A Level Psychology Essentials 3 includes Idiographic and Nomothetic Approaches to Psychological Investigation (Issues and Debates); Ethical Implications of Research Studies and Theory (Issues and Debates); Applying Issues and Debates to Memory and Eyewitness Testimony Research (Issues and Debates); Applying Issues and Debates to Conformity and Obedience Research (Issues and Debates); Sexual Selection and Human Reproductive Behaviour (Relationships); Factors in Attraction: Self-Disclosure and Physical Attractiveness (Relationships); Filter Theory of Relationship Formation (Relationships); Social Exchange Theory and Equity Theory of Romantic Relationships (Relationships); Rusbult's Investment Model of Commitment in Relationships (Relationships); Duck's Phase Model of Relationship Breakdown (Relationships); Virtual Relationships in Social Media (Relationships); Explaining Parasocial Relationships: Absorption-Addiction and Attachment (Relationships); Biological Explanations of Gender Development (Gender); Cognitive, Psychodynamic and Social Explanations of Gender Development (Gender); Piaget's Theory of Cognitive Development and Vygotsky's Sociocultural Theory (Cognition and Development); Baillargeon's Infant Research and the Development of Social Cognition (Cognition and Development); Classification and Diagnosis of Schizophrenia (Schizophrenia); Biological Explanations for Schizophrenia: Genetics and Neural Correlates (Schizophrenia); Psychological Explanations for Schizophrenia: Family and Cognitive Theory (Schizophrenia); Treating Schizophrenia: Therapies and the Interactionist Approach (Schizophrenia); Explanations for the Success and Failure of Dieting (Eating Behaviour); Biological Explanations for Anorexia Nervosa (Eating Behaviour); Psychological Explanations for Anorexia Nervosa (Eating Behaviour); Biological and Psychological Explanations for Obesity (Eating Behaviour); The Physiology of Stress and Stress-Related Illness (Stress); Sources of Stress, Individual Differences and Managing Stress (Stress); Biological Explanations of Aggression: Neural and Hormonal Mechanisms (Aggression); Ethological and Evolutionary Explanations of Aggression (Aggression); Social Psychological Explanations of Aggression (Aggression); Defining and Measuring Crime, and Offender Profiling (Forensic Psychology); Biological and Psychological Explanations of Offending Behaviour (Forensic Psychology); Dealing with Offending Behaviour: Custodial Sentencing and Treatment (Forensic Psychology); The Nature of Addiction and Risk Factors (Addiction); Explanations for Nicotine and Gambling Addiction, and Reducing Addiction (Addiction).
Method recap - Rusbult's Investment Model of Commitment in Relationships
- Learn the three factors by name and definition: satisfaction level, comparison with alternatives, and investment size.
- Note that commitment is the outcome the three factors combine to predict, not one of the three factors itself.
- Learn the distinction between tangible investments (e.g. shared property) and intangible investments (e.g. shared memories).
- Learn what Le and Agnew's meta-analysis did and found, including which populations it sampled.
Worked example - Rusbult's Investment Model of Commitment in Relationships
Priya and Jamal have dated for two years. Priya feels highly satisfied in the relationship, believes that potential alternative partners would not treat her as well as Jamal does, and has moved into a shared flat with him and introduced him to her family. Using Rusbult's three factors, determine whether Priya is likely to show high or low commitment, and justify your conclusion.
- Identify satisfaction level: Priya reports high satisfaction, which on its own points towards high commitment.
- Identify comparison with alternatives: she judges alternative partners as worse, which also points towards high commitment.
- Identify investment size: the shared flat is a tangible investment and introducing Jamal to her family is an intangible one, both sizeable.
- Combine the three factors: satisfaction, alternatives and investment all point in the same direction, with no conflicting factor to weigh up.
- State the final answer: Priya is likely to show high commitment, because all three of Rusbult's factors favour staying in the relationship.
Question 8 - Rusbult's Investment Model of Commitment in Relationships
12 marks
Discuss whether Rusbult's investment model could be usefully applied to explain commitment in non-romantic contexts, such as friendships or long-term employment, evaluating one strength and one limitation of extending the model in this way.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [12 marks]| Question 8[12 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| states the three factors and explains how each could transfer to a non-romantic context, e.g. job satisfaction, alternative employers, and sunk costs such as training or pension contributions | 2 |
| develops the investment analogy further, e.g. years of service, workplace friendships or acquired skills acting like tangible and intangible investments | 2 |
| identifies a strength of extending the model this way, e.g. it suggests the same reward-alternative-investment mechanism may operate generally, broadening the model's explanatory reach | 2 |
| identifies a limitation, e.g. the model and its strongest supporting evidence, including Le and Agnew's meta-analysis, were developed and tested on romantic couples, so applying it elsewhere is an untested extrapolation | 2 |
| identifies a further limitation, e.g. intangible romantic investments such as shared memories may not map cleanly onto workplace or friendship ties, weakening the validity of the analogy | 2 |
| reaches a balanced conclusion on whether the extension is justified. Final answer: the three-factor logic may plausibly generalise to loyalty in workplaces or friendships, but because the strongest evidence comes from romantic relationships, the extension should be treated as plausible rather than established. | 2 |
Question 7 - Rusbult's Investment Model of Commitment in Relationships
6 marks
In a hypothetical study of 240 participants, satisfaction correlated with commitment at r = 0.35, and investment size correlated with commitment at r = 0.72. (a) Calculate how much more variance in commitment investment size explains than satisfaction does, using r-squared. (b) Using this data, explain which factor Rusbult's model would predict to be the stronger single correlate of commitment here, and why the correlational design limits what can be concluded about causality.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 7 [6 marks]| Question 7[6 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| converts the correlations to r-squared values: investment size 0.72 squared = 0.518 (51.8%), satisfaction 0.35 squared = 0.1225 (12.25%) | 1 |
| calculates the difference between them, showing investment size explains about 39.6 percentage points more of the variance in commitment than satisfaction does | 1 |
| identifies investment size as the stronger single correlate of commitment in this data set | 1 |
| links this to Rusbult's model, noting that it predicts investment size can sustain commitment even when satisfaction is only moderate | 1 |
| states that correlation alone does not establish that investment size causes commitment | 1 |
| suggests a plausible alternative explanation, such as reverse causality (already-committed people may invest more) or a third variable such as personality. Final answer: investment size explains roughly 40 percentage points more variance than satisfaction, making it the stronger correlate here, but the correlational design means this cannot be read as proof that investment causes commitment. | 1 |
Method recap - Duck's Phase Model of Relationship Breakdown
- Learn the four original phases of Duck's model in order: intra-psychic, dyadic, social and grave-dressing.
- Learn the threshold statement that marks the start of each phase: intra-psychic ('I can't stand this any more'), dyadic ('I would be justified in withdrawing'), social ('I mean it') and grave-dressing ('It's now inevitable').
- For each phase, learn who is involved and what the dissatisfied partner is doing: intra-psychic (private brooding over the partner's behaviour, weighing up the relationship, no confrontation yet), dyadic (the couple confront the dissatisfaction directly and discuss whether to repair or end the relationship), social (the breakdown is made public to friends and family, who may take sides, offer support, or attempt to mediate) and grave-dressing (each partner constructs their own account of why the relationship ended, aiming to protect their reputation and social standing).
- Learn the later addition to the model, the resurrection phase, in which individuals use what they learned from the breakup to prepare themselves for future relationships.
Question 9 - Duck's Phase Model of Relationship Breakdown
6 marks
After weeks of arguing, Priya and Josh finally sit down together and admit that neither of them is happy, discussing openly whether the relationship can be saved or should end. Using Duck's phase model, identify which phase this represents and explain your reasoning.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [6 marks]| Question 9[6 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| identifies the dyadic phase | 1 |
| explains using the definition, e.g. the dyadic phase involves the couple confronting their dissatisfaction directly with each other, rather than one partner brooding privately | 2 |
| links to the threshold statement, e.g. sitting down and openly discussing whether the relationship can be saved matches the threshold 'I would be justified in withdrawing' | 2 |
| notes the outcome described (deciding whether to repair or end the relationship) is a defining feature of the dyadic phase | 1 |
Question 10 - Duck's Phase Model of Relationship Breakdown
16 marks
Discuss Duck's phase model as an explanation of relationship breakdown. (16 marks)
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 10 [16 marks]| Question 10[16 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| Knowledge of the relevant theory/research is accurate and generally detailed. Discussion/evaluation is thorough, effective and clearly focused on the question. The answer is coherent, well organised and expressed with effective use of psychological terminology throughout. | Level 413-16 marks |
| Knowledge is evident but there may be occasional inaccuracies or a lack of detail. Discussion/evaluation is apparent and mostly effective, though it may lack a little depth or focus in places. The answer is mostly clear and organised, with appropriate use of terminology. | Level 39-12 marks |
| Knowledge is present but limited, and there may be inaccuracies. There is some attempt at discussion/evaluation, but it is not fully effective, may be brief or largely descriptive rather than evaluative. The answer lacks clarity and organisation in places, and terminology is not always used appropriately. | Level 25-8 marks |
| Knowledge is very limited. Discussion/evaluation, if present, is muddled, superficial and/or largely irrelevant to the question. The answer as a whole lacks organisation and coherence, and terminology is used inaccurately or not at all. | Level 11-4 marks |
| No relevant content, or the answer is not creditworthy in the context of the question. | 0 |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: accurate description of the intra-psychic phase and its threshold | |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: accurate description of the dyadic phase and its threshold | |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: accurate description of the social phase and its threshold | |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: accurate description of the grave-dressing phase and its threshold | |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: reference to the later addition of a resurrection phase | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a strength based on real-world application (the model can help relationship counsellors identify which phase a couple has reached and target support accordingly) | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a limitation concerning the model's fixed, linear order (real breakdowns may not follow the phases in a strict sequence, and couples can move back and forth between phases) | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a limitation concerning the retrospective, self-report nature of much of the supporting evidence (accounts given after a breakup may be reconstructed to protect the storyteller's reputation rather than accurately describe what happened) | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a point about the model's descriptive rather than explanatory nature (it describes what typically happens at each stage but does not fully explain why some relationships break down while similar ones survive) | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a balanced conclusion weighing the model's practical, structured value against its limited predictive power for any individual relationship | |