Classifying Social Class and the Growth of an Underclass - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Classifying Social Class and the Growth of an Underclass revision guideMore GCSE Sociology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 11 of GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 5 and chapter 19 of GCSE Sociology 10-Minute Tests 3.
6.8 Classifying Social Class and the Growth of an Underclass
Question 1
- identifies stigma or discrimination, e.g. employers reject applicants from certain estates or with long gaps in employmentB1
- development, e.g. this locks people out of jobs, making workless households persist across generations and reinforcing marginalisationB1
- Answer: Stigma can lead employers to reject applicants from certain council estates or with long gaps in employment, locking people out of jobs and making workless households persist across generations, reinforcing marginalisation.
Question 2
- identifies structural explanation, e.g. long-term economic change causing industrial decline and fewer jobs for less skilled workersB1
- brief development, e.g. combined with weak local services this produces persistent worklessness rather than a cultural choiceB1
- Answer: A structural explanation is that long-term economic change, such as industrial decline, reduced jobs for less skilled workers; together with weak local services, this produces persistent worklessness rather than a cultural choice.
Question 3
- first valid measure, e.g. rates of long-term unemployment or economic inactivity in local areasB1
- developmentB1
- second valid measure, e.g. levels of poverty, benefit dependency or low household income in small-area statisticsB1
- developmentB1
- Answer: Two other measures are local rates of long-term unemployment or economic inactivity, and levels of poverty or benefit dependency measured by small-area statistics such as local household incomes.
Question 4
- identifies one policy, e.g. reducing welfare benefits to increase work incentivesB1
- development, e.g. the idea is that reducing benefits forces people to seek paid workB1
- identifies second policy, e.g. promoting stricter law and order or sanctions to discourage welfare dependencyB1
- Answer: New Right policies include cutting or tightening welfare to increase work incentives, on the assumption people will seek paid work, and tougher sanctions or law and order measures to discourage dependency and antisocial behaviour.
Question 5
- identifies evidence, e.g. studies showing worklessness often follows job loss and local economic decline rather than initial choiceB1
- brief development, e.g. this suggests structural causes drive dependency rather than welfare causing a culture of lazinessB1
- Answer: Evidence against the New Right includes studies showing worklessness often follows job loss and local economic decline rather than voluntary choice, suggesting structural causes drive dependency rather than welfare creating a culture of laziness.
Question 6
- Level 1 Basic statements, limited development. May offer a simple claim about an underclass with little or no evidence or comparison of views.1-2
- Level 2 Clear description of competing views and some analysis. For example, outlines New Right claims about culture of dependency and structural arguments about economic change, with some supporting evidence or examples.3-5
- Level 3 Detailed and balanced discussion, evaluating both cultural and structural explanations, using evidence (for example research on long-term unemployment, transport barriers, stigma, or Goldthorpe style analysis of class). Reaches a supported and well-reasoned judgement about whether a distinct underclass exists in Britain today.6-8
- Indicative content:
- The New Right view: claim that a distinct underclass has developed characterised by welfare dependency, low work ethic, persistent antisocial behaviour and multi-generational reliance on benefits.
- Structural explanations: long-term local economic decline, deindustrialisation, weak labour markets, poor transport and employer discrimination produce concentrated worklessness and exclusion, not a cultural pathology.
- Empirical evidence examples: studies showing concentrations of long-term unemployment in some neighbourhoods, evidence that job loss precedes welfare reliance, and findings on stigma and employer practices limiting re-entry to work.
- Methodological issues: difficulties measuring an underclass using occupation-based class schemes, the usefulness of small-area statistics, and the danger of moralising language in some New Right accounts.
- Evaluation: synthesis weighing the relative explanatory power of cultural versus structural accounts, possible interaction of factors, and a conclusion that accepts localized, serious exclusion exists while questioning whether this amounts to a single, homogeneous underclass across Britain.
Question 7
- one correct difference, e.g. RG used six broad classes while NS-SEC has eight categoriesB1
- second correct difference, e.g. NS-SEC emphasises employment relations and status, not just job title or manual/non-manual distinctionB1
- Answer: Differences include: the Registrar General scale used six broad classes while NS-SEC uses eight categories; NS-SEC emphasises employment relations and status rather than just a simple manual versus non-manual occupation split.
Question 8
- (a) identifies change in the labour market, e.g. growth of service and professional jobs making the old manual/non-manual split less usefulB1
- (a) development, e.g. NS-SEC better captures these new employment patterns and variety of workB1
- (a) Answer: One reason is changes in the labour market, such as growth of service and professional jobs that made the old manual versus non-manual split less useful; NS-SEC better captures these new employment patterns.
- (b) identifies need for a more nuanced measure, e.g. to reflect employment relations, job autonomy and statusB1
- (b) development, e.g. NS-SEC allows more precise comparisons across surveys and policy contextsB1
- (b) Answer: Another reason is the need for a more nuanced measure that reflects employment relations, job autonomy and status; NS-SEC allows more precise comparisons across surveys and for policy analysis.
Question 9
- identifies that embourgeoisement is the idea that skilled, well-paid manual workers adopted middle-class values and lifestylesB1
- development, e.g. this suggested class culture was becoming more similar between manual and middle-class workersB1
- Answer: The embourgeoisement thesis is the idea that skilled, well-paid manual workers began to adopt middle-class values and lifestyles, suggesting class cultures were becoming more similar between manual and middle-class workers.
Question 10
- identifies a methodological strength, e.g. use of detailed interviews and surveys to gather both attitudes and behaviourB1
- brief development, e.g. this provided both quantitative and qualitative evidence rather than relying on pay aloneB1
- Answer: Goldthorpe used detailed interviews and surveys combining attitudes and behaviour, providing both quantitative and qualitative evidence rather than relying on pay alone.
Question 11
- identifies criticism, e.g. it assumes material position alone changes values and ignores persistent cultural distinctionsB1
- brief development, e.g. cultural identity and class symbols can persist even when incomes riseB1
- Answer: A criticism is that embourgeoisement assumes material position alone changes values, ignoring persistent cultural distinctions; class identities and symbols can remain even when incomes rise.
Question 12
- identifies a structural cause from the item, e.g. poor public transport limiting access to jobsB1
- develops explanation, e.g. limited transport reduces opportunities to attend interviews or reach workplaces, increasing long-term unemployment riskB1
- identifies a second structural cause, e.g. local economic change and job rejection due to lack of local employment opportunitiesB1
- develops explanation, e.g. decline of nearby industries and weak local labour markets can create persistent worklessness across householdsB1
- Answer: Two structural causes are poor public transport, which limits access to jobs and makes attendance at interviews or shifts difficult, raising long-term unemployment risk, and local economic change such as decline of nearby industries creating weak labour markets so people face repeated job rejection and few local opportunities.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.