mark schemes 

This topic in real past papers

We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:

Free printable worksheet

Want more practice on paper? Download the Conformity: types, explanations, Asch's research and Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Experiment worksheet pack - 5 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.

This topic is chapter 1 of A Level Psychology Essentials 1, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 1 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 1 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 1, free printable practice books.

Other versions of this worksheet:

Keep going

Not quite what you needed?

Tell us what is missing on Conformity: types, explanations, Asch's research and Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Experiment, or which topic to write up next.

Build a full practice pack.