Comparative US/UK Legislatures: Congress and Parliament - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
6 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Comparative US/UK Legislatures: Congress and Parliament revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Politics practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 6 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 4 and chapter 24 of A Level Politics 10-Minute Tests 2.
5.12 Comparative US/UK Legislatures: Congress and Parliament
Source A (US Congress): 'In periods of divided government Congress has used its investigative powers and confirmation processes to delay, alter or block executive policy. The Senate confirmation process can impose significant constraints on presidential appointments, and standing committees regularly hold hearings that attract public attention to administration behaviour.'
Source B (UK Parliament): 'When a governing party has a solid Commons majority the ability of backbench MPs and select committees to stop or amend government legislation is limited. The government controls the parliamentary timetable and ministers often command party loyalty, so Parliament frequently ratifies rather than originates major policy.'
Question 1
- (a) identifies the House of Commons and the House of Lords caoB1
- (a) Answer: The House of Commons and the House of Lords.
Question 2
- (a) identifies that the executive is made up of ministers who are also members of ParliamentB1
- (a) identifies that this creates closer control of the legislature by the executive, for example through the party whip systemB1
- (a) Answer: Fusion of powers means the executive is formed from members of Parliament, so ministers sit in the legislature and the government depends on parliamentary support, creating closer integration of legislative and executive functions often enforced by party whips.
Question 3
- (a) identifies a mechanism, e.g. congressional committees can launch investigations when controlled by the oppositionB1
- (a) develops the point, e.g. opposition committees can subpoena witnesses and hold televised hearingsB1
- (a) links to effect, e.g. this can expose executive errors or misconduct and constrain policy implementationB1
- (a) Answer: When government is divided, opposition-controlled congressional committees can investigate the executive, issuing subpoenas, calling witnesses and holding televised hearings, which can expose mistakes or misconduct and place political pressure on the President and administration.
Question 4
- (a) identifies a strength, e.g. divided government enables opposition committees to investigate the executiveB1
- (a) develops with an example, e.g. Watergate-era or 2019 House investigations into executive actionsB1
- (a) explains impact, e.g. investigations can produce political pressure, subpoenas and public awareness that constrain the PresidentB1
- (a) Answer: One strength is that divided government lets opposition-controlled congressional committees investigate and subpoena executive officials. For example, the 2019 House investigations into executive actions raised public scrutiny. Such investigations produce political pressure and factual records that can constrain presidential action.
- (b) identifies a weakness, e.g. divided government can cause gridlock, preventing Congress from passing legislation to address problemsB1
- (b) develops with an example, e.g. budget standoffs and government shutdowns when House and Senate or presidency disagreeB1
- (b) identifies a further weakness, e.g. partisan investigations may be symbolic and fail to produce legal consequencesB1
- (b) Answer: Weaknesses include that divided government can produce legislative gridlock, making it hard for Congress to pass budgets or reforms and sometimes causing shutdowns when compromise fails, and that oversight can become partisan theatre which, even if politically damaging, may not lead to prosecutions or policy change.
Question 5
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Level 1 Basic knowledge of one system only or generalised assertions about scrutiny with little accurate supporting detail, and little or no evaluation.1-7
- Level 2 Clear, accurate knowledge of both US and UK institutional arrangements with some analysis of how these affect scrutiny; evaluation is present but may be one-sided or underdeveloped.8-15
- Level 3 Detailed knowledge of institutional powers and political practice in both systems used to construct a sustained comparative analysis of scrutiny, weighing evidence for and against the claim and reaching a reasoned judgement.16-23
- Level 4 Sophisticated and wide-ranging comparative evaluation, integrating constitutional design, committee powers, party discipline, and political context; addresses counterarguments and produces a clear, balanced and well-supported conclusion on the extent to which Congress is more effective at scrutinising the executive than the UK Parliament.24-30
- Indicative content:
- Arguments that Congress is more effective: constitutional separation of powers gives Congress formal independence, with the Senate's confirmation powers and House and Senate committees having strong subpoena and investigatory powers; divided government can force the executive to face sustained oversight.
- Examples supporting Congress: high-profile congressional investigations (Watergate, Iran-Contra, 2019 hearings), Senate holds that refuse to confirm or delay appointments, and the ability of Congress to control appropriations which can constrain executive agencies.
- Arguments that Congress is not necessarily more effective: congressional oversight effectiveness depends on political control and partisanship; when the President's party controls both chambers, oversight weakens and gridlock may halt constructive scrutiny. Investigations can become partisan and fail to generate accountability.
- Arguments that the UK Parliament can effectively scrutinise the executive: select committees have grown influence since the late 20th century, with expert reports, effective questioning of ministers, and the Commons' ability to call ministers to account; Prime Ministers remain politically vulnerable to their parties and backbench rebellions in certain circumstances.
- Examples supporting UK scrutiny: influential select committee reports that have shaped policy, successful backbench rebellions on specific bills, and media-amplified inquiries which force government responses; also urgent questions and PMQs provide sustained public scrutiny.
- Limitations of UK scrutiny include the fusion of powers and strong party whips which often allow majority governments to pass legislation with limited amendment, leading to the 'elective dictatorship' concern when single-party majorities are large.
- Comparative synthesis: effectiveness depends on political context as much as formal powers. Congress has stronger formal tools in law, but political incentives and partisanship limit practical outcomes. The UK Parliament can be constrained by majority government but can also produce focused scrutiny when cross-party consensus or media pressure exists.
- A balanced conclusion might argue that while Congress has institutionally stronger legal tools for constraint, in practice neither legislature is uniformly more effective across all contexts; the comparative advantage of Congress is conditional, and the UK Parliament can be highly effective in particular political circumstances, so Congress is more effective in some respects but not definitively so in all.
Question 6
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Level 1 Basic points drawn from one source only with limited development and little analysis of similarities or differences.1-3
- Level 2 Clear analysis of at least one similarity or difference using both sources, but explanation may be partial or lacking in wider contextual knowledge.4-6
- Level 3 Developed analysis using both sources, integrating specific features of congressional and parliamentary scrutiny and showing how the sources support these points, with some evaluation of impact.7-9
- Level 4 Detailed, well-supported analysis using both sources to compare multiple similarities and differences, placing the extracts in a wider constitutional and political context and reaching a reasoned judgement on how the practical capacities differ or align.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Source A emphasises procedural tools available to Congress, such as investigative hearings and the Senate confirmation process, which can delay, alter or block executive appointments and expose executive behaviour.
- Source B emphasises the consequence of a strong Commons majority: government control of the timetable and party loyalty tends to limit Parliament's capacity to stop legislation, so Parliament often ratifies government policy.
- A similarity is that both legislatures have formal mechanisms aimed at scrutiny: congressional committees and Senate confirmations on the US side, and select committee inquiries and parliamentary questions on the UK side, though Source B suggests the effectiveness of the UK tools depends heavily on political context.
- A difference is that Source A presents Congress as able to use legal and procedural compulsion to constrain the executive in divided government, while Source B presents the UK Commons as more susceptible to executive dominance when the government commands a majority, limiting effective constraint.
- Contextual points that strengthen analysis include noting that US separation of powers makes Congress constitutionally independent and that the Senate has unique confirmation powers, while UK fusion of powers gives the executive agenda control and stronger whipping powers.
- A balanced judgement might argue the extracts show Congress has stronger procedural tools to constrain the executive in certain political circumstances, particularly when divided government exists, while the UK Parliament can be an effective scrutiniser in specific situations but is more vulnerable to majority-government dominance, so the practical capacity to constrain varies by political context in each system.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.