A country joins a customs union. It previously imported a good from an efficient producer outside the union, paying a world price plus a tariff, but after joining switches to importing the same good tariff-free from a less efficient producer inside the union, at a higher pre-tariff price than the original supplier charged.
Using the concepts of trade creation and trade diversion, explain whether this switch in the source of imports is likely to raise or lower the country's economic welfare.
Answer
This is an example of trade diversion, since the country switches from a more efficient external producer to a less efficient one inside the union purely because of the tariff; this generally lowers overall economic welfare compared with trading freely with the original, more efficient, supplier, even though the country itself avoids the tariff.
Mark scheme
| 1 mark for explaining that trade creation occurs when joining a trading bloc causes a country to switch from a less efficient domestic producer to a more efficient producer inside the bloc, raising welfare |
| 1 mark for explaining that trade diversion occurs when a country instead switches from a more efficient producer outside the bloc to a less efficient producer inside it, simply because the external tariff no longer applies to trade within the bloc |
| 1 mark for identifying that switching from the original, efficient, external producer to a less efficient producer inside the union, as described here, is an example of trade diversion |
| 1 mark for explaining that resources are now being used less efficiently overall, even though the country itself avoids paying the tariff, since a genuinely more efficient supplier has been replaced by a less efficient one |
| 1 mark for concluding that this trade diversion is likely to reduce the country's, and the world's, overall economic welfare compared with trading freely with the original efficient supplier |