GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 5 includes Situational Crime Prevention: Target Hardening and Designing Out Crime (from page 3); Environmental Crime Prevention: Broken Windows and Zero Tolerance Policing (from page 8); The Role of the Police and Courts in the Criminal Justice System (from page 13); Theories of Social Stratification (from page 17); Social Class and Life Chances (from page 22); Poverty and Wealth (from page 28); Power and Authority (from page 33); Social Mobility (from page 38); Inequality by Gender, Ethnicity and Age (from page 44); Forms of Social Stratification: Caste, Feudal and Slave Systems (from page 49); Classifying Social Class and the Growth of an Underclass (from page 53); Explanations of and Solutions to Poverty (from page 58); Pluralist and Elite Theories of Power (from page 62); Inequality Based on Disability and Other Social Divisions (from page 67); Marxist and Feminist Perspectives on Power and the State (from page 72).
Worked question 15 - Social Mobility
Open the included worksheet
Item A: Two Generations
A hypothetical illustration, written for Revision Library, of intergenerational social mobility. Not based on real individuals; both examples are presented as ordinary instances of mobility, not as more or less successful than one another.
Noah's grandfather left school at fifteen and worked as a factory machinist for over thirty years. Noah's mother trained as a nurse, the first in the family to complete a professional qualification. Noah has recently qualified as a solicitor after studying law at university, helped by a student loan and, in his final year, a paid internship at a local firm. In the same town, Isla's grandmother worked as a shop manager. Isla's father took over running the same shop when her grandmother retired, and the family business has stayed in the same trade for two generations. Isla has recently started an apprenticeship in engineering, a field none of her family has worked in before.
Explain John Goldthorpe's contribution to the study of social mobility in Britain.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 15
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies that Goldthorpe led major studies of social mobility in Britain, including the Oxford Mobility Study |
| B1 | development, e.g. his research distinguished between absolute mobility, which rose over the twentieth century partly due to growth in professional and managerial jobs, and relative mobility, which he found remained much less equal between class backgrounds |
| B1 | identifies this suggested that, although more people were moving upward overall, people from advantaged backgrounds were still much more likely to reach the top than people from disadvantaged backgrounds |
| B1 | development, e.g. this challenged the idea that rising absolute mobility on its own showed society had become more meritocratic |
- Answer: Goldthorpe's Oxford Mobility Study distinguished absolute mobility (which rose with job-market change) from relative mobility (which stayed much less equal), challenging the idea that rising absolute mobility alone shows society is more meritocratic.
Question 14 - Social Mobility
Open the included worksheet
Item A: Two Generations
A hypothetical illustration, written for Revision Library, of intergenerational social mobility. Not based on real individuals; both examples are presented as ordinary instances of mobility, not as more or less successful than one another.
Noah's grandfather left school at fifteen and worked as a factory machinist for over thirty years. Noah's mother trained as a nurse, the first in the family to complete a professional qualification. Noah has recently qualified as a solicitor after studying law at university, helped by a student loan and, in his final year, a paid internship at a local firm. In the same town, Isla's grandmother worked as a shop manager. Isla's father took over running the same shop when her grandmother retired, and the family business has stayed in the same trade for two generations. Isla has recently started an apprenticeship in engineering, a field none of her family has worked in before.
Explain the difference between absolute and relative social mobility.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 14
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies absolute mobility as the total amount of movement between class positions in a society, which can rise simply because the shape of the job market changes (oe) |
| B1 | development, e.g. if there are more professional/managerial jobs available than in the past, more people can move upward in absolute terms |
| B1 | identifies relative mobility as comparing the chances of people from different class backgrounds reaching a particular class position, relative to each other |
| B1 | development, e.g. relative mobility can stay unequal even while absolute mobility rises, if people from advantaged backgrounds are still more likely to reach top positions than people from disadvantaged backgrounds |
- Answer: Absolute mobility is the total amount of movement between class positions, which can rise as the job market changes; relative mobility compares the chances of people from different backgrounds, which can stay unequal even as absolute mobility rises.
Question 17 - Social Mobility
Open the included worksheet
Item A: Two Generations
A hypothetical illustration, written for Revision Library, of intergenerational social mobility. Not based on real individuals; both examples are presented as ordinary instances of mobility, not as more or less successful than one another.
Noah's grandfather left school at fifteen and worked as a factory machinist for over thirty years. Noah's mother trained as a nurse, the first in the family to complete a professional qualification. Noah has recently qualified as a solicitor after studying law at university, helped by a student loan and, in his final year, a paid internship at a local firm. In the same town, Isla's grandmother worked as a shop manager. Isla's father took over running the same shop when her grandmother retired, and the family business has stayed in the same trade for two generations. Isla has recently started an apprenticeship in engineering, a field none of her family has worked in before.
State one criticism of using only absolute mobility figures to judge how meritocratic a society is.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 17
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies a genuine criticism, e.g. rising absolute mobility can simply reflect a changing job market, such as more professional jobs overall, rather than genuinely fairer competition between people from different backgrounds |
| B1 | brief development |
- Answer: Rising absolute mobility can simply reflect a changing job market rather than genuinely fairer competition between people from different backgrounds.
Question 14 - Social Class and Life Chances
Open the included worksheet
Item A: Two Households
A hypothetical comparison, written for Revision Library to illustrate how social class background can shape access to resources. Not based on real individuals; described neutrally, without suggesting either household's circumstances reflect anything about their own character or effort.
Deacon lives with his parents in a three-bedroom house in a suburb with a highly rated secondary school. Both his parents are in professional careers, and the family owns their home outright. Deacon has his own bedroom to study in, and his parents can afford a tutor when he is preparing for exams. Elsewhere in the same city, Farah lives with her mother and younger brother in a rented flat above a shop. Her mother works two part-time jobs to cover the rent, and money is often tight towards the end of the month. Farah shares a bedroom with her brother and often studies at the kitchen table in the evening, when it is quieter.
Explain the link between social class and educational life chances.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 14
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies a pattern, e.g. pupils from higher-income/professional backgrounds tend, on average, to achieve higher qualifications than pupils from lower-income backgrounds |
| B1 | development, e.g. this is linked to factors such as access to resources including books, tutoring and quiet study space, rather than differences in ability |
| B1 | identifies material deprivation as one structural explanation, e.g. families with less income may find it harder to afford educational extras, or older children may need to contribute to household income |
| B1 | development, e.g. sociologists stress these are patterns about circumstances and resources, not judgements about the ability or effort of pupils from any particular background |
- Answer: Pupils from higher-income backgrounds tend, on average, to achieve higher qualifications, linked to access to resources such as tutoring and study space; sociologists stress this reflects circumstances, not the ability of pupils.
Question 16 - Social Class and Life Chances
Open the included worksheet
Item A: Two Households
A hypothetical comparison, written for Revision Library to illustrate how social class background can shape access to resources. Not based on real individuals; described neutrally, without suggesting either household's circumstances reflect anything about their own character or effort.
Deacon lives with his parents in a three-bedroom house in a suburb with a highly rated secondary school. Both his parents are in professional careers, and the family owns their home outright. Deacon has his own bedroom to study in, and his parents can afford a tutor when he is preparing for exams. Elsewhere in the same city, Farah lives with her mother and younger brother in a rented flat above a shop. Her mother works two part-time jobs to cover the rent, and money is often tight towards the end of the month. Farah shares a bedroom with her brother and often studies at the kitchen table in the evening, when it is quieter.
State one way social class can affect a person's employment-related life chances.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 16
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies, e.g. people from professional/higher-income family backgrounds may have wider access to useful contacts (social networks) or unpaid work experience opportunities that can help with job applications |
| B1 | development, e.g. this can affect access to some careers, without meaning people from other backgrounds lack ability |
- Answer: People from higher-income backgrounds may have wider access to useful contacts or unpaid work experience, which can affect access to some careers, without meaning others lack ability.