GCSE History Topic Workbook 1 includes Medicine in Britain, c1250-c1500: Ideas About the Cause and Treatment of Disease (from page 3); Medicine in Britain, c1700-c1900: Vaccination, Germ Theory and Public Health (from page 8); Medicine in Britain, c1500-c1700: The Medical Renaissance and Ideas About the Cause of Disease (from page 13); Medicine in Britain, c1500-c1700: Treatment, Prevention and the Great Plague of 1665 (from page 18); Medicine in Britain, c1900-present: War, Science and the Development of Penicillin (from page 23); Medicine in Britain, c1900-present: The NHS, Genetics and Modern Public Health (from page 28); Medicine in Britain, c1250-present: Change and Continuity in Ideas About the Cause of Disease (from page 33); Medicine in Britain, c1250-present: Change and Continuity in the Treatment and Prevention of Disease (from page 38); The Black Death, 1348-49: Causes, Spread and Contemporary Responses (from page 43); The Cholera Epidemic of 1854 and John Snow's Broad Street Investigation (from page 48); The Role of Individuals in Driving Medical Change, c1250-Present (from page 53); The Role of Attitudes in Society in Medical Change, c1250-Present (from page 57); The Role of Government and Legislation in Medical Change, c1250-1900 (from page 62); Anaesthetics and Antiseptics: Simpson, Lister and Safer Surgery (from page 66).
Worked question 12 - Anaesthetics and Antiseptics: Simpson, Lister and Safer Surgery
Open the included worksheet
Explain one way in which the development of anaesthetics in the mid nineteenth century was similar to the development of antiseptic surgery later in the century.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 12
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B2 | identifies one clear similarity, for example that both depended on scientific discoveries which changed practice, and explains it with supporting detail |
| B2 | supporting detail showing the similarity, e.g. both used a new scientific idea to transform surgery: chloroform applied chemistry/physiology to relieve pain, and Lister applied Pasteur's microbial ideas to prevent infection |
- Answer: Both developments transformed surgery by applying a new scientific idea to solve a specific problem: chloroform anaesthesia applied chemistry and physiology to remove the pain of operations, while Lister's carbolic antisepsis applied Pasteur's germ theory to prevent wound infection, so each used scientific discovery to make operations safer and more widely acceptable.
Question 7 - Anaesthetics and Antiseptics: Simpson, Lister and Safer Surgery
Open the included worksheet
State one reason why some doctors at first resisted Lister's antiseptic methods.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 7
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | some surgeons were sceptical of the new germ ideas and thought infection was due to bad air or patient weakness |
| B1 | supporting detail, e.g. using carbolic was seen as messy and time-consuming and some feared it would damage living tissue |
- Answer: Doctors resisted because they rejected germ-based explanations of infection and because carbolic procedures were seen as messy, time-consuming and possibly harmful to tissue.
Question 8 - Anaesthetics and Antiseptics: Simpson, Lister and Safer Surgery
Open the included worksheet
State one way the introduction of anaesthetics changed surgery in the nineteenth century.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 8
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | allowed surgeons to perform longer and more complex operations without the patient feeling pain |
| B1 | supporting detail, e.g. operations that had been impossible because of patient pain became practicable |
- Answer: Anaesthetics allowed longer, more complex operations without pain, so surgeons could attempt procedures previously impossible because patients could not bear them.
Question 8 - Medicine in Britain, c1250-present: Change and Continuity in Ideas About the Cause of Disease
Open the included worksheet
State one idea about the cause of disease that was widely believed in the medieval period (c1250-1500) but had been abandoned by scientifically trained doctors by 1900.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 8
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies a valid abandoned idea, e.g. supernatural/religious explanations such as disease being sent by God as a punishment for sin, or astrological explanations |
| B1 | supporting detail, e.g. by 1900 Germ Theory (from 1861) had given doctors a scientifically tested alternative that these older explanations could not compete with |
- Answer: E.g. religious or astrological explanations for disease, largely abandoned by scientifically trained doctors once Germ Theory was accepted.
Question 10 - Medicine in Britain, c1250-present: Change and Continuity in Ideas About the Cause of Disease
Open the included worksheet
Explain how the improvement of the microscope helped scientists such as Pasteur and Koch to develop and prove Germ Theory in the nineteenth century.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 10
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | it allowed scientists to see microorganisms (germs/bacteria) that were invisible to the naked eye |
| B1 | so they could directly observe and identify the specific organisms responsible for particular diseases, rather than relying only on theory |
- Answer: The microscope let scientists see and identify the specific microorganisms causing disease, rather than relying only on theory.
Question 3 - Medicine in Britain, c1500-c1700: Treatment, Prevention and the Great Plague of 1665
Open the included worksheet
Give one reason why wealthier people, including the King's court, were better able to survive the Great Plague than the poor.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 3
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | wealthier people, including King Charles II's court, could afford to leave London for the countryside |
| B1 | away from the crowded and unsanitary conditions in the city, whereas poorer Londoners could not afford to abandon their homes and livelihoods and had to remain |
- Answer: The wealthy could afford to leave London for the countryside; the poor could not afford to abandon their homes and had to stay in crowded, unsanitary conditions.
Question 1 - Medicine in Britain, c1500-c1700: Treatment, Prevention and the Great Plague of 1665
Open the included worksheet
State two ways in which treatment of illness in the years c1500-1700 remained similar to treatment in the medieval period.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 1
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | one valid continuity, e.g. bloodletting; purging; herbal remedies; treatments still based on the Theory of the Four Humours; prayer and religious remedies; care at home by women of the family, oe |
| B1 | a second, different valid continuity, oe (bloodletting and purging may be credited as two separate ways) |
- Answer: Any two, e.g. bloodletting; purging; herbal remedies; treatment based on the Four Humours; prayer; care at home by women.