Skip to the worksheet
Revision Library
Choose a subject

Structure and Action - Worksheets, Questions and Revision

14 original exam-style questions - 6 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.

Grades 6-9

This topic is chapter 5 of GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 5 of GCSE Sociology 10-Minute Tests 1.

Revision Library
revisionlibrary.co.uk
GCSE · AQA

1.5 Structure and Action

AQA 8192 · about 70 minutes
Total Marks
Name: _______________________________    Date: ____ / ____ / ______
Answer ALL questions. Where a question refers to Item G, use both the Item and your own knowledge of the structure and action debate in your answer.

Item G: Amara and the family business

A hypothetical scenario written for this exercise, for students to apply structure/agency ideas to.

Amara grew up in a family that has run a small bakery for three generations, and most relatives expected her to join the business after school. Instead, she decided to apply to study engineering at university, a choice several relatives found surprising. She still visits the bakery every weekend to help out, and says she feels a strong sense of duty to the family even though she chose a different path.

1
Sociologists use the term 'social structure' to describe a key feature of society that shapes individual lives.
  • A) The organised pattern of institutions and relationships that shapes people's lives
  • B) A single person's individual opinion about society
  • C) A type of building found only in cities
  • D) A method used only in laboratory science
(Total for Question 1 is 1 mark)
2
Evaluate the view that individual behaviour is best explained by social structure rather than by individual choice and action. In your answer you should refer to sociologists' views on both sides of the debate.
(Total for Question 2 is 12 marks)
3
For each statement below, state whether it best reflects a structural or an action (agency) view of behaviour.
(a)Society consists of social facts that exist externally to the individual and constrain behaviour.(1)
(b)Sociologists should try to understand the subjective meaning an individual attaches to their own behaviour.(1)
(c)Structure both constrains and enables action, and is itself reproduced by individuals' everyday actions.(1)
(Total for Question 3 is 3 marks)
4
Explain one strength of a purely structural explanation of behaviour.
(Total for Question 4 is 2 marks)
5
Explain one strength of an action (agency) based explanation of behaviour.
(Total for Question 5 is 2 marks)
6
Explain why the structure-and-action debate matters for how sociologists explain social change.
(Total for Question 6 is 2 marks)
7
The functionalist sociologist Emile Durkheim argued that society is made up of 'social facts'. Explain what Durkheim meant by 'social facts'.
(Total for Question 7 is 4 marks)
8
Sociologists who emphasise 'structure' argue that a person's behaviour is largely shaped by forces outside their control.
(a)Give one example of a structural force that might shape a person's life choices.(2)
(b)Explain briefly why a strongly structural view can be criticised for underestimating individual choice.(2)
(Total for Question 8 is 4 marks)
9
Max Weber offered a different starting point, focused on individual social action and its meaning. Explain Weber's view of social action and verstehen.
(Total for Question 9 is 4 marks)
10
Weber identified four types of social action, based on the different reasons people act.
(a)Explain what is meant by 'traditional' action, giving an example.(2)
(b)Explain what is meant by 'instrumentally-rational' action, giving an example.(2)
(Total for Question 10 is 4 marks)
11
The American sociologist Dennis Wrong (1961) criticised sociology for often presenting an 'oversocialised' view of human beings. Explain Dennis Wrong's criticism of the 'oversocialised' view of human beings.
(Total for Question 11 is 4 marks)
12
Anthony Giddens tried to move beyond a simple choice between structure and action. Explain Giddens' structuration theory and how it links structure and action.
(Total for Question 12 is 6 marks)
13
Using Item G, explain how Amara's decision could be used as evidence for the importance of individual agency.
(Total for Question 13 is 4 marks)
14
Using Item G and Giddens' idea of the 'duality of structure', explain why Amara's story shows both structure and agency at work.
(Total for Question 14 is 4 marks)
Mark scheme · 1.5 Structure and Action

Question 1

  • A (the organised pattern of institutions and relationships)B1
  • Answer: A

Question 2

  • Level 4 A detailed, well-balanced evaluation that accurately explains BOTH a structural view (e.g. Durkheim's social facts) AND an action/agency view (e.g. Weber's social action, or a critique such as Wrong's), supported by accurate reference to named sociologists. Giddens' attempt to reconcile the two is used to add nuance. Strengths and weaknesses of each side are analysed, and a reasoned, supported judgement is reached. Sociological terminology is used accurately and consistently throughout.10-12
  • Level 3 A clear evaluation that explains both a structural view and an action/agency view, with some accurate reference to sociologists. Some analysis of strengths/weaknesses. An attempt at a conclusion, which may be only partly supported.7-9
  • Level 2 Some relevant explanation of a structural and/or an action view, with limited development or accuracy. Little clear evaluation or comparison.4-6
  • Level 1 One or two isolated, undeveloped points about structure or individual choice, with little or no sociological terminology or accurate detail.1-3
  • Level 0 No relevant content.0
  • Indicative content:
    • Structural case: Durkheim argued society consists of 'social facts' that are external to the individual and exert real constraint, e.g. laws, shared moral rules and family expectations such as those on Amara in Item G.
    • Action/agency case: Weber argued sociology should study individual social action and its subjective meaning (verstehen), and Amara's choice to study engineering despite family tradition could be cited as evidence individual meaning-making shapes outcomes as much as structure.
    • Critique of the structural view: Dennis Wrong (1961) argued strongly structural theories can present an 'oversocialised' view of human beings, underestimating people's ability to reflect on and resist social expectations.
    • Critique of the action view: a purely action-based account can struggle to explain why some structural patterns (e.g. patterns of family occupation, or wider patterns of class and gender) recur so consistently across many different individuals, if choice is really unconstrained.
    • Giddens' reconciliation: structuration theory argues structure and action form a 'duality', with structure both constraining and enabling action, while action in turn reproduces or slowly changes structure; Amara's continuing sense of duty alongside her different career choice illustrates both processes operating together.
    • A balanced conclusion could argue that neither a purely structural nor a purely action-based account fully explains behaviour on its own, and that Giddens' structuration theory offers a way of holding both insights together rather than choosing one side.
    • A convincing top-level answer uses Item G as a worked example to show how structure and agency can both be seen operating in a single, real-feeling case, rather than treating the debate only in the abstract.

Question 3

  • (a) structuralB1
  • (a) Answer: Structural
  • (b) actionB1
  • (b) Answer: Action (agency)
  • (c) bothB1
  • (c) Answer: Both (Giddens' duality of structure)

Question 4

  • identifies a genuine strength, e.g. it can explain consistent, large-scale patterns that recur across many different individuals, such as patterns linked to class or family backgroundB1
  • development, e.g. this makes it useful for explaining why inequality tends to persist across generations, rather than treating each individual case as randomB1
  • Answer: A structural explanation can explain consistent, large-scale patterns that recur across many individuals, such as patterns linked to class or family background, making it useful for explaining why inequality tends to persist across generations rather than looking random.

Question 5

  • identifies a genuine strength, e.g. it can explain why individuals from similar backgrounds sometimes make very different choices, which a purely structural account struggles to explainB1
  • development, e.g. it takes individual meaning and motivation seriously rather than treating people only as products of their circumstancesB1
  • Answer: An action-based explanation can explain why individuals from similar backgrounds sometimes make very different choices, taking individual meaning and motivation seriously rather than treating people only as products of their circumstances.

Question 6

  • identifies that a purely structural view can make social change hard to explain, since structure is presented as constraining rather than as something individuals can alterB1
  • development, e.g. an account that includes agency, such as Giddens' structuration theory, can better explain how individuals' actions gradually change social structures over timeB1
  • Answer: A purely structural view can make social change hard to explain, since structure is presented mainly as constraining; an account that includes agency, such as Giddens' structuration theory, can better explain how individuals' actions gradually change social structures over time.

Question 7

  • identifies that Durkheim used the term 'social facts' to describe ways of thinking, feeling and acting that exist outside the individualB1
  • explains that social facts are external to any one person, e.g. laws, customs and shared moral rules existed before the individual was born and will continue after they dieB1
  • explains that social facts are constraining, meaning they exert real pressure on individuals to behave in particular ways, whether or not the individual is aware of itB1
  • development, e.g. Durkheim argued this shows society is more than just the sum of individual choices, and should be studied as a reality of its ownB1
  • Answer: Durkheim's 'social facts' are ways of thinking, feeling and acting, such as laws and shared moral rules, that exist externally to the individual and constrain their behaviour, showing that society is more than the sum of individual choices and should be studied as a reality of its own.

Question 8

  • (a) a plausible structural example, e.g. social class, family expectations, gender norms, the education system or the economyB1
  • (a) development/explanation of how it constrains choice, e.g. limited family income restricting which universities or careers feel realisticB1
  • (a) Answer: Family income is a structural force: a family with limited income may make certain university courses or unpaid work placements feel unrealistic, whatever the individual would otherwise choose.
  • (b) identifies that a strongly structural view can suggest individuals have little or no real freedom to act differently from what structure predictsB1
  • (b) development, e.g. this struggles to explain why some individuals from similar backgrounds make very different choices from one anotherB1
  • (b) Answer: A strongly structural view can suggest individuals have little real freedom to act differently, but this struggles to explain why some people from very similar backgrounds still make very different choices from one another.

Question 9

  • identifies that Weber argued sociology should focus on 'social action', behaviour to which the individual attaches a subjective meaning and which takes account of other peopleB1
  • identifies the method of 'verstehen' (empathetic understanding): the sociologist tries to understand the meaning an action has for the person doing itB1
  • development, e.g. this contrasts with an approach that simply observes external behaviour without asking what it means to the individualB1
  • development, e.g. Weber's approach places individual meaning and choice closer to the centre of sociological explanation than a purely structural approach doesB1
  • Answer: Weber argued sociology should study 'social action', behaviour to which the individual attaches subjective meaning, using 'verstehen' (empathetic understanding) to grasp what the action means to the person doing it, placing individual meaning and choice closer to the centre of explanation than a purely structural approach.

Question 10

  • (a) identifies that traditional action is action guided by long-established custom or habit, done because 'it has always been done that way'B1
  • (a) a correct example, e.g. following a family religious custom, or a traditional greetingB1
  • (a) Answer: Traditional action is guided by long-established custom or habit, done because it has always been done that way, e.g. following a family religious custom.
  • (b) identifies that instrumentally-rational action is action chosen deliberately as the most efficient means to achieve a clear goalB1
  • (b) a correct example, e.g. choosing the fastest route to work, or comparing prices before making a purchaseB1
  • (b) Answer: Instrumentally-rational action is chosen deliberately as the most efficient means to a clear goal, e.g. comparing prices carefully before making a purchase.

Question 11

  • identifies that Wrong argued some sociological theories treat individuals as if they simply absorb society's norms and values without question, leaving little room for independent thought or resistanceB1
  • development, e.g. Wrong argued this 'oversocialised' picture underestimates that people can and do reflect on, question or resist social expectationsB1
  • explains that Wrong's argument was aimed particularly at strongly structural, consensus-based accounts of socialisationB1
  • development, e.g. this criticism helped encourage more attention to individual agency and social action within sociologyB1
  • Answer: Wrong (1961) argued that an 'oversocialised' view treats individuals as if they simply absorb social norms without question, underestimating that people can reflect on, question or resist social expectations; this criticism, aimed at strongly structural accounts, encouraged more attention to individual agency.

Question 12

  • identifies that Giddens developed 'structuration theory' to explain the relationship between structure and individual actionB1
  • explains the 'duality of structure': structure both constrains and enables individual action, rather than only limiting itB1
  • explains that, in turn, individuals' actions reproduce or gradually change social structure over timeB1
  • development, e.g. an example such as language: grammar rules constrain how a sentence can be formed, but every time people speak they also reproduce (and can slowly change) the languageB1
  • development, e.g. Giddens therefore rejected the idea that structure and agency are opposites, seeing them instead as two sides of the same ongoing social processB1
  • correct source attribution, e.g. reference to The Constitution of Society (1984)B1
  • Answer: Giddens' structuration theory argues structure and action form a 'duality': structure constrains and enables individual action, while individuals' actions reproduce or gradually change that structure over time, illustrated by language, whose grammar constrains speech but is also reproduced and slowly changed by every speaker (The Constitution of Society, 1984).

Question 13

  • correctly identifies agency as a person's own capacity to make choices, distinct from simply following structural expectationsB1
  • applies this to Item G, e.g. despite three generations of family expectation, Amara chose a different path (engineering)B1
  • development, e.g. this shows that structural pressure (family tradition) does not fully determine individual behaviourB1
  • clear, accurate use of agency-related terminologyB1
  • Answer: Amara's decision to study engineering despite three generations of family expectation to join the bakery shows that structural pressure does not fully determine behaviour, supporting the importance of individual agency and choice.

Question 14

  • identifies that Amara's choice of career shows individual agency, as established in Q13B1
  • identifies that her continued sense of duty and weekend involvement shows the structural pull of family tradition has not disappearedB1
  • development, e.g. this fits Giddens' duality of structure: structure (family tradition) still shapes and partly constrains her, while her agency (choosing engineering) shows she is not simply determined by itB1
  • clear, accurate use of structuration terminology (duality of structure, constrains and enables)B1
  • Answer: Amara's choice of engineering shows individual agency, while her continued sense of duty and weekend visits show the structural pull of family tradition has not disappeared, fitting Giddens' duality of structure: structure still shapes her without fully determining her choices.

Mark your answers

Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.

Question 1

1 mark
Choose an answer

Question 2

12 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 3

3 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 4

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 5

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 6

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 7

4 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 8

4 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 9

4 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 10

4 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 11

4 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 12

6 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 13

4 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 14

4 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?
Mark my answers

Worksheets are written for Revision Library and come with a full mark scheme; a few English packs quote an out-of-copyright text, and name it on the page. Exam board names and specification codes say which qualification a pack suits: we are not affiliated with, endorsed by or approved by any exam board, and no past-paper question is reproduced here. Rights queries: hello@revisionlibrary.co.uk