Marketisation, Parentocracy and School Choice - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
11 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Marketisation, Parentocracy and School Choice revision guideMore GCSE Sociology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 2 of GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 4 and chapter 20 of GCSE Sociology 10-Minute Tests 2.
4.9 Marketisation, Parentocracy and School Choice
Question 1
- identifies a correct example, e.g. grant-maintained schools or academy status as types linked to marketisationB1
- brief development, e.g. such statuses gave schools greater autonomy and increased competitionB1
- Answer: An example is grant-maintained schools, and later academy status, which gave schools greater autonomy and increased competition.
Question 2
- identifies silt-shift as the process where disadvantaged or lower-achieving pupils are concentrated in certain schoolsB1
- development, e.g. this happens when selective schools take the most advantaged pupils, leaving others 'silted' with harder-to-teach intakesB1
- Answer: Silt-shift is the process where disadvantaged or lower-achieving pupils become concentrated in certain schools because selective or successful schools take the most advantaged pupils, leaving others with more challenging intakes.
Question 3
- identifies one reason, e.g. lack of economic resources such as money for transport or to move houseB1
- development of first reason, e.g. this limits the practical ability to access popular schools outside the local areaB1
- identifies second reason, e.g. lack of cultural or informational capital to interpret league tables, fill forms or use social networksB1
- development of second reason, e.g. parents with less education may not know which questions to ask or how to navigate admissions proceduresB1
- Answer: Some parents cannot take full advantage of choice because they lack economic resources, like money for transport or to move house, limiting access to popular schools; they may also lack cultural or informational capital to interpret league tables, fill forms or use networks, making admissions harder to navigate.
Question 4
- identifies New Right view, e.g. supports marketisation as increasing efficiency and standards through competitionB1
- identifies Marxist view, e.g. sees marketisation as reproducing class inequalities and benefiting ruling-class interestsB1
- explains New Right rationale, e.g. parents acting as consumers force schools to improveB1
- explains Marxist rationale, e.g. choice advantages privileged families and helps legitimize unequal outcomes as 'fair' market resultsB1
- Answer: The New Right supports marketisation, arguing competition and parental choice increase efficiency and standards as parents act like consumers; Marxists argue marketisation reproduces class inequalities, advantaging privileged families and legitimising unequal outcomes as if they result from fair market processes.
Question 5
- Level 1 Simple statements about marketisation with little or no sociological explanation, or an unbalanced description of one side only.1-3
- Level 2 Clear explanation of one or two relevant sociological arguments about marketisation and equality of opportunity, with some use of evidence or examples, limited evaluation.4-6
- Level 3 Developed analysis using competing sociological perspectives and examples, showing awareness of how market mechanisms have both positive and negative effects on equality of opportunity.7-9
- Level 4 Thorough, balanced discussion drawing on several sociological perspectives and specific evidence, with a supported judgement on the extent to which marketisation has increased equality of opportunity.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Arguments that marketisation increases equality: New Right claim that parental choice and competition drive up standards, giving parents power to choose better schools and rewarding effective schools; league tables and Ofsted provide transparent performance data so parents can make informed choices; some disadvantaged pupils may gain from improved schools and targeted interventions in competition-driven contexts.
- Arguments that marketisation reduces equality: Ball, Bowe and Gewirtz and other critics argue parentocracy privileges middle-class parents who have economic and cultural capital to choose, leading to cream skimming and silt-shift; league tables can stigmatise struggling schools and concentrate disadvantaged pupils; selective admissions, marketing and resource differences increase segregation by class and reduce genuine equality of opportunity.
- Empirical and practical considerations: evidence that oversubscribed schools are dominated by pupils from advantaged backgrounds, that academy or autonomous status can lead to variable outcomes, and that Ofsted pressure can lead to short-term improvements but also to teaching to the test and exclusion of challenging pupils.
- Perspectives to use: New Right supportive view, Marxist and critical sociologists highlighting reproduction of class inequality, Ball et al. on parentocracy, and feminist or interactionist comments on how choice affects different social groups in varied ways.
- Possible judgement: balanced conclusion that marketisation has produced some improvements in choice and accountability but overall has tended to increase inequalities because advantaged families benefit most; extent of agreement depends on which sociological perspective is used and on how equality of opportunity is defined.
Question 6
- identifies parentocracy as a system where parents are given power to choose schools, with choice supposedly driving school improvement (oe)B1
- development, e.g. credits Ball, Bowe and Gewirtz in noting this idea can mask inequalities between parents in the ability to chooseB1
- Answer: Parentocracy describes a system where parents are given power to choose schools, with the idea that parental choice drives school improvement; Ball, Bowe and Gewirtz note it can mask unequal ability among parents to exercise choice.
Question 7
- identifies a correct feature, e.g. pupils can apply to schools outside their local catchment areaB1
- brief development, e.g. this increases competition between schools for pupil placesB1
- Answer: Open enrolment allows pupils to apply to schools outside their local catchment area, increasing competition between schools for pupil places.
Question 8
- identifies one way, e.g. to provide parents with information to compare school performanceB1
- development of first way, e.g. so parents can choose higher performing schools, creating demand incentivesB1
- identifies second way, e.g. to pressure schools to raise standards to improve their published positionB1
- development of second way, e.g. lower-ranked schools may change practices or recruit differently to improve resultsB1
- Answer: League tables are meant to give parents information to compare school performance so they can choose higher performing schools, creating demand incentives; they also pressure schools to raise standards to improve their published position, leading some schools to change practices or recruitment.
Question 9
- identifies an aim, e.g. to raise educational standards through competitionB1
- brief development, e.g. by giving parents choice and by using performance information to reward successful schoolsB1
- Answer: An aim was to raise educational standards through competition, by giving parents choice and using performance information to reward successful schools.
Question 10
- identifies one response, e.g. focusing resources on subjects that improve league table measuresB1
- development of first response, e.g. setting more exam-focused teaching or revision classesB1
- identifies second response, e.g. selective admissions practices or marketing to attract desirable pupilsB1
- development of second response, e.g. highlighting successes in publicity to boost reputation and applicationsB1
- Answer: Schools may focus resources on subjects that improve league table measures, for example using exam-focused teaching and revision classes; they may also adopt selective admissions practices or market themselves to attract desirable pupils, highlighting successes to boost reputation and applications.
Question 11
- identifies a criticism, e.g. choice benefits more advantaged parents who have information, money and social networksB1
- development, e.g. these parents can move, use private transport, pay for tutoring or navigate admissions to secure placesB1
- links criticism to consequence, e.g. less advantaged families remain in lower performing schools, widening attainment gapsB1
- further development, e.g. marketisation can lead to cream skimming by successful schools, increasing segregation by classB1
- Answer: Critics argue marketisation benefits more advantaged parents who have the information, money and networks to choose schools; they can move house, pay for tutoring or navigate admissions, while less advantaged families remain in lower performing schools, widening attainment gaps. Successful schools may cream skim, increasing class segregation.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.