Worked question 9 - Legal, Moral, Cultural and Ethical Issues
Answer and mark scheme
Question 9
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) (i) Section 1: unauthorised access to computer material applies |
| B1 | (a) (i) Valid justification, e.g. he accessed the system without the hospital's consent, regardless of his benign intent, which is sufficient for the Section 1 offence |
| B1 | (a) (ii) Recognises that publishing the exploit code is not itself an act of unauthorised access, so it does not directly commit the Section 1 or Section 3 offence |
| B1 | (a) (ii) Valid nuance, e.g. this could potentially fall under Section 3A (making, supplying or obtaining articles for use in a computer misuse offence) if the code is judged likely to be used for such offences, though this is a more complex legal question than (i) |
| B1 | (b) Data Protection Act 2018 / UK GDPR |
| B1 | (b) Explains the requirement to report the breach to the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) without undue delay, and where feasible within 72 hours |
| B1 | (b) Explains the requirement to notify the affected patients directly if the breach is likely to result in a high risk to their rights and freedoms |
| B1 | (b) Explains a possible consequence for the trust, e.g. an ICO fine, reputational damage, a requirement to improve security measures |
| 1-3 | (c) L1 Basic explanation of responsible disclosure or of a legal issue, with limited reference to the scenario and little evaluation. |
| 4-6 | (c) L2 Clear explanation of responsible disclosure principles and of the limitations of current legislation, with reference to the scenario, and some evaluation, though it may be one-sided. |
| 7-9 | (c) L3 Sustained, well-structured evaluation that draws directly on the scenario to weigh the interests of researchers, organisations and the public, considers the adequacy of current law, and reaches a well-justified overall conclusion. |
- (a) Answer: (i) Section 1 offence applies to the unauthorised access. (ii) Publishing alone is not a direct access/modification offence, but could potentially engage Section 3A depending on intent and likely use.
- (b) Answer: Data Protection Act 2018/UK GDPR requires the trust to report the breach to the ICO within 72 hours where feasible, notify affected patients if the risk is high, and it may face a fine or enforcement action.
- (c) Indicative content:
- Responsible disclosure norms: report privately first, allow a reasonable fixed period (commonly around 90 days in industry practice) for the organisation to patch the flaw, only publish full technical details afterwards, and ideally withhold or delay publication of working exploit code even then.
- In this scenario, Ryan followed part of the process (private report first) but the hospital trust failed to respond, and Ryan then published full working exploit code rather than a limited disclosure or an extended private escalation, which arguably went beyond responsible practice and directly enabled the criminal attack.
- The Computer Misuse Act 1990 does not provide an explicit statutory defence or 'safe harbour' for good-faith security research; the Section 1 offence can technically apply even where access was for a benign purpose, unlike some other jurisdictions that provide specific protections for authorised or good-faith testing.
- This creates a chilling effect: legitimate researchers may be deterred from testing real systems for fear of prosecution, meaning vulnerabilities may go undiscovered or unreported, reducing overall public benefit.
- Counter-argument: without some deterrent, any unauthorised access could be excused as 'research', which would undermine legitimate prosecution of malicious actors, so the law cannot simply exempt all such access.
- Possible reforms discussed by security professionals include an explicit public interest defence for authorised/ethical security research, wider adoption of formal bug bounty and vulnerability disclosure programmes by organisations, and clearer statutory response-time obligations on organisations receiving vulnerability reports.
- A well-reasoned conclusion should recognise that the harm in this case arose from failures on both sides (the hospital's lack of response and the researcher's decision to publish working exploit code), and that legal reform alongside better organisational processes, rather than either the criminal law or individual ethics alone, is likely needed to properly balance these interests.
- (c) Answer: N/A - levels-marked extended response.



