Global Governance: Human Rights and Environmental
This topic covers how the world tries to protect human rights and the environment when state sovereignty makes enforcement difficult. Human rights are claimed to be universal, held by all people because they are human. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) is a General Assembly declaration setting out those rights; it is not itself a treaty, though later treaties and domestic laws build on it. Courts are often confused: the International Court of Justice (ICJ, The Hague, from 1945) is the UN's principal judicial organ and settles disputes between states and gives advisory opinions; the International Criminal Court (ICC, The Hague) was created by the Rome Statute (adopted 1998, in force 2002) and prosecutes individuals for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression, usually only where a state is unwilling or unable to do so; the European Court of Human Rights (Strasbourg) belongs to the Council of Europe, not the EU, and hears complaints under the European Convention on Human Rights (1950). Ad hoc tribunals such as the ICTY (1993) and ICTR (1994) tried individuals for crimes in former Yugoslavia and Rwanda. The Responsibility to Protect (R2P), endorsed at the 2005 World Summit, says states have a duty to protect their populations from mass atrocities and that the international community may take collective action through the Security Council if they fail. On the environment, shallow-green views accept growth with technology and management (sustainable development), while deep-green thinkers such as Arne Naess give nature intrinsic value. Global commons such as the high seas are exposed to Hardin's tragedy of the commons (1968). The IPCC assesses the science, the UNFCCC (1992) is the framework treaty, the Kyoto Protocol (1997) set binding targets for developed states, and the Paris Agreement (2015) relies on nationally determined contributions.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Sort every institution by what it can do: declares (UDHR), judges states (ICJ), prosecutes individuals (ICC), assesses science (IPCC), frames treaties (UNFCCC), and who it binds. Most errors come from crossing these categories.
- Always link the institution to sovereignty. The ICC and ICJ depend on state consent, and R2P was framed to respect sovereignty as responsibility rather than abolish it.
- Know the limits with dated evidence: the ICC has no police force and relies on states to arrest; major powers such as the USA, Russia and China are not parties to the Rome Statute; Security Council vetoes constrain intervention.
- For R2P, learn its three pillars (state responsibility; international assistance; collective action if a state manifestly fails) and the 2011 Libya intervention as the case that made states wary of its use for regime change.
- For the environment, contrast shallow and deep green, then apply them to a treaty. The Paris Agreement's voluntary targets are a compromise that gets wide participation but gives no guaranteed outcome.
- Use the tragedy of the commons as an explanation: individually rational use of a shared resource leads to collective damage unless rules, monitoring or agreement exist.
- In an evaluate answer, test the claim that sovereignty is the main obstacle against alternatives: great-power interests, weak enforcement design, cost, disagreement between rich and poor states, and lack of public pressure.
Worked example
Explain two reasons why the International Criminal Court may struggle to bring suspects to trial. (6 marks)
- Pick the first reason: the ICC depends on state cooperation because it has no police force of its own. Explain that a suspect inside a state that will not arrest them cannot be tried.
- Develop it with a dated example: an arrest warrant issued in 2009 for Sudan's president Omar al-Bashir, referred by the Security Council in 2005, was not carried out while he held power, as Sudan was not willing to surrender him. State this only to the level you are certain of.
- Pick the second reason: limited jurisdiction. Explain that the Court acts only over states that are parties (or that accept its jurisdiction for a particular case) or on a Security Council referral, and that the USA, Russia and China are not parties.
- Develop it: so powerful states' nationals are largely outside its reach unless a case arises on the territory of a member, and a Security Council referral can be blocked by a permanent member's veto.
- Check for balance: each reason has an identification, an explanation and a development, giving three marks each.
Practice questions
Q1Why is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) not a treaty, and does that make it meaningless?Show answer
Answer: It was adopted as a General Assembly declaration, which is not legally binding on states. It is not meaningless: it set a common standard, and its principles were turned into binding treaties and influenced national constitutions and courts.
Q2State two differences between the ICJ and the ICC.Show answer
Answer: The ICJ hears disputes between states and gives advisory opinions, while the ICC prosecutes individuals. The ICJ is a principal organ of the UN (since 1945); the ICC is a separate treaty-based court created by the Rome Statute (in force 2002). The ICC deals with genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression.
Q3Why is the European Court of Human Rights not an EU institution?Show answer
Answer: It belongs to the Council of Europe, a separate organisation of which more states are members than the EU, and applies the European Convention on Human Rights (1950). It hears individual complaints against states and does not imprison anyone; the EU's court is the Court of Justice of the EU in Luxembourg.
Q4Explain what 'responsibility to protect' (R2P) means.Show answer
Answer: A principle endorsed at the 2005 World Summit that each state has a responsibility to protect its population from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity, that the international community should help, and that if a state manifestly fails, collective action authorised by the Security Council can be taken.
Q5Explain how the Libya intervention of 2011 affected later attitudes to R2P.Show answer
Answer: The Security Council authorised force to protect civilians (Resolution 1973), but NATO-led action contributed to the overthrow of the Gaddafi government. Russia and China argued that the mandate had been stretched into regime change, making them more reluctant to support similar authorisation, for example over Syria.
Q6Contrast shallow-green and deep-green ecology on the value of nature.Show answer
Answer: Shallow greens regard nature as valuable mainly for human use and believe technology, markets and regulation can keep growth sustainable. Deep greens such as Arne Naess hold that nature has intrinsic value apart from human use and call for radical change in values and lifestyle.
Q7Explain why the high seas can suffer a tragedy of the commons.Show answer
Answer: No state owns them, so each fishing fleet gains from catching more while the cost of depletion is shared by all. If everyone follows that logic fish stocks collapse. Remedies include agreed quotas, monitoring and treaties that bind fleets.
Q8Explain the difference between the IPCC and the UNFCCC.Show answer
Answer: The IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) is a scientific body that assesses and reports on climate research; it cannot make policy. The UNFCCC (1992) is a treaty framework under which states negotiate climate agreements, such as Kyoto in 1997 and Paris in 2015.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Politics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Q1[6 marks]Explain one strength and one weakness of the Paris Agreement (2015) as a means of global environmental governance. (6 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[12 marks]Analyse the extent to which state sovereignty restricts the protection of human rights through international law. Use at least two institutions in your answer. (12 marks)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
See real A Level Politics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Global Governance: Human Rights and Environmental worksheet pack - 3 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This worksheet is chapter 14 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 4, a free printable practice book.
Other versions of this worksheet: