Worked question 10 - Inheritance, Variation and Evolution
Answer and mark scheme
Question 10
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) lay a tape measure/grid across the habitat and use a random number generator (or random number table) to choose coordinates for quadrat placement |
| B1 | (a) place the quadrat at each random coordinate and count/record the snails found inside it, repeating this for a suitable number of quadrats across the habitat |
| B1 | (b) e.g. time of day, time of year/season, weather conditions, or sampling effort (number of quadrats/area sampled) - any one sensible controlled variable |
| M1 | (c) (32 / 40) x 100 |
| A1 | (c) 80% cao |
| B1 | (d) 75% cao [(45/60) x 100] |
| B1 | (e) predators (e.g. thrushes) hunt snails by sight, and snails that are less well camouflaged in their habitat are more likely to be seen and eaten |
| B1 | (e) in the hedgerow, the patchy light and shade mean plain (unbanded) shells are better camouflaged, while in the short grassland, banded shells are better camouflaged against the streaky grass background |
| B1 | (e) in the grassland the banded/striped shell gives better camouflage against the streaky grass background, so banded snails are less likely to be predated by birds, more likely to survive and reproduce, and pass on the allele for banding; this selection pressure explains the higher percentage of banded snails in the grassland (80%) than in the hedgerow (75%) (oe reasoning credited) |
| B1 | (f) a larger sample size reduces the effect of chance/random variation on the results (e.g. from sampling a few snails in one patch by chance) |
| B1 | (f) so the calculated percentages are more likely to be representative of the true population in each habitat, making the comparison between habitats more valid |
| B1 | (g) e.g. the populations may be isolated with little migration between them (so allele frequencies can drift apart by chance), or one population may have started with a different allele frequency by chance (founder effect) - any sensible alternative explanation |
| B1 | (h) the process by which organisms with characteristics (e.g. shell pattern) best suited to their environment are more likely to survive and reproduce, passing those characteristics on to their offspring (oe, in context) |
| B1 | (i) other factors could also affect the observed percentages, e.g. differences in predator density between the two sites, or migration of snails between habitats, which are not measured in this investigation (oe) |
| B1 | (i) so a difference in banding percentage alone does not prove that camouflage/predation (natural selection) is the cause, without ruling out these other factors |
- (a) Answer: Use random numbers to choose coordinates along a grid laid across the habitat, then place the quadrat at each coordinate and record the snails found, repeating for several quadrats.
- (b) Answer: For example, sampling at the same time of year and in similar weather conditions in both habitats.
- (c) Answer: 80%
- (d) Answer: 75%
- (e) Answer: Grassland has 80% banded snails versus 75% in the hedgerow. Banded shells might be better camouflaged against the streaky grassland background, while plain shells might be better camouflaged in the patchy light and shade of the hedgerow. Birds hunt snails by sight, so better-camouflaged banded snails in grassland are less likely to be eaten and more likely to survive and reproduce. They pass the banding allele to their offspring, increasing its frequency over generations.
- (f) Answer: A bigger sample reduces the effect of chance, so the percentages calculated are more likely to reflect the true population, making the comparison more valid.
- (g) Answer: For example, the two populations may be isolated from each other, so random chance (genetic drift) or the starting allele frequencies could differ, independent of camouflage.
- (h) Answer: The process by which the best-camouflaged (best-adapted) snails are more likely to survive, reproduce and pass on their shell-pattern allele.
- (i) Answer: Other factors, such as differences in predator numbers or migration between sites, could also explain the pattern; the data alone cannot rule these out as the true cause.









