Worked question 6 - Biodiversity, Cycles and Human Impact
Biodiversity Under Pressure
Original text written for Revision Library.
Biodiversity, the variety of species and the genes within them found in an ecosystem, both depends on and helps to maintain stable natural cycles such as the carbon and water cycles. As the human population grows and standards of living rise, increasing amounts of land are used for building, farming, quarrying and waste disposal, leaving less space for other organisms. One example is the loss of peat bogs: these waterlogged habitats take thousands of years to form, store large amounts of carbon, and support specialised plants and animals, yet many have been drained and dug up so the peat can be sold as garden compost. Similar pressures, including large-scale deforestation, pollution of land, air and water, and the effects of global warming, are reducing biodiversity in ecosystems around the world. Conservation organisations use a range of strategies, from captive breeding programmes to the protection and restoration of habitats, to try to maintain and increase biodiversity. This worksheet covers the carbon and water cycles, the effects of waste, land use, deforestation and global warming on biodiversity, the required practical investigating the effect of temperature on the rate of decomposition, and strategies used to conserve biodiversity.
The results are shown in the table below.
| Temperature (°C) | Repeat 1 (s) | Repeat 2 (s) | Repeat 3 (s) | Mean time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 | 330 | 327 | 336 | 331 |
| 30 | 180 | 174 | 183 | 179 |
| 40 | 93 | 90 | 87 | (to be calculated) |
| 50 | 128 | 205 | 132 | (to be calculated) |
| 60 | 240 | 249 | 246 | 245 |
Answer and mark scheme
Question 6
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) temperature (of the water bath) |
| B1 | (b) any one suitable control variable, e.g. the volume/concentration of milk powder solution, sodium carbonate solution, indicator, or lipase used |
| B1 | (b) controlling it ensures that temperature is the only variable that could affect the rate of reaction between the tubes (oe) |
| B1 | (b) if it were not controlled, any difference in the time taken could be caused by this other variable rather than by temperature, so it would not be a valid (fair) test and no valid conclusion about the effect of temperature could be drawn |
| M1 | (c) mean time at 40 C = (93+90+87)/3 = 90 s; rate = 1000/90 |
| A1 | (c) 11.1 (arbitrary units), awrt |
| B1 | (d) the repeat 2 reading of 205 s at 50°C is anomalous, as it does not fit the pattern of the other two repeats at that temperature (128 s and 132 s) |
| B1 | (d) any suitable cause, e.g. the tube may not have reached the stated temperature before timing started, there may have been a delay in adding the lipase or starting the stop clock, or the student may have misjudged the colour change end point |
| B1 | (e) the rate of reaction increases as temperature rises from 20 to 40°C |
| B1 | (e) the rate then decreases as temperature rises further, to 50 and 60°C |
| B1 | (e) up to 40°C, increasing temperature gives the enzyme and substrate more kinetic energy, increasing the frequency of successful collisions between the enzyme's active site and the substrate, so more enzyme-substrate complexes form per second |
| B1 | (e) above the optimum temperature (40°C), the enzyme begins to denature: the shape of its active site changes so it is no longer complementary to the substrate, so fewer enzyme-substrate complexes can form and the rate decreases |
| B1 | (f) judging by eye exactly when the solution becomes colourless is subjective, so different people (or the same person on different occasions) could record slightly different times, reducing precision (oe) |
| B1 | (f) a colorimeter could be used to measure the light transmission/absorbance of the solution at set time intervals, giving an objective, quantitative measurement of the colour change |
| B1 | (f) this would allow a more precise determination of the exact point at which the colour changes, improving the precision/reliability of the calculated rate |
| B1 | (g) the lipase breaking down lipid into fatty acids represents the type of chemical breakdown carried out by decomposer microorganisms during natural decomposition (oe) |
| B1 | (g) the pH/colour change models the production of acidic products as complex organic matter is broken down |
| B1 | (g) however, this experiment uses only one enzyme, one substrate and one controlled temperature at a time, whereas natural decomposition involves many species of decomposer microorganisms and enzymes acting on a range of substrates (proteins, carbohydrates and lipids) under conditions (temperature, moisture, oxygen) that are not controlled |
- (a) Answer: Temperature.
- (b) Answer: The volume and concentration of lipase solution added (or an equivalent variable such as the milk powder solution, sodium carbonate solution or indicator) must be kept the same in every tube, so that temperature is the only variable that could affect the rate; if it were not controlled, any difference in results could be due to this other variable rather than temperature, making the test invalid.
- (c) Answer: 11.1 (arbitrary units).
- (d) Answer: The 205 s reading (repeat 2 at 50°C) is anomalous, since it is much higher than the other two repeats (128 s and 132 s) at that temperature; a possible cause is a delay in adding the lipase or starting the stop clock, or the tube not having reached 50°C before timing began.
- (e) Answer: The rate of reaction rises as temperature increases from 20 to 40°C, because more kinetic energy leads to more frequent successful collisions between the enzyme's active site and its substrate; above 40°C the rate falls, because the enzyme starts to denature, changing the shape of its active site so it no longer fits the substrate as well.
- (f) Answer: Judging the colour change by eye is subjective and can vary between observers, reducing precision; using a colorimeter to measure light transmission or absorbance at set time intervals would give an objective, quantitative measurement of the colour change, improving the precision of the results.
- (g) Answer: The breakdown of lipid by lipase, and the resulting pH change, models the type of chemical breakdown and acidic products produced during natural decomposition; however, the experiment uses only one enzyme and substrate at a controlled temperature, whereas natural decomposition involves many species of decomposer microorganisms acting on a range of substrates under uncontrolled environmental conditions.









