Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 9 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
26 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 9 revision guideMore 11+ English practice
This topic is chapter 3 of 11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 4.
1.2-9 Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 9
Should Homework Be Scrapped?
Source written for Revision Library (original, copyright-free).
Do you dread the moment your teacher says, 'Right, here's tonight's homework'? You are not alone. For as long as anyone can remember, homework has followed every school day home through the front door, and for just as long, pupils, parents and even some teachers have argued about whether it actually does any good. Is homework a genuinely useful part of learning, or is it, as some critics claim, an outdated habit that schools should finally scrap?
Supporters of homework make a straightforward case. Lessons only last a certain number of minutes, they argue, and homework gives pupils extra time to practise what they have learned, whether that means working through maths problems, reading a novel chapter by chapter, or revising key facts before a test. Homework can also teach skills that go beyond any single subject: managing your own time, working without a teacher standing over your shoulder, and building the kind of independent study habits that become essential in secondary school and beyond. Some surveys of secondary school pupils suggest that those who regularly complete homework tend to feel more confident walking into exams, simply because the material feels familiar rather than new.
Critics, however, argue that homework causes more problems than it solves. After a full day of lessons, they say, children need time to rest, play, see their families and get enough sleep, and homework eats into all of these. There is also a fairness problem. A pupil with a quiet bedroom, a reliable laptop and a parent free to help after dinner has a huge advantage over a pupil sharing a noisy living room with younger siblings and no computer at all. Rather than levelling the playing field, critics argue, homework can end up widening the very gaps in achievement that schools are supposed to be closing.
Faced with this disagreement, some schools have started to rethink their approach rather than abandoning homework altogether. At Ashcroft Academy, a secondary school in Leeds, homework was cut back sharply two years ago in favour of shorter, more focused tasks, alongside free after-school homework clubs where pupils without a quiet space at home can work using the school's computers and books. 'We didn't want to scrap homework completely,' explains deputy head teacher Daniel Osoba, 'but we wanted every pupil to have a genuinely fair chance of completing it well, not just the ones lucky enough to have the right conditions at home.'
It is worth asking whether the real argument is not homework versus no homework, but good homework versus bad homework. Twenty identical spelling words copied out five times each teaches a pupil very little except how to hold a pen for longer. A short, carefully chosen task that makes a pupil think, practise a genuine skill, or connect a lesson to their own life is a completely different matter, however long or short it happens to be.
So, should homework be scrapped? Perhaps the fairest answer is that scrapping homework altogether would throw away something genuinely useful, but simply setting more of it is not the answer either. What seems to matter far more than the amount of homework a school sets is its quality, and whether every pupil, whatever their home life looks like, has a fair chance to complete it. The next time homework lands on your desk, it might be worth asking not 'why do I have to do this?' but 'is this actually helping me learn?'
- A) making something larger or broader
- B) making something completely disappear
- C) making something more expensive
- D) making something happen more slowly
- A) improving something gradually
- B) copying something exactly
- C) postponing something briefly
- D) giving up on something completely
- A) only occasionally or rarely
- B) truly or really, without any pretence
- C) according to a strict set of rules
- D) in a way that costs very little money
- A) extremely rare or unusual
- B) based on a mistake
- C) simple and easy to understand
- D) written in a very technical style
- A) enjoyed by only a small number of people
- B) no longer suitable because it belongs to the past
- C) extremely expensive to continue
- D) officially banned by the government
Question 1
- rest (accept: sleep)B1
- play (accept: see their families)B1
- Answer: Any two of: rest; play; see their families; get enough sleep.
Question 2
- describes the advantaged pupil's conditions, e.g. a quiet bedroom, a reliable laptop, a parent free to help after dinnerB1
- describes the disadvantaged pupil's conditions, e.g. a noisy living room with younger siblings and no computer at allB1
- explains the resulting inequality, e.g. some pupils have a much easier time completing homework well through no fault of their own, giving them an unfair advantage over othersB1
- Answer: The 'fairness problem' is that a pupil with a quiet bedroom, a reliable laptop and a parent free to help has a much easier time completing homework than a pupil sharing a noisy living room with younger siblings and no computer at all, meaning some pupils have an unfair advantage through no fault of their own.
Question 3
- AB1
- Answer: A) making something larger or broader
Question 4
- explains that the phrase means making a situation fair or equal for everyone involvedB1
- links this to the point being made, e.g. critics argue that homework actually does the opposite of this, giving already-advantaged pupils a further edge rather than making things equalB1
- Answer: 'Levelling the playing field' means making a situation fair and equal for everyone; the writer uses it to show that critics believe homework does the opposite, giving pupils who already have advantages an even bigger edge, rather than making things equal.
Question 5
- LeedsB1
- Answer: Leeds
Question 6
- two years agoB1
- Answer: Two years ago.
Question 7
- the school's computers and booksB1
- Answer: The school's computers and books.
Question 8
- deputy head teacherB1
- Answer: Deputy head teacher.
Question 9
- identifies that a direct quotation from someone closely involved, the deputy head teacher, adds authority to the school's reasoningB1
- explains the effect, e.g. it lets the reader hear the school's justification in its own words, making the example feel more genuine and convincing than a plain summaryB1
- Answer: Including a direct quotation from the deputy head teacher adds authority, since it comes from someone closely involved in the decision, and lets the reader hear the school's own reasoning in its own words, making the example feel more genuine and convincing than a plain summary would.
Question 10
- DB1
- Answer: D) giving up on something completely
Question 11
- BB1
- Answer: B) truly or really, without any pretence
Question 12
- 'why do I have to do this?'B1
- 'is this actually helping me learn?'B1
- Answer: 'Why do I have to do this?' and 'is this actually helping me learn?'
Question 13
- working through maths problemsB1
- reading a novel chapter by chapter (accept: revising key facts before a test)B1
- Answer: Any two of: working through maths problems; reading a novel chapter by chapter; revising key facts before a test.
Question 14
- accept any one of: managing your own time; working without a teacher standing over your shoulder; building independent study habitsB1
- Answer: Any one of: managing your own time; working without a teacher standing over your shoulder; building independent study habits.
Question 15
- CB1
- Answer: C) simple and easy to understand
Question 16
- identifies that they tend to feel more confident walking into examsB1
- identifies the reason given: because the material feels familiar rather than newB1
- Answer: They tend to feel more confident walking into exams, because the material feels familiar rather than new.
Question 17
- identifies that addressing the reader directly with a question draws them into the passageB1
- explains the effect, e.g. it makes the topic feel personal and relatable by referring to an experience many readers will recognise, engaging them before the debate is introducedB1
- Answer: Opening with a direct question draws the reader in immediately, since it refers to an experience many of them will recognise, which makes the topic feel personal and relatable before the writer introduces the wider debate.
Question 18
- identifies that it reassures the reader that this is a common, shared feeling rather than something unusual to themB1
- explains the effect, e.g. it builds a sense of connection or solidarity between the writer and the reader, making the reader feel understood before the argument developsB1
- Answer: The phrase reassures the reader that dreading homework is a common feeling, not something unusual to them, which builds a sense of connection between the writer and the reader before the wider argument is introduced.
Question 19
- for as long as anyone can rememberB1
- Answer: For as long as anyone can remember.
Question 20
- accept either: parents; (some) teachersB1
- Answer: Parents (or: some teachers).
Question 21
- BB1
- Answer: B) no longer suitable because it belongs to the past
Question 22
- identifies that it shifts the argument away from a simple yes/no debate towards a more thoughtful comparison of qualityB1
- explains the effect, e.g. it encourages the reader to think more carefully about the issue and moves the argument forward, rather than just restating the two sides already givenB1
- Answer: Reframing the debate this way shifts it away from a simple yes-or-no argument towards a more thoughtful comparison of quality, encouraging the reader to think more carefully about the issue and moving the argument forward rather than simply restating the two sides already given.
Question 23
- identifies the contrast between a repetitive, low-value task and a purposeful, thoughtful oneB1
- explains the effect, e.g. it makes clear to the reader that the amount of homework matters less than its quality, supporting the writer's wider argumentB1
- Answer: The comparison contrasts a repetitive, low-value task with a purposeful, thoughtful one, making clear to the reader that the amount of homework matters far less than its quality, which supports the writer's wider argument.
Question 24
- identifies that it invites the reader to form their own judgement, keeping the debate open rather than closing it downB1
- explains the effect, e.g. it leaves a thought-provoking, memorable final impression and connects back to the direct, personal tone used at the start of the passageB1
- Answer: Ending on a question invites the reader to form their own judgement rather than simply being told what to think, leaving a thought-provoking, memorable final impression that echoes the direct, personal tone used to open the passage.
Question 25
- identifies the fairness problem from paragraph 3, e.g. pupils with a quiet bedroom, a laptop and a helpful parent have an advantage over those withoutB1
- identifies the relevant detail from paragraph 4, e.g. free after-school homework clubs offering computers and books to pupils without a quiet space at homeB1
- draws the two together, e.g. explains that the clubs are specifically designed to give every pupil access to the resources needed to complete homework well, directly addressing the inequality raised earlierB1
- Answer: Paragraph 3 describes how pupils with a quiet bedroom, a laptop and a helpful parent have a big advantage over those without; Ashcroft Academy's free after-school homework clubs, described in paragraph 4, offer computers and books to pupils who lack these things at home, directly addressing that inequality by giving every pupil access to the resources needed to complete homework well.
Question 26
- identifies that the writer does not think homework should be scrapped altogether, since scrapping it would 'throw away something genuinely useful'B1
- identifies that the writer instead believes the amount of homework matters less than its quality, and whether every pupil has a fair chance to complete itB1
- Answer: The writer does not think homework should be scrapped altogether, since paragraph 6 states that doing so would 'throw away something genuinely useful'; instead, the writer believes what matters most is the quality of homework, and whether every pupil has a fair chance to complete it well.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.