Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 5 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
24 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 5 revision guideMore 11+ English practice
This topic is chapter 5 of 11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 3.
1.2-5 Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 5
Bees Above the Rooftops
Source written for Revision Library (original, copyright-free).
Just after seven o'clock on a June morning, Zara Hutton climbs a metal staircase to the roof of an office block in central Manchester. She has not come for the view, although the wooden planters of lavender and the city skyline beyond make it worth pausing for a moment. She has come to check on forty thousand bees. Six wooden hives stand in a neat row beside a rainwater tank, their occupants weaving busily between the flowers and out over the rooftops of the city beyond. It is an unlikely picture: bees, so often pictured drifting through meadows and orchards, thriving twelve storeys above a car park.
Such a scene would once have seemed unlikely for a different reason. For much of the twentieth century, honeybee numbers across the United Kingdom were in steady decline. Wildflower meadows were ploughed up for farmland or built over for housing, hedgerows were torn out to make way for larger fields, and pesticides sprayed on crops proved harmful to the insects that pollinated them. On 21/07/2018, a national survey of beekeepers reported that colony losses over the previous winter had reached one of the highest levels on record, and scientists warned that without pollinators, many fruits and vegetables would become scarcer and more expensive. It was against this troubling backdrop that an unexpected solution began to take shape, not out in the countryside, but in Britain's towns and cities.
It turns out that cities can be surprisingly good places for bees to live. Gardens, parks, allotments and even roadside verges are planted with an enormous variety of flowers, shrubs and trees, many of which bloom at different times of year. This gives bees a far more reliable supply of nectar and pollen than a single farmer's field of one crop, which flowers for only a few weeks before it is harvested. Cities also tend to be a degree or two warmer than the surrounding countryside, since brick, concrete and tarmac soak up heat during the day, and pesticide use is generally lower in gardens than on farmland. For a hungry colony, a city rooftop can offer richer pickings than a distant hillside.
Setting up a hive in a city is not simply a matter of buying a box and filling it with insects. Anyone wishing to keep bees on a rooftop, in a school garden or on an allotment is strongly encouraged to register their hives with the local council and complete a training course first, since an untended hive can quickly become a nuisance to neighbours or a danger to the bees themselves. Local beekeeping associations run evening classes and mentoring schemes, pairing beginners with experienced keepers who show them how to inspect a hive without being stung, how to spot the early signs of disease, and how to harvest honey safely. Some employers have gone further still, installing hives on their roofs and inviting staff to help care for them as part of wellbeing programmes, while a growing number of primary schools now keep an observation hive in the classroom so that pupils can watch the bees at work through a pane of glass.
Beyond the jar of honey on the breakfast table, this quiet trend has begun to feed into something larger. Through citizen-science projects run by conservation charities, hobbyist beekeepers now record the health of their colonies and the plants their bees visit most, building up a detailed picture of how urban wildlife is changing that professional researchers could never gather alone. Community beekeeping projects have also brought together neighbours who might otherwise never have met, and many keepers speak of the calm concentration required to work with a hive as a welcome escape from the noise of city life. In this way, a single rooftop hive can quietly benefit a garden, a research project and a community all at once.
Not everyone is convinced that more hives are always a good thing. Grace Adeyemi, who has run a beekeeping training course in Bristol for eight years, admits the trend brings real risks. 'People assume that keeping bees is automatically good for the environment, but that is not quite right,' she explains. 'In some popular neighbourhoods, there are now more hives than the local flowers can support, and the honeybees can end up competing with wild bees and other pollinators for a limited amount of food. Before anyone buys a hive, I always ask them to consider whether their garden or street actually needs more pollinators, or whether simply planting more flowers would do more good.' Responsible beekeeping, she argues, means thinking about the whole neighbourhood, not just the six wooden boxes on the roof.
Back in Manchester, Zara lowers the lid of the last hive and looks out across the rooftops. Below her, buses trundle along the high street and pigeons squabble over crumbs outside a cafe, while above her head the bees rise in a shimmering column before scattering towards gardens she will never see. It is a small, hopeful sign that even the busiest of cities can make room for something wild, provided, as Grace Adeyemi would insist, that it is done with care.
- A) a source of annoyance or trouble
- B) a valuable prize
- C) a type of insect
- D) a legal document
- A) certain that something is true
- B) confused about a topic
- C) excited about an idea
- D) forbidden from doing something
- A) causing worry or concern
- B) extremely exciting
- C) completely ordinary
- D) very colourful
Question 1
- identifies that 'richer pickings' suggests a more plentiful or better quality supply of food for the beesB1
- explains that comparing this favourably to a 'distant hillside' emphasises how surprising it is that a city can outdo the countryside, which the reader might expect to be better for bees - oeB1
- Answer: The phrase suggests the bees find a more plentiful, better supply of food in the city, and the comparison to a 'distant hillside' emphasises how surprising this is, since readers might expect the countryside to be the richer habitat.
Question 2
- accept any one of: how to inspect a hive without being stung; how to spot the early signs of disease; how to harvest honey safelyB1
- accept a second, different skill from the same listB1
- Answer: Any two of: inspecting a hive without being stung; spotting early signs of disease; harvesting honey safely.
Question 3
- local beekeeping associations (running evening classes and mentoring schemes)B1
- employers/businesses (installing hives on roofs as part of wellbeing programmes)B1
- primary schools (keeping an observation hive in the classroom)B1
- Answer: Local beekeeping associations, employers/businesses and primary schools.
Question 4
- AB1
- Answer: A) a source of annoyance or trouble
Question 5
- identifies that beekeepers record the health of their coloniesB1
- identifies that beekeepers record the plants their bees visit mostB1
- Answer: Citizen-science projects let hobbyist beekeepers record the health of their colonies and the plants their bees visit most.
Question 6
- whether their garden or street actually needs more pollinatorsB1
- whether simply planting more flowers would do more good insteadB1
- Answer: Whether the area actually needs more pollinators, and whether planting more flowers would do more good.
Question 7
- eight yearsB1
- BristolB1
- Answer: Eight years, in Bristol.
Question 8
- AB1
- Answer: A) certain that something is true
Question 9
- accept any one of: wildflower meadows were ploughed up for farmland or built over for housing; hedgerows were torn out to make way for larger fields; pesticides sprayed on crops proved harmful to pollinating insectsB1
- accept a second, different reason from the same listB1
- Answer: Any two of: meadows ploughed up or built over; hedgerows removed for larger fields; pesticides harming pollinators.
Question 10
- AB1
- Answer: A) causing worry or concern
Question 11
- 21/07/2018B1
- Answer: 21/07/2018
Question 12
- identifies that cities contain a huge variety of flowers, shrubs and trees that bloom at different times of yearB1
- identifies that a single crop flowers for only a few weeks before it is harvested, leaving bees without food for the rest of the year - oeB1
- Answer: Cities offer an enormous variety of plants that flower at different times, giving bees food all year round, whereas a farmer's field of one crop only flowers for a few weeks before it is harvested, leaving bees with nothing for the rest of the year.
Question 13
- accept either: cities are a degree or two warmer than the countryside; pesticide use is generally lower in gardens than on farmlandB1
- Answer: Cities are warmer than the countryside, or pesticide use is lower in gardens than on farmland (either accepted).
Question 14
- twelve storeys (accept: twelve storeys above a car park)B1
- Answer: twelve storeys
Question 15
- SixB1
- Answer: Six
Question 16
- accept any one of: wooden planters of lavender; the rainwater tank beside the hives; the city skyline visible beyond the roofB1
- accept a second, different detail from the same listB1
- Answer: Any two of: the wooden planters of lavender; the rainwater tank; the city skyline beyond.
Question 17
- Zara HuttonB1
- Answer: Zara Hutton
Question 18
- identifies that the passage states this data builds a detailed picture that professional researchers 'could never gather alone'B1
- explains that many amateur beekeepers, spread across different gardens and rooftops, can collect far more information from far more locations than a small team of researchers could manage by themselves - oeB1
- identifies that this ongoing, everyday recording builds up a wide and changing picture of urban wildlife over time, rather than a single snapshot - oeB1
- Answer: Because so many hobbyist beekeepers are already keeping bees across many different gardens and rooftops, they can gather far more data, from far more locations and over a longer period, than a small team of professional researchers could collect alone, building a fuller and more up-to-date picture of urban wildlife.
Question 19
- identifies that in some popular areas there are now more hives than the local flowers can support - oeB1
- identifies that honeybees end up competing with wild bees and other pollinators for a limited amount of food - oeB1
- explains the implied consequence, e.g. wild pollinators may go without enough food and be harmed by this competition - oeB1
- Answer: In some popular areas, too many hives have been set up compared with the amount of food the local flowers can provide, so honeybees end up competing with wild bees and other pollinators for a limited food supply, which could leave the wild pollinators worse off.
Question 20
- identifies that Adeyemi is an expert with direct experience (eight years running a training course), so a quotation adds authority and credibilityB1
- explains that hearing her own words lets the reader engage with her caution more directly and personally than a plain summary would - oeB1
- Answer: Because Adeyemi is an expert with eight years of direct experience, quoting her words directly adds authority and credibility to her warning, and lets the reader hear her caution in a more personal, convincing way than a simple summary could.
Question 21
- identifies that it creates a vivid, visual image of light reflecting or glittering off the mass of moving beesB1
- explains that it makes an everyday scene seem beautiful or almost magical, and suggests energy and movement - oeB1
- Answer: 'Shimmering column' creates a vivid image of light catching the bees as they rise together, making an everyday moment seem beautiful and almost magical while suggesting energy and movement.
Question 22
- identifies that returning to Zara links back to the opening scene, giving the passage a circular, frame-like structureB1
- identifies that the ending gives a vivid, hopeful, memorable image rather than closing on a warning, which may leave a more positive final impressionB1
- explains that Grace's caution is still referenced ('provided... that it is done with care'), so the balance of the passage is not lost even though it ends on a hopeful note - oeB1
- Answer: Returning to Zara gives the passage a circular structure that links back to its opening, and leaves the reader with a vivid, hopeful final image rather than a warning; the reference to Grace Adeyemi's caution in the final line still keeps the ending balanced rather than simply celebratory.
Question 23
- identifies support for bees themselves through training, mentoring and careful management by associations, employers and schools - oeB1
- identifies benefits to people and communities, such as staff wellbeing programmes, school observation hives, or bringing neighbours together - oeB1
- identifies the contribution to scientific understanding through citizen-science recording of colony health and plant visits - oeB1
- Answer: Training and mentoring from associations, employers and schools help new beekeepers look after their bees properly; the hobby also brings people together and supports staff and pupil wellbeing; and the records kept by hobbyist beekeepers feed into scientific research, helping build a detailed picture of urban wildlife.
Question 24
- recognises that the statement is not entirely accurate, since the passage is broadly positive but also includes genuine cautionB1
- supports this with evidence of clear benefits, e.g. citizen-science research or community wellbeing (paragraph 5), or bees thriving unexpectedly well in cities (paragraph 3)B1
- supports this with evidence of a genuine concern, e.g. Grace Adeyemi's warning about hives outcompeting wild pollinators (paragraph 6), reaching a balanced overall judgementB1
- Answer: The passage is not entirely one-sided: it presents clear benefits, such as bees thriving unexpectedly well in cities and beekeeping supporting research and community wellbeing (paragraphs 3 and 5), but it also gives real weight to Grace Adeyemi's warning that too many hives can harm wild pollinators (paragraph 6), so the overall view is balanced rather than entirely positive.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.