Argumentative reading - Set 4
Our site-authored practice category for identifying conclusions, evaluating support and checking inferences against a passage. This is not an official LNAT strand; two sets are planned. Test standard. 11 questions, 11 marks, about 25 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer all eleven questions using only the relevant passage. Each question has one best answer from A-E.
- Allow 25 minutes as our short-practice suggestion, including reading time.
- Argumentative reading is our site-authored practice category, not an official LNAT strand. All passages and questions are original.
- 11 mark
What can be inferred from the contrast between ease and fidelity in the opening paragraph?
- 21 mark
Which claim would the writer most directly reject in the discussion of the invented diary?
- 31 mark
How is the writer's attitude to the objection about mismatched ambiguities best described?
- 41 mark
Which recommendation best expresses the position reached at the end of the translation passage?
- 51 mark
Assuming the second comparison is carried out as described, which conclusion is warranted by paragraph 3?
- 61 mark
Why can the writer allow continuation of the whole arrangement while questioning the manager's promise to another workshop?
- 71 mark
On what point does the writer disagree with the critic who calls the first trial worthless?
- 81 mark
Which assumption is required for paragraph 1's move from the unchanged payment to assessing the remaining evenings?
- 91 mark
What follows from the writer's treatment of perseverance as a possible reason to continue?
- 101 mark
What role does the friend's warning about slowly acquired skills play in the third paragraph?
- 111 mark
Which judgement about leaving the course is consistent with the limit stated in the final paragraph?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks C 1 C follows because the opening paragraph allows easy understanding of a definite claim produced by settling the original's uncertainties. The reader's ease therefore need not reveal the range of possibilities offered by the original. The argument neither treats difficulty as proof of fidelity nor fluency as evidence of a single intended meaning. Award B1 for selecting C. Paragraph 1: "A translation can be easier to read precisely because it gives its readers less to consider." Paragraph 1: "The absence of hesitation would conceal the translator's intervention rather than demonstrate its absence." Why not A: Converts a warning about ease into a guarantee about difficulty. Paragraph 4 says a clumsy sentence may also mislead readers. Why not B: Substitutes word order for available meanings. Paragraph 2 locates the relevant reason in interpretations, not the number of words retained. Why not D: Invents awareness of the intervention. Paragraph 1 says the absence of hesitation can conceal the translator's intervention. Why not E: Infers the writer's intention from the translation's fluency. Paragraph 1 allows that the translator has settled uncertainty the writer deliberately retained. Question 2
Answer or working Marks E 1 E makes coherence sufficient for fidelity, precisely the inference paragraph 2 refuses. The writer grants that choosing relief creates a coherent story, then denies that coherence alone establishes reproduction of the diary's ending. The other options describe features or concessions within that example. Award B1 for selecting E. Paragraph 2: "That choice would produce a coherent story." Paragraph 2: "Yet coherence alone would not establish that the story reproduced the diary's ending." Why not A: Describes the example rather than a disagreement. Paragraph 2 says earlier entries support both feelings and neither reading defeats the other. Why not B: States the possibility the writer recommends considering. The proposed natural phrase can sustain both readings. Why not C: Matches the stated basis for preference. Paragraph 2 explicitly values the range of interpretations rather than the number of retained words. Why not D: Repeats a concession rather than the rejected inference. The writer grants that choosing relief produces a coherent story. Question 3
Answer or working Marks B 1 B captures the measured response: the objection is called reasonable and limits a simple preservation rule, but does not vindicate every clear sentence. The writer accepts a genuine problem without abandoning the distinction between fluency and fidelity. Neither dismissal, indignation nor confidence in a universal remedy fits the concessions. Award B1 for selecting B. Paragraph 3: "A reasonable objection is that languages do not offer matching sets of ambiguities." Paragraph 3: "The objection rules out a simple instruction to reproduce every ambiguity at any cost." Paragraph 3: "It does not make every clear sentence faithful." Why not A: Misstates the response and attributes a motive. Paragraph 3 calls the objection reasonable and accepts that it rules out a simple instruction. Why not C: Turns acknowledgement of some losses into wholesale defeat. Paragraph 4 retains the aim of helping readers encounter the writer's choices. Why not D: Makes a limited possibility universal. Paragraph 3 says notes can sometimes help and sometimes no satisfactory solution is available. Why not E: Reverses the concession. The writer accepts that reproducing every ambiguity at any cost is not a workable instruction. Question 4
Answer or working Marks A 1 A combines the final paragraph's two requirements: fluency remains valuable, while losses of uncertainties significant to understanding should be visible by means suited to the edition. The writer rejects both effortless clarity as a certificate and difficulty as an end in itself. Preserving the reader's access to the writer's choices is the purpose of this qualified recommendation. Award B1 for selecting A. Paragraph 4: "The editor should ask which uncertainties affect a reader's understanding of what the writer is doing, and make significant losses visible by means suited to that edition." Paragraph 4: "Fluency remains a virtue, but it cannot certify fidelity on its own." Why not B: Removes the accepted limit. Paragraph 3 rejects reproducing every ambiguity at any cost, including introducing new uncertainties. Why not C: Makes commentary mandatory whenever two readings exist. Paragraphs 2 and 3 allow a natural phrase or sometimes a note, while paragraph 4 requires means suited to the edition. Why not D: Presents the translator's selection as the writer's choice. The final sentence identifies avoiding precisely this substitution as the aim. Why not E: Replaces the criticised test with another unsupported test. Paragraph 4 rejects awkwardness for its own sake and still calls fluency a virtue. Question 5
Answer or working Marks B 1 B states exactly the improvement and the limit: holding equipment and order allocation comparable makes the hours explanation stronger, but a limited packing comparison does not settle every task or period. It also cannot retrospectively assign the earlier increase among all the changes bundled in the first trial. Award B1 for selecting B. Paragraph 3: "This would make the explanation involving shorter hours stronger, since the comparison no longer bundles them with a different bench or easier orders." Paragraph 3: "It would not show that the same change would work for every task or indefinitely." Why not A: Extends the result beyond its tasks. Paragraph 3 explicitly limits the observed tasks to packing rather than every kind of work. Why not C: Removes the time limit without evidence. Paragraph 3 says the comparison does not show that the change works indefinitely. Why not D: Reads later support back as a full explanation of the first month. The later comparison does not disentangle the contributions in that earlier package. Why not E: Mistakes the new comparison for a decomposition of the old result. It compares hours with equipment and orders controlled, not each earlier contribution. Question 6
Answer or working Marks D 1 D follows from the distinction between retaining the package and explaining its components. Receiving parcels and an earlier finish may support continuing the whole arrangement. Promising the same improvement from hours alone needs evidence about that particular contribution, which the first comparison cannot supply. The distinction gives no guarantee of lasting success. Award B1 for selecting D. Paragraph 2: "A decision about keeping a package of changes need not wait until every contribution has been separated." Paragraph 2: "Evidence that an arrangement worked in one month does not establish which parts can be removed without losing the result." Why not A: Invents two approval requirements. The contrast concerns evidence for a package and evidence for one component, not different groups' permissions. Why not B: Turns unresolved contributions into proof that every component was essential. Paragraph 2 says the evidence cannot establish which parts can be removed. Why not C: Adds certainty about local durability. Paragraph 4 says the first trial cannot show that the arrangement would remain workable over a year. Why not E: Replaces limited evidence with disregard of evidence. The observed result informs the practical decision; the writer does not prescribe ignoring output. Question 7
Answer or working Marks E 1 E identifies the critic's overreach. The writer agrees that the first trial cannot isolate a cause, but denies that this deprives it of all value. It records local workability for a month and suggests further investigation. Nothing reported makes the critic and writer opponents over the possibility of later comparisons or a specified observation period. Award B1 for selecting E. Paragraph 4: "One critic calls the first trial worthless because it cannot isolate a cause." Paragraph 4: "The trial establishes that the combined arrangement was workable there for that month and supplies a reason to investigate it further." Why not A: Attributes the manager's original overclaim to the writer. Paragraph 1 rejects isolating the effect of hours from the first comparison. Why not B: States common ground rather than the dispute. The critic's complaint and the writer's analysis both accept the failure to isolate a cause. Why not C: Invents a dispute about later investigation. The critic is reported as calling the first trial worthless, not denying the possibility of another comparison. Why not D: Shifts the disagreement to a time requirement not attributed to the critic. The writer only says the month cannot establish workability over a year. Question 8
Answer or working Marks C 1 C supplies a necessary bridge. An unchanged payment could still favour attendance if paying itself imposed a duty to attend independently of future benefits and burdens. The paragraph's move to that comparison therefore requires the absence of such a duty from payment alone. This does not exclude a separate commitment to a partner, which the later paragraphs expressly retain. Award B1 for selecting C. Paragraph 1: "Attendance therefore cannot change the payment already made." Paragraph 1: "The relevant comparison is between the benefits and burdens of attending those lessons and the benefits and burdens of using the evenings differently." Paragraph 4: "An irrecoverable fee, by itself, is no reason to attend; deciding whether to attend still requires an assessment of what remains possible, including commitments to other people." Why not A: Makes complete knowledge of future content necessary. Paragraph 3 instead asks the learner to consider overlooked benefits when assessing attendance. Why not B: Requires alternatives to be free when only their benefits and burdens need comparing. Any further payment could be included in that assessment. Why not D: Imports a right to cancel commitments. Paragraphs 2 and 4 expressly include commitments to others among the reasons still relevant to attendance. Why not E: Makes the original decision permanently decisive. Paragraph 4 allows changed circumstances or aims, even without an initially foolish purchase. Question 9
Answer or working Marks A 1 A preserves the conditional reason the writer allows: a habit the learner has reason to value would be a future benefit of continuing, even in an unexciting activity. The benefit must be explained; it is neither generated by the fee nor automatically more important than the other remaining benefits and burdens. Award B1 for selecting A. Paragraph 2: "If continuing an unexciting activity would develop a habit she has reason to value, that benefit belongs in the comparison." Paragraph 2: "But the friend must explain such a benefit rather than assume it from the existence of a receipt." Why not B: Makes the receipt sufficient evidence of a benefit. Paragraph 2 requires the friend to explain the benefit rather than assume it from payment. Why not C: Invents an ordering of benefits. Paragraph 2 allows company, helping a partner and valuable practice without ranking perseverance above them. Why not D: Turns an irrecoverable fee into useful discipline. The last sentence of paragraph 2 explicitly denies that an unsuitable purchase does this automatically. Why not E: Adds a new-technique condition. Paragraph 2 considers perseverance while discussing reasons to attend lessons that repeat familiar techniques. Question 10
Answer or working Marks D 1 D distinguishes what the writer accepts from what remains rejected. The warning makes uncertainty about later rewards relevant and calls for reassessment of possible benefits. It does not turn an irrecoverable payment into a benefit still obtainable through attendance. The friend's concern refines the comparison rather than replacing it with an automatic rule. Award B1 for selecting D. Paragraph 3: "The warning deserves attention, but it concerns how to assess future benefits under uncertainty." Paragraph 3: "It does not make a past payment into a future benefit." Paragraph 3: "The learner should consider whether her early disappointment is misleading and whether later lessons offer something she has overlooked." Why not A: Restores the inference the response rejects. Paragraph 3 says the warning does not make a past payment into a future benefit. Why not B: Converts a possibility into established error. The learner should consider whether her disappointment is misleading; later novelty is not known. Why not C: Reverses the response to the warning. The writer says it deserves attention and encourages assessing overlooked future benefits. Why not E: Reverses both the warning and the proposed response. Deliberate reassessment considers temporary frustration rather than requiring withdrawal. Question 11
Answer or working Marks C 1 C retains the distinction between assessing an earlier purchase and choosing what to do now. Changed circumstances or aims can make withdrawal reasonable without showing the earlier decision was foolish. Conversely, the fee's irrecoverability does not settle the attendance decision because future benefits and commitments still matter. Award B1 for selecting C. Paragraph 4: "Such reflection has a different purpose from deciding how to spend next Tuesday." Paragraph 4: "Equally, leaving would not by itself prove that the purchase was foolish: circumstances or aims may have changed." Why not A: Infers original carelessness from later withdrawal. Paragraph 4 allows changed circumstances or aims and does not make carelessness inevitable. Why not B: Converts rejection of one reason into rejection of attendance. Paragraphs 2 and 4 retain possible benefits and commitments that could justify continuing. Why not D: Makes attendance necessary for retrospective learning. Paragraph 4 separates reflection on enrolment from deciding how to spend next Tuesday. Why not E: Adds a prior-foolishness condition. Paragraph 4 says the learner need not defend the purchase and that leaving would not itself prove it foolish.