Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

LNAT Section A: Argumentative reading, set 6

Our site-authored practice category for identifying conclusions, evaluating support and checking inferences against a passage. This is not an official LNAT strand; two sets are planned. Test standard. 11 questions, 11 marks, about 25 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Answer all eleven questions using only the relevant passage. Each question has one best answer from A-E.
  • Allow 25 minutes as our short-practice suggestion, including reading time. This is not a full mock.
  • Argumentative reading is our site-authored practice category, not an official LNAT strand. All passages and questions are original.
  1. 11 mark

    Which distinction most directly undermines the householders' defence in paragraph 1?

    1. A The distinction between intending to obstruct an activity and knowing that others oppose it.
    2. B The distinction between adding to interference and being able to remove it single-handedly.
    3. C The distinction between a popular celebration and an activity enjoyed by fewer residents.
    4. D The distinction between responsibility for choosing a lantern and responsibility for buying it.
    5. E The distinction between a temporary inconvenience and damage that cannot later be reversed.
  2. 21 mark

    On the passage's stated conditions, what follows if one resident alone takes down a lantern?

    1. A That resident ceases to owe any explanation for the village's remaining interference.
    2. B The remaining residents become equally responsible regardless of their lanterns' brightness.
    3. C The observers gain a restored view even though most of the lanterns remain lit.
    4. D The village has less lantern light, but the observing activity remains obstructed.
    5. E The resident's action demonstrates that a shared reduction would also be ineffective.
  3. 31 mark

    What is the role of the practical objection at the start of paragraph 3?

    1. A It explains the attraction of coordination without vindicating the denial of contribution.
    2. B It shows that residents who refuse to act alone have correctly identified the sole possible remedy.
    3. C It establishes that the loss of celebration must outweigh the loss of an observing opportunity.
    4. D It withdraws the claim that a dim lamp can contribute when its removal has no useful result.
    5. E It transfers responsibility for arranging a response entirely from residents to the observers.
  4. 41 mark

    Which proposed argument would the author reject for the same reason as the original householders' defence?

    1. A The village should compare the cost of dimming lamps with the benefit of a clearer sky.
    2. B Residents with more powerful lanterns should explain why their larger contribution is justified.
    3. C The observers should consider whether a different evening could accommodate both activities.
    4. D A shared plan may deserve support even when no resident can bring about its result alone.
    5. E An agreement is unnecessary because no household can restore the view by acting alone.
  5. 51 mark

    Why does the author mention that the two descriptions might concern different incidents?

    1. A To show that borrowing an interpretation prevents a reader from noticing genuine contradictions.
    2. B To illustrate a challenge that addresses Lena's present evidence rather than her original motive.
    3. C To establish that a narrator can never be judged unreliable on evidence from the story alone.
    4. D To reveal that Lena's friend deliberately misled her about the events described in the story.
    5. E To demonstrate that the critic's account of Lena's motive is sufficient to disprove her conclusion.
  6. 61 mark

    What does the guessing friend in paragraph 3 establish about the relevance of a belief's origins?

    1. A An unreliable source makes the opposite of its claim the most reasonable conclusion to accept.
    2. B Origins can undermine a claimed ground without showing that the belief itself is false.
    3. C Origins cease to matter once the person repeating a claim admits having no direct evidence.
    4. D A belief borrowed from someone else cannot acquire adequate support through later investigation.
    5. E A person's motive for repeating a claim determines whether its original source was well informed.
  7. 71 mark

    Which additional case best fits the author's recommendation in the final paragraph?

    1. A A club rejects a proposal solely because its proposer originally supported it to gain popularity.
    2. B A reader accepts an interpretation because it was inherited from someone with admirable motives.
    3. C A speaker refuses to answer questions about sources because the conclusion could still be true.
    4. D A committee tests the reasons for an inherited rule and retains it when those reasons withstand scrutiny.
    5. E A reviewer dismisses new evidence because the person offering it once defended the claim for poor reasons.
  8. 81 mark

    Which claim best expresses the author's answer to the critic's first objection?

    1. A A boundary can be justified by its purpose even where the underlying change is gradual.
    2. B An artificial line is defensible only if the physical difference across it is immediately visible.
    3. C A gradual change in depth allows every position to serve equally well as a beginner boundary.
    4. D The absence of a sudden step means staff must negotiate a separate limit with each learner.
    5. E A boundary is legitimate only if all reasonable centres would choose exactly the same position.
  9. 91 mark

    Why does paragraph 2 describe a line placed well into water too deep for the intended learners?

    1. A To concede that a line cannot assist staff unless the pool has a sudden change of depth.
    2. B To suggest that clearer instructions compensate for a position poorly suited to the exercise.
    3. C To distinguish the ease of stating a rule from the adequacy of its placement.
    4. D To show that the centre must choose the shallowest possible line whatever the exercise requires.
    5. E To establish that the critic favours deeper water because it gives learners more room to practise.
  10. 101 mark

    The author grants that several positions might be acceptable under the same conditions. What does the author nevertheless maintain?

    1. A Selecting one position makes it correct for every later exercise conducted in that pool.
    2. B Different acceptable positions must correspond to differences in learners or supervision.
    3. C Staff should alternate between incompatible instructions to acknowledge the range of acceptable choices.
    4. D No position can be criticised once the centre has explained the purpose of drawing a line.
    5. E Consistent instructions can be valuable after a reasonable position has been selected.
  11. 111 mark

    Which later development would most directly challenge the centre's continued reliance on its existing line, according to paragraph 4?

    1. A Another centre keeps a different line for an otherwise similar exercise with similar learners.
    2. B The centre changes to an exercise for which the marked zone no longer provides suitable supervision.
    3. C Learners notice that the difference in depth immediately across the line is very small.
    4. D Staff discover that more than one position would have been reasonable at the time of selection.
    5. E The centre confirms that the line affects permitted activity without creating a physical step in the floor.

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The residents argue from the ineffectiveness of one removal to the absence of any contribution. Paragraph 2 blocks that inference: each lamp adds light even though one removal cannot restore the view.
    B separates contribution from the ability to remedy the whole problem. None of the other distinctions addresses that inference.
    Therefore B is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting B.
    Why not A: Substitutes intention for contribution. The passage makes no finding about residents intending interference, and intention is not the defence it challenges.
    Why not C: Substitutes relative popularity for causal reasoning. The number of people enjoying either activity does not explain why the individual-removal defence fails.
    Why not D: Invents a distinction between choosing and purchasing. The argument concerns added light and effective remedies, not how a lamp was acquired.
    Why not E: Imports a distinction about permanence. The passage does not make irreversible damage a condition for contributing to a problem.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    Each lamp is stipulated to add light, so removing one reduces the total. But the example also expressly says that any single removal leaves the sky too bright.
    D preserves both conditions: a real reduction occurs without achieving the observers' aim. The outcome does not settle the removed lamp owner's wider responsibilities.
    Therefore D is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting D.
    Why not A: Converts a change in contribution into complete release from responsibility. The passage does not settle all obligations by the removal of one lamp.
    Why not B: Assumes equal responsibility from a shared outcome. Paragraph 2 explicitly allows differences in contribution and leaves further enquiry open.
    Why not C: Contradicts the threshold stipulated in paragraph 1: removing any one lantern leaves the sky too bright for the observing activity.
    Why not E: Generalises the failure of a solitary remedy to a coordinated one. Paragraph 3 states that enough residents together could reduce the glow sufficiently.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The author accepts that acting alone could cost the resident something without restoring the view. That makes an agreement worth seeking; it does not show that lamps make no contribution.
    A identifies the objection's limited force. The subsequent discussion requires assessment of both activities rather than establishing an automatic priority.
    Therefore A is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting A.
    Why not B: Treats a reason to seek cooperation as proof of a unique remedy. The author offers several possible arrangements and endorses none as the only option.
    Why not C: Turns recognition of a cost into a ranking of activities. The paragraph explicitly leaves their relative value to further assessment.
    Why not D: Reads a practical difficulty as a retraction of the causal distinction. The paragraph accepts that solitary action may fail while retaining the shared problem.
    Why not E: Invents a transfer of responsibility. The objection concerns residents coordinating their actions, not observers assuming all duties.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    The challenged inference moves from 'one resident cannot fix it' to 'there is no need for a shared response'. E makes exactly that move.
    The author leaves the merits of particular plans open. The other options either examine those merits or recognise why a plan could have value.
    Therefore E is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting E.
    Why not A: Mistakes open assessment for evasion. Comparing costs and benefits is precisely the further judgement paragraph 3 requires.
    Why not B: Mistakes differentiated responsibility for denial of contribution. Paragraph 2 expressly allows larger contributions to matter.
    Why not C: Mistakes a possible compromise for dismissal of the shared problem. A different evening is among the possibilities paragraph 4 leaves open.
    Why not D: Reverses the author's position on cooperation. Paragraph 3 explains why combined action may achieve what solitary action cannot.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    If the descriptions concern different incidents, their incompatibility may not establish an inaccurate narrator. This challenges the inference Lena now makes from the story.
    The example thus shows what a relevant criticism could look like without deciding whether it succeeds. B captures that role; the passage does not settle the fictional story's interpretation.
    Therefore B is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting B.
    Why not A: Infers a permanent incapacity from the borrowed origin. The example allows Lena to provide independent reasons later.
    Why not C: Universalises one possible objection. The author questions whether these descriptions conflict, not whether textual evidence can ever support unreliability.
    Why not D: Invents deception by the friend. Nothing in paragraph 2 identifies the friend's intentions or establishes what the friend knew.
    Why not E: Confuses a possible evidential objection with the critic's actual reply. The motive alone leaves Lena's later reasoning unaddressed.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    Lena's only offered basis in this variant is her friend's assertion. Discovering that the friend was guessing removes that offered basis for confidence.
    The passage expressly separates this loss of support from a demonstration that the conclusion is false. B preserves the distinction.
    Therefore B is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting B.
    Why not A: Confuses loss of support with proof of the opposite. The author expressly says the facts do not demonstrate a reliable narrator.
    Why not C: Reverses the purpose of the example. When Lena relies only on the friend, how the friend obtained the claim is relevant to that reliance.
    Why not D: Treats an unsupported beginning as an incurable defect. Paragraph 2 allows later reasons to be assessed on their own merits.
    Why not E: Confuses the believer's motive with the source's information. Whether the friend read the story does not depend on why Lena repeated the opinion.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    The final sentence permits retaining inherited opinions when their reasons survive examination. D examines the present case for the rule instead of accepting or rejecting it merely because it was inherited.
    The other cases all let a history or motive replace scrutiny, or refuse scrutiny of a relevant source. D alone follows the recommendation.
    Therefore D is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting D.
    Why not A: Makes an initial motive a sufficient ground for rejection. The author requires assessment of its connection to the support now offered.
    Why not B: Makes admirable motives a certificate of truth. Paragraph 1 rejects automatic validation by a respectable origin.
    Why not C: Uses possible truth to avoid investigating grounds. The last paragraph explicitly rejects shielding a weak argument in this way.
    Why not E: Treats earlier poor reasoning as a permanent stain. The passage allows later independent evidence to support the same claim.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The author accepts gradual depth but denies that it prevents meaningful differences between distant points or a useful administrative line. Placement must fit the purpose and conditions.
    A combines these claims. The alternatives demand a physical break or unique position, infer universal suitability, or abandon a justified convention.
    Therefore A is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting A.
    Why not B: Restates the critic's requirement. The passage explicitly allows a useful boundary without a discontinuity in the water.
    Why not C: Confuses several acceptable positions with all positions. Paragraph 2 gives an example of a convenient but unsuitable placement.
    Why not D: Assumes that no administrative convention is possible without a natural break. Paragraph 2 explains how a marked zone avoids constant renegotiation.
    Why not E: Confuses justification with uniqueness. Paragraph 3 allows different reasonable lines, including with relevant conditions held constant.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The line in the example is easy to describe but fails the intended learners. It therefore tests the proposed justification of convenience and shows that convenience is insufficient.
    C identifies this separation of administrative clarity from substantive suitability. Nothing in it requires a sudden step or the shallowest conceivable zone.
    Therefore C is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting C.
    Why not A: Mistakes a badly placed line for a general defect of boundaries. The example concerns suitability, not the need for a physical step.
    Why not B: Reverses the example's conclusion. Ease of description does not rescue a line that is bad at its job.
    Why not D: Turns a constraint on excessive depth into a requirement to minimise depth at all costs. The author calls for placement suited to the exercise and learners.
    Why not E: Invents the critic's preference. The critic objects to an artificial division, and is not said to prefer a deeper zone.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    Paragraph 3 distinguishes the range of defensible decisions from the usefulness of instructions after choosing. Several reasonable positions can exist while consistent directions remain valuable.
    E follows without claiming that the chosen line is unique, permanent or beyond criticism. Those stronger claims are excluded elsewhere in the passage.
    Therefore E is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting E.
    Why not A: Overextends a contextual justification. Paragraph 4 requires reconsideration when exercises or learners change.
    Why not B: Excludes a possibility the author explicitly allows. Paragraph 3 says a range may be acceptable even with learners and supervision held constant.
    Why not C: Confuses freedom to choose beforehand with usefulness of conflicting instructions afterwards. Paragraph 3 explicitly separates them.
    Why not D: Makes a stated purpose sufficient for immunity. The last paragraph requires appropriate placement and permits criticism of the decision.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The line's justification is conditional on its function for particular learners and an exercise. B changes that function and stipulates that the marked zone no longer supports suitable supervision.
    This directly undermines the contextual justification. The other developments describe features the author has already accepted as compatible with a useful line.
    Therefore B is the best answer. Award B1 for selecting B.
    Why not A: Treats a different choice elsewhere as disproof. Paragraph 3 explicitly permits more than one reasonable placement.
    Why not C: Repeats the original objection from continuity. The author accepts this small difference while defending a boundary suited to its purpose.
    Why not D: Treats non-uniqueness as a later defect. A range of acceptable original choices is expressly compatible with consistent use of one line.
    Why not E: Treats the intended administrative function as a defect. The final sentence permits an activity boundary without a physical discontinuity.

Keep going

More free LNAT practice