A student carried out a pilot survey of pedestrian counts at 4 sites, recording these totals over 10 minutes at each: Site 1: 18, Site 2: 45, Site 3: 22, Site 4: 61.
Calculate the mean pedestrian count, then evaluate whether the mean is a suitable single measure to summarise this particular data set, referring to the actual values recorded.
Answer
Mean = (18 + 45 + 22 + 61) / 4 = 36.5 pedestrians per 10 minutes. It summarises overall activity across equal-duration counts, but no site actually recorded that number. Sites 18 and 22 are much quieter than 45 and 61; the range is 43. A mean alone conceals spatial variation. Retain individual site counts; 61 is not established as an outlier from four values.
Mark scheme
| M1 | 18 + 45 + 22 + 61 = 146 pedestrians. |
| M1 | 146 / 4. |
| A1 | 36.5 pedestrians per 10-minute observation. |
| B1 | Mean is an overall summary but the contrast between 18 and 22 and 45 and 61 shows substantial spatial variation. |
| B1 | Individual site values or a located plot preserve the variation; median 33.5 also hides location. |
| B1 | Supported judgement about using the mean alongside the site values; do not require or assert that 61 is an outlier. |