LNAT Section A: Argumentative reading, set 5
Our site-authored practice category for identifying conclusions, evaluating support and checking inferences against a passage. This is not an official LNAT strand; two sets are planned. Test standard. 11 questions, 11 marks, about 25 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer all eleven questions using only the relevant passage. Each question has one best answer from A-E.
- Allow 25 minutes as our short-practice suggestion, including reading time. This is not a full mock.
- Argumentative reading is our site-authored practice category, not an official LNAT strand. All passages and questions are original.
- 11 mark
What does the agreement among the three members in paragraph 2 establish about the early-locking report?
- 21 mark
Which limitation remains even if the two later members accurately report what they found?
- 31 mark
How does the writer regard the search for independent sources in the final paragraph?
- 41 mark
In the closing sentence, what is the point of "hearing fewer witnesses than there are voices in the room"?
- 51 mark
Which assumption does the manager need when treating a higher completion total as evidence of helping more people?
- 61 mark
Why does paragraph 2 stress that nobody needs to invent a record?
- 71 mark
What conclusion about rewards is the writer entitled to draw from this example?
- 81 mark
Which principle best captures the passage's recommendation for evaluating an analogy?
- 91 mark
Why is simultaneous entry important to the criticism of the bicycle comparison?
- 101 mark
What is the role of the revised admission rule in the final paragraph?
- 111 mark
How does the writer respond to the second committee member's demand for unrestricted sharing?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks D 1 D follows because the three accounts trace back to the same message. They establish its circulation, but the number of forwarders cannot be counted as separate checks of the event. This leaves the original report open to assessment rather than either confirming it or discrediting its source. Award B1 for selecting D. Paragraph 2: "Their agreement establishes that the message circulated." Paragraph 2: "It does not add three observations of the door to the fourth member's observation." Why not A: Counts recipients as independent observers. All three members refer to one message, so their agreement does not add three observations of the door. Why not B: Infers reduced credibility of the original observer from circulation alone. The passage explicitly says this is not a reason to disbelieve that member. Why not C: Treats the content of the allegation as established while shifting doubt to timing. The three repetitions establish circulation rather than who locked the door. Why not E: Attributes deliberate deception without evidence. The members identify their shared source when asked, and the opening allows honest repetition. Question 2
Answer or working Marks A 1 A preserves the distinction between the state of the door and the person who brought it about. Accurate observations of a locked door still do not identify who locked it. The passage also leaves possible errors about the relevant closing time open; accuracy about what was found cannot settle all parts of the original allegation. Award B1 for selecting A. Paragraph 3: "Finding a locked door does not identify who locked it." Why not B: Makes identifying the person responsible a prerequisite for evidence about closure. The passage separates the early-closure claim from the identity claim. Why not C: Invents a source relationship contrary to the scenario. The later members are described as unaware of the message, not as its known authors. Why not D: Turns a possible shared error into an established change of timetable. An outdated notice is raised as a possibility, not a reported fact. Why not E: Extends support for a locked door to every detail of the message. In particular, the observations do not identify the caretaker as the person responsible. Question 3
Answer or working Marks B 1 B captures the practical but careful attitude: tracing sources is recommended, while perfect independence is not made a condition of action. Urgency permits a decision with acknowledged limits; it does not improve the quality of the evidence. The writer neither abandons source checking nor makes it an unlimited demand. Award B1 for selecting B. Paragraph 4: "This need not become an endless hunt for perfect independence." Paragraph 4: "If a decision cannot wait, the club must act on the evidence available and acknowledge its limits." Why not A: Turns rejection of an endless search for perfection into rejection of enquiry itself. The paragraph recommends following accounts back to their sources. Why not C: Removes the practical limit explicitly allowed. The writer permits acting on available evidence when a decision cannot wait, while acknowledging its limits. Why not D: Confuses honesty and headcount with independent support. The opening allows all the repeaters to be honest while their accounts share a source. Why not E: Converts a reduction in corroboration into proof of falsity. The paragraph explicitly rejects declaring the claim false merely because its source is shared. Question 4
Answer or working Marks E 1 E explains the metaphor through the passage's distinction between voices and observations. The number of speakers can exceed the number of sources that checked the event. The sentence asks listeners to assess that difference, without excluding repeaters or attributing dishonesty. Award B1 for selecting E. Paragraph 1: "Five accounts may be five opportunities to observe an event, or five routes by which a single account has travelled." Paragraph 4: "What has been weakened is one reason for confidence, the apparent number of separate observations." Why not A: Turns distinguishing evidential roles into a ban on speaking. Forwarders can explain circulation and sources even though they add no observations of the door. Why not B: Introduces a general inverse relationship between group size and reliability. The passage concerns source dependence, not whether smaller groups are more reliable. Why not C: Reads the contrast as advice about volume or reticence. Nothing ranks a quiet person's evidence above that of other speakers. Why not D: Substitutes detecting dishonest motives for tracing evidence. The argument explicitly allows honest speakers who are repeating one source. Question 5
Answer or working Marks C 1 C identifies the bridge between what is counted and what the manager claims. If counted completions had no dependable connection to resolved requests, their increase would not support an increase in help. The inference does not need every completion to be perfect, but it does need a sufficiently informative relationship. Paragraph 2 supplies a way that relationship can weaken. Award B1 for selecting C. Paragraph 1: "Its manager reports a rise in the number of records marked complete and takes this as evidence that the office is helping more people." Paragraph 1: "A completed record is convenient to count, and staff usually close a record when the request has been resolved." Why not A: Imposes a one-request-per-person rule that the inference does not require. The relevant bridge is between completions and help, not the lifetime number of requests. Why not B: Makes universal staff preference necessary. The manager's inference could be warranted without rewards at all, and does not depend on how every worker ranks them. Why not D: Adds universal self-sufficiency. The office could help residents resolve requests through other organisations while completions still indicated help. Why not E: Makes the complete absence of returns necessary. Some returns could occur while the count still provided useful evidence; the needed link is weaker than this absolute claim. Question 6
Answer or working Marks D 1 D captures the distinction the sentence protects. Even without fictional entries, real closures under a permissive rule may count the same unresolved request repeatedly. The defect lies in what a closure means for the office's purpose, so checking that every counted record exists would not resolve it. Award B1 for selecting D. Paragraph 2: "Nobody needs to invent a record for this to happen." Paragraph 2: "Every counted completion can be real under the recording rule while the total becomes less informative about the purpose the office serves." Why not A: Invents responsibility and intent for residents. The manager introduces rewards; residents are described as returning because they still need help. Why not B: Reverses the point of the example. Inventing records is unnecessary: genuine completions under the rule can include unresolved requests. Why not C: Confuses accuracy under the recording rule with usefulness as evidence of help. The passage explicitly separates these two properties. Why not E: Converts a claim about the new shortcut into certainty about every earlier request. Earlier counts were useful, but universal earlier success is never established. Question 7
Answer or working Marks E 1 E states the limited conclusion supported by the mechanism: rewards can encourage closures that cease to represent resolutions when the rule permits that shortcut. The example is conditional, not a proof against every incentive. Removing the shortcut would block this particular mechanism, while leaving other possible problems to be argued separately. Award B1 for selecting E. Paragraph 4: "Nor does the example show that rewards must always corrupt a useful measure." Paragraph 4: "If a record could be closed only after a genuinely resolved request, the particular shortcut described would be unavailable." Why not A: Turns a specified mechanism into a universal claim. Paragraph 4 explicitly denies that rewards must always corrupt a useful measure. Why not B: Reads a later incentive effect backwards in time. Paragraph 3 says the earlier count helped reveal unfinished work, rather than being uninformative. Why not C: Turns supplementary information into a guarantee. Paragraph 3 says a follow-up might supply missing information, not that it removes every possible problem. Why not D: Prescribes abandoning counts, which paragraph 3 rejects as potentially concealing delays. No such necessary condition for useful measures is given. Question 8
Answer or working Marks E 1 E joins the opening criterion to the final recommendation. An analogy is useful when the feature it shares with the original case bears on the reason for the original judgement. A familiar picture, any isolated difference, or the demand that one comparison settle everything would each bypass this examination. Award B1 for selecting E. Paragraph 1: "It is whether they share the feature that made the original judgement appropriate." Paragraph 4: "We should use comparisons to expose reasons for examination, and refuse to let a familiar picture stand in for that examination." Why not A: Substitutes familiarity and agreement for the missing link. The opening warns that familiarity can replace a reason without justifying its transfer. Why not B: Makes any difference fatal. The opening says differences are inevitable; the final paragraph requires asking whether a difference affects the relevant reason. Why not C: Demands completeness rather than relevance. The final paragraph allows an analogy to illuminate one consideration without deciding the entire issue. Why not D: Infers the opposite conclusion from failure of one argument. Paragraph 3 expressly rejects that move in the second committee member's response. Question 9
Answer or working Marks C 1 C identifies why this difference matters rather than merely observing that words and bicycles differ. Both people may enter at once, so sharing does not deprive the member of use. The offered bicycle argument depends precisely on such deprivation, and therefore fails to supply its stated reason under the original rules. Award B1 for selecting C. Paragraph 2: "Under the club's stipulated arrangements, sharing that word with another person does not prevent the member from entering, and both may enter at once." Paragraph 2: "But the particular reason offered concerns an owner's loss of use during a loan." Why not A: Confuses ability to enter with membership. The imagined arrangements specify access, while paragraph 3 leaves the existence of a members-only rule unsettled. Why not B: Reverses the comparison. The bicycle reason depends on the owner being unable to use the bicycle during the loan, not on that loss being impossible. Why not D: Overextends the failure of one reason to all possible reasons. Paragraph 3 explicitly allows a separate argument based on reserving the room for members. Why not E: Infers total incomparability from one relevant difference. The final paragraph shows a changed admission rule could make the lost-use comparison more relevant. Question 10
Answer or working Marks A 1 A states both the function and limit of the changed rule. If another person consumes the sole admission, sharing now deprives the member of use, matching the offered bicycle reason. That makes the comparison more relevant on this point, while the writer expressly retains other differences and considerations. Award B1 for selecting A. Paragraph 4: "Suppose instead that each use of a member's word consumed the member's sole admission for that day." Paragraph 4: "The bicycle comparison would then gain force on the specific issue of lost use, though other differences could still matter." Why not B: Treats a counterfactual change as a correction of the original scenario. The writer says "Suppose instead", retaining the original arrangements for the earlier criticism. Why not C: Confuses one restored resemblance with identity in every respect. The writer explicitly says that other differences could still matter. Why not D: Imports an exclusive policy conclusion. The change concerns the member's lost admission, not the justification of membership restrictions. Why not E: Turns increased force on one issue into a complete decision. The paragraph explicitly denies that a relevant resemblance supplies a complete decision procedure. Question 11
Answer or working Marks D 1 D captures a critical but limited response. The second member overreaches by deriving unrestricted sharing from the failure of the bicycle argument. The writer does not thereby vindicate a restriction: a separate reason, its existence and its justification would still need examination. Award B1 for selecting D. Paragraph 3: "That conclusion is also too quick." Paragraph 3: "The imagined arrangements do not tell us whether such a rule exists or whether it would be justified." Paragraph 3: "Rejecting the bicycle argument settles neither question." Why not A: Confuses the absence of a successful offered argument with proof of permission. Paragraph 3 explicitly calls the demand for unrestricted sharing too quick. Why not B: Treats a possible separate reason as an established justified rule. Paragraph 3 leaves both the existence and justification of a members-only rule open. Why not C: Invents acceptance and an objection about familiarity. The writer criticises the inference to unrestricted sharing, not the familiarity of the example. Why not E: Attributes arbitrary certainty to a reason-sensitive argument. The passage tests the specific lost-use reason rather than allowing any preferred policy to follow.