Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 13 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
24 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 13 revision guideMore 11+ English practice
This topic is chapter 7 of 11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 4.
1.2-13 Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 13
Reading by Touch: The Story of Braille
Original non-fiction text written for Revision Library.
Across the world, millions of blind and partially sighted people read every single day, not with their eyes but with the tips of their fingers, moving lightly across patterns of raised dots pressed into paper. This system, now used in almost every language on Earth, is named after the boy who invented it: Louis Braille, who was only fifteen years old when he solved a problem that had frustrated inventors for decades.
Louis was born in 1809 in the small French village of Coupvray, the son of a leatherworker whose workshop was filled with sharp tools. At the age of three, while playing with one of his father's awls, he suffered an accident that badly damaged one eye; an infection soon spread to the other, and by the time he was five, Louis was completely blind. Determined that he should still receive an education, his parents sent him, aged ten, to the Royal Institute for Blind Youth in Paris.
At the Institute, students learned to read using books printed with large, raised letters that had to be traced slowly, letter by letter, with a fingertip; a single page could take several minutes to read, and writing was almost impossible. Everything changed when a former soldier named Charles Barbier visited the school and demonstrated a system he had designed for the French army: a code of raised dots, called night writing, that allowed soldiers to pass silent messages to one another in the dark without lighting a dangerous lamp.
Barbier's military code used cells of twelve dots, arranged in two columns of six, which Louis found frustratingly difficult; a fingertip could not feel an entire cell without moving, which slowed reading down considerably. Working largely at night in his dormitory, using an awl not unlike the one that had blinded him, Louis spent three years experimenting with smaller patterns, until, aged just fifteen, he arrived at a six-dot cell, arranged in two columns of three, that a single fingertip could read in one touch.
"What made Louis's system so remarkable was not only its simplicity, but how completely he understood the problem from the inside," explains Professor Aline Rousseau, a historian of assistive technology. "He was not a sighted inventor guessing at what blind readers might need. He was a blind fifteen-year-old solving his own daily frustration, and that is precisely why it worked so well." Despite its brilliance, the Institute's own director banned the system for years, insisting that blind students should learn to read the same raised-letter text as sighted people.
It was not until 1854, two years after Louis Braille's death from tuberculosis at the age of forty-three, that France officially adopted his system nationwide. Since then, braille has been adapted for nearly every written language, as well as for mathematics and music notation, and today it remains in daily use even as technology advances: modern refreshable braille displays now allow digital text to be felt, dot by dot, in real time. Nearly two centuries after a teenager sat working in the dark, his six small dots continue to open books to readers who cannot see the page.
- A) Simple
- B) Compound
- C) Complex
- D) Minor
- A) Noun
- B) Verb
- C) Adjective
- D) Adverb
Question 1
- Identifies that this shows the real danger soldiers faced, since lighting a lamp could reveal their positionB1
- Explains that it shows why a touch-based code was so useful, since it worked without light or soundB1
- Explains the effect on the reader, e.g. it makes the reader appreciate the ingenuity behind the dot system's military origins before Louis adapted itB1
- Answer: This description shows the real danger soldiers faced, since lighting a lamp could reveal their position, and explains why a touch-based code that needed neither light nor sound was so useful. It makes the reader appreciate the ingenuity behind the dot system's military origins, before Louis adapted it for reading.
Question 2
- Adds authority and credibility, since she is an expert (a historian of assistive technology)B1
- Makes the information feel more personal and engaging for the reader than a plain statement of factB1
- Her specific point about Louis being 'a blind fifteen-year-old solving his own daily frustration' emphasises exactly why the invention succeeded, making the claim more vivid and convincingB1
- Answer: Including an expert's direct words makes the information more credible, since Professor Rousseau speaks with authority as a historian of assistive technology; her specific point that Louis was 'a blind fifteen-year-old solving his own daily frustration' also makes the reasons for his success feel more vivid and convincing to the reader.
Question 3
- He insisted that blind students should learn to read the same raised-letter text as sighted peopleB1
- This shows a resistance to changing the existing method, despite the new system's advantagesB1
- Answer: He insisted that blind students should learn to read the same raised-letter text as sighted people, showing a resistance to change even though the new system had clear advantages.
Question 4
- (a) CB1
- (a) Answer: C) Complex
Question 5
- They still allow digital text to be felt, dot by dot, with the fingertips, rather than seen with the eyesB1
- This shows the underlying dot-based reading system Louis invented is still the basis for reading by touch today, even as the technology has changedB1
- Answer: Modern refreshable braille displays still allow digital text to be felt, dot by dot, with the fingertips, showing that the underlying dot-based system Louis invented remains the basis for reading by touch today, even as the surrounding technology has changed.
Question 6
- Identifies that the paragraph opens with the limitation of Barbier's twelve-dot systemB1
- Identifies that it then explains why this was difficult (a fingertip could not feel an entire cell without moving) before describing three years of experimentationB1
- Explains the effect, e.g. this takes the reader step by step through the problem to the solution, mirroring Louis's own process and building a sense of achievementB1
- Answer: The paragraph opens with the limitation of Barbier's twelve-dot system, explains why it was difficult to read, and then describes three years of experimentation before arriving at the six-dot solution. This takes the reader step by step through the problem to the solution, mirroring Louis's own process and building a sense of achievement.
Question 7
- Identifies the phrase 'It was not until'B1
- Explains its effect, e.g. it signals how long recognition took, emphasising the contrast between years of resistance and eventual official adoptionB1
- Answer: The connective phrase is 'It was not until'. It signals how long recognition took, emphasising the contrast between years of resistance and the system's eventual official adoption.
Question 8
- (a) Meaning close to 'left unable to be solved, or annoyingly blocked'B1
- (a) Answer: left unable to be solved, or annoyingly blocked
- (b) Meaning close to 'firmly decided, resolved to make something happen'B1
- (b) Answer: firmly decided, resolved to make something happen
- (c) Meaning close to 'by a large amount, significantly'B1
- (c) Answer: by a large amount, significantly
- (d) Meaning close to 'impressive and worthy of attention'B1
- (d) Answer: impressive and worthy of attention
Question 9
- They were determined that he should still receive an educationB1
- This was despite the fact that he had become completely blind by the age of fiveB1
- Answer: His parents were determined that he should still receive an education, despite the fact that he had become completely blind by the age of five.
Question 10
- Because each large, raised letter had to be traced slowly, letter by letter, with a fingertipB1
- Answer: Because each large, raised letter had to be traced slowly, letter by letter, with a fingertip.
Question 11
- (a) CB1
- (a) Answer: C) Adjective
Question 12
- Identifies that the semicolon links two closely related independent clauses (each of which could stand alone as a sentence)B1
- Explains that the second clause continues the sequence of events introduced in the first, without needing a conjunctionB1
- Answer: The semicolon links two closely related independent clauses, without a conjunction; the second clause continues the sequence of events described in the first.
Question 13
- Identifies that people read with their fingertips, moving across raised dots, and that Louis Braille was fifteen when he invented the systemB1
- Answer: They read with their fingertips, moving across patterns of raised dots, and Louis Braille was fifteen years old when he invented the system.
Question 14
- Night writingB1
- Answer: Night writing.
Question 15
- He was not a sighted inventor guessing at what blind readers might needB1
- He was a blind fifteen-year-old solving his own daily frustrationB1
- Answer: Because he was not a sighted inventor guessing at what blind readers might need, but a blind fifteen-year-old solving his own daily frustration.
Question 16
- 1854B1
- Answer: 1854.
Question 17
- Forty-three (43)B1
- Answer: Forty-three.
Question 18
- frustrated inventors for decadesB1
- Answer: frustrated inventors for decades
Question 19
- 1809B1
- Answer: 1809.
Question 20
- Coupvray, in FranceB1
- A leatherworkerB1
- Answer: He was born in Coupvray, France, and his father was a leatherworker.
Question 21
- Level 1 Basic identification of purpose (e.g. to inform), with little or no use of evidence.1
- Level 2 Clear identification of purpose with relevant supporting evidence from the text.2-3
- Level 3 Well-evidenced explanation of purpose, showing how specific facts, dates and quotations build the writer's case across the whole article.4
- Indicative content:
- Purpose is to inform readers about Braille's history and to convey admiration for a remarkable teenage achievement
- Precise dates (1809, 1854) and the age fifteen give the article factual authority
- The historical detail (Barbier's night writing, three years of experimentation) creates a sense of process and achievement
- The expert quotation from Professor Rousseau adds credibility and explains why the invention succeeded
Question 22
- Identifies that the writer presents Louis as a determined, patient inventor working through a personal problemB1
- Supports this with reference to specific detail, e.g. he 'spent three years experimenting with smaller patterns' at night in his dormitoryB1
- Explains that the closing paragraph, describing braille's continued use today, suggests his achievement has had a lasting, worldwide legacyB1
- Answer: The writer creates the impression that Louis Braille was a determined, patient inventor, shown by the detail that he 'spent three years experimenting with smaller patterns' working at night in his dormitory. The final paragraph, describing braille's continued use in nearly every language and in modern refreshable displays, suggests his achievement has had a lasting, worldwide legacy.
Question 23
- Identifies that the chronological structure lets the reader follow Louis's whole life story in a clear, logical orderB1
- Explains the effect, e.g. it builds towards the final point about the system's lasting adoption, which only makes sense once the reader understands the years of resistance that came before itB1
- Answer: The chronological structure lets the reader follow Louis's whole story, from his birth and blindness to his invention and its eventual adoption, in a clear, logical order. This builds towards the final point about the system's lasting adoption, which only makes full sense once the reader understands the years of resistance that came before it.
Question 24
- Level 1 States a viewpoint with little or no justification; minimal or no textual reference.1-2
- Level 2 Gives a clear opinion supported by relevant reference to at least one viewpoint from the text.3
- Level 3 Gives a well-reasoned, developed opinion that engages with both viewpoints from the text, supported by precise textual evidence.4
- Indicative content:
- Case for agreeing: the system was 'remarkable' and worked because Louis understood the problem 'from the inside', so delaying it denied students a better method for years
- Case for disagreeing: the director may have sincerely believed blind students should read 'the same raised-letter text as sighted people', reflecting genuine (if mistaken) educational belief rather than pure stubbornness
- Either viewpoint is acceptable if supported by precise evidence from the text
- Reward answers that weigh the clear eventual success of braille against the director's stated reasoning at the time
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.