A Level Economics Essentials 1 includes Perfect competition, imperfectly competitive markets and monopoly (Microeconomics); Market failure and government intervention (Microeconomics); Price determination in a competitive market (Microeconomics); Scarcity, Choice and the Production Possibility Frontier (Microeconomics); Specialisation, Division of Labour and the Functions of Money (Microeconomics); Rational Decision Making and the Theory of Diminishing Marginal Utility (Microeconomics); Behavioural Economics: Bounded Rationality and Biases in Decision Making (Microeconomics); Production, Productivity and the Law of Diminishing Returns (Microeconomics); Costs of Production and Economies and Diseconomies of Scale (Microeconomics); Revenue, Profit and the Profit-Maximising Level of Output (Microeconomics); Wage Determination and the Labour Market (Microeconomics); Price Elasticity of Demand: Determinants and Business Applications (Microeconomics); Income and Cross Elasticities of Demand (Microeconomics); Price Elasticity of Supply and Its Determinants (Microeconomics); Consumer and Producer Surplus and the Incidence of Indirect Taxes (Microeconomics); Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly: Non-Price Competition and Game Theory (Microeconomics); Price Discrimination and the Theory of Contestable Markets (Microeconomics); Measuring Income and Wealth Inequality: The Lorenz Curve and Gini Coefficient (Microeconomics); The Poverty Trap and the Equity-Efficiency Trade-Off in Redistribution (Microeconomics); Wage Differentials Between Occupations and the Gender Pay Gap (Microeconomics); Causes of Poverty and Inequality in Income and Wealth (Microeconomics); Government Policies to Reduce Poverty and Inequality (Microeconomics); Public Goods and the Free-Rider Problem (Microeconomics); Externalities: Negative and Positive Production and Consumption Effects (Microeconomics); Asymmetric Information, Merit Goods and Demerit Goods (Microeconomics); Government Intervention: Indirect Taxes, Subsidies and Price Controls (Microeconomics); Tradable Pollution Permits, Regulation and Government Failure (Microeconomics); Economic Systems: Market, Mixed and Planned Economies (Microeconomics); Exam Technique: Extended Essays on Rational Choice and Utility Theory (Microeconomics); Productive, Allocative, Dynamic and X-Efficiency (Microeconomics).
Method recap - Price Elasticity of Supply and Its Determinants
- State the PES formula and calculate percentage changes for both quantity supplied and price before dividing.
- Interpret the sign: PES is normally positive because price and quantity supplied normally move in the same direction along an upward-sloping supply curve.
- Interpret the size against the elastic/inelastic boundary of 1, and identify the two extreme cases on a diagram: perfectly inelastic supply, a vertical line, PES = 0, and perfectly elastic supply, a horizontal line, PES = infinite.
- Learn the determinants of PES: the time period allowed for producers to respond, the amount of spare production capacity a firm currently has, the ease and cost of storing the product, and how mobile factors of production are between uses.
Worked example - Price Elasticity of Supply and Its Determinants
The price of a good rises from 20 pounds to 25 pounds, and the quantity firms are willing to supply rises from 1,000 to 1,150 units. Calculate the price elasticity of supply and state whether supply is elastic or inelastic, with a reason.
- Calculate the percentage change in quantity supplied: (1,150 - 1,000) / 1,000 x 100 = 150/1,000 x 100 = 15%.
- Calculate the percentage change in price: (25 - 20) / 20 x 100 = 5/20 x 100 = 25%.
- Calculate PES: PES = percentage change in quantity supplied / percentage change in price = 15% / 25% = 0.6.
- Interpret the sign: PES is positive, as expected, since price and quantity supplied moved in the same direction, both rose.
- Interpret the size: since 0.6 is less than 1, supply is price inelastic over this range, quantity supplied changed proportionately less than price, suggesting firms had limited spare capacity.
Question 8 - Price Elasticity of Supply and Its Determinants
6 marks
A furniture manufacturer has spare factory capacity. Explain, using the concept of price elasticity of supply, why its supply of a particular chair is likely to be more price elastic in the long run than in the short run.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [6 marks]| Question 8[6 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| correctly defines PES as the responsiveness of quantity supplied to a change in price | 1 |
| identifies that in the short run at least one factor of production, e.g. factory size or machinery, is fixed | 1 |
| explains that spare capacity allows some short-run response to a price rise, but expansion is still limited by the fixed factor | 1 |
| identifies that in the long run all factors of production can be varied, e.g. the firm can build a new factory or install more machinery | 1 |
| explains that this greater ability to vary factors of production in the long run allows a proportionately larger response of quantity supplied to a given price change | 1 |
| correctly concludes that PES is higher, supply is more elastic, the longer the time period allowed | 1 |
Question 9 - Price Elasticity of Supply and Its Determinants
15 marks
Evaluate the extent to which price elasticity of supply explains why house prices in the UK have risen sharply in areas of high demand.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [15 marks]| Question 9[15 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| basic, undeveloped assertion, e.g. not enough houses, with little reference to PES/elasticity. | Level 11-4 marks |
| one or more developed chains linking low PES of housing to price rises, but one-sided or with limited evaluation. | Level 25-9 marks |
| balanced chains including the role of PES and other factors, with a supported judgement on the extent. | Level 310-15 marks |
| Specific content: chain - new housing supply takes a long time to build and land in high-demand areas is geographically fixed, so PES of housing is low in the short to medium run; when demand rises sharply, the mostly fixed supply cannot expand quickly, so the increase in demand is absorbed mainly through a rise in price. | |
| Specific content: chain - this differs by area, in areas with more available land and fewer planning restrictions supply is comparatively more elastic, so the same rise in demand causes a smaller price increase and more new homes built. | |
| Specific content: counter/other factors - house prices are also driven by factors PES alone does not capture, e.g. the availability and cost of mortgage credit, foreign investment demand, and expectations of further price rises encouraging speculative buying. | |
| Specific content: evaluation - the extent to which low PES explains the price rise depends on the specific local planning and land-availability constraints, and on how much of the observed rise is instead attributable to demand-side factors. | |
| Specific content: judgement - a supported conclusion that low PES of housing supply is a major structural explanation for sharp price rises in high-demand UK areas, but demand-side and finance factors interact with, and can amplify, this supply-side constraint. | |
Method recap - Consumer and Producer Surplus and the Incidence of Indirect Taxes
- Define consumer surplus and producer surplus, and shade each correctly on a supply and demand diagram: consumer surplus is the triangle bounded by the demand curve above, the horizontal price line below, up to the equilibrium quantity; producer surplus is the triangle bounded by the price line above, the supply curve below, up to the same quantity.
- Explain that total economic welfare, community surplus, is the sum of consumer and producer surplus, and that a competitive market equilibrium maximises this total welfare when there are no externalities.
- Draw the effect of a specific, per-unit, indirect tax: the supply curve shifts vertically upward by the amount of the tax, the new equilibrium price rises and quantity falls, label the new consumer price, the lower price producers keep after tax, and the vertical gap between them as the tax per unit.
- Identify and shade tax incidence on the diagram: the portion of the tax passed on to consumers is the area between the old and new price up to the demand curve; the portion absorbed by producers is the area between the old price and the lower amount they now keep.
Question 9 - Consumer and Producer Surplus and the Incidence of Indirect Taxes
15 marks
Evaluate the case for the government using indirect taxes on goods with price inelastic demand, such as tobacco, as a way of raising tax revenue and reducing consumption.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [15 marks]| Question 9[15 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| basic, undeveloped assertion, e.g. taxes raise money, with little diagrammatic or elasticity-based reasoning. | Level 11-4 marks |
| one or more developed chains, e.g. revenue-raising or the deadweight loss/consumption effect, but one-sided or with limited evaluation. | Level 25-9 marks |
| balanced chains covering both the case for and against this policy, referencing elasticity and the surplus/deadweight loss diagram, with a supported judgement. | Level 310-15 marks |
| Specific content: chain (for, revenue) - because demand for tobacco is price inelastic, a tax raises price but quantity demanded falls only a little, so the government collects tax revenue on almost the same volume of sales as before, giving high and stable revenue. | |
| Specific content: chain (for, externality) - tobacco consumption creates negative externalities, e.g. health costs to the NHS, so a tax that raises price, even by a small amount given inelastic demand, still reduces consumption somewhat at the margin. | |
| Specific content: chain (against) - because demand is inelastic, the reduction in quantity consumed is small relative to the size of the tax, so the tax is not very effective at reducing consumption on its own, and the deadweight welfare loss triangle is relatively small precisely because inelastic demand means few trades are lost. | |
| Specific content: chain (against, equity) - indirect taxes on inelastically demanded goods like tobacco tend to be regressive, taking a larger proportion of income from lower-income smokers than higher-income smokers. | |
| Specific content: evaluation - the case for the tax depends on the primary policy goal, revenue raising is well served by taxing an inelastic good while reducing consumption is better served by a good with more elastic demand or by combining the tax with other measures, and on how the extra revenue is used. | |
| Specific content: judgement - a supported conclusion, e.g. that the tax is well suited to revenue raising given inelastic demand, but a government aiming primarily to cut consumption significantly needs to combine the tax with non-price policies. | |
Question 8 - Consumer and Producer Surplus and the Incidence of Indirect Taxes
6 marks
The government places a new indirect tax on a good with price inelastic demand and relatively more price elastic supply. Using a supply and demand diagram, explain who is likely to bear the greater share of the tax burden, consumers or producers.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [6 marks]| Question 8[6 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| correctly labelled diagram showing the original equilibrium and the supply curve shifting upward by the amount of the tax | 1 |
| correctly shows the new, higher price paid by consumers and the new, lower price kept by producers | 1 |
| correctly identifies that consumers bear the greater share of the tax burden | 1 |
| explains that because demand is price inelastic, quantity demanded falls only a little as price rises, so most of the tax can be passed on to consumers in a higher price | 1 |
| explains that because supply is relatively more elastic, producers are better able to adjust the quantity supplied rather than absorb the tax through a lower price | 1 |
| correctly shades or identifies the larger consumer share and smaller producer share of the tax incidence on the diagram | 1 |