Comprehension: Fiction Set 6 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
24 original exam-style questions - 8 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Comprehension: Fiction Set 6 revision guideMore 11+ English practice
This topic is chapter 6 of 11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 1.
1.1-6 Comprehension: Fiction Set 6
Shelter at Craig Dhu
Original story written for Revision Library.
Priya Chandra had been counting down the days to half term for weeks, not for the usual reasons but because her cousin Deepak Verma had finally talked their families into letting her join his hillwalking club's overnight trip into the Cairngorms. She had trained for this: three practice walks around the local reservoir, a new pair of boots worn in until they no longer pinched, and a rucksack packed and repacked until every strap sat exactly where it should. Still, as the minibus rattled along the single-track road towards the car park at Glen Aivie, her stomach fizzed with something that was not quite excitement and not quite fear.
The plan, Mr Whitlock had explained the night before, was straightforward enough. Twelve of them, four adults and eight members of the Year 6 to Year 8 club, would follow the well-marked path along the river, climb steadily through the pass, and reach Craig Dhu bothy - a stone shelter maintained by volunteers for walkers - well before dark. Supper would be cooked on camping stoves, sleeping bags rolled out on the wooden sleeping platform, and the whole group would be back at the minibus by lunchtime the next day. The forecast had promised a clear, cold morning with only a slim chance of afternoon showers.
For the first two hours, the walk matched the forecast exactly. The path wound along a burn that chattered over grey stones, and heather-covered slopes rose on either side, dusted here and there with the season's first frost. Priya found a rhythm in the steady crunch of boots on gravel, and Ffion Pritchard, walking beside her, pointed out a pair of red deer picking their way along a distant ridge. It was only as they began the climb into the pass that Priya noticed the sky behind them had turned the colour of an old bruise.
'Weather's changing its mind,' Mr Whitlock said, glancing back rather more often than he had before. He quickened the pace, and the easy chatter of the group thinned into the harder breathing of a proper climb. By the time they crested the pass, the wind had sharpened into something with edges, and the first flakes of snow were spinning sideways rather than falling. Within twenty minutes, the world had shrunk to a few metres of swirling white in every direction.
The blizzard did not build gradually; it simply arrived, as though a switch had been thrown. Snow hurled itself at them in fistfuls, stinging any bare skin it found, and the wind snatched the words from Mr Whitlock's mouth before the group at the back could hear them. Priya kept her eyes fixed on Deepak's rucksack, a dull orange smudge in the whiteout, terrified of losing sight of it even for a second. Ffion stumbled once on a hidden rock and Marcus Reid grabbed her arm before she could go down, both of them roped together now by nothing more than instinct and a shared refusal to panic.
Mr Whitlock stopped the group in the lee of a boulder, pulled out a map sealed in plastic, and checked it against his compass with hands that had gone clumsy with cold. 'Craig Dhu is four hundred metres that way,' he shouted over the din, pointing into what looked, to Priya, like solid white nothing. 'We stay together. Nobody stops. Nobody wanders.' It was the first time all day his voice had sounded anything other than cheerful, and that, more than the storm itself, was what finally frightened her.
They found the bothy more by luck than navigation, stumbling almost into its stone wall before anyone saw it. The door, weathered grey and swollen with damp, stuck fast until Deepak and Marcus threw their combined weight against it, and then the whole group tumbled gratefully into the dim, cold room beyond, hauling the door shut against the shrieking wind behind them.
Inside, Craig Dhu was little more than a single stone chamber with a rough hearth, a wooden sleeping platform along one wall, and a small table bearing a battered tin box. While the adults set about lighting the camping stoves and unpacking dry clothes, Priya knelt by the table and lifted the box's lid. Inside was a thick, water-stained visitors' book, its pages filled with decades of cramped handwriting: dates, names, weather reports, small jokes, and messages of thanks left by walkers who had sheltered here before her.
She read them by torchlight while her boots dried by the stove, and one entry, dated almost thirty years earlier, made her sit up straight. A hillwalker named Isla Fraser had written of being caught in a storm 'every bit as fierce as the ones the old shepherds warn you about', of surviving a night at Craig Dhu with two frightened younger cousins in her care, and of walking them safely down the next morning once the weather had cleared. 'The mountain doesn't care how scared you are,' Isla had written, 'it only cares whether you keep your head.' Priya read the line twice, then a third time, and found that her hands had finally stopped shaking.
Deepak, ladling out mugs of soup, noticed her expression and came to read over her shoulder. 'Sounds like good advice,' he said simply, and passed her a mug before she could answer. Outside, the wind battered the little building in long, shuddering gusts, but inside, for the first time since the pass, the room felt almost warm.
Supper that night was tinned soup and flatbread eaten by torchlight, and afterwards Mr Whitlock ran through the plan for the morning in a voice that had recovered its usual calm. If the snow eased, as the forecast suggested it might, they would retrace their steps to the minibus; if not, they would sit tight and wait, since a warm, dry bothy was infinitely safer than an exposed mountainside. Nobody argued. Twelve sleeping bags were laid out on the platform in a row, and Priya fell asleep faster than she had expected to, lulled by the low murmur of the wind and the occasional creak of the old stone building settling around them.
She woke to an unfamiliar sound: silence. The wind had dropped entirely overnight, and thin grey light was seeping under the door. When Mr Whitlock eased it open, the glen beyond had been transformed: every rock and heather clump smoothed under a thick, unbroken blanket of snow, glittering faintly under a sky that had finally cleared to a pale, washed-out blue.
The walk out took twice as long as the walk in had been planned to, since the group had to break a fresh trail through knee-deep drifts in places, but nobody complained. Priya found she was no longer watching Deepak's rucksack out of fear but simply enjoying, for the first time since the blizzard hit, the astonishing quiet of the mountains after snow. By the time the minibus came into view, small and yellow against the white expanse of the car park, her legs ached in a way that felt entirely earned.
That evening, back home, Priya took out her own notebook, the one she had been given for the trip and had barely touched, and wrote a single entry by the light of her bedside lamp. She did not describe the blizzard in detail, nor the fear she had felt crouched behind the boulder. Instead, she copied out Isla Fraser's words exactly as she remembered them, and beneath them added a line of her own: she had kept her head, and next time, she thought, she would be a little less afraid of having to.
- A) He had lost his voice from shouting
- B) He was excited about the weather
- C) He was pleased with their progress
- D) He was angry with the walkers for being slow
- E) He was genuinely worried, despite trying to stay calm for the group
- A) Writing that has been typed
- B) Writing that has been erased
- C) Writing that is small and close together
- D) Writing done in coloured ink
- E) Writing that is large and spaced out
- A) It suggests the group had fallen asleep
- B) It shows the group disagreed silently
- C) Its brevity emphasises how seriously the group took Mr Whitlock's plan, with no room for doubt
- D) It shows the group was too tired to speak
- E) It shows Mr Whitlock was speaking too quietly to be heard
- A) It suggests the wind was gentle and calm
- B) It suggests the wind was so powerful it seemed to actively steal sound, making communication almost impossible
- C) It suggests Mr Whitlock had stopped speaking
- D) It suggests the group could hear him perfectly well
- E) It suggests the wind was warm
- A) It made her feel unwell
- B) It frightened her further
- C) It was too loud for her to notice
- D) It kept her wide awake and alert
- E) It soothed her and helped her fall asleep
- A) Made longer
- B) Made quieter
- C) Made slower
- D) Made faster
- E) Made safer
- A) It was dark, purplish and looked threatening
- B) It was bright and cheerful
- C) It was a soft, pale pink
- D) It had turned pure white
- E) It was completely clear and blue
- A) A quiet whisper
- B) A type of map
- C) A type of boulder
- D) A loud, confused noise
- E) A gentle breeze
- A) Two kilometres
- B) Four hundred metres
- C) Two hundred metres
- D) One kilometre
- E) One hundred metres
- A) Northgate
- B) Glen Aivie
- C) Hollow Beck
- D) Ben Aivie
- E) Craig Dhu
- A) Ten
- B) Twelve
- C) Twenty
- D) Four
- E) Eight
- A) A clear, cold morning with only a slim chance of afternoon showers
- B) Heavy snow all day
- C) Warm sunshine throughout
- D) Thunderstorms
- E) Fog clearing by midday
- A) It was falling gently straight down
- B) It was mixed with rain
- C) It was spinning sideways in the wind
- D) It had stopped completely
- E) It was melting as soon as it landed
- A) She was angry that the walk had been too difficult
- B) She felt the ache was undeserved and unfair
- C) She was in so much pain she wanted to stop
- D) She felt proud of what she had achieved, so the tiredness felt justified and satisfying rather than purely unpleasant
- E) She resented the pain in her legs
Question 1
- EB1
- Answer: E) He was genuinely worried, despite trying to stay calm for the group
Question 2
- identifies the contents: a thick, water-stained visitors' book / logbook containing decades of entries (dates, names, weather reports, jokes, thanks)B1
- explains a plausible reason it was kept there: so that walkers sheltering at the bothy can record who has stayed, leave messages or weather information for later visitors, as a shared tradition among people using the shelterB1
- Answer: Priya found a thick, water-stained visitors' book containing decades of entries: dates, names, weather reports, jokes and messages of thanks. It was probably kept in the tin box to protect it from damp while allowing every walker who shelters at Craig Dhu to record their visit and leave useful information or encouragement for whoever comes next.
Question 3
- CB1
- Answer: C) Writing that is small and close together
Question 4
- suggests the bothy has been used by walkers for a very long time, shown by 'decades of cramped handwriting'B1
- suggests a sense of community and goodwill between walkers who have never met, shown by 'small jokes, and messages of thanks left by walkers who had sheltered here before her'B1
- suggests the bothy has a genuine history of being important for survival in dangerous weather, shown by Isla Fraser's entry describing being caught in a storm 'every bit as fierce as the ones the old shepherds warn you about'B1
- Answer: The entries suggest Craig Dhu has sheltered walkers for a very long time, shown by 'decades of cramped handwriting'. The 'small jokes, and messages of thanks' suggest a sense of community between strangers who share the same shelter. Isla Fraser's entry about a storm 'every bit as fierce as the ones the old shepherds warn you about' shows the bothy has a real history of protecting people from genuine danger, not just bad weather in general.
Question 5
- explains that nature/the mountain is indifferent to how frightened a person feels; being afraid does not make the danger any less real or any greaterB1
- explains that what actually determines survival/success is staying calm and thinking clearly, rather than panickingB1
- Answer: Isla means that feeling frightened will not change how dangerous the mountain actually is; the weather and terrain do not respond to human emotions. What really matters for getting through safely is staying calm and thinking clearly, rather than letting fear take over.
Question 6
- CB1
- Answer: C) Its brevity emphasises how seriously the group took Mr Whitlock's plan, with no room for doubt
Question 7
- identifies the comparison: the snow's movement is compared to something being thrown forcefully at the walkers, as if by an attacker, rather than falling naturallyB1
- explains the effect: conveys the violence, force and almost deliberate aggression of the blizzard, making the weather feel like an active threat and emphasising how dangerous the conditions had becomeB1
- Answer: The image compares the falling snow to fistfuls being thrown, as though by an attacker, rather than snow drifting down naturally. This makes the blizzard feel violent and almost deliberately aggressive, emphasising just how dangerous and overwhelming the conditions had suddenly become for the walkers.
Question 8
- BB1
- Answer: B) It suggests the wind was so powerful it seemed to actively steal sound, making communication almost impossible
Question 9
- reading about someone who had survived a similarly frightening storm, and safely brought her younger cousins through it, gave Priya reassurance and a model of someone coping successfullyB1
- Isla's specific advice about keeping her head gave Priya something practical to focus on, helping her calm down rather than dwelling on her fearB1
- Answer: Reading Isla Fraser's account of surviving an equally fierce storm, and safely leading two frightened younger cousins through it, reassured Priya that the situation could be survived. Isla's advice about keeping her head gave Priya something practical and calming to focus on instead of her fear, which is why her hands finally stopped shaking.
Question 10
- EB1
- Answer: E) It soothed her and helped her fall asleep
Question 11
- DB1
- Answer: D) Made faster
Question 12
- AB1
- Answer: A) It was dark, purplish and looked threatening
Question 13
- identifies that the change was near-instant, shown by 'did not build gradually; it simply arrived, as though a switch had been thrown'B1
- identifies a detail showing the violence/suddenness of the conditions, e.g. 'snow hurled itself at them in fistfuls' or 'the wind snatched the words from Mr Whitlock's mouth', showing how quickly calm conditions became a dangerous whiteoutB1
- Answer: The paragraph suggests the weather changed almost instantly rather than gradually, as shown by 'did not build gradually; it simply arrived, as though a switch had been thrown'. This suddenness is reinforced by the violent imagery of snow that 'hurled itself at them in fistfuls' and wind that 'snatched the words' from Mr Whitlock's mouth, showing conditions became dangerous within moments.
Question 14
- DB1
- Answer: D) A loud, confused noise
Question 15
- BB1
- Answer: B) Four hundred metres
Question 16
- EB1
- Answer: E) Craig Dhu
Question 17
- BB1
- Answer: B) Twelve
Question 18
- AB1
- Answer: A) A clear, cold morning with only a slim chance of afternoon showers
Question 19
- CB1
- Answer: C) It was spinning sideways in the wind
Question 20
- practical and capable, shown by helping Marcus force open the stuck bothy door in paragraph 7B1
- caring and reassuring towards Priya, shown by noticing her reaction to the visitors' book, reading over her shoulder, and passing her soup with a simple, calm comment in paragraph 10B1
- a steadying, trustworthy presence generally, shown by Priya fixing her eyes on his rucksack for guidance and reassurance throughout the blizzard in paragraph 5B1
- Answer: Deepak is shown to be practical and capable, helping force open the stuck bothy door alongside Marcus. He is also caring and reassuring, noticing Priya's reaction to the visitors' book and responding gently and simply rather than making a fuss. More broadly, the fact that Priya fixes her eyes on his rucksack throughout the blizzard for reassurance suggests he is a steadying, trustworthy presence she relies on without needing to be told to.
Question 21
- DB1
- Answer: D) She felt proud of what she had achieved, so the tiredness felt justified and satisfying rather than purely unpleasant
Question 22
- structural point: the paragraph opens with the short, contrasting phrase 'an unfamiliar sound: silence', immediately signalling a dramatic change after a paragraph dominated by noise and dangerB1
- language point: calm, visual imagery such as 'smoothed under a thick, unbroken blanket of snow, glittering faintly' creates a peaceful, almost beautiful atmosphereB1
- evaluative point: this calm imagery contrasts sharply with the earlier violent imagery of the blizzard (e.g. snow 'hurled' in 'fistfuls'), and the change in language mirrors the characters' emotional shift from fear to reliefB1
- Answer: The paragraph opens with the short, contrasting phrase 'an unfamiliar sound: silence', immediately signalling a dramatic shift after the noise and danger of the storm. The calm, visual imagery of the glen 'smoothed under a thick, unbroken blanket of snow, glittering faintly' creates a peaceful, almost beautiful atmosphere that contrasts sharply with the earlier violent imagery of snow being 'hurled' in 'fistfuls'. This shift in language mirrors the characters' emotional change from fear and tension to relief and calm.
Question 23
- identifies the opening atmosphere of nervous excitement and anticipation as Priya sets off on the tripB1
- identifies the shift to fear, danger and confusion once the sudden blizzard hits and the group struggles to reach shelterB1
- identifies the calmer, reassuring atmosphere once inside the bothy, especially after Priya reads the visitors' bookB1
- identifies the peaceful, proud and reflective atmosphere at the end, once the storm clears and Priya walks out with new confidenceB1
- Answer: The extract begins with a nervous, excited atmosphere as Priya sets off on her first big hike. This quickly changes to fear and confusion when the sudden blizzard hits and the group struggles through the whiteout to reach shelter. Once inside the bothy, especially after reading the visitors' book, the mood becomes calmer and more reassuring. By the end, after the storm has cleared, the atmosphere becomes peaceful and reflective, with Priya feeling proud and quietly more confident than before.
Question 24
- shows she has been genuinely affected by the experience, choosing to write in the notebook she had 'barely touched' before the tripB1
- shows she processes the experience thoughtfully rather than dwelling on fear, choosing to record Isla's words rather than describe the frightening details of the blizzardB1
- shows growing self-awareness and quiet, realistic confidence, admitting she would be 'a little less afraid' next time rather than claiming to be completely fearlessB1
- Answer: The final paragraph shows Priya has been genuinely changed by the trip, since she finally writes in the notebook she had 'barely touched' before. Her choice to record Isla's words rather than describe the frightening details of the blizzard shows she processes the experience thoughtfully rather than dwelling on her fear. Her honest admission that she would be 'a little less afraid' next time, rather than claiming to feel no fear at all, suggests a realistic, quietly growing confidence.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.