Functionalist and Marxist Explanations of Crime - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
10 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Functionalist and Marxist Explanations of Crime revision guideMore GCSE Sociology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 7 of GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 4 and chapter 1 of GCSE Sociology 10-Minute Tests 3.
5.2 Functionalist and Marxist Explanations of Crime
Question 1
- identifies selective law enforcement or differential treatment of corporate versus street crime as relevantB1
- links the company's lenient fine to the harsher treatment of street crime described in the scenarioB1
- explains the individual's prison sentence for a relatively low-value offence as evidence of harsher treatment for working-class or street crimeB1
- explains this pattern could disguise or underrepresent the true extent and seriousness of crime committed by the powerfulB1
- development referencing the Marxist argument that law can serve capitalist or business interestsB1
- clear, accurate use of Marxist terminology throughoutB1
- Answer: The company's small fine compared with the individual's prison sentence for a much smaller-value offence is consistent with the Marxist argument of selective law enforcement, where street crime is treated more harshly than corporate crime, disguising the true scale of harm caused by the powerful.
Question 2
- Level 4 A detailed, well-balanced evaluation that accurately explains BOTH the functionalist case AND the Marxist case, supported by accurate reference to named sociologists where appropriate. Strengths and weaknesses of each view are analysed, and a reasoned, supported judgement is reached. Sociological terminology is used accurately and consistently throughout.10-12
- Level 3 A clear evaluation that explains both the functionalist case and the Marxist case, with some accurate detail. Some analysis of strengths/weaknesses. An attempt at a conclusion, which may be only partly supported.7-9
- Level 2 Some relevant explanation of the functionalist and/or Marxist case, with limited development or accuracy. Little clear evaluation or comparison between perspectives.4-6
- Level 1 One or two isolated, undeveloped points about crime benefiting society or the ruling class, with little or no sociological terminology or accurate detail.1-3
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Functionalist case: Durkheim argued crime performs boundary maintenance, reaffirming shared values when society reacts to it, and allows for adaptation and change as some deviance introduces new ideas that later become accepted.
- Functionalist case continued: Merton's strain theory explains crime as a response to a gap between culturally approved goals, such as wealth, and the legitimate means of achieving them, e.g. through innovation.
- Marxist case: capitalism is criminogenic, with poverty and inequality pushing some people towards crime, while crime by the wealthy (fraud, corporate crime) is also extensive but comparatively underpoliced.
- Marxist case continued: selective law enforcement means laws are enforced more strictly against working-class crime than against crime by the powerful, which Marxists argue serves and protects ruling-class interests.
- Evaluation of the functionalist case: critics argue it is too optimistic about how functional crime really is, given the real harm caused to victims, and does not fully explain who benefits from crime and who does not.
- Evaluation of the Marxist case: critics argue it can be too deterministic and focuses heavily on capitalism and social class, saying comparatively little about other patterns in crime such as gender or age.
- A balanced conclusion should weigh Durkheim and Merton's claims that crime serves genuine functions for society as a whole against the Marxist argument that recorded crime and its enforcement still systematically favour the already-powerful, without presenting either side as simply correct.
Question 3
- the socially approved, legitimate ways of achieving a culturally valued goal (oe)B1
- a correct example, e.g. education and work as legitimate routes to financial successB1
- Answer: The socially approved, legitimate ways of achieving a culturally valued goal; for example, education and work as legitimate routes to financial success.
Question 4
- identifies a genuine similarity, e.g. both are structural, macro perspectives explaining crime through the wider structure of society rather than individual choiceB1
- development, e.g. both link crime to economic factors, though they interpret this relationship very differentlyB1
- Answer: Both are structural, macro perspectives that explain crime through the wider structure of society; both also link crime to economic factors, even though they interpret this relationship very differently.
Question 5
- a state of normlessness, when social norms are weak, unclear or breaking down (oe)B1
- development, e.g. this can occur during periods of rapid social change, when established norms lose their grip on behaviourB1
- Answer: A state of normlessness, when social norms are weak, unclear or breaking down; this can occur during periods of rapid social change, when established norms lose their grip.
Question 6
- identifies that strain arises from a gap, or disjunction, between culturally approved goals, e.g. financial success, and the legitimate institutionalised means available to achieve themB1
- explains that individuals who are unable to achieve the approved goals through legitimate means experience strainB1
- development, e.g. this strain can push some people towards crime as an alternative route to the goalB1
- correctly and specifically attributes this theory to Merton's strain theoryB1
- Answer: Merton's strain theory argues strain arises from a gap between culturally approved goals, such as financial success, and the legitimate means available to achieve them; people unable to achieve these goals legitimately may turn to crime as an alternative route.
Question 7
- identifies innovation as accepting the culturally approved goal, e.g. wealthB1
- identifies that the individual rejects or lacks access to the legitimate means of achieving itB1
- development, e.g. instead using illegitimate or criminal means to pursue the same goalB1
- a correct example, e.g. theft or fraud as a way of acquiring money when legitimate routes seem blockedB1
- Answer: Innovation means accepting the culturally approved goal, such as wealth, but rejecting or lacking access to the legitimate means of achieving it, and instead using illegitimate means such as theft or fraud to pursue the same goal.
Question 8
- names a genuine second response, e.g. retreatism, ritualism or rebellionB1
- brief accurate description, e.g. retreatism: rejecting both the goal and the legitimate means, e.g. some drug users or people who drop out of mainstream societyB1
- development consistent with the response namedB1
- correctly distinguishes it from innovation, explained in Q7B1
- Answer: Retreatism: rejecting both the culturally approved goal (e.g. wealth) and the legitimate means of achieving it, as with some drug users or people who drop out of mainstream society altogether, unlike innovation, which still pursues the goal by illegitimate means.
Question 9
- identifies the Marxist claim that capitalism can be 'criminogenic', meaning it creates conditions that encourage crimeB1
- development, e.g. poverty and inequality produced by capitalism can push some poorer people towards crime as a means of survival or of acquiring the goods capitalism encourages everyone to wantB1
- further point, e.g. Marxists also argue crime is not confined to the poor, pointing to extensive crime by the wealthy, such as fraud or tax evasionB1
- clear, accurate use of Marxist terminologyB1
- Answer: Marxists argue capitalism is criminogenic: poverty and inequality it produces can push poorer people towards crime as a means of survival or of acquiring the goods capitalism encourages everyone to want, while crime by the wealthy, such as fraud or tax evasion, is also extensive.
Question 10
- identifies selective law enforcement as the claim that laws are enforced more strictly against, and more likely to target, working-class crime than crime committed by the wealthy or powerfulB1
- development, e.g. street crime attracts more police resources and media attention than white-collar or corporate crime, even though the latter can cause greater financial harmB1
- further point, e.g. Marxists argue this makes crime appear to be mainly a working-class problem, disguising the true extent of crime among the wealthyB1
- clear, accurate use of Marxist terminologyB1
- Answer: Selective law enforcement is the Marxist claim that laws are enforced more strictly against working-class crime than crime by the wealthy or powerful, e.g. street crime attracts more policing than white-collar crime, which Marxists argue disguises the true extent of crime among the wealthy.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.