Worked question 7 - Statistics: Data Presentation and Interpretation Depth
A-Level Statistics: Data Presentation and Interpretation - Depth Practice
Original material written for Revision Library, styled on Edexcel AS/A-level Mathematics (9MA0) Statistics content.
This pack extends core data presentation and interpretation skills to full A-level depth: measures of location and spread (including coding), identifying outliers by the quartile rule and the standard deviation rule, box plots and skewness, histograms and frequency density, linear interpolation, correlation and regression (including coding and residuals), and evaluating statistical models in context, in the style of the large data set used across the qualification. All contexts and figures are original.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 7
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| M1 | (a) mean = sum(x)/n = 217/31 attempted |
| A1 | (a) mean = 7.00 (exact) |
| M1 | (a) variance = sum(x2)/n - mean2 = 1859.4/31 - 72 used |
| A1 | (a) standard deviation = awrt 3.31 |
| M1 | (b) upper boundary = mean + 2 x SD = 7.00 + 2(3.3137) attempted |
| A1 | (b) upper boundary = awrt 13.6 (ft from (a)) |
| A1 | (b) correct conclusion with comparison: since 42 > 13.6, the value of 42 knots is classified as an outlier |
| 1-2 | (c) L1 A basic, one-sided comment is made (e.g. simply states the value should or should not be removed), with little or no reference to the statistical outlier test from part (b) or to the storm context. |
| 3-4 | (c) L2 Some valid discussion is given, referencing either the numerical outlier classification from part (b) or the contextual, genuine nature of the storm reading, but the discussion is not fully developed or does not weigh up both sides. |
| 5-6 | (c) L3 A full, balanced discussion is given: correctly identifies 42 as a statistical outlier (using the result from part (b)), recognises that it is a genuine measurement linked to an identifiable cause (a storm) rather than a recording error, and reaches a reasoned conclusion (e.g. that it may be reasonable to exclude it only when describing a 'typical' day, while retaining it in the full data set for other purposes such as studying extreme weather), showing clear understanding that the decision depends on the purpose of the analysis. |
- (a) Answer: Mean = 7.00 knots, standard deviation = 3.31 knots (3sf)
- (b) Answer: Upper boundary = 13.6 knots; 42 knots is an outlier
- (c) Indicative content:
- 42 knots is confirmed as a statistical outlier by the 2 standard deviation rule from part (b), since it exceeds the upper boundary of approximately 13.6 knots by a large margin
- However, the value is a genuine recorded measurement, not a data entry or recording error, since it is linked to an identifiable and explainable cause, a named storm
- There is therefore no statistical justification for removing it on the grounds that it is invalid data
- If the aim is specifically to describe a 'typical' October day, including the storm value would inflate both the mean and, especially, the standard deviation (as seen in part (a)), giving a misleading impression of a typical day
- This gives some justification for excluding it for that specific purpose, provided this is stated clearly and transparently
- Removing genuine data can understate the true variability and risk of extreme wind events at this location, so it should be retained in any analysis concerned with extremes or risk, and both sets of summary statistics could reasonably be quoted
- Overall, the decision should depend on the purpose of the analysis rather than being made automatically because the value is a statistical outlier
- (c) Answer: 42 knots is a genuine, explainable outlier (a storm); it could reasonably be excluded only when describing a 'typical' day, but should be retained for analyses of extreme weather, since the decision depends on the purpose of the analysis





