Variation, Evolution and Selection - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
22 original exam-style questions - 15 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Variation, Evolution and Selection revision guideMore GCSE Science practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 2 of GCSE Biology Topic Workbook 4 and chapter 20 of GCSE Biology 10-Minute Tests.
1.16 Variation, Evolution and Selection
Survival of the Fittest Bacteria
Original text written for Revision Library.
Every time a course of antibiotics is prescribed by a GP surgery or an NHS hospital, it puts a bacterial population under intense selection pressure. Most bacteria in an infection are killed by the drug, but a tiny number may already carry a random mutation that happens to protect them, for example by breaking down the antibiotic molecule before it can act. These resistant bacteria survive, face far less competition for space and nutrients, and reproduce rapidly by binary fission, doubling in number every twenty minutes or so under favourable conditions. Because bacteria reproduce so quickly, resistant strains can become established in a population within days rather than the many generations natural selection usually takes in animals or plants. Meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) is one well-known example that now causes serious problems in hospitals across the United Kingdom. Understanding this process, essentially natural selection acting on a very short timescale, helps explain why doctors are urged to prescribe antibiotics only when necessary, and why patients are always told to complete the full course.
Question 1
- (a) Kingdom first and Species lastM1
- (a) fully correct order: Kingdom, Family, Genus, SpeciesA1
- (a) Answer: Kingdom, Family, Genus, Species.
- (b) Papaver (the genus name is always given first and capitalised)B1
- (b) Answer: Papaver.
Question 2
- only prescribe antibiotics for serious bacterial infections, not for viral infections such as colds or fluB1
- patients should always complete the full course of antibiotics as prescribed, rather than stopping early once they feel betterB1
- avoid unnecessary use of antibiotics, e.g. in agriculture, and improve hygiene/infection control to reduce the spread of resistant strains; any three distinct measures for 3 marks, oeB1
- Answer: For example: only prescribe antibiotics for bacterial (not viral) infections; patients complete the full course; improve hygiene and avoid unnecessary agricultural use to limit the spread of resistant strains.
Question 3
- (a) differences between individuals of a species caused by differences in their genes/alleles/DNA, oeB1
- (a) Answer: Differences between individuals caused by differences in their genes (alleles).
- (b) mutation (creates new alleles)B1
- (b) meiosis (independent assortment of chromosomes) or sexual reproduction / random fusion of gametes from two parents, oe; any two of these sources for 2 marksB1
- (b) Answer: Mutation, and meiosis (or sexual reproduction / the random fusion of gametes from two parents).
Question 4
- (a) correct substitution shown: (68 - 2) / 2 x 100M1
- (a) 3300% caoA1
- (a) Answer: 3300%
- (b) 22 (percentage points per decade) cao; ecf allowed from a correctly divided total increase carried forward from (a)B1
- (b) Answer: 22 percentage points per decade.
- (c) mutations occurring in the bacterial population meant some individual bacteria already carried a gene/allele giving resistance to meticillin, even before it was widely usedB1
- (c) when meticillin was used, non-resistant bacteria were killed, while resistant bacteria survived and faced less competition for resourcesB1
- (c) resistant bacteria reproduced (by binary fission), passing on the resistance allele to their offspring, so the proportion of resistant bacteria in the population increased over each decade, oeB1
- (c) Answer: Some bacteria already carried a resistance mutation before meticillin was used; non-resistant bacteria were killed by the antibiotic while resistant ones survived with less competition; resistant bacteria reproduced and passed on the resistance allele, so the proportion of resistant bacteria increased each decade.
Question 5
- (a) number of divisions = 120 / 20 = 6 (or 26 identified)M1
- (a) 256 caoA1
- (a) Answer: 256 bacteria.
- (b) correct number of doublings identified = 8 (population = 4 x 28 = 1024, the first value to exceed 1000); ecf from a correct doubling calculation carried forward from (a)M1
- (b) 160 minutes cao (accept 2 hours 40 minutes)A1
- (b) Answer: 160 minutes (2 hours 40 minutes).
- (c) bacteria reproduce (and produce new generations, including any new mutations) far more quickly and frequently than slower-reproducing organisms, so natural selection can act, and resistant strains can become established, over a much shorter timescale, oeB1
- (c) Answer: Because bacteria produce new generations, and therefore new mutations, far more quickly than slower-reproducing organisms, so natural selection can act over a much shorter timescale.
Question 6
- selective breeding reduces the genetic variation within the population, because only individuals with the desired characteristic(s) are bred fromB1
- this can lead to inbreeding, increasing the chance that individuals inherit two copies of a harmful recessive allele (inbreeding depression)B1
- reduced genetic variation also makes the population less able to adapt to a new environmental change, or to resist a new disease, which could threaten the whole population, oeB1
- Answer: Selective breeding reduces genetic variation, which can cause inbreeding depression (an increased chance of inheriting two copies of a harmful recessive allele) and leaves the population less able to adapt to new diseases or environmental change.
Question 7
- the gene for human growth hormone is identified/isolated from human DNA, often using a restriction enzyme to cut the DNA at specific points either side of the geneB1
- a plasmid (a small circular piece of bacterial DNA) is removed from a bacterium and cut open using the same restriction enzyme, leaving matching/complementary endsB1
- the growth hormone gene is inserted into the cut plasmid using an enzyme called ligase, joining the two pieces of DNA together to form recombinant DNAB1
- the recombinant plasmid (acting as a vector) is inserted into a new bacterial cellB1
- the genetically modified bacteria are grown/cultured in large numbers (e.g. in fermenters); as they reproduce, they express the inserted gene, producing human growth hormone, which is then extracted and purified, oeB1
- Answer: The HGH gene is cut from human DNA and a bacterial plasmid is cut open, both using the same restriction enzyme; the gene is inserted into the plasmid using ligase to form recombinant DNA; the recombinant plasmid (vector) is inserted into a bacterium, which is then cultured in large numbers to express and produce human growth hormone.
Question 8
- (a) the theory challenged the widely held religious belief that God had created all species and that species did not changeB1
- (a) there was not enough evidence available at the time to fully convince other scientists, as the mechanism of inheritance (genes/DNA) was not yet known/understood; or the theory contradicted Lamarck's well-established theory of inheritance of acquired characteristics; any two for 2 marks, oeB1
- (a) Answer: It challenged widely held religious beliefs about the fixed creation of species, and there was not yet enough scientific evidence (the mechanism of inheritance was unknown) to fully convince other scientists.
- (b) characteristics acquired during an organism's lifetime are not caused by a change to the genes/alleles in its sex cells (gametes), so they cannot be passed on to offspring through inheritanceB1
- (b) example, e.g. a giraffe that stretches its neck to reach higher leaves does not produce offspring with longer necks, because stretching does not change the DNA/genes passed on in its gametes, oe (accept other valid example)B1
- (b) Answer: Characteristics gained during a lifetime do not change the alleles in an organism's gametes, so they cannot be inherited; for example, a giraffe stretching its neck does not change the genes passed on to its offspring.
Question 9
- (a) X is the oldestB1
- (a) because, in undisturbed sedimentary rock, the lowest/deepest layers were deposited first (formed longest ago), so fossils found in the lowest layer must be the oldest, oeB1
- (a) Answer: X is the oldest, because in undisturbed rock the lowest layers formed first, so contain the oldest fossils.
- (b) many early life forms were soft-bodied and had no hard parts (such as bone, shell or teeth), so they decayed away completely and left few or no traces to be preserved as fossilsB1
- (b) many of the rocks that did contain early fossils have since been destroyed by geological activity (e.g. heat, pressure, erosion) over the vast amount of time that has passed, oeB1
- (b) Answer: Most early life was soft-bodied, so it decayed without leaving traces; also, much of the rock that did contain early fossils has since been destroyed by geological processes.
Question 10
- (a) Archaea, Bacteria and Eukaryota (all three needed for the mark), oeB1
- (a) Answer: Archaea, Bacteria and Eukaryota.
- (b) ribosomal RNA (rRNA)B1
- (b) Answer: Ribosomal RNA (rRNA).
- (c) organisms can look similar, or different, due to factors such as convergent evolution or the environment affecting appearance, so this does not necessarily reflect how closely related they actually areB1
- (c) rRNA (molecular) evidence directly reflects genetic/evolutionary relatedness between organisms, and can reveal similarities or differences that are not visible from appearance alone, oeB1
- (c) Answer: Appearance can be misleading, as similar features can evolve independently or be affected by environment, whereas rRNA sequences directly reflect genetic relatedness, revealing relationships not visible from appearance alone.
Question 11
- Level 3 A clear, well-linked evaluation is given of both benefits and risks, leading to a justified conclusion. The answer shows a good understanding of the underlying science and of the wider ethical/social issues involved.5-6
- Level 2 Benefits and risks are both described, showing some understanding of the science and/or ethical issues involved. There is some linking of ideas, but the evaluation or conclusion may be one-sided or underdeveloped.3-4
- Level 1 Simple, largely unlinked statements are made about a benefit or a risk. The answer may be one-sided, with little evaluation or scientific detail.1-2
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Benefit: could prevent vitamin A deficiency, which can cause blindness and can be fatal, especially in children, in populations whose diets are low in vitamin A.
- Benefit: genetic engineering is much faster than selective breeding at introducing a new characteristic, and can introduce genes from a completely different species, which selective breeding cannot do.
- Benefit: genetically engineered crops could increase yield or resistance to pests or disease, reducing pesticide use and helping food security.
- Risk: the long-term effects of eating GM crops, or of GM genes spreading into wild relatives through cross-pollination, are not yet fully known.
- Risk: GM seed may be more expensive, and patented/owned by large companies, making farmers dependent on buying new seed each year rather than saving their own.
- Risk/ethical: some people have religious, cultural or personal ethical objections to modifying the genomes of living organisms.
- Risk: if a single GM variety replaces many traditional varieties, this could reduce biodiversity (monoculture).
- A reasoned conclusion should weigh the benefits (such as preventing vitamin A deficiency) against the risks (such as uncertainty and cost), and may reasonably come down on either side provided it is supported by the points made.
Question 12
- (a) eye colour and blood group are controlled only by genes, and the twins have identical genes (identical DNA), so these characteristics are the sameB1
- (a) build/muscle mass is affected by the environment (e.g. exercise and diet) as well as by genes, so it can differ between the twins even though their genotype is identical, oeB1
- (a) Answer: Eye colour and blood group depend only on genes, which are identical in identical twins; build is also affected by environmental factors such as exercise, so it can differ.
- (b) identical twins have identical genes/DNA (the same genotype)B1
- (b) so any differences observed between them must be caused by environmental factors rather than genetic differences, allowing the effect of the environment to be studied/isolated, oeB1
- (b) Answer: Because identical twins have identical genes, any differences between them must be due to the environment, allowing its effect to be studied in isolation.
Question 13
- (a) variation where individuals can take any value within a range, with no distinct/separate categories, oeB1
- (a) Answer: Variation where measurements can take any value within a range, with no clear-cut categories.
- (b) variation that falls into a small number of distinct/discrete categories, with no intermediate values, oeB1
- (b) Answer: Variation that falls into a small number of distinct categories, with no intermediate values.
- (c) height is controlled by many genes acting together (polygenic) and is also affected by the environment (e.g. diet), producing a continuous range of values / a bell-shaped spreadB1
- (c) the earlobe data were recorded in just two categories, 'attached' and 'free', so there is one bar for each category (discontinuous variation, no intermediate values), oeB1
- (c) Answer: Height's graph is a smooth spread because height is polygenic and affected by environment. The earlobe graph has two separate bars because Ffion recorded only two categories, 'attached' and 'free'.
Question 14
- (a) select the highest milk-yielding cows and a bull with high genetic merit for milk production in his daughtersB1
- (a) breed the selected cows with the selected bullB1
- (a) select the highest milk-yielding daughters and bulls with high genetic merit for their daughters' milk production as parents for the next generationB1
- (a) repeat this selection and breeding process over many generations, until the desired milk yield is reached in most/all of the herd, oeB1
- (a) Answer: Select the highest milk-yielding cows and a bull with high genetic merit for his daughters' milk production, then breed them. Select the highest-yielding daughters and bulls with high genetic merit for their daughters' milk production as parents for the next generation. Repeat this selection and breeding process over many generations.
- (b) selective breeding (artificial selection)B1
- (b) Answer: Selective breeding (artificial selection).
Question 15
- (a) P and QB1
- (a) Answer: P and Q.
- (b) they share the most recent common ancestor; their branches diverge from the node closest to the present day (the tips of the tree), oeB1
- (b) Answer: They share the most recent common ancestor, shown by the branching point closest to the tips of the tree.
- (c) comparing DNA/RNA base sequences (genomes) between speciesB1
- (c) any second valid type of evidence, e.g. comparing amino acid sequences of shared proteins, anatomical/structural similarities, or similarities in embryonic development between species, oe; any two for 2 marksB1
- (c) Answer: For example, comparing DNA base sequences and comparing the amino acid sequences of shared proteins between the species.
Question 16
- (a) there was already variation in body colour within the grasshopper population before the fireB1
- (a) dark-brown grasshoppers were better camouflaged against the black ash, so were less likely to be eaten by predators (had a survival advantage)B1
- (a) grasshoppers that survived were more likely to reproduce, passing on the allele(s) for dark colouring to their offspringB1
- (a) over many generations, the allele for dark colouring became more common (increased in frequency) in the population, oeB1
- (a) Answer: Variation in colour already existed; dark grasshoppers were camouflaged and survived predation better; they reproduced more and passed on the dark-colour allele; over generations the allele became more frequent in the population.
- (b) mutationB1
- (b) Answer: Mutation.
Question 17
- (a) sterilise the inoculating loop/spreader before and after use (e.g. by passing it through a Bunsen burner flame)B1
- (a) any second valid precaution, e.g. work near a Bunsen burner flame to create an updraught, tape (do not fully seal) the lid of the Petri dish, or wash hands/disinfect surfaces before and after, oe; any two for 2 marksB1
- (a) Answer: For example, sterilise the inoculating loop before and after use, and tape rather than fully seal the lid of the Petri dish.
- (b) to prevent/reduce the growth of pathogens that could be harmful to humans, which grow best near human body temperature, oeB1
- (b) Answer: To reduce the growth of pathogens that could harm humans, which grow best at human body temperature.
- (c) radius = 26 / 2 = 13 (mm); correct substitution shown: 3.14 x 132M1
- (c) 531 mm2 cao (3 s.f.)A1
- (c) Answer: 531 mm2 (3 s.f.)
- (d) a larger zone does suggest disc B was more effective against this species of bacteria, under these conditionsB1
- (d) however, this conclusion is only valid if all three discs contained the same concentration of antibiotic and diffused into the agar at a similar rate; if the concentrations differed, the comparison would not be fair, oeB1
- (d) Answer: A larger zone does suggest greater effectiveness, but the comparison is only valid if all discs contained the same concentration of antibiotic and diffused at similar rates.
- (e) to show that any clear zones around the antibiotic discs were caused by the antibiotic, and not by another factor such as the paper disc itself or the general growth conditions, oeB1
- (e) Answer: It shows that any clear zones on the other discs are caused by the antibiotic itself, not by some other factor.
- (f) repeating reduces the effect of anomalous results/random errorB1
- (f) a mean is more representative of the true effect of the antibiotic, increasing confidence that the pattern observed is a genuine effect rather than due to chance, oeB1
- (f) Answer: Repeats reduce the effect of random error or anomalies; the mean is more representative of the antibiotic's true effect, increasing reliability.
- (g) use discs soaked in a range of different concentrations of antibiotic B, keeping all other variables the same (e.g. same bacteria species, temperature and incubation time)B1
- (g) independent variable = concentration of antibiotic (on the disc)B1
- (g) Answer: Test discs soaked in a range of concentrations of antibiotic B, keeping all other variables constant; the independent variable is the concentration of antibiotic.
- (h) so that any difference in the size of the clear zones is due to the effectiveness of the antibiotics (a fair test)B1
- (h) rather than being due to a difference in the starting number/concentration of bacteria on different parts of the plate, oeB1
- (h) Answer: So any difference in zone size is due to antibiotic effectiveness (a fair test), rather than an uneven starting concentration of bacteria on the plate.
Question 18
- (a) select the individual wheat plants from the current population that show the greatest natural resistance to the disease, oeB1
- (a) breed these selected, more resistant plants together, oeB1
- (a) select the most disease-resistant offspring from this generation, oeB1
- (a) repeat this process of selecting and breeding the most resistant individuals over many generations, until most/all plants in the population show strong disease resistance, oeB1
- (a) Answer: Select the wheat plants showing the greatest natural disease resistance, breed them together, select the most resistant offspring, then repeat this selection and breeding process over many generations until most plants show strong resistance.
- (b) reduced genetic variation means there are fewer different alleles present in the population, oeB1
- (b) this makes the population less able to adapt if a new disease, pest or environmental change (e.g. a new strain of the fungus) appears, because fewer individuals are likely to already carry a useful resistance allele, risking the whole crop, oeB1
- (b) Answer: Reduced genetic variation means fewer different alleles are present in the population, making it less able to adapt if a new disease, pest, or environmental change appears, since fewer individuals are likely to already carry a useful resistance allele, putting the whole crop at risk.
Question 19
- the gene for human insulin is identified and cut out of human DNA, usually using a restriction enzyme, oeB1
- a plasmid (a small circular piece of bacterial DNA) is removed from a bacterium and cut open using the same restriction enzyme, leaving matching/complementary ends, oeB1
- the insulin gene is inserted into the cut plasmid and joined together using an enzyme called ligase, forming recombinant DNA, oeB1
- the recombinant plasmid (acting as a vector) is inserted into a new bacterial cell, oeB1
- the genetically modified bacteria are cultured/grown in large numbers (e.g. in fermenters), where they express the inserted gene and produce human insulin, which is then extracted and purified, oeB1
- Answer: The insulin gene is cut from human DNA and a bacterial plasmid is cut open, both using the same restriction enzyme; the gene is inserted into the plasmid using ligase to form recombinant DNA; the recombinant plasmid (vector) is inserted into a bacterium, which is cultured in large numbers to express and produce human insulin.
Question 20
- within a bacterial population there is variation; some bacteria already carry a mutation/allele giving resistance to the antibiotic, before the antibiotic is ever usedB1
- when the antibiotic is used, non-resistant bacteria are killedB1
- resistant bacteria survive (are not killed) and face less competition for resources such as nutrients and spaceB1
- resistant bacteria reproduce (by binary fission), passing the resistance allele/gene on to their offspringB1
- because bacteria reproduce rapidly, the resistant allele/population increases in frequency quickly, over successive generationsB1
- eventually most/all of the population becomes resistant to the antibiotic, oe; award any 6 of the marking points, max 6B1
- Answer: Existing variation means some bacteria already carry a resistance mutation; the antibiotic kills non-resistant bacteria; resistant bacteria survive with less competition and reproduce, passing on the resistance allele; because bacteria reproduce so quickly, the resistant allele spreads through the population over successive generations until most bacteria are resistant.
Question 21
- (a) organisms that can breed (interbreed) with each other to produce fertile offspring, oeB1
- (a) Answer: Organisms that can breed with each other to produce fertile offspring.
- (b) a physical barrier separates the population into two groups, which can no longer interbreed with each other, oeB1
- (b) the two isolated environments may differ, so different mutations arise and different characteristics are favoured by natural selection in each population, oeB1
- (b) over many generations, the allele frequencies of the two populations change and become increasingly different, until individuals from the two populations can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring, meaning a new species has formed, oeB1
- (b) Answer: A physical barrier separates the population into two groups that can no longer interbreed. The two isolated environments may differ, so different mutations arise and different characteristics are favoured by natural selection in each group. Over many generations, the allele frequencies of the two populations become increasingly different, until they can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring, meaning a new species has formed.
Question 22
- Level 3 A clear, logically sequenced explanation that links geographical isolation, differing selection pressures in the two environments, changing allele frequencies over many generations, and the eventual inability to interbreed, to the formation of two new species.5-6
- Level 2 A mostly correct explanation covering some of: isolation, differing selection pressures, and changing allele frequencies, but the reasoning may be incomplete or not fully sequenced, or the final step (reproductive isolation defining a new species) may be missing.3-4
- Level 1 A simple, partial answer, for example stating that the mice are separated and become different, with little or no explanation of the mechanism (mutation, selection, allele frequency change).1-2
- Indicative content:
- The landslide and new lake formed a physical barrier that geographically isolated the two mouse populations, so they could no longer interbreed with each other.
- Mutations occur randomly in both populations, producing new alleles and increasing genetic variation within each group.
- The two environments differ (one drier, one damp and forested), so different characteristics will be advantageous for survival in each; natural selection will therefore favour different alleles in the two populations.
- Individuals with characteristics better suited to their own environment are more likely to survive and reproduce, passing on the favourable alleles to their offspring.
- Over many generations, the allele frequencies of the two populations diverge (become increasingly different), because different alleles are being selected for in each environment.
- Eventually, the genetic differences between the two populations become so great that individuals from one population can no longer interbreed with individuals from the other population to produce fertile offspring.
- At this point, the two populations are classified as two separate species, formed by the process of speciation.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.