Required practical: Two students, Amara and Josh, from a school near Bristol investigated variation in the shell banding pattern of the land snail Cepaea nemoralis. This snail's shell can be plain (unbanded) or striped (banded), a characteristic controlled by a gene. The students sampled snails from two habitats: a short grassland meadow and a hedgerow with variable light and shade. Their results are shown below. Grassland: 32 banded out of 40 snails sampled. Hedgerow: 45 banded out of 60 snails sampled.
(a)Describe how the students could use quadrats to obtain an unbiased, random sample of snails within each habitat.(2)
(b)Suggest one variable, other than the species sampled, that the students should try to keep the same when comparing the two habitats.(1)
(c)Calculate the percentage of snails that were banded in the grassland habitat.(2)
(d)Calculate the percentage of snails that were banded in the hedgerow habitat.(1)
(e)Using your answers to (c) and (d), and the idea of natural selection, explain why banded snails might be more common in the grassland than in the hedgerow.(3)
(f)Explain why increasing the sample size from 40-60 snails per habitat to 400-600 snails per habitat would make the students' conclusion more valid.(2)
(g)Suggest one reason, other than camouflage and predation, why the frequency of the banded allele might differ between two separate snail populations.(1)
(h)State what is meant by 'natural selection', using this investigation as an example.(1)
(i)Explain one limitation of using shell-banding percentage alone as evidence that natural selection is acting on this population.(2)
(Total for Question 11 is 15 marks)