Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

LNAT Section A: Argumentative reading, set 2

Our site-authored practice category for identifying conclusions, evaluating support and checking inferences against a passage. This is not an official LNAT strand; two sets are planned. Test standard. 11 questions, 11 marks, about 25 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Answer all eleven questions using only the relevant passage. Each question has one best answer from A-E.
  • Allow 25 minutes as our short-practice suggestion, including reading time.
  • These original passages and questions are site-authored practice.
  1. 11 mark

    Which statement best expresses the main conclusion of the passage?

    1. A Technical specialists should settle public priorities before estimating likely consequences.
    2. B Public preferences should determine the forecasts used to compare transport proposals.
    3. C Expert forecasts should inform choices whose priorities decision-makers must defend.
    4. D Citizens should calculate the likely effects of proposals before questioning priorities.
    5. E Public decisions should wait until every uncertainty in expert advice has been removed.
  2. 21 mark

    What does the example of the two routes chiefly show about a measure described as 'efficient'?

    1. A It may incorporate a judgement about which benefits deserve to count.
    2. B It must favour small settlements whenever both routes have equal costs.
    3. C It is useful only when every anticipated journey has the same duration.
    4. D It can remove uncertainty by comparing the number of journeys precisely.
    5. E It necessarily gives the same result as an explicit debate about priorities.
  3. 31 mark

    What is the function of the objection about slow and ill-informed decisions?

    1. A It supplies evidence that citizens usually reject technically sound recommendations.
    2. B It concedes that public scrutiny must be suspended whenever a decision is urgent.
    3. C It exposes an inconsistency that leads the author to withdraw the proposed distinction.
    4. D It establishes that specialists should decide which citizens may question their estimates.
    5. E It prompts a distinction between scrutinising priorities and repeating technical work.
  4. 41 mark

    Which description best captures the author's tone towards the proposed division of labour?

    1. A Triumphant, because it guarantees both fair priorities and accurate estimates.
    2. B Cautiously approving, because it clarifies disagreement without ensuring good decisions.
    3. C Resigned, because it merely disguises an unavoidable surrender to technical authority.
    4. D Dismissive, because it replaces practical transport choices with abstract debate.
    5. E Distrustful, because it depends on citizens who are incapable of judging priorities.
  5. 51 mark

    Why does the author favour retaining neglected material surrounding the market-square decision?

    1. A It would establish that the final design was less useful than the rejected designs.
    2. B It would enable scrutiny of how the available choices came to be narrowed.
    3. C It would remove the need for an archive to make any further selection decisions.
    4. D It would ensure future readers asked the same questions as present visitors.
    5. E It would prove that those who chose the final design deliberately excluded dissent.
  6. 61 mark

    Which inference about documenting an archive's selection is best supported?

    1. A It can help readers assess the surviving record even though discarded documents remain unavailable.
    2. B It can provide all the information contained in documents that the archive has destroyed.
    3. C It makes popularity a sufficient basis for discarding connected but little-used material.
    4. D It removes the need to describe surviving holdings for readers unfamiliar with the collection.
    5. E It permits preservation costs to be ignored whenever an unknown future reader might benefit.
  7. 71 mark

    How does the author respond to the objection that an archive cannot keep everything?

    1. A By denying that description and storage impose any significant limits on preservation.
    2. B By accepting popularity as the only selection rule that can be publicly defended.
    3. C By accepting the need to select while disputing the proposed basis for selection.
    4. D By arguing that connected material must always be kept regardless of its cost.
    5. E By conceding that preservation for future enquiry is less important than current access.
  8. 81 mark

    In the opening paragraph, what is the main purpose of contrasting a signature with judgement?

    1. A To show that automated recommendations should never be approved by a person.
    2. B To show why all operators need to reconstruct the internal calculations themselves.
    3. C To show that any decision bearing a signature is preferable to an unsigned decision.
    4. D To show why personal approval always transfers responsibility away from managers.
    5. E To show that formal approval alone may not provide meaningful control over a decision.
  9. 91 mark

    Why does the author ask the reader to assume that automated recommendations are usually better than hurried human judgements?

    1. A To establish as a fact that automated systems make fewer errors in every application.
    2. B To concede a reason for using automation while keeping a separate question about challenges open.
    3. C To show that a single unsuitable result is sufficient reason to abandon the system.
    4. D To demonstrate that human oversight necessarily makes recommendations less reliable.
    5. E To conclude that responsibility can be settled by comparing overall performance alone.
  10. 101 mark

    Which arrangement would most directly satisfy the requirement for intervention described in paragraph 2?

    1. A Every operator signs each recommendation, while another team keeps the basis inaccessible.
    2. B Managers record overall accuracy, while particular disputed recommendations remain final.
    3. C Operators receive technical manuals, while nobody can require a disputed result to be revisited.
    4. D Available staff can explain and correct recommendations, and someone can require reconsideration.
    5. E Each operator rebuilds the system, while the resulting recommendation cannot be changed.
  11. 111 mark

    Which claim about operators in poorly designed arrangements follows from the final paragraph?

    1. A They should answer for their own opportunity to act, while managers also answer for choices shaping it.
    2. B They should bear all blame because they are the last people to touch the applications.
    3. C They have no responsibility to raise recognisable concerns when investigation time is limited.
    4. D They should be held responsible only if they can alter the entire recommendation process.
    5. E They can meet their responsibility by remaining silent whenever managers reward speed.

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The author distinguishes estimating consequences from deciding their importance. The closing sentences assign the first task to expertise and require those answerable for a choice to explain the weights assigned to its consequences.
    C preserves both roles. It neither makes specialists the judges of priorities nor allows public preferences to determine factual forecasts.
    Why not A: Role reversal: the passage gives the defence of priorities to those answerable for the choice, not to technical specialists as such.
    Why not B: Confuses values with predictions: the final paragraph says a vote cannot improve an estimate merely by expressing a preference.
    Why not D: Invents a prerequisite: paragraph 3 explicitly permits citizens to challenge priorities without calculating traffic flows.
    Why not E: Turns uncertainty into a veto: the author accepts that estimates can be mistaken and never demands complete certainty.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    Paragraph 2 asks what the measure includes and says its definition might contain the judgement that the table appears to deliver. Choosing what counts can already give weight to some benefits over others.
    A captures that possibility. The example does not prescribe a winning route or claim that measurement resolves uncertainty or value disagreements.
    Why not B: Converts illustration into prescription: neither route is endorsed, and equal costs do not decide the relative weight of their benefits.
    Why not C: Adds an unstated condition: equal journey durations are not required for a measure to be useful.
    Why not D: Confuses precision with certainty: the specialist must explain uncertainty, and the example concerns priorities even with agreed forecasts.
    Why not E: Strengthens a possibility into a guarantee: an embedded judgement need not match the outcome of an explicit debate.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    The objection suggests that public debate could obstruct informed action. The response grants its force against a demand that everyone repeat specialist work, then denies that scrutiny requires this.
    E identifies how the objection refines the proposal: citizens can question priorities while specialists produce the estimates.
    Why not A: Mistakes a hypothetical objection for evidence: no pattern of citizens rejecting sound advice is reported.
    Why not B: Invents an exception: the passage gives a division of labour, not a rule suspending scrutiny in urgent cases.
    Why not C: Misreads a qualified concession as a retraction: the author retains the distinction between estimates and priorities.
    Why not D: Introduces a power not proposed: specialists are not given control over who can scrutinise their work.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The final paragraph explicitly denies infallibility and describes the advantage as modest: disagreement becomes easier to locate. The author nevertheless recommends distinct responsibilities.
    B combines this approval with its stated limits. The other descriptions either erase those limits or attribute rejection and distrust that the passage does not express.
    Why not A: Ignores explicit qualifications: openly stated priorities can be unfair and honestly offered estimates can be mistaken.
    Why not C: Reverses the proposed accountability: the author wants priorities defended openly rather than hidden under technical authority.
    Why not D: Mistakes scrutiny for avoidance: the division of labour is presented as useful for making and defending actual choices.
    Why not E: Attributes an unstated incapacity: citizens are explicitly allowed to challenge priorities without technical calculations.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The future enquiry concerns why some uses were not considered. Drafts, rejected suggestions and invitation notes could illuminate the process that a final design alone cannot reveal.
    B states this evidential purpose without assuming an unfavourable verdict. The author expressly says preservation would not prove the decision unjust.
    Why not A: Invents a comparison: no judgement about the usefulness of competing designs is established.
    Why not C: Overextends a local example: the author accepts that selection remains necessary under resource limits.
    Why not E: Confuses enabling enquiry with proving wrongdoing: neither deliberate exclusion nor injustice is established.
    Why not D: Reverses the purpose: retaining these materials supports future questions beyond the current popular enquiry.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    Paragraph 3 says an account of selection cannot restore a destroyed document but can stop readers treating a curated remainder as complete. The account supplies context for assessing what survives.
    A is a restrained inference from that contrast. It does not turn the account into a replacement document or remove the other duties and limits the author recognises.
    Why not B: Confuses a selection record with recovery: the text expressly says the account cannot restore a destroyed document.
    Why not C: Reverses the response to scarcity: the objection does not establish popularity as the appropriate selection rule.
    Why not D: Confuses selection transparency with access: the final paragraph still requires description and navigation.
    Why not E: Drops the resource qualification: the author rejects an unlimited claim on present resources in the name of future readers.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The author acknowledges limits on space, staff time and description. The objection defeats indiscriminate accumulation, but does not establish popularity as the right rule.
    C preserves both parts of the response: selection is necessary, yet its justification remains open to argument. The proposed alternative is connected material and an account of selection, within limits.
    Why not A: Denies an explicit concession: the paragraph opens by recognising these resource limits.
    Why not B: Attributes the rejected rule to the author: popularity is precisely what the objection fails to establish.
    Why not D: Turns a possible approach into an absolute duty: the passage says an archive might retain enough connected material and rejects unlimited resource claims.
    Why not E: Invents a ranking: the final paragraph defends both present access and the possibility of future challenge.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    The person described can approve but cannot obtain the basis, question relevance or change the order. The contrast separates a formal act from a practical capacity to affect the decision.
    E states this limited point. The passage does not reject human approval; it requires an opportunity to exercise judgement alongside it.
    Why not A: Turns a criticism of inadequate oversight into a ban on human approval, which the passage never proposes.
    Why not B: Confuses judgement with technical reconstruction: the next paragraph explicitly denies the need to understand every internal calculation.
    Why not C: Misreads the signature as sufficient: the contrast is designed to challenge that assurance.
    Why not D: Invents a transfer of responsibility: the final paragraph retains responsibilities for both managers and operators.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The author accepts the claim only for the argument, then distinguishes a reason for using a system from an answer to who should address a particular unsuitable recommendation.
    B captures this concession and its limit. General reliability cannot guarantee each result or settle the arrangements for answering a challenge.
    Why not A: Treats an assumed proposition as an established finding and strengthens usually better into better in every application.
    Why not C: Reverses an explicit qualification: a single unsuitable recommendation would not establish that automation should be abandoned.
    Why not D: Invents a causal claim: the passage does not say oversight reduces reliability.
    Why not E: Collapses two concerns that paragraph 3 distinguishes: evidence about reliability does not settle answerability.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    Paragraph 2 allows explanation, identification of doubtful cases and correction to be distributed across individuals. These abilities must be available in an arrangement where someone can require reconsideration.
    D supplies both available abilities and authority to intervene. The other arrangements substitute signatures, aggregate performance or technical knowledge for that capacity.
    Why not A: Repeats the formal-approval defect: a signature without access to the basis does not supply the required oversight.
    Why not B: Confuses general performance with individual answerability: disputed recommendations still cannot be reconsidered.
    Why not C: Substitutes information for authority: manuals do not give anyone the ability to require reconsideration.
    Why not E: Adds unnecessary expertise but omits intervention: rebuilding is not required, and an unchangeable result fails the practical requirement.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The author retains an operator duty to raise recognisable concerns while rejecting all blame being placed on operators. Managers must answer for arrangements that shape the opportunity to act.
    A reflects the closing requirement that each answer for the part within their control. It neither erases individual duties nor ignores responsibility for the process.
    Why not B: Ignores the explicit rejection of assigning operators all blame and hides choices made by managers.
    Why not C: Treats poor arrangements as complete exemption: the author explicitly retains a duty to raise a recognisable concern.
    Why not D: Confuses responsibility for a part with control of the whole: the passage assigns responsibility for what each could control.
    Why not E: Contradicts the retained duty: poor arrangements do not make silence admirable, even when managers prioritise speed.

Keep going

More free LNAT practice