Comprehension: Non-Fiction: Practice Set 2 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
17 original exam-style questions - 8 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Comprehension: Non-Fiction: Practice Set 2 revision guideMore 11+ English practice
This topic is chapter 2 of 11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 3.
1.2-2 Comprehension: Non-Fiction: Practice Set 2
Back from the Brink: A Report on the Return of the Beaver to Britain
Source written for Revision Library (original, copyright-free). Informative non-fiction report created for 11+ comprehension practice.
For over four hundred years, the steady sound of splashing water and gnawed willow bark was missing from Britain's rivers and streams. The Eurasian beaver, a remarkably industrious engineer of wetlands, was hunted to extinction in this country by the sixteenth century, prized for its thick, waterproof fur and for castoreum, a musky oil harvested from its scent glands and once valued in perfumes and medicine. Without the beaver's instinctive habit of damming and diverting water, Britain's rivers gradually straightened, its wetlands were drained for farmland, and a rich, tangled habitat quietly vanished from the landscape, taking countless other species with it.
The beaver's fortunes in Britain began to change unexpectedly in 2015, when a small population was discovered living wild on the River Otter in Devon, apparently released without permission some years before. Rather than trap and remove the animals immediately, the government agreed to a cautious five-year trial, allowing ecologists to study their impact under strict licence. Numbers were monitored with great care: from a single breeding pair recorded in 2015, the population grew steadily year on year until, by the trial's conclusion in 2020, eight established family groups were thriving along the river's banks.
Beavers reshape almost any landscape in which they settle. Using their powerful, curved teeth, they fell small trees and drag branches and mud across streams to build dams, creating ponds and boggy wetlands behind them. Dr Priya Nair, an ecologist who monitored the River Otter trial closely, described the transformation as 'remarkable': the new wetlands slowed floodwater after heavy rainfall, held water in reserve during dry spells, and filtered harmful pollution from the water long before it reached the sea. Populations of fish, dragonflies and wading birds all increased sharply in the years that followed, delighting local birdwatchers.
Not everyone welcomed the beavers back with open arms, however. Several farmers whose land bordered the river complained that flooded fields and gnawed fruit trees threatened their livelihoods, and called publicly for stricter controls on where the animals could be permitted to spread. In response, a compensation scheme was introduced to cover the cost of damaged crops, alongside practical advice on protecting valuable trees with wire guards. Dr Nair argued that such conflicts were 'entirely manageable with patience and honest dialogue', rather than sufficient reason to abandon the project altogether.
The trial's evident success paved the way for wider change across the country. In 2022, the government granted beavers full legal protection in England and permitted licensed releases into enclosed sites, with proposals for cautious wild releases into open rivers expected to follow. By 2025, an estimated one thousand beavers were living across England, Scotland and Wales combined, a striking recovery for an animal that had been entirely absent from the landscape for centuries. Conservationists now hope that beavers might eventually spread along most major river systems in Britain without further direct human help.
Whether this represents an unqualified triumph or merely the beginning of a more complicated relationship between people and wildlife remains a matter of genuine debate. Supporters point to cleaner water, richer wildlife and stronger protection against flooding as reasons to celebrate the beaver's return. Critics counter that reintroducing a large, landscape-shaping animal into a crowded, carefully farmed country was always bound to create friction, and that the needs of farmers must be weighed just as carefully as those of the beavers themselves. What is certain is that, after four centuries of silence, the sound of beavers at work has returned to Britain's rivers, and shows no sign of disappearing again.
- A) a slow decline
- B) a complete change
- C) a minor adjustment
- D) a repeated pattern
- A) family homes
- B) the means by which people earn a living
- C) areas of farmland
- D) legal rights
- A) careful and hesitant, to avoid risk
- B) sudden and reckless
- C) expensive and complicated
- D) popular and widely welcomed
- True
- False
- True
- False
- True
- False
- True
- False
Question 1
- beavers were granted full legal protection in England in 2022B1
- licensed releases into enclosed sites were permittedB1
- proposals for wild releases into open rivers were expected to followB1
- by 2025, an estimated one thousand beavers were living across England, Scotland and WalesB1
- Answer: Any four of: full legal protection granted in England (2022); licensed releases into enclosed sites permitted; proposals for wild releases into open rivers expected; around one thousand beavers living across England, Scotland and Wales by 2025.
Question 2
- Level 1 Simple identification of a word or idea (for example that something is missing) with limited or undeveloped comment on effect.1-2
- Level 2 Clear and detailed explanation of how the language sets up the idea of absence and eventual return that runs through the whole passage, with precise reference to the language used.3-4
- Indicative content:
- 'Missing' immediately signals absence and loss, creating a sense that something is wrong
- The precise sensory detail, 'splashing water' and 'gnawed willow bark', makes the lost presence feel vivid and specific rather than abstract
- This establishes the passage's central theme of restoration, of something once lost being brought back
- It sets up the structure of the whole passage, which moves from absence, through reintroduction, to the beaver's eventual return
Question 3
- Level 1 A simple comment that the ending is positive or hopeful, with little or no reference to the text.1
- Level 2 A clear, and at the top of the band detailed, explanation of the structural and thematic effect of the ending, supported by relevant reference to the text.2-3
- Indicative content:
- The ending returns to the sound imagery introduced in the first paragraph, giving the passage a circular structure
- Describing the return as showing 'no sign of disappearing again' emphasises permanence and confidence in the project's success
- The ending follows a balanced discussion of both supporters' and critics' views, letting the image speak for itself rather than the writer stating a direct opinion
- This reinforces the passage's wider theme of restoration after centuries of absence
Question 4
- Level 1 A simple summary of the change, largely lifted from the text, with limited detail.1-2
- Level 2 A clear summary in the student's own words covering both the discovery and the trial's outcome, showing understanding of how and why the population changed.3-4
- Indicative content:
- A small population was found already living wild on the River Otter, apparently released without official permission
- Rather than removing the beavers straight away, the government chose to allow a supervised trial lasting five years
- Ecologists tracked the population closely throughout this period
- The population grew from a single breeding pair to eight established family groups by the time the trial ended
- Good answers will be expressed in the student's own words rather than copied directly from the text
Question 5
- Level 1 A simple comparison identifying that the two paragraphs present different views, with limited or no supporting reference.1-2
- Level 2 A clear comparison supported by relevant evidence from both paragraphs.3-4
- Level 3 A perceptive, well-developed comparison that selects precise evidence from both paragraphs and explores the shift in tone and focus in a nuanced way.5
- Indicative content:
- The third paragraph focuses on positive environmental change, for example 'slowed floodwater' and populations of wildlife increasing sharply
- The fourth paragraph focuses on the human cost of that same change, for example 'flooded fields and gnawed fruit trees threatened their livelihoods'
- Both paragraphs use expert or specific evidence to support their point, whether Dr Nair's description of 'remarkable' change or the farmers' practical complaints
- The third paragraph is largely celebratory in tone, while the fourth is more cautious and conflict-focused, though it ends on a reassuring note from Nair
- The contrast reflects the passage's wider balanced approach, acknowledging both benefits and genuine costs of reintroduction
- The strongest answers will select well-chosen evidence from both paragraphs and discuss the shift in tone precisely
Question 6
- (a) accept: 'Using their powerful, curved teeth, they fell small trees' or 'fell small trees'B1
- (a) Answer: fell small trees
- (b) held water in reserve during dry spellsB1
- (b) Answer: held water in reserve during dry spells
Question 7
- (a) BB1
- (a) Answer: B) a complete change
- (b) BB1
- (b) Answer: B) the means by which people earn a living
- (c) AB1
- (c) Answer: A) careful and hesitant, to avoid risk
Question 8
- 2015B1
- eight (8) family groupsB1
- Answer: 2015; eight family groups
Question 9
- Level 1 A simple, general comment about why the quotation is included, with little or no reference to the text.1
- Level 2 A clear and, at the top of the band, detailed explanation supported by relevant reference to the farmers' complaints, the compensation scheme and Nair's expert response described in the paragraph.2-3
- Indicative content:
- The paragraph first acknowledges genuine, serious complaints from farmers about flooded fields and damaged trees
- Nair's quotation, from an expert who monitored the trial, reassures the reader that these problems can be solved without abandoning the project
- It gives the passage balance, showing the writer takes both farmers' concerns and the project's benefits seriously
- As an ecologist directly involved in the trial, her calm, measured view carries particular authority
Question 10
- Level 1 A simple comment that 'engineer' suggests building or changing things, with little explanation of its effect.1
- Level 2 A clear explanation of the connotations of 'engineer' and its effect, for example the sense of skill, purpose or deliberate design it gives the beaver's behaviour.2
- Indicative content:
- 'Engineer' compares the beaver to a skilled human professional who designs and builds structures on purpose
- It suggests precision and deliberate skill, rather than random or accidental change to the landscape
- This word choice introduces the idea, developed later in the passage, of beavers actively reshaping wetlands through dam-building
Question 11
- Level 1 A simple, general comment that Nair supports the project, with little or no reference to the text.1
- Level 2 A clear, and at the top of the band detailed, explanation of her attitude supported by relevant and precise reference to the text.2-3
- Indicative content:
- She is enthusiastic and impressed, describing the transformation as 'remarkable'
- She does not dismiss the farmers' complaints, showing she takes real-world conflicts seriously
- She remains hopeful and constructive, believing conflicts are 'entirely manageable with patience and honest dialogue'
- Overall she comes across as an informed, balanced but ultimately supportive voice on the project
Question 12
- (a) industriousB1
- (a) Answer: industrious
- (b) prizedB1
- (b) Answer: prized
- (c) graduallyB1
- (c) Answer: gradually
- (d) vanishedB1
- (d) Answer: vanished
Question 13
- (a) FalseB1
- (a) Answer: False
- (b) FalseB1
- (b) Answer: False
- (c) TrueB1
- (c) Answer: True
- (d) TrueB1
- (d) Answer: True
Question 14
- correctly places 'Beavers are hunted to extinction in Britain' as event 1B1
- correctly places 'A small population is discovered living wild on the River Otter' as event 2B1
- correctly places 'Eight beaver family groups are recorded thriving on the River Otter' as event 3B1
- correctly places 'The government grants beavers full legal protection in England' as event 4B1
- Answer: 1: beavers hunted to extinction (by the sixteenth century); 2: small population discovered on the River Otter (2015); 3: eight family groups recorded thriving (2020); 4: full legal protection granted (2022).
Question 15
- Level 1 A simple statement of agreement or disagreement with limited or no textual support.1-2
- Level 2 A clear response with relevant reference to language or structure, showing some understanding of the effect of Nair's quotations.3-4
- Level 3 A detailed, well-supported evaluation exploring more than one aspect of the passage (for example Nair's quotations alongside another section), with well-chosen quotations.5-6
- Level 4 A perceptive, well-structured evaluation that considers different aspects of the whole passage in a balanced way, with precise textual support and a convincing, considered personal judgement.7-8
- Indicative content:
- Consideration of how Nair's quotations provide expert authority, lending credibility to claims about the beavers' benefits
- Discussion of specific persuasive detail in her quotations, such as 'remarkable' and 'entirely manageable with patience and honest dialogue', and how these reassure the reader
- Consideration of the quotations' position at key turning points in the argument, following both the description of benefits and of conflict
- A balanced response might argue that the closing paragraph's balanced reflection, or the statistics in paragraph 5, are equally or more persuasive, since these frame the passage's overall case
- Reward well supported personal judgements in either direction, provided they are backed by precise reference to language and structure across the whole passage
Question 16
- Level 1 A simple, generalised response with little or no reference to different parts of the passage.1-2
- Level 2 A clear explanation supported by some accurate reference to different parts of the passage.3-4
- Level 3 A detailed, well-developed explanation drawing on well-chosen evidence from across the passage, showing clear understanding of how the writer's view develops from beginning to end.5-6
- Indicative content:
- The passage opens by establishing what was lost when beavers vanished from Britain centuries ago
- It describes a careful, monitored process of reintroduction, backed by expert study and growing population numbers
- It acknowledges genuine conflict with farmers, showing the writer is not presenting an entirely one-sided view
- It ends with a deliberately balanced reflection on whether the return is an unqualified success or a more complicated ongoing relationship
- Overall the writer conveys cautious optimism about restoring lost wildlife, alongside honest acknowledgement that coexistence with people requires ongoing effort
Question 17
- Content and organisation (AO5)
- Level 3 A convincing and engaging article voice suited to visitors. Ideas are skilfully developed, balancing what has been gained and what challenges remain with clear, well supported personal opinion. Structure is well controlled, with an effective introduction, purposeful paragraphing and a satisfying conclusion. Vocabulary is ambitious and well matched to purpose and audience.8-10
- Level 2 A consistent article voice. Ideas are developed with relevant points about what has been gained and what challenges remain, and a clear personal opinion. Structure is clear, with a suitable introduction, middle and conclusion. Vocabulary is chosen for effect.5-7
- Level 1 Some awareness of an article style. Ideas are simple and may be one-sided or list-like. Organisation is limited, with little sense of shape. Vocabulary is plain or repetitive.1-4
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 A wide range of punctuation is used with a high level of accuracy. Sentence structures are varied and controlled for effect. Spelling is consistently accurate, including ambitious vocabulary. Standard English forms are used extensively and effectively.5-6
- Level 2 A range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately. There is some variety of sentence structures. Spelling is generally accurate. Standard English is used with reasonable control.3-4
- Level 1 Punctuation is limited or repetitive, with some errors. Sentence structures are mainly simple. Spelling errors are frequent, though meaning remains clear.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- Award up to 10 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 6 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above
- Do not itemise individual points as marks; use best-fit judgement across each grid
- Reward well organised, well argued non-fiction writing that engages the reader and reaches a clear, supported personal view, whether or not the student concludes that the beaver's return has been an overall success
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.