Worked question 14 - Sociological Perspectives: Functionalism, Marxism, Feminism and Interactionism
Item B: The Elmfield youth club
A hypothetical scenario written for this exercise, for students to apply sociological perspectives to.
In the town of Elmfield, a local youth club run by volunteers organises weekly sports sessions for teenagers. Many residents believe the club successfully brings together young people from different backgrounds, teaching them teamwork, discipline and respect for shared rules. Other residents point out that taking part costs money for kit and transport, and argue that the club mainly benefits young people whose families already have time and money to spare, while poorer families in Elmfield rarely take part.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 14
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | identifies a valid feminist criticism, e.g. Ann Oakley and others criticised the unequal division of domestic labour; or the family socialises children into gender roles; or Marxist feminists see it as serving capitalism through women's unpaid work; or radical feminists see it as a site of patriarchal control and domestic violence, oe |
| B1 | explains the criticism, e.g. even when women work outside the home, research has found that they continue to carry out most housework and childcare, oe |
| B1 | development, e.g. Oakley's 1974 study of housework found claims of a fully 'symmetrical family' were exaggerated, or other relevant evidence for the criticism chosen, oe |
| B1 | development/consequence, e.g. this means the family can reinforce, rather than challenge, wider gender inequality in society |
- Answer: Any one developed feminist criticism is accepted. For example, the unequal division of domestic labour means women often do paid work alongside most housework and childcare; Oakley's research challenged claims of fully shared roles, showing how family life can reproduce wider gender inequality. Other valid routes include gender socialisation, patriarchal control or unpaid work serving capitalism.






