Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

LNAT Section A: Argumentative reading, set 1

Our site-authored practice category for identifying conclusions, evaluating support and checking inferences against a passage. This is not an official LNAT strand; two sets are planned. Test standard. 10 questions, 10 marks, about 23 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Read the three original passages and answer all ten questions from the passages alone.
  • Choose one answer, A-E, for each question. Each correct answer earns one mark.
  • 23 minutes is our suggested short-practice allowance, including reading time. This is a short practice set.
  • Argumentative reading is our site-authored practice category, not an official skill taxonomy.
  1. 11 mark

    Which statement best expresses the main argument of the passage?

    1. A Publicly funded reports should be simplified before anyone is permitted to inspect their full reasoning.
    2. B Public funding creates an unconditional duty to publish every document produced during an inquiry.
    3. C Publicly funded reasoning should normally be accessible, with explanation that supports its scrutiny.
    4. D Public access is justified chiefly by its ability to give non-specialists the expertise they lack.
    5. E Public reports should be released only when readers can be protected against mistaken interpretations.
  2. 21 mark

    Which conclusion is best supported by the example of the resident in paragraph 2?

    1. A A reader may have a legitimate use for a report without being able to assess it unaided.
    2. B A resident is better placed than an accredited specialist to evaluate an unfamiliar method.
    3. C A report becomes understandable to a resident once the resident has permission to read it.
    4. D A resident who finds a report difficult should rely on its gatekeeper to select an adviser.
    5. E A specialist consulted by a resident must accept the conclusions of a publicly funded inquiry.
  3. 31 mark

    What role does the discussion of misunderstanding in paragraph 3 play in the argument?

    1. A It supplies evidence that unrestricted publication has already reduced misquotation of research.
    2. B It concedes that qualified readers should control access until explanations become unnecessary.
    3. C It establishes that the risk of error outweighs the public interest in inspecting research.
    4. D It dismisses the possibility that a cautious research finding could become a misleading slogan.
    5. E It accepts a risk while challenging whether that risk justifies restricting access to the report.
  4. 41 mark

    Which proposal best captures the author's approach to allocating the square?

    1. A Give the busiest activity a continuing entitlement, while checking that it still attracts participants.
    2. B Assess competing needs and alternatives, then review how the decisions distribute opportunities over time.
    3. C Rotate the square among all applicants, allowing each group an identical share regardless of circumstances.
    4. D Draw names for each afternoon, ensuring that every claim is treated as equally strong from the outset.
    5. E Choose whichever activity has no alternative location, giving it priority over every other consideration.
  5. 51 mark

    In paragraph 4, what does a lottery expressing "equal standing" mean in context?

    1. A It recognises that the competing activities provide exactly the same kind of public benefit.
    2. B It gives an equal chance to claims that remain equally strong after relevant differences are considered.
    3. C It ensures that every group receives an equal number of afternoons throughout the schedule.
    4. D It gives each participant an individual ticket, regardless of which group they belong to.
    5. E It declares that no relevant difference between applicants could ever justify unequal treatment.
  6. 61 mark

    Which judgement about repeated unsuccessful applications is most consistent with the final paragraph?

    1. A If one group repeatedly loses, each previous decision must have been unfair when it was made.
    2. B If each decision has a defensible reason, the overall schedule must distribute opportunities fairly.
    3. C A group that has repeatedly lost should acquire a permanent entitlement to the square thereafter.
    4. D A sequence of defensible individual choices can still give grounds for reviewing the overall schedule.
    5. E Reviewing a sequence of decisions requires disregarding the particular circumstances of each applicant.
  7. 71 mark

    Which statement best expresses the author's central position?

    1. A Repairable objects should normally be kept for useful change, subject to the demands of other worthwhile uses.
    2. B Repairable objects should remain with their present owners because continued possession honours past labour.
    3. C Repairable objects should be restored to their original form whenever restoration is technically possible.
    4. D Repairable objects deserve preservation because they have an interest in their own continued existence.
    5. E Repairable objects should be replaced whenever doing so would reduce the effort required from their owners.
  8. 81 mark

    What does "puts a burden of explanation on disposal" mean in the final paragraph?

    1. A An owner must obtain another person's permission before disposing of a repairable object.
    2. B Any decision to repair must be justified more fully than a decision to throw an object away.
    3. C A person disposing of an object must provide its next user with full instructions for repair.
    4. D Disposal is permissible only after proving that repair is technically impossible for anyone.
    5. E A decision to discard a repairable object calls for reasons that can outweigh the presumption to keep it.
  9. 91 mark

    What is the main argumentative purpose of the imagined cabinet in paragraph 3?

    1. A To show that preserving an object in its original form is always the best acknowledgement of labour.
    2. B To establish that replacing damaged furniture generally consumes fewer resources than repairing it.
    3. C To show why the possibility of repair must be weighed against the other possibilities it would remove.
    4. D To show that practical independence can be achieved only by avoiding the use of shared resources.
    5. E To establish that an object ceases to be repairable whenever repairing it would be costly.
  10. 101 mark

    Which action would be most consistent with the passage's reasoning?

    1. A Keep an unused table indefinitely because disposing of anything made by someone else disrespects their work.
    2. B Restore a cabinet even if the repair removes all the materials needed for more worthwhile household uses.
    3. C Discard a repairable chair solely because its owner lacks the personal skills to make it usable again.
    4. D Pass a repairable table to a willing user who can adapt it without unreasonable costs to other needs.
    5. E Refuse to alter an unused table because changing its purpose necessarily destroys the value of past labour.

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The opening defends the public claim to inspect research while distinguishing access from expertise. Paragraph 4 then requires both the full argument and an explanation of its scope.
    The final paragraph brings these points together as a presumption for access to reasoning, subject to particular justified exceptions. C preserves both the recommendation and its purpose: scrutiny.
    Why not A: Reverses the relationship between the two publication layers: explanation supports access to the full reasoning rather than being a condition that postpones it.
    Why not B: Overextends the presumption of access into an absolute rule, ignoring the final paragraph's justified protection of confidential contributions.
    Why not D: Confuses access with expertise: the opening separates the two goods and the conclusion rejects a promise to confer expertise.
    Why not E: Adopts the objection as the conclusion: the author acknowledges misunderstanding but rejects perfect understanding as the comparison required for publication.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The imagined resident cannot evaluate the unfamiliar methods but can show the report to someone who can. Access therefore remains useful even without unaided technical understanding.
    A follows from that distinction. Nothing establishes the resident's superior expertise, automatic understanding, a gatekeeper's right to select an adviser or an adviser's duty to agree.
    Why not B: Converts a right to consult someone else into a comparison of expertise; the example expressly assumes the resident cannot evaluate the methods.
    Why not C: Treats permission to read as sufficient understanding, contradicting the distinction between access and ability established in paragraph 1.
    Why not D: Reinstates the gatekeeper's control that the example questions; the resident's ability to show the report to someone else supports direct access.
    Why not E: Introduces compulsory agreement by the specialist. The example allows scrutiny of methods and says nothing requiring the adviser to accept the conclusion.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    The author grants that a cautious possibility can become a slogan. The reply is that restricting the report can also prevent readers from consulting the qualifications that correct that slogan.
    This accepts the risk but disputes the move from risk to restriction, as E states. It shifts attention to responsible ways of publishing without claiming that misunderstanding can be eliminated.
    Why not A: Mistakes a hypothetical comparison of publication choices for empirical evidence of an observed reduction; no such outcome is reported.
    Why not B: Attributes endorsement to the author of the specialist gatekeeping questioned in paragraph 2; the reply favours responsible presentation.
    Why not C: Reverses the reply's conclusion: the objection is called incomplete because restriction also removes access to the qualifications.
    Why not D: Mistakes a rebuttal of the case for restriction for denial of the risk itself; the passage explicitly calls careless presentation a serious concern.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The author considers seriousness of exclusion, reasonable alternatives and past allocations, rather than using numbers or chance as an automatic rule.
    The conclusion adds review of cumulative consequences. B joins the assessment of claims with that continuing review; the other proposals elevate one consideration or procedure into a fixed rule.
    Why not A: Elevates participant numbers into the permanent entitlement expressly rejected at the end; numbers are relevant but insufficient.
    Why not C: Confuses equal concern with automatic identical shares; the conclusion rejects rotation that ignores users' actual circumstances.
    Why not D: Uses the lottery before assessing claims, precisely the error identified in paragraph 4; equal merit must not simply be assumed.
    Why not E: Turns one relevant consideration into a decisive rule. Paragraph 3 says considerations can conflict and denies a permanent priority from one example.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The phrase is immediately qualified: the claims remain equally strong after the relevant considerations have been examined. The lottery acknowledges that residual equality by giving the tied claims an equal chance.
    B captures that conditional meaning. It does not promise equal outcomes, specify tickets per participant or declare all activities and circumstances identical.
    Why not A: Confuses equal merit of claims with identity of the activities or benefits; different uses may have equally strong claims.
    Why not C: Confuses an equal chance in a particular tie with a guaranteed equal allocation over time; a lottery provides no such guarantee.
    Why not D: Imports a ticket-allocation mechanism never specified and returns to participant numbers, which paragraph 2 treats as insufficient.
    Why not E: Universalises equality in a particular assessed tie into a denial that relevant differences exist; paragraph 4 requires examining them first.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    The author distinguishes reviewing a sequence from condemning every decision in it. Continuing exclusion can emerge from decisions that appear harmless when taken separately.
    D retains both points: individual choices may be defensible while their cumulative effect supplies a reason to review the schedule. The passage neither guarantees aggregate fairness nor imposes a permanent remedy.
    Why not A: Turns a reason to review cumulative exclusion into proof about every past decision, which the paragraph explicitly denies.
    Why not B: Assumes fairness of each isolated choice guarantees fairness of the sequence; the paragraph raises exactly the possibility this overlooks.
    Why not C: Converts a trigger for reconsideration into a permanent entitlement, repeating the rigid priority the passage rejects.
    Why not E: Creates a false choice between reviewing the sequence and considering circumstances; the author requires both in an accountable procedure.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The opening treats repairability as a reason to pause, not as a decision by itself. The examples then defend preserving useful options while allowing adaptation and recognising the costs to other needs.
    The final paragraph states a presumption for retaining repairable objects under those conditions. A expresses that qualified position without requiring original form, continued ownership or preservation at any cost.
    Why not B: Confuses preserving future usefulness with preserving ownership; the last paragraph permits passing an object to another user.
    Why not C: Turns repairability into an absolute obligation and original form into the goal, ignoring both the cabinet objection and the defence of adaptation.
    Why not D: Attributes an interest to the object itself, expressly denied in the opening; the duties discussed concern people and shared resources.
    Why not E: Makes the owner's effort a decisive reason for replacement, whereas the conclusion permits transfer and requires weighing worthwhile uses and other needs.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    A presumption supplies an initial reason to retain the object, but the next sentence says it does not forbid disposal. The burden is therefore to justify a departure from that initial position.
    E expresses that requirement for countervailing reasons. The passage requires neither outside permission nor proof that repair is impossible, and it does not use explanation to mean a repair manual.
    Why not A: Mistakes a requirement for reasons for a requirement to secure approval; no approving person or permission procedure is proposed.
    Why not B: Reverses the direction of the presumption: the passage places the explanatory burden on disposal rather than repair.
    Why not C: Misreads explanation as practical repair instructions and conflates disposal with the separately discussed transfer to another user.
    Why not D: Turns a defeasible presumption into a ban unless repair is impossible, contrary to the cabinet example and the express statement that disposal is not forbidden.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The cabinet can technically be repaired, but doing so would use wood otherwise available for other needs. It is a counterexample to treating technical possibility as sufficient justification.
    C identifies its role: a repair must be judged partly by the options it closes elsewhere. The example does not establish general resource comparisons or redefine an expensive repair as impossible.
    Why not A: Imports the preservation of original form as a goal, when paragraph 4 explicitly allows adaptation and the cabinet concerns costs to other needs.
    Why not B: Generalises a deliberately imagined comparison into an empirical rule about furniture; the example establishes a possible objection, not a typical outcome.
    Why not D: Turns recognition of competing resource uses into a demand to use no shared resources, which the passage neither states nor needs.
    Why not E: Confuses technical feasibility with whether a feasible repair is sensible. The cabinet remains repairable under the hypothetical conditions.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    The final paragraph allows passing an object to someone able and willing to use it. Paragraph 4 also allows adaptation, and the conclusion requires reasonable costs to other needs.
    D satisfies all these conditions. Each alternative makes possession, original form, personal repair skills or the existing object decisive in a way that the passage rejects.
    Why not A: Treats past labour as an unconditional reason for storage, ignoring paragraph 4's rejection of keeping unusable objects merely to acknowledge that labour.
    Why not B: Ignores the limitation established by the cabinet objection: preserving one object cannot automatically override more worthwhile uses of the same resources.
    Why not C: Mistakes the owner's inability to repair for absence of worthwhile future use; the final paragraph expressly allows transfer to someone able and willing.
    Why not E: Treats change of purpose as destruction of value, reversing paragraph 4's argument that adaptation can carry past effort into new activity.

Keep going

More free LNAT practice