LNAT Section A: Argumentative reading, set 3
Our site-authored practice category for identifying conclusions, evaluating support and checking inferences against a passage. This is not an official LNAT strand; two sets are planned. Test standard. 10 questions, 10 marks, about 23 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Read the three original passages and answer all ten questions from the passages alone.
- Choose one answer, A-E, for each question. Each correct answer earns one mark.
- 23 minutes is our suggested short-practice allowance, including reading time. This is our short-practice suggestion, not an official timing for this selection.
- Argumentative reading is our site-authored practice category, not an official skill taxonomy.
- 11 mark
Which standard for assessing an apology does the writer ultimately recommend?
- 21 mark
What can be inferred if the companions accept the apology but choose another player?
- 31 mark
How does the concern about repeated apologies in paragraph 3 affect the preceding argument?
- 41 mark
The advice to give a novice feedback about particular merits relies on which assumption?
- 51 mark
What limit does the final paragraph place on the demand for judges to explain their decisions?
- 61 mark
Two panels agree on every described feature but award different plays. Which interpretation does the passage support?
- 71 mark
Which claim best captures the conclusion about using silence to reach an agreement?
- 81 mark
What must the organiser establish before the old silence convention can justify treating the equipment payment as accepted?
- 91 mark
Why does the writer introduce the claim that members could always allege misunderstanding afterwards?
- 101 mark
How does the route example qualify what an accepted proposal tells us about members?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks D 1 The final paragraph assesses an apology by recognition of a justified complaint and a practical response. Earlier paragraphs explain why neither prediction nor a fixed gesture can replace these requirements. D states that combined standard. Restoring trust is a separate judgement, so an apology need not secure the former relationship to meet this standard. Why not A: Confuses apology with restored trust: paragraph 4 allows acceptance of the apology while choosing another player. Why not B: Substitutes prediction for acknowledgement: paragraph 1 rejects a guarantee of non-recurrence as the test of an apology. Why not C: Universalises the remedy: paragraph 3 says responses differ with the wrong and rejects a universal gesture of sincerity. Why not E: Recasts responsibility as lowering expectations: limiting a future undertaking can be a response, but cannot replace recognition of the justified complaint. Question 2
Answer or working Marks B 1 Paragraph 4 explicitly distinguishes accepting acknowledgement from deciding that renewed reliance is prudent. The companions can therefore accept the apology while changing the performance arrangements. B preserves that distinction. Neither dishonesty, a guarantee, dismissal of remedies nor denial of the original undertaking follows from their choice. Why not A: Contradicts paragraph 4: choosing another player need not imply disbelief about the missed rehearsal. Why not C: Conflates acceptance with certainty: the passage separates acknowledging the wrong from evidence supporting future reliance. Why not D: Overstates the separation: practical responses matter to assessing the apology even when trust is not immediately restored. Why not E: Reverses the acknowledged wrong: acceptance of the apology does not erase the entitlement to rely on her original undertaking. Question 3
Answer or working Marks B 1 The concern is that words may merely end an uncomfortable conversation. The writer answers it by asking what the speaker is prepared to do now. B describes this additional requirement. It gives acknowledgement practical substance while retaining the earlier rejection of guaranteed future behaviour. Why not A: Mistakes refinement for retraction: paragraph 3 expressly rejects answering the concern by demanding future certainty. Why not C: Treats a possible abuse as empirical evidence: the speaker might use responsibility vocabulary insincerely; no observed pattern is reported. Why not D: Invents authority over future possibility: the paragraph asks what the speaker will do now, not who can certify future conduct. Why not E: Confuses practical response with restored relationship: paragraph 4 keeps renewed trust separate from assessing acknowledgement. Question 4
Answer or working Marks E 1 The proposed feedback identifies a particular achievement or weakness and explains its relevance to the writer's aims. For that to help learning, such information must be capable of guiding a revision towards those aims. E supplies that link. The recommendation needs neither a universal scale nor agreement about weights, and depends on the insufficiency of the order alone. Why not A: Replaces the novice's aims with imitation: paragraph 3 warns that following a higher-ranked play can lead her to abandon promising work. Why not B: Imports the common scale questioned in paragraph 2: useful particular feedback does not require all revisions to share one measure. Why not C: Confuses agreement with explanation: different panels can accept the descriptions while assigning different weights and awards. Why not D: Assumes precisely what the novice example denies: the ranking alone does not identify which feature decided the comparison. Question 5
Answer or working Marks A 1 The writer denies a demand for every fleeting impression, then requires an account of the considerations that actually carried the decision. A captures both the obligation and its limit. Nothing makes explanation conditional on protest or a common scale, and publication is not a guarantee of convincing reasons. Why not B: Adds an unsupported condition: paragraph 2 allows explanation where merits cannot be expressed on one common scale. Why not C: Drops the explicit limit: entrants cannot demand a complete account of every fleeting impression, and keeping a ranking is permitted. Why not D: Invents a restriction to protesting entrants: the reasonable requirement concerns the considerations carrying the decision, not whether someone objects. Why not E: Turns explanation into guaranteed persuasion: the final paragraph expressly allows detailed reasons to be unconvincing. Question 6
Answer or working Marks C 1 Paragraph 2 says another panel might accept every description yet reasonably assign the award differently. Its discussion of giving staging greater weight than restraint explains how this can happen. C is the supported possibility. The passage neither forces an unnoticed feature nor treats differing judgements as making awards impossible. Why not A: Converts disagreement into an observational error: paragraph 2 explicitly says it need not show a failure to notice a feature. Why not B: Draws a veto from plural merits: paragraph 2 permits choosing a winner even without a common scale. Why not D: Invents an asymmetry: the passage permits judges to explain their weighting and gives no special defect to favouring restraint. Why not E: Confuses differing weightings with universal equivalence: the example establishes neither identical merits nor suitability for every writer's aims. Question 7
Answer or working Marks D 1 The closing sentence permits silence to play a legitimate role provided its meaning and scope are sufficiently clear. Paragraph 2 illustrates a familiar convention with a real opportunity for questions. D states this conditional position. Silence alone, enthusiasm and an unlimited extension of an old convention are all rejected as substitutes for that condition. Why not A: Confuses a record of no objections with acceptance: paragraphs 1 and 4 require a procedure with an understandable meaning. Why not B: Confuses preference with acceptance: paragraph 2 expressly allows someone to accept a route while preferring another. Why not C: Demands impossible certainty: paragraph 4 rejects proof of every private thought as the standard for attributing agreement. Why not E: Extends a convention beyond its scope: paragraph 3 denies that an ordinary-route convention automatically covers a new payment. Question 8
Answer or working Marks A 1 Paragraph 3 places the burden on the person claiming acceptance to establish that the procedure covered the commitment. Paragraph 1 also requires a reasonable opportunity to speak. A combines those requirements. Past silence about an ordinary route or beliefs about the payment's merits cannot establish informed procedural acceptance of the additional commitment. Why not B: Substitutes value for acceptance: the passage requires establishing that the procedure covered the commitment, not that the payment was economical. Why not C: Confuses popularity with procedural scope: a preferred route does not establish acceptance of a new financial obligation. Why not D: Substitutes the organiser's expectation for members' understanding: paragraph 3 asks whether they knew what required an objection. Why not E: Treats precedent as sufficient: prior use for ordinary routes cannot establish that this additional payment falls within the convention. Question 9
Answer or working Marks E 1 The objection suggests that the writer's conditions make decisions impossible because misunderstanding can always be claimed. The reply distinguishes reasonable grounds from proof of every private thought. E identifies this role. A sufficiently clear procedure can justify attributing acceptance without eliminating all later disputes, while an obscure one remains defective. Why not A: Turns a possible allegation into a verdict on all objections: the writer allows later disputes without calling them invariably dishonest. Why not B: Reverses the reply: paragraph 4 says a clear familiar procedure can supply reasonable grounds despite possible disputes. Why not C: Attributes the rejected standard to the writer: proof of every private thought is expressly not required. Why not D: Mistakes a reply to an objection for retraction: the obscure-procedure criticism is immediately reaffirmed in paragraph 4. Question 10
Answer or working Marks C 1 Paragraph 2 says that someone might prefer another route but accept this one for coordination. A procedure for agreement therefore need not discover what everyone most wants. C retains this limit on the inference from acceptance. Acceptance neither proves enthusiasm nor automatically covers extra obligations or rules out later disputes. Why not A: Conflates acceptance with preference: paragraph 2 allows a member to prefer another route while accepting the proposed one. Why not B: Adds a spoken-enthusiasm requirement: the familiar silence convention can give grounds for treating a route as accepted. Why not D: Extends acceptance beyond scope: the next paragraph requires checking that a new financial commitment is covered. Why not E: Converts reasonable grounds into certainty: paragraph 4 explicitly allows later disputes despite an adequate procedure.