Worked question 4 - Market failure and government intervention
Answer and mark scheme
Question 4
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| M1 | (a) total external cost = marginal external cost x quantity = 15 x 800 |
| A1 | (a) = £12,000 |
| M1 | (b) the tax raises the factory's marginal private cost by £15 per unit, so its marginal private cost curve shifts up to equal marginal social cost |
| M1 | (b) the factory will now only produce output up to the point where its (higher, post-tax) marginal cost equals marginal (private) benefit |
| A1 | (b) this internalises the externality, since the factory now faces the full social cost of production in its own decision-making |
| A1 | (b) if the tax is set correctly (equal to the marginal external cost), the new market equilibrium output should fall towards the socially optimal level of 650 units |
| M1 | (c) it is difficult for the government to accurately measure/value the external cost, so the tax may be set too high or too low (allow: firms may relocate abroad to avoid the tax, causing 'carbon leakage'; monitoring and enforcement costs) |
| A1 | (c) developed explanation: e.g. if the tax is set below £15, output remains above 650 units, so the externality is only partially corrected |
| M1 | (c) second valid limitation: monitoring output and enforcing the tax impose administrative costs on the government |
| A1 | (c) developed explanation linking back to the scenario: measuring the factory's taxable output and checking that the tax is paid use resources, reducing the net welfare gain from correcting the pollution externality |
- (a) Answer: £12,000.
- (b) Answer: The £15 tax raises MPC to MSC, so the factory's profit-maximising output falls towards the socially optimal 650 units.
- (c) Answer: Limitations include uncertainty when measuring the external cost, which can lead to an incorrectly set tax, and monitoring and enforcement costs, which reduce the net welfare gain.





