Worked question 13 - Year 11 Paper 1: Medicine, the Western Front and Elizabethan England
Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of a letter written by an English sea captain to his family shortly after the Spanish Armada was defeated in 1588. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.
'We chased the Spanish ships for days, firing on them whenever we came close enough, but our powder ran low before we could sink many. It was the fireships off Calais, and then the great storm that drove them north, that truly broke them.'
How useful is Source A to a historian studying why the Spanish Armada was defeated? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.
Answer
The captain stresses ammunition limits and fireships, then weather. The imagined captain's viewpoint illustrates naval experience but may simplify causation; context should distinguish Gravelines and return-voyage storms. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry.
Mark scheme
| Level 1 (1 mark): identifies relevant detail or gives a simple usefulness judgement. | |
| Level 2 (2 marks): explains a relevant inference using detail and accurate context, or explains a specific evidential limit. | |
| Level 3 (3-4 marks): supports a reasoned judgement with detail and linked context, explaining the limit of a constructed teaching extract as evidence. Select the mark by reasoning and accuracy, not the number of comments. | |
| Short practice task with a local 4-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: The captain stresses ammunition limits and fireships, then weather. Evidence audit: The imagined captain's viewpoint illustrates naval experience but may simplify causation; context should distinguish Gravelines and return-voyage storms. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution. |





